Kamal Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another


 

 
  
 
   

  !"#"$%&''



 

           



 %
 ()*'

+ *+ ** ) ****  

  ! "#  

 $  !%& 

 ! "#

'

! "#  ()



 + $,

-.,/"01 '  $+  ,-(./0 .1.))2.3 4 5 .6  #  .)2789:2/9:)29::09:/09:/;9:0.912/ -<!    #   8   ! %# <  %   # + #   =  #   >        >"    .22).33;4 5:6  5# > $      (.##  ! > #          "          #     )!12!22297 >   #   #         

>  $   !       #     

       *  #    #         

   <"    ' #    "     .3.))2.3

- 2 - 4 5 16!    #     + * 

    5#   "  > 5# 

 )021.333 4 5 ;6   "     

!     #  ! >         #     )!22!22297  ,- > 

   #

9  

  # #     >"     !      9



    ##

$ "#  !   "> "     $   %   "  !   # #  >     # #  #   "  >#   #  ,- 

   -    #     (.          ' #    #    >    "   .3.).3334 516! <

    

    

     #      ##   !   # ## #!,-(./0 .1.))2.3! # .)278!:2/!:)2! ::0!:/0!:/;!:0.!12/-<! # 8  !%# < % ! > #  #   > ,-! #  $         #   #     '

   #7   8 #     <  
  

  
     

   

- 3 -

    

 ! 

"#"#$#!  % & 

  
  ' (

  #  .3..)2.3 =   #       #     #   !     *   () # " #  ##  #>$     

   #    #      *   >     ,-  $5 #         ! # # ::0-<      -    #      5                    #  >     >## -  >     # > >   ## *  (.  # #           #              5#        -  "   #           5  )) 

,- # #    7#  > >  =  #  "   

,-     5

> # "    5> #  #   (.  "       #       (. >   #          #    # ># #  # ) 


 %



 + , -' ..

- 4 - ?   >  >  ()    "# # # ##      #  ,-     > "  "/ 0 &   2 %, %
 

 "

    

3  
 .! -  #!   (.   

!       +    ()!  (-   -!    #          @ $  .@  # # > " >  ### #    )2.@    "#   (@          /)2297 "      @221)2.; 4 5.6 );..)2.3!   () "# ! < %  "#        =   #        () "  ! # $  >   ,-   !" #          ' #   " 5     ./.))2.3      " #  #"  #   "  " # # 

   !  "#   >  '  

!  "# "          #   >    ()  $ 

 "  )021.333 4 5 @6     (.0@       A*          () "  .220)22/4 5:6       " # 

- 5 - -    "    (.    #   #   > # #"   *-     >  ()4 516     !     #    "    #  #          (.  

 9 

"    $##   #   #        (.  #  ! .0 #!  #   #  !   * $   #  $BC=  #   ()  #'

  ><"A

4%" 6!< %  <7 .@2@)2)2 )2.2)2)2" #" >   (. >    "      #          

# ! < #   "   

    <  
   4  % '  5 )  6  

 66!     #  :;)<< 

# ))/   <    -   +         > 5#     "          >    # $  #   *       #  >' #   

<###   ##* #   >5#  !  ###    #

- 6 - -  7

   22  8 & ,  % "


   ' 9!



,  <    > 

< # :;) < "   "         +  #     5#   

<!>

#!     " 

   #  #   # # D! 7     "  #   >  ##     #  >  #  "" !  # !   # >   #"  #  -  "/ 0 &  1  2 %,  # 46!  <   #    7  #     #  '#!  

<!   5#       #  :;)<<  9# ))/   <    - !+ ,-9# 9# #  "    "  - #  <  >     # #    !!+     

,-9#    #   "  # "      ,-9# !

     

9     #    "   < < #  -      #!   #     >      () ))..)2.3 #     ,- .1.))2.3   #"./.))2.3-#   # $     4  ()6 

- 7 -   #    ))..)2.3   #    ,-      (.!      #"    ./.))2.3  " #" #   # # #    (.      (."#   #"'        () E"    !   #"    >   (.  >  

    ()  >      ##      "     (.   #    ()  #   (.   #    !.0# #! ""   !     (.* <      (.#  #   > # # >     ! $  $ ! >#   ! # !## >    ,     #  >"!   <      

 + ,-   !   %   # 46! !  ##  2/2))2)@ 
 + $,

-.,/"0

.,/

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No