Nishan Singh v. State Of Punjab
!" "#$%$&'
$%( &)$&*( +"!$!$&", -",%.% )! !" .&/ 0 +"%1&2"&!
, 3'
&405",.%!$#")6 5$ ,"%"&!' ,)7($&2 82-# !"
,!("1"!$!$&", , &9 / .1! 8225 8.&/ 0 ::: ;, 5< , =",$&!("1"!$!$&.&2",)"#!$&>? , $% ,*, &! ,"*.5 , 0 $5 ! !(" 1"!$!$&", $& # %" @ 2 !"2 @@
,"*$%!","2.&2",)"#!$& 8A@ !5$#")! !$&(5 !(8$%!,$#! 7 1.,!( 5 2.,$&*!("1"&2"&#= !("!,$ 5 B" ,&"2#.&%"5 ,!("1"!$!$&",#&!"&2%!( !!("1"!$!$&", $%$&#.%!2=%$&#"
@
8 ( 55 &( %0""&1,"%"&!"2&?
!(.*(8 #( ,*"% ( -" &! 0""& , 3"2 &2 > .! 1,%"#.!$& C$!&"%%"%C( ,""="C$!&"%%"%( -"*$-"&
$2 -$!;&&"D.,"% ! <!( !!("$&#$2"&!C % & ##$2"&! &2!(","C %&$&!"&!$&&!(" 1 ,! !("1"!$!$&",!,.&-",!("#315 $& &!% !(", (" %"#&2 1"!$!$& , ,"*.5 , 0 $5 C % 2$%3$%%"2 0= !(" 5" ,&"2225)"%%$&%.2*"87 1.,!( 5 -$2",2",2 !"2
0= ! 9$&*$&! ##.&!!( !!("1"!$!$&",C %0"$&**$-"& 0" !$&*0=($% %",- &!7 &.C(",".1&!("1"!$!$&",%! ,!"2#( %$&*% $27 &.&($%
!, #!, &2 C("& !(" #315 $& &!4% !(", 0/"#!"2 ! !(" % 3"8 !(" 1"!$!$&", , & -", ($3 C$!( ($% !, #!, C$!( !(" $&!"&! ! 9$55 ($38 ,"%.5!$&* $& !(" %"#&2 5"* !(" #315 $& &!4% !(", 5% 0"$&* 31.! !"2 > & !(" ,"3"&!$&"2 #$,#.3%! &#"%8 !(" 5" ,&"2 225 )"%%$&%.2*"87 1.,!( 5 82$%3$%%"2!("%"#&21"!$!$& ,,"*.5 ,0 $5 & ##.&! !("
"&#" 55"*"2 * $&%!!("1"!$!$&",0"$&**, -" &2 !(" !(", !("#315 $& &!( -$&*0""&,"&2","2 #,$115"& ##.&! ($%,"3 $&$&*5"* 5%( -$&**! 31.! !"2$&!("$&#$2"&! B" &"2 #.&%"5 , !(" 1"!$!$&", %! !"% !( ! !$55 2 !" "-"& #( ,*"% ( -" &! 0""& , 3"28 !(","
,"8 !(" !,$ 5 $% 5$9"5= ! ! 9" #&%$2", 05"1",$2 !$3"( -"#&%$2","2!("%.03$%%$&% 5" ,&"2 #.&%"50.!C($5"! 9$&*$&! ##.&! 55 %1"#!% !("3 !!",8 3 !(" #&%$2","2-$"C!( !!("$&%! &!1"!$!$&2"%&!C ,, &!$&!", ","&#" &2 # & 0" 2$%1%"2 0= 2$,"#!$&* !(" 5" ,&"2 !,$ 5 .,! ! ! 9" %!"1% ! "D1"2$!$.%5="D 3$&"!("1,%"#.!$&C$!&"%%"%$.2$&*!("C$!&"%%"% C(%"
$2 -$!%( -"0""& !! #("2 5&*C$!(!("$&%! &!1"!$!$& &2! #.2"!("!,$ 5$& !$3"0.&23 &&", @ B" ,&"2 225 8 .&/ 08 & $&%!,.#!$&% ,3 ) -$&2",)$&*(8)(5 !(87 1.,!( 5 8%! !"%!( !("( %&0/"#!$& !!("1,1%"2#.,%" #!$& ##,2$&*5=8$&!("5$*(! !("1%$!$&&!"2 0-"8C($5" 2$%3$%%$&*!(" 115$# !$& ,,"*.5 ,0 $585" ,&"2!,$ 5 .,!$%2$,"#!"2 !! 9"%!"1%!#.2"!("!,$ 5 %"D1"2$!$.%5= %1%%$05"81," ", 05= C$!($&?3&!(% ,3!("2 !" ,"#"$1! #",!$ $"2#1= !(",2",
A B$0",!=!3-" & 115$# !$& ,,"*.5 ,0 $5$& ##,2 &#" C$!( 5 C !", !(" "-$2"&#" !(" > 1,%"#.!$& C$!&"%%"% $ !(" #$,#.3%! &#"% !("# %"%C ,, &! ?
C"-",8&!($&*%! !"2(","$& 0-"%( 550"! 9"&!0" & "D1,"%%$& 1$&$&&!("3",$!% !("# %"