Sukhdev Singh @ Bobby v. State Of Punjab
!"#$"%&'&()
*+,$"-&(.,/001 "!&!&(" 2 ! !"# *(3 0 "'4($"(!
) 56 76
"'"(!) , ($&8$-% !"8#!,"4"!&!&(" *(6*!, 88 *(3 0 9999999 768:
6;
,*.,!,"4"'"(!4"!&!&(#&<"$*($""%!&(= !,"
4"!&!&("'""+'&''* (%"#$&"%!&('!!,"$$&!&( <"''&('*$.":# ',!8!,"& <*!;!#&( <<1$"%&$""''&(' '" >#
?,&%, &.&( !"'#@ =$ !"$=
".&'!""$*($""%!&(' :"%!&('
8
($ $$"$< !"(; ! <&%"! !&(&-&'&( >8 < ($, 6" ("$! !"%*('"<&(#@'!,"*!!, !(=
!,"
& <*!, '%(-&%!"$!,"4"!&!&("*($""%!&('
A 8
A ($
A ($!, !&(4*'* (%"!'*%,%(-&%!&(!,"4"!&!&(", '0""( '"(!"(%"$!<&#"&@4&'(@"(!(
*($""%!&('
A B !,""1" '&.*'&@4&'(@"(!*($""%!&('
A ($!"(1" '
&.*'&@4&'(@"(!*($""%!&(' A <<!,"'"(!"(%"', -"
0""($&"%!"$!*(%(%*"(!<1 (!,"<&.,!#!," 0-"8!,"% *'"#?,&%,!,"4"!&!&(", $ 44 %,"$ !,&' *! !,*., !," &('! (! 4"!&!&( , ' 0""( "($""$ &(#*%!**' ?"-"8!,""&' (!," '4"%! ( C
!,&'*!, $
D E 4 ''"$!,"#<<?&(.$") F6" ("$%*('"<#!,"4"!&!&("&(!" <& %(!"($'!, !
=$ !"$=
? '".&'!""$ . &('!!,"4"!&!&("*($""%!&(
:"%!&('
8
G $$"$< !"(;&( <&%"! !&( &-&'&(>8 < ($, B #!"&(-"'!&. !&(!,"4<&%"#&<"$ "4!*($" "%!&(> (!,"0 '&'?,""#!,"4"!&!&("? '%, ."',""!"$ !# %"!& <*($""%!&(' 8
($
" $?&!,"%!&( B&( !," !& < ?,&%, "('*"$ !," 4'"%*!&( <"$ &!' "(!&" "-&$"(%" 01
CB !," $"#"(%" "-&$"(%" <' <"$ &!' "(!&" "-&$"(%" 01
CB!,"" #!" ( 44<&% !&(? '#&<"$01!,"4'"%*!&(*($" "%!&( #"% <<&(.#!?4'"%*!&(?&!("''"'?,&%,? ' <<?"$01!,"& <*!( C =
C ($!,"" #!"!,"'"?&!("''"'
?"""H @&("$B(
!,"4"!&!&("5''! !"@"(!*($""%!&( ? '"%$"$01!,"& <*!B!,*.,$"$ !"$
(!," 44<&% !&(? '#&<"$01!,"! !"*($""%!&( ! "% << (!," 4'"%*!&( ?&!("'' ?,&%, ? ' $&'@&''"$B ( =
AC
#&( < .*@"(!'?""4 !<1 $$"''"$0"#"!," & <*! ($!,"@ !!"? ' $3*("$##*!," .*@"(!'B!,"" #!"8 #(" <1!?1" '!,"4"!&!&("5'!& <, '0""( $3*("$('"-" < %% '&(' ($(?&'4'!"$#=
($!, !!," #"$"< 1&( $&'4' <#!,"4"!&!&("5'!& <&'"&!,"0"% *'"('"-" <%% '&('!," 4"!&!&("8?,&'&(%*'!$18? '(!4$*%"$01!,"4'"%*!&(0"#" !,"& <*!0"% *'"!,"& <*!@"%, (&% <<1 $3*("$!," @ !!"5#4$*%!&(# I'AI'5&('4&!"#!,"# %!!, !'*%,"H"%&'" , $ <" $10""(-"<(. . !&%"#@!&( *(6*!, 88 *(3 0 %%"4!'(!&%"(0", <##!,"! !"
($4 1'#!&@"!'""+&('!*%!&('A#&<""4<1 $3*("$!
0"! +"(*4&(!,"*."(!% '"' "#"!," $3*("$$ !" ( ##&$ -&!#!,"@@&''&("#
<&%"8 < ($, ', <<0"#&<"$$"! &<&(.!,""&(!,"" '(' '!?,1 #!" =
('"-" <%% '&('!,"4"!&!&("? '(!4$*%"$0"#"!," & <*!% *'&(.$"< 1&(!,"$&'4' <#,&'!& < ,"&'!&%! ($"''&('*$."8 < ($, ', << <'4"'( <<1 <+&(!!,"@ !!" ($#&<" "4!&( '" <"$%-" '!?,1 #!" =
!,"4"!&!&("5'!& <? ' $3*("$#4$*%!&(# I'AI'
?,"( '4"!,"$"'4< %"$(!,""%$01!,"4"!&!&("8 <<!,"
I'AI', $ <" $10""(4$*%"$@*%," <&"J (4*'* (%"!!," #"K*!"$$"#!,&'*!8!,"! !" , '#&<"$ '! !*'"4!&(*!!$ 1!,*.,?,&%,!,&'*!, ' 0""(&(#@"$!,"" '('#((4$*%!&(#!,"4"!&!&("A %%*'"$ 0"#"!,"& <*!?,&%, " '#<<?') ,"4"!&!&("A %%*'"$, $0""(! ('#""$#@"(! < &<8 7 4*!, < ! @&!' 3 &< 0*! ,&' 4$*%!&( ? (!'A'*@@('?""'"(!!"(! < &<87 4*!, <
( - &< 0&<&!1 # $"K* !" '"%*&!1A#%" &( !," @&!' 3 &<
D E '" <"$"4!$ !"$
#@!,"&'!&%!G"''&('
*$."8 < ($, , ' <'0""("%"&-"$?,&%,, '0""(4"("$&(*! ,"4" !&-"4 !#!,""4!" $' '*($") F#!".&(.!,*.,!,""%$#!,&'% '"@&(*!"<18!,".&'!&'!, ! !," %%*'"$, $#@ <<1%<'"$,&'"-&$"(%"( >
($!,"" #!"8 '
"H4< &("$&(!,"" <&"4 !#!,""4!8!,"% '""@ &("$4"($&(.@ &(<1 #4$*%!&(# %%*'"$ ($$"%&'&(( 44<&% !&(*($""%!&( I,"(!,"% '"? '4*!*4#!,"#&'!!&@"0"#",7&', (7 (! &(8$$<"''&('*$."8 < ($, 8(>
8&!? '#&H"$# 4$*%!&(# %%*'"$ '?"<< '#'*@@(&(.!," I',"" #!"8!,"
% '"? ' $3*("$#"H @&(&(.!,""@ &(&(.I'8&# (18 ($# .*@"(!',"##&%", '""$01#&H&(.!,"% '"&(&!& <<1# I'( #&'!$ !" ($'*0'"K*"(!<1#!,"I'(!,"'*0'"K*"(!$ !"'8?,"" ' !,"$"#"(%""-&$"(%"? ' <" $1%<'"$( >
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
D 76E ', @'," I,"!,"'4" +&(.A" '("$ ) "'A I,"!,""4! 0<"
)"'A