High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/305/2022allowed

Suresh And ANR v. Union Of India And ANR

2023-09-13Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj24 pages

!"#$# % % #

& '! ( )'

# %* %#

!" # $%& '( ++++ * %#

, #- ). ) * +* !,-./-/-/0-//-/!!1-./-/!23 "."4"!! 5

6 ! 7 # * & $++ +!4.- & * %*+-8-1/-/-23 "05

9"88/- /-!. 6 : ; <0 /-/!%*+-!-1/-/! 6+

! ( *

+ * && =+ & & $++ 2 6 > ?5 6 *&

: ++ @ &

( *+=+ *( *% 6 * .0,0 A :& # & %6 *+ ( & -4 !41- & * !.-/!480 *

6 *&

;( * :& # %6 *+ !< 6 6* * * 6* ++6 # & * + ( *

& /.-.!44/*6 &&=+

& 6 & 6+& 6 * 6

+ &

& # ) +

6 "

&* 6* B + + =+ * ' + ( ) + 6+6 + &

+ %6 *+ & (& & 6 " ( ## + *# + /--< & * & & + /,-./-!< 6

* &

: //!-/-!- * & !/ + #& 6 B < 6+6 =+ + %6 *+ # 4-.,0! C <0 D & ( *& # #& 6 ( +& * & ( & $++ + 6$ + (* &

+ 6 "

$ +=+ 6

*9 88/- /-!.+* 6 + 6% & 6 # * * -0-./-!8&&

6 ( D + 6 6 + 6 ) & 6 ++ C%*+ -8-1/-/-

!<<8 /-!. >+=

E = 6 /1!//-!, %*+ -8-1/-/- +* 1 & = & * + * + " # & &$ ) " #&

+ ( & &$ * 2 52= 5& *6*& & F4G +) %*+ 9"!<<8 /-!. "#$ "

%& %%' (

) *"

+,-.

% /

" /

# #

# $

# / # /

-4 "

)6 * 88/- /-!. 6 =+ 7 2+ 5 & + %*+ -8-1/-/- & * %*+ + & + & + =+ " + D"!144 /-/-/!-,/-/-

6 &

& 6 ' + ( & & +( *& * + 6*++6 # && + =+ 2 5 & *6 +

* ' + ( + *& ' + #

& *+ * ( * ) " # & % +

* + * + =+ !,-./-/- * * ( * %

*) 3

6 D# !

/ $

" #

" 6" "

5 8

$ "

# #

" "$

(

5 ##

$ " #

# #

5 "

# #

" " "

5 8

$ " #

) & 6 * + : & D"!144 /-/- & * (& + :

6 " #& # ; <0

/-/!!--//-/!**%*+-8-1/-/-

6 *: =+ "+ # (?6 : @ ; *

* 6

6 + " #

& + + ) 6 (?6 : & 6 * # + # ++ & *++ + * #

/0-//-/! %*+* + )3

/0-//-/! 6& 2

" "

5# "

" 6"

# "

" # 9

# /

5 " ##

$ " #

# #

" "

# #

" " "

5 8

$ " #

); <0C/-/! 6 " # =+ & +

6 : -!-1/-/!6 * :

# " #

;

<'- -!2 * *"

+, # /

9 /

'-'= -&'

2'% -<!

8#0 ;5$ >

% !%' 2

$ /

" ?,

) .

# /

## A# 1

)%.

## ## #

## @

# /

@ /

@ 1 / @"

0 "

@ 8

## " #

# ##

/9"

@ 9 " 1

# 0

)1+1.

# ).

" #

5# /

# ).

# ;

$ ;

/ A#

" = "

# ##

* " /

*, /

# 0

0 /

##9

" # ##

" #

); * + * +%*+ = ?

& +

6 : & $* /0-//-/! +; 6 " # =+ & +; 0- /-/! * & 6 =

6 B

6 & +; 0- /-/!& +

*; ++

+ =+

& -/-0/-/! * D !144 /-/-)+ !144 /-/- & 6 -0!//-/! * * + =+

+* !1-./-/!23 "!!5#& +& %& * & **6 & +&6 + & & += &+6 6 ) 3 !1-./-/!23 "!!5& 6 + + & % * HIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIII 5 A 3+ * 3 "/ & $ ++ + !4.- & *6 B +8 6* *6 6 /.!-/-!8 * 66

6 +

%6 *+ + C + 6 # & > *? & B

* 5 )*+!4.- & + ++ +& *6 ++ # 6 ++

* + + + %6 *+ ++6

# 6* *

* + + *

* +C 3 +

C + 5 # + # 6*++6 # * 6 ' + / #& 6+ + J% 6 * + * 6

9 88/-C/-!. -8-1/-/- 6+* *6 B + & $ ++ J% 6

*6 * + * + 6 J%)

+ * + * 6 J% 6* + K ** 6 6

6 " # & + 6 / 6

6 ' + ( ' + + * !< C' + ' + (+ -0-./-!8+=+

& *6 + #& ( * * +

/.-.!44/)& 6+ /-!1 * /! + 6 3 6 * * C +*6 ) +* 6 & + *@ 6

+6 + * * + +

+ * 6 + 6+

C 6 +C &

+ 6 6 6 %

6 ' + # 6 6 !) 6 & %*+

6 & L; & +# & =+ 6 6 6 +

&* +* & 6 ).

"# ##

% ).

$ 9

5# " $ A

/ $

# $

" :

+ $

5# "

" @"

" "

+ D #$

5# "

% ).

+ $ -2'$

, D

# #

5# "#

$ "

" $ "

# "

: $

, D

+91#"

+ # 0 /#

# / $

" " "

$ +E1

5# "

" "#

9> $

" $

# "

: $

+ " +E1

#" 9 % ).

# / " #

) /

" $ A

/ $

" / $

+ "

" "

# 5# "

" / "#

# 5# "

) .

#9#

<=9'&9%' <,CC)+.

5$ #

# /

9> "#

# "

$ #

+ #

) / ##

" ,##

$ /

* +& E & +* *6 B + J%& * % * & $* * + * + !<-.!4.! + 6 & *6

& *6 ++ )

+ "

#" )

# .

/ / / /

$ "

# #

# # /##

/ / / / $

" " $

# 5#

/ $

*, # /##

# #

9 "

# #

' '2 -2'

" /##

# "

/##

$ "

# /##

" / "#

/##

## "

6"#

" "

/ /

9 /

" G

/ "

9 *

/ *

# "

" #

) .

# "

"#$

%&'()* +,) -)(.

,/( 0)1 "&*.'2- )'

.2.&

)3&'*4&*.$ 2*5 .,6( 4&2*( )# -/3&-/,))5 #)'

%2'./7/%2./)* /* *2./)*24)3&4&*.

A;87;

/ 0##

/ / # "

/## #"

*,A# /

# *6 && + * *6 + 6**6+ =+ & 6 5 & %62 5 + + ( +$ ++ C+ *@ + +!4.-& # ++ 6 + !. 3 "! ( 6+ *6 + 8 +

* B 6

* 6 +6 C + * +( ( * %6& ' + & * A :& %6 *+ +

+ ) * +$ * + 6* C

&# ++#

*6 % + B + 6 ( * * + + 6 & B + & 6 + + & %6 )

* + + + + + & + &

+ + 825 6 + E+ * + 6 5 6 + 6 +* 825 # & * 6% & * !< < +-0-./-!8 6 6 * : 6% & % * & % + E+ ( * + 6 63

+ = & & + 6 6 ++& ?+ * +=++= & = & % 6 : & * & ; 0- /-/! * 9 += + *

6 + 6 + 6 :

; <0 /-/! & : +; 0-C/-/! 6 6 B + % !1-./-/! & + %*+ : 9 * 6% 6 "

( * *

+& ++ 6 ++ 6+ *:M*+& 6 ? +

+;& 6 6% & 6 6( %*+ (E6 + + H8696*5 2- ,2*52'/ 2*5 ).,&'( :( ;*/)* )# *5/2 2*5

).,&'(< ) 3 (

# $ /

5" #

0 /#

" #

# # #

"# :

$ # ##

/ /

" "

0 /#

: $

" /

"$ ##,

# " #

$ "#

8 / "#

/ 0

" "

-2=

5 :

$ "

# / "#

6"#

/ /

# 0

# $

#$ "#

, #

$ I$

# "

# #

$ /

# ## 8

$ /

# "

/ "

" #

$ / "#

6" "

$ " "

# # 8"

# " 8

# 8

$ " #

# / "#

" /

# :

" #

# # 8

/ $

" 8

" "# 0

# $

# # $

# /

# #

* + 6% +& +6 + * & + ** ) + & 6 ++$&*3+ * & + ++ ) &

& 6

) +6* & +

6 6 * * +

* 6 *+ "

# 6 * *6 B + 6B 6 & *& ++ + ( ) 6 " # & 6 6 " ( & + *6 + =+ & & 6

6+6 +=+ //!-/-!-

6 *+ & & & & # 6 # &

+ *& 6

+6 # * * + 6 & 6

) + 3 & + * + + & +* 6 25

( * & & $* & * +%6 *+& *

+ !480

C # ++ 25 # 6 6 + & $++ + !4.- 6 # !. 3 # 25 ) + &&C+ + * 6*6 C 25 ) *6 6 8 + + 6

* ) *6& B

B + & B

6 +

* & + 6* 6 25 )+ 6 * ++ & 6 82 5 & & %6 6*

& +& ++ 25 ) *++ &

" *( * & * + + + +

25 ) * 6 " # * + 825 & B

+++ + + ) + 6

+6* +" 6 B + 825 B + 6 6&* &

* 82 5 ) *6 B + + 3 "##+63+ + /0 3 && 82A5

+ )(( )# )3&'*4&*.

=)1

" #

# #

/ $ /

## /

# #

) B + 6 $* ++

' + M6 > * +

+ + E) B > + 6 +

& + +?# ( * & &

& + + +

&&6*6 C B /0 3 7## 6* *6 B + & ++ +!4.- # +

6 *M* & 6 (E6 : + =+ 6 + = 6% & *6 -0-./-!86 %6 *: & : & * % +

& + 6% & 6 6 %6 )6 )6% +& 6 + 6 + * 6 + 66

&6* &

& + + ) 6 ++ & + 6 *6 6 * + "

3+ + & & % * ) + 6

A +

* + 6

" # ) " #& & +$ + 6%

6 !-----C"2 D; 5 ) * && 6 &3 6 ) &6 + + !4.- & //!-/-!- & & 6+ 6 + =+ -/-0/-/! &

& *& F0G +# *& 6 & + F4G + & * -* %#

. "#$## '20&*5&'

: 0 9

: #