Nafe Singh v. State Of Haryana



         



 






! "
#"$



%"&
'      

  

   !"

"
($)'
 "*
+, *

"
 
' "
"
# )
)-*
+.*
%"&

  


/ " $
 
", 
' 
)
$"
 
0 
"!*
' "

 ))
 
1$2

 , 

 3 3

""



4 3 3
'
5&
 
 $"

)"
+ )
 
6$)
"*
( )*
7 "5&
' "

5
 ,



$"
2'" 2

$"


"
 89



3
:!
/
$"
" " $
2'" 2
"

'" 

2 


'&





9*

 $)

'&2



$"
2')
2'" 2
"

& 
3
:!
/
$"
" " $
2'" 2
"

'" 

2 


'&





9*

 $)

'&2



$"
2')
2'" 2
"

& 
 0+
:! /
$"
" " $
2'" 2
"

'" 
7
&"


'&





9*

 $)

'&2



$"
2')
2'" 2
"

2  



0
 
:!
/
'&
 2' 



*

9

 
'

9,2*
7

" ,"
"
2 $
 "
" 2
' "
"
" 2

'" )
'" '"
$"
)7
 "
)'9;'"&
'" 
)) 7
"
'"
'')9", 
"
 &
'')9", 

'"*
 

 "
7
 
 

''" '"
$ "&
 " +))
 

,
5
""

"$
 $"")&

 ))

)
5
)

 
1$2

0 
'
5&
 
 $"

)"
+ )
 
6$*
( )*
7 "5&
'')

 
' "

5
2
7
2   

 



 


7
&"
7"
$"

 
 0+
5&
 
")
 $"

5
"$


&"

<" 

 

"
 
=:

 
'"

7
""

 
5

 
 2')
6 "

 
!$"
 
"

 "*
( )*
%"&
 

3 

5 $


'2*

) 7

7 
2
2"
7
'" 
 7"
)
<)-"

 
%-2
 

 "
,))
 "*
( )*
%"&*

 ))
"
"
 "
)*
$5>$)&

 
7&*

2  "
, )
5"
"" 
%
+
4?
2-
/"$-9/+/+
 
5
",
5&

","

@ 
'*
"

)
2"

'$5)
7&@
2
" 2
""
*
 ))9"22

 2
5&
"$
,"

7 
"$)

"


' 

$
1$"

2*
" ))&
-
$$
,

 
;
$ 
 
 "2 
2"9","

 


, )
2

'*
 ")&


$"

 
3*
3
9
 0+
:!
4?

7
""*
 >$)&
 
>$
'" 
$"
 
30
"!
3
) 7



, 
7


2  

+)
, )
7"
-

' )
'  
" 2
' 

$""*
$5>$)&

4  ' " 

$)&
 
5&
 
 2')
7
''" 

/ " "
 
2

7
$"
 
?"!
7"
" "
 '

 ))
7"
$'')

 
' "
"

 

'" ,
$"
 
 3
"!
0







 
' "*

7
 " 
"
 
 22 


'$ 5)
$"

 
3*
3

 0+

:
!)
 *
4?

*

7 

')
 
$)&

)2
")

+ "
"
5 
 
'"

 
 " $
 
" "*
 
)"
")
 $"*
,
2'$
1$2

 , 

  3 3

""



4 3 3
)
 
' "
$)&


2

 
2"

""
5 ,

+",

 
1$2

""
")
 $"*
' "
'" ""

'')*
7 
7
2
5&
 
+''))
 $"
,
2'$
1$2

0 

A"
 $)
"
 
' "


 
$52
 
' "

 
 )
5"
""


2)&
7
,")
)2

%
$" "
$52
 

 
 
 ))
 
 , 

 
' "

""

'"&"
)&
7
""

 
'" 



)"&
$" 
%
$" "
$52
 


)"&
5
' 

' "


"
2

"*
 " "*
)
,7
2&
5
-
>$



:
 
""


$52
 



 
&"


 
' "

$

"
 
 &

")9'')9", 
"
))
 
&"

:


0

$" "
$52
 
' "

)"&
$" 
,
2  
 
 )

7"
5&
 
")
 $"

8"
 
"$2*
 

2' 
$' 
 
' "
2&
5
"$

 

)"&
$" 
5&
 2

?


 
 "
*
)"

 $)*
7 )
'' 
 
$52 
2
5&
 
)"
 $)
"
 
' "*
7 $)
$52
 
 

7"

 
' "


'" ' " 

 


 22
5&
2
/ 
' "
 
 
",
&
)&

% 7,"*

$52
 
' "

"
2

"


 "


'

2



$" 
$)


2  
?
&
$

 )



&"
3
:
,
"
)"
 $)
"
 
'"

'"$
 
" "

4 / 
 $"


 
,7
 
 



 
&"
*
 
' "

$

"
 &

")9'')9", 
"
))
 
&"


'"
$ &
" 



$" 
5&
)"

 $)*
' "

$" 
$)

"

'" 

2  

?
&

 $
-'

,7
 


"$2*


1$

;'

"$
 

' "

 
'" 
)"&
$" 
5&
2
:

)
'" '  

)7
 




5



'$)"


"$2
/ 
,7
-
5&
 
 $"
)

$'' "

" 2
 
1$2

 
% @5)
$'"2
 $"

 



 

        
     

 

!"
#

$  %&

'

 (

 

)*+), )-.

 
1$2


 $"

/  $

 %&

'

 0)* . --


/ 
"),
5", 
2
5&
 
% @5)
$'"2
 $"

 




!"#$%&%'%#
$'"
"

$"

      


   

       

               

 
  

                    
        

         

             

  

     



       
          



    

 !  
    

        "       
  

   !    
   
   #    



2)")&

 


#

 $
$'"
 
+';
 $"

5",

$"

$      
       

     

     
     % &%'&'&'      "  
   

 

      
         ( !    

        

             

 
  

   



    

 

     

      ( !    



)
        *+     

   
   ,    


       

      #      +-.     



?

(          /
       (!          

   



  
       

  

      

    
        

        0  

 
    
:
 


   $
$'"
5&
)) 7
 
1$2

 
% @5)
$'"2
 $"

/  % 1

   

 2 30 )!    *!*
 
 $"
7 )
$' )
 
 , 

 
' "
 "

"$
 


 
' "
5&
5",

$"

1(    
            

 

   
  /

       (


   ! 3 

   

 2 34      
   4  

    
        
      
      *

  5     

 

 
 
    (


   !     

 2 3(   &
'  

      (!

      

 
 
          
       -       

   / 

     6 
 

   4    76 1%*4   

       

  

  

     

 

              

                 



   

4        #            

 

 

3

      



         
       

     
    
     

  
     $         
              
     

  

  


  
   8            

           

    

  


         

  

       

        
         
       9  

   
 

   :    
   
              /  


  8      
 


   ;        

                
     
 
       
                  ( !  

        
   

   
 
 


 
      

  - 4   

    
 
    #   ,    

  

 

         "    !   

  



              4 



 

       


     4   

   
 

     <   

      

       /

=

+,"

 


 
'"


-'

,7
 
2
"$2
 
5 ,


,7

4

)
'" '  

)7*
 
 $"


 
 "
,7



 

 )$
 
 


1$
7 $)
5
>$)&
2

 


 
' "

""

5
"$

 
'" 
)"&
$" 
5&
2

:
,7

 
'$)"


"$2
'"

 
5 ,*
 $')
7
 
" 
 "2 *
 
 , 

 
' "

 
"2)
", 
' 

$' )
% 7,"*
 


""

5
"$

 
'" 
)"&
$" 
5&
 
' "
/ 
2
7 $)*
7,"*
5
$51

' 

 

 *

9
5&
 
' "
7
 
<"
)"-
+  *
!$15

%"&
%
 $"*
 " *
7 

'" 

7
2  
" 2
 &

:

2
)"
 


 
 "
2 $

 *

9

 
' 
7 
 
'$)
'" *
 
 
'"
", 
' 
7 $)
5
2

,
5
2
14.

:2'$
1$2

 , 



"2
7
5 ,
2   
/ 


 2' 

7"
$"

 
 
"!
5&
 
")
 $"
 ))

2

/ 
2
 ))
5
'
7 
7
2  
" 2
 


'

 
""*

 

'
 D' 

!
'')  *

&*

' 


,7

 
 "
1$2 (   ) 






















 B  "
'-9" 


C9 B  "
' "5)


C9