Pardeep & ORS v. Suresh Kumar & ANR
!
!
"#$ #!
! !
% !
!
"#$ #!
! !
#& ' !
!
"#$ #!
! !
"# $%&'
# ()!
")*)!
* * #"! $
! ( )$# * ) +, - + .
& &
!$ )$* /& +& &
*, - *+ %0+ .
!
!$
2 &! + ! -& -
!&$$ !$345+43 43 .63! & &
! & , - &! **'& ' ,& * &
8-
*& - . !!02 &! 9 $53 .555 & *!!*#& '
!,!$ # %0
6$6$6:
<$
-
, & -+.- !0& ' / .
$345 .63
= *& '!-
* & = -
!+
&- !2
0 &!! !
!$ !*.
& &
!!0 & ! !
!= &- 02 &! 02%'
6$6$6:
;
8< ' & &
! . 2!-*!=& !!
** = -.
. %'
7 ..&*& . =& & &
+ ! -! 20+0 !&0 .& !
0 ' !& ;
& -
! & 02 !
! ,& '-
.,
!* ' 2 ,0 '*&>& !,&-!
*&-2 . ,
%0 ?$4$6$-
!
& &
! & * !.
& &
.'*&> &
02' ' . 2!-*!*
'=& !!** = -$-
! .& *-&!&
+= &- !0
/ 02 !
! = &* !!& ' ?$?$63 :
8<+&!& ,& * &
. !!02 &! # !-&**2& *&' . .- ;
& & .,
!+= &- =!-
! & & -
*& - =& &- &
!&!!02 # $ !+-
! !
!!, 0 -'& !
. !
- +5@$ !*.
!
!+
+!0 & ! !-
!
0*! 6$6$6 :
8<!!02 &! 9 $53 .555 !
!,&,! # ** = *.02 #
%0&$$&,&** $5@A .6402%'
3$?$65 :
;86<$-
! &,&!&
- %'
. &!
'=& %'
!!02 # = &- *! .&*$ & &
! - # 02.&*& ' -
& &
+= &- =! !& 2*&- &
&!
&!!02
3$$6:
83<02 ' 3$?$65!!02 # 0 !0! &**2-
*& =&
'!,&,& -
$. !0 & ! , ! -*& +! !0 =& ' !+&!
!! & 0*! & &
! .&* *&- &
0.
# 0& '$$ $4 .63.
! 0 .& += &- =!&!
&!! 02 @$$63:
8B<=& *&0 2 *&- !
- & .
$ &! -**2.*- ! #
, %'
!!02 &! 9 $ 53 .555 !-
!-*& ' ! *&.+= &- !0 -*& 02 # +
0*$ + ! ! .& * -&!&
=& ' & * . & &
!=!*. 0 / 02 # += &- +& ;-&! .& !
&!- &
+ ! - -
!& -*&
! !! !/& ?$?$63:
8<%- & ' &-*& $ + !+-
! !-
!!, 0&!
&!!$ , - !* .
&! =& & !!&! -+ ,'
' - ! . -!$ &.*2+ .- ! . -! & &
! , - &! 02.&*& ' 0 ,.=& & &
2& '.
=& !&- & ' !
! ' 2!-* . ! ! *02
& -&* .CD*2.
D*= /C !
.*
'=& & ! $ !&=& & &
=!** =02 &!
; & &
!=' . 2!-* =& !!** = -.
. %'
& &
!+ = = * 2& 2!55A 55@
-
* & .&;02 #
64$$6= &* & &
!= ' ! *&.0 .
..&*& . =& & &
$ ! -*& 02 & &
!=!!-&.&-**2-*& $ # %0 - # '& ! %'
!!02 &,&!&
- . &! += &- =! 0 !&,&** $5@A .64 & *!# %0
,!$ #%& #& ' !$ !&*=!** =02 # 02 3$?$65:
;86< &- &
=!&!! # ; -!! . & &
! 02 ' ;
& =& ' & &
! & * . 0 .& +!
-*& 02 + = & -&*! . *=*& = & %'
. # ,&>$+! = & &
!! &!.2 .- !.
& , - &
. -&!&
& # .2 "!$ %& #& ' + :6A< 5 # 46 & & ! & 2 & -*& ' D! &
.
& ! . -& *! ,0 .
** =$ =!
. 0!, 0 , !& &,-
- D*& 2 -*!-
& &-*3!
*0& , /
*2= &! !& &**2!& = !!& &., &!*'*
&**'* *20-!!
% ! ,'
0 .& + ! 02 & !*. = *
0 ' .
; & ' ! 0 .& & &
!$ #& - !
!&
-
*2=& !!02 # + & &
!.&*
& &
:< $43 .6$
!& -
& &
+!
8# .&* ..&,& 4$@$6 :
; 86<+ = & & =! ! ;
& + = &- 0 -
! & + !0 & & !
65$@$6 ! = *0-
!&02 # ,
*,* . &.#- 2 ,
%0 !
..&-&*!$=
!C & =!! 0 / .
!& 0*-&!&
&
&! . ' !- & 2 . . ; -
& $ =!*!
& ,
%0. *&-2 ,&& !* ?$4$6.
'*&> &
. !,&-! .**&*2 ='= /!!0%- -
& &
2*&'&0*.
! !+ '& ! = &- 2== /& ' ,-
* 2! .!,&-!
4$6$6A$ . + & &
* ..&,& $$6 :
84<=!.&*& # = &- & =!! . ;
& =!& .,
! ,
*'*
0 & .
, - *+ %0+=!
!& &,!&!
.! & &
!-
- $
C0*# += &* /& '&
-
!& &
!0!D ..&,& .&* 02 # + !! 3$$6 :
; 83< &!
&!!& ' -
& &
2*&- &
$ .6+= & & =!
5A * 2! ,*20 '*&> *4 & &
!+ =
.*.&* *&'&0&*& 2 -& &+
!
, - &-* D*&.&- &
+
!*. % 0+ = ,&
&!
-0*$ # =! .
3$?$65!!& &,&** $646 .64 0 !0! &**2 -
*&=&
'!,&,& -
+= &- =!
+ !& 2*&- &
,& C! @$$6$ . + & &
.&* 2*&- &
$4
.63& &,&** $646 .64+= &- - .
& '
0.
#
@$$63$ !&*&- &
+
. 2!=!.
' ' & &
! ! .2.
.
.&*& . =& & &
7 .%'
. &' $ !& *&- &
=!&!
&!!
@$$63:
8B<=& *&0 2 *&- ! - & .
$
& &
! ,
=.&* !-
!**'& '
8-
*& - . !!02 &,&!&
- . &!
9 $53 .555 6$6$6:
8<$
&! /& ' -
. - !*.
!
!
=& ' 0&*& 2 . !-
!& *&' .
%'
!!02 # += 02 * . # =!** =+ &! +& & !-
!&
.& !& !*.& '
=& ! $ &,&!&
- . &! ** = =& & &
!02%'
6$6$6+'& ! = &- # .
%0 - # $ !*!=** =02 # ,&%'
3$?$65:
;86<$ 9& -- - . *!+ !!02 &! '=&
. # & &! %'
. # += &- . *! .&*$ !-
!+ .
+= *
0
0*& &! $ &!
!
.
-- & ' 0%- &
=& ' 0&*& 2 . !-
!$ & &
!
,*2 - # 02.&*& '
& &
:<
, $43 .6& &,&** $646 .64+= &- =! !
2*&- &
$,& @$$6
0!&! . ..&,& !+= &- ,0 .&*& # = &- ,0 . & 0 ,+ # -
&!
&!! ! ,& 3$$6:
83<+= &- !
!.
** =!(8 *&' . !0!D ..&,& .&* 02 !
$6 ' =&
;!
=& ' &
5A * 2! ,*20 '*&> * 4 & &
!+ =
.*.&* *&'&0&*& 2-& &+
!
.*.&* - &-*D*&.&- &
+
!*2*.
% 0+ = 0
&!
-0* &! /! .&' .4$ !+& -
!&
+ 3$?$65 !!& &,&** $646 .6402 &! !
,0 !0! &**2-
*&=& $. 0!
+
'
!,&,!& -
+= &- !* 0 ! & 2 *&- &
,& &! C! @$$6$ &!-- & '*2&!
&!!$F #& - -
& &
.&* 02 & &
! ! !
*2&!
&!!+ !-
!
0*$ # &** . + & &
! '& .&* 2 *&- &
$4 .63& &,&** $646 .64+= 2 02 & &
!=!!.
** =!(8 &!+ .
+
! !- .**2 2 ! &! 2'-& !*20*! ** = &!*&- &
' ! .2 *&- !
!& ! .
&- &
!-
& %'
6$6$6!! 9 $53 .555+ !!!- .
!! &!
C0* 2 .& & .- ! -&- ! -! . -!$F !&& 2*&- &
!- .
& '0.
C0*#
@$$63:
8B< = .
** =& =!!!(8
$$ $4&!&!
&!!=& *&0 2 *&- !
- & .
$F !*.
& &
! !!! -
.
!!02 &! ; 2 ,
0 '
. 2!-*!*
'=& !!** = -.
2= & * ! %'
. &,&!&
- . &! &! 0*+= &- 0,& !*2-
*20!& 0!+!!,&-!
!! '*&>! *&-2 . ,
.
%0 ?$4$6+-
0-- & .- . @$$63 .
C0*# -0 ,$ *&' . 0!, &
! 02 # -*& ' 2*&- &
$4
!,& @$$63+ -0 ,+!*!
!!02 &,&!&
- . &! ! ! '=& %'
. # +! *0 ,+ !-
! -*& & &**.
0*$ ,&= . 0 ,+ !-
!&!
&!!!
0*$
& &
! 2,&* . & 2+&. 2,&*0* + -- -=& *='& ! ?$?$63:
8<$ "-.- /
0")*)!
* * #"! $1 % ()*