← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/1513/2015dismissed

Harsimran Singh v. Hussan Lal I..A.S And ORS

2017-07-18Mr. Justice Krishna Murari9 pages



       

 !!"#$#%&'()*+, -$#.-%/#%01 2 ! # #%!- 3$ '$$%4(+/%5%- 2 !$6%5!% $ &  74

 / / 88 

-!$!% &8

-/ 9 +5:" !- 1!6! # #%!-

$$(!!%;'-/#51'++ '%<=

-/;!1-+5:" !- 1!66(#"% 8- <#%5!-/#%01 88  1!6! # #%!-1$#(!5 1!6-!$!% 6! # #%'%5!-/!" #%$ %5   1! % !.6   '- $ "  ((!0#%0 1  1! <'50.!%  5 !5 !"!.=!- + > 6$$!5 =) 1#$ '-  #% ?   ,@>  8 --$#.-%/#%013$/  ! '%<=%5 1!-$++1$% =!!%".6(#!5 9# 1=) 1!-!$6%5!% $ !-!5:!- #%0  1!((!0 #%$+# #$5!!.!566-6-# !  66-!"# ! 1!- # 1!<'50.!% 91#"1#$((!0!5 1:!=!!%:#( !5 1!6! # #%!-15$'01 9-# #% 1!% '-!A'B9--% 0#%$ -

<#%5!- /#%01+ /!%#- 4!" '-!-+ 5!$#0% !5 $ $$#$ %  -!$$- #% 1!

!6- .!%  61 1(.(0)+:!-%.!%  !5#"(((!0!+  #(1! $#59-# 6! # #%9$((9!5%5 1!((9#%05#-!" #%9$6$$!5&8  



 

               

   



 

   

     

   !

 

   

  

    

" !"  

      !

   

 

   !



 



   " 

# 

  !

  

      

      

 !    $%

 !       !       

 ! 

 

 # 

    

 

   ! 

  !

 ! "   "     

 &  '

  

 

                (       )   *      +  , " -$./ . 00 .1$2 !          !    #

 

!"

    "      

 

   !

   !  #

!

 & 3

4  

   

     

  !

 &     !



 

5  

5 

   (    "      6 &  

 -88%/ 00 $   (    



      

    

     

      5 

5 

5 

 9!   

 "      :       !

     5      

     !

 

  !

    

 ! 

   



     

  

          !" 0 

 

 #

    

    



 

            

  "     

";  

     

"  



      "! !" 0 

       

"   5  " !

 

 (  

     !

  : &  "

 

      ( 

  ( 



   !





 

 





 " "  0     

      !"    

   (       

 

    :

 "

     

  (               &      

(  !

 

 

       "

       

     

  <  & 

  (  ! "   "

:

 

   

   0

"    

  "  ! 

     " 

 : 

 

 

!

"

  !

"

 

 

   !

 

 

 

     !" "      

  

        

  !

   

  

  

    " <

0   =:

& &    

   

   

  " +    

     

    !" 8$$           "



      



"

: "!& 

 .8 >   " 



  

  &   !

"

   

 !" 

     " !"  =       

  !

    

(

      <

            

  !"  

    

"

    ?

  ;   @

                            "  

   





           !     !

       

  

    

  

 

      



!      "  

 



& 







 

&   

   & 

 

" .$ :   

      

" !

 

!

  

 

 

   #"



  

"



  !

   # "

"!"

A 

 

  -     /    "!   "  

    !

 



  



  





" . <

  

" !

 " 

   "   



;

  

  

&       

   "       

     

!"

 ( 

   

"

"  

      

 *!  7

 "   <     &     " !     "    "  

     

  



 

 

 " 

     

!  

  !"  

   

  



      

  "  

     

&       :

 @!   0

  !

   &   



 

"    

 

 " B !   " <

   







     " $$     



  "  

  !

     

&       



  :   ,>CD  

     

   !

   !"         ..  

7

 "   

   



  



   (   !"  &

     !    "



 

 :  8$8         



 !"    



               "    

 

      

 

 

 

 





 )    , 

  @#! 

!#   .A

 ,>CD @#!   

    





 !

<     

" !

    

&         ! 

  

"

  !"



 

 <  

, 

  ! 

  !      

 !  "

 !"   (

  !"

     !

   !  

  "



"      $A$%  !    E     !

   (  E  

   

         ( 5  * #  ,  $  D   *      

@

C  D 5

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

 -5!-6-. #%%5 1 1!1$(-!5)=!!%-5!-!5 =!-!:!- !5 1#$ 6-!:#'$6$ $6!- 1!<'50.!%  1!'-   1!6$ /!%#-4!" '-!

 -!85!$#0% !5$$$#$ %  -!$$- %51"=$#$!($=-'01   1! % #"!  1! '-  1  1! (%0 9# 1 - %#( ;'.- 15 =!!% 6-. !5 9# 1 1! 6! # #%!- %5 15 ($ =!!% -5!-!5  =! -!0'(-#F!5 :#5!:!-%.!% -5!-5 !5'()E+ %:#!9 1!-5!-$1:#%0=!!%".6(#!59# 1+ 1!6! # #%!- 9$'%%!"!$$-#()"(#.#%0 1  1!-5!-1$=!!%:#( !5  #$% ' 6("! .!% #%1!-! 1 -!$6%5!% 15 ($#(!5%4 >91#"19$6!-.# !5 =!9# 15-9% 9# 1(#=!- ) .:!%66(#" #%--!"((#%0 1!-5!-5 !5!"!.=!-+ >=' 1!5#5% 6  .:!%)66(#" #%9!:!-+6! # #%!-- -$#.-% /#%0115 .:!5     >*8?

 , - 5#-!" #% 1  -!$6%5!%   $1'(5 =! -!:!- !5 ="C  1! 5#-!"  A'  6$   /!%#-4!" '-!-%51"=$#$#% 1!!6- .!%  61 1(.(0)1! $#566(#" #%1$(-!5)=!!%5#$.#$$!5=) 1!/#%0(!!%"1% )+ ,=)6$$#%0 1!((9#%0-5!-&8 > " 

  !

 0 

 

  &     0"   +      ! !  



(    @  

   

   

#

     @F  

    " 

 !

  

:   

   

    



    (    



    ! 

   

   

       

  C



      ;     

!

  





   ( 

 

 G        

  ;   ;

 

  



   



    0   "

    

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