Manoj Kumar v. Post Graduate Institute Of Medical Education And Research Sector 12 Chandigarh Through Its Director






     
 




   



 

    !



           



     

   
    

 

 !   

 "  
" # $%&'( ) *+,-.
( *.-($ "

#"+#"$

# $%&'( ) *+,-.
( /./(0 +.

 

  !"#$%! &$ ' $ 

 (!"#$%! &$ '$" ))))

 

 ( * +' $+, 

"$$&% ,  - , $&"( %
./0 + $"' +% $  ' 

,  +%$&1   +$& % $  &$ 2+ ,   ('+," $" "" 345035/6 '" *7

CWP-1302-2019 (O&M) -2- - "(  #  *+-!  "

,   % !  "

,  8  &&"$9 *+-:;
 '++% $&   "# ( "" /45<35/4!   ' $!1 $*-$,$ % "+-" *%,$7! "''- "&$  '$$& $='1   '$"' "# ("" /45<35/4! - 7% $& '$1'% "&$--$1 ,. 
# $    !

    %   %

  #

!

   !

 % "  
 
!

    

!&  '( ) %   

*(     +"

    ! 

 

  ,

"!   

"

 -)   

" "-  "

(  

 

 .

!



!& '( )  *(  



!

   !

 % "  
 
!



!& '( )%  /  0

 )   +"

    ! 

  

 "

 -)  

  (  - %

( 



1   ' $ " '"  8 - ,(; "  1"%-"$* - *-' %+ (+-$& '$  ' $ " +*( "  $ - ''- $ *&$    *+- &$

+%$&"

% $$ '$"$ (- *-!*+ (  * "

( " # "   ('+," $" ' ( -7 $*# ,   2+ #-% $& "+% $- 2+- $  '+-7  %  %- %"( %

CWP-1302-2019 (O&M) -3- ("  $*%$ ""*7 ''$' + $ 7>?'  $$*7'% %$""+-7'+*-  "' $$ $$&%+ ('$% "&+  ' $ " (-&"( "   +"

"9(@$ 7 $& +*@% +,  $"+,>  - ,(:  +% !   * %$%-+""     $ "+ ,>   - ,(  "

&& &$( $ "+ ,> -,(   '$" '+.&$   %$  &&% '$$&

$ =' 1 "# " $ /45<35/4   ' $ 1 "%-"

- *-$355/35/A*7 %+ 7%$((  1$ # ,  2+ 2+- $ %+ ('$% *%$%-+"""  +-  * "%-" $1#! &   "%- $ $&   +-!   %+ (+-1(""$345B35/A"1"# (  * +" $ /3/53535 $ & -- +'   # -*- " #% '$   ' $%$*%$ ""&$ '$"# "  735/4  1 - *- '$ $& ( C # "-"%$+-&$ ' "'+"  %$"
 *,+"*7 -"%$+-&$ ' $   ' ", $-" 8 -,(;"$  *  $&   2+ #-%!   - *- &$   '$ $& $ ='   ' $  * "%-" - *- 1  $+ & ,   ( $  ?' %$((  + ($!   +- # * ("" *7   '$" "   - 7 %   * '% *" &$ --  ", $-"
+% % %+(%! %*& -7+(" #

CWP-1302-2019 (O&M) -4- '   # $ $&   '$"!   1 2+    ", $&  -" *7   ' $ " %$2+-7! --    # *

%-+""  +*2+("(D"%$+-&$ ' '-%" - %+'$  "% $ "" *7   $+  D $ ///5$&35/3!@+=+(  $&7"$ !"% ""$ 355035/3 $ ,+     (  - *- $ * &" $  ?' %$((  $ ,$ $   2+ $ $& 2+ #$-#"    ' %  %$7!  *,+"*7 -"%$+-&$   '$"     -% $ '$% "    7 35/4  %+-( " ' $1$ # , 2+ 2+- $  '$  $&  ( " %$2+-7!   ( 1 ?( " *7   %+ 7 $(( " ' $1"%-"$- *-' %+ ( +-$& '$ ("(   +- #*% "$+ +*2+,&"%- $$& +-!  +-1(""$ 345B35/A "  &!  &  "# (  * +" $ /3/53535  '   1 ("(! (7 $  % , # *

%$'$" 1 % !   ! %-+" --    , $-" $1#! +%  ("( 1 -- $ + 7 *& $ ' " (%$*("$*$'% # +$$#!  (1  ,"$2+ #-%%$*%$ ""*7 $+  ( '  $   %"( % ( "   $+ %$ ?' 7 "& $'

$ +'$ "( "-7!   ' $ " ''- " &$   '$ $& $ =' '++%$& "# (""/45<35/4
 $*

CWP-1302-2019 (O&M) -5- "

'+"  ' 8 -,(;" - 7 %  1 '% *"  $,"+ , >    - ,($&%$, E" # 7>
 + $
 ' $$  # F2+ #-%G -$*'% *"  - 7%    ' $  *"%-" - *-$  %$   %$+-"$ ( - 7% '% *"  "# ( % -7! %$$#7   % $ &&%  $1   '  -"$*%$ ""- *-&$  '$$ * $& 2+ #-%$$  -" *+- - "+'$"% $  %$&  
 





 
!"#!$
%

#!&
%  -7 "$1   ( F2+ #-G  $ $ * %$ ""  ?%

+ ($!   -"  *+-  -$ '-%" +'$ "% $    % $& ' (

)( 

 
* 


 
+,
#&-.

/&#
) 00

+

 

' 

,


 
#&1.$
%

1-
" 



 

2
+ 
!""!$
-

!.!
$ $-"  $+ $+-"& &$(?' ,7 "&  $'

$ *$+   2+  1$ "

&& %"( % 2+- $  -"%$+-&$ '$" $+, $,+   (1  ,"$ 2+ #-%%$*%$ ""*7 $+  (  "$( $& ?'
 ,"! (7*( $"   (1  ,"$ 2+ #-% $*%$ ""*7  ?'%$(( " $+ $+( , $-$&?' "( , 2+   % $+% &

CWP-1302-2019 (O&M) -6-  "% $$&2+  #! (  $1$**"$ ?$+$ -#%$ " $$%+"1  (-& "$+&& &$( '# 7 $ ( &-7 1$, $1#!     %!   (  $ * ?( " *7   ?' %$((  "  +%  % %+(%!   -- * ''$'  $ &   ( $   ?' %$(( $"(  2+ #-%
  $ * "

'+"   $ %"

"    %,$7 %  ' $ "''- "1-%""''$ " '++%$&  "# ( +"  735/4"& '$%&$''$ ( * "   "(  $ $& 2+     % +( +* - , %%$%%$+$&+*2+"#-$'(1  ," $ ("(   +-' ,$ - 7% '% *" &$   '$ $& $ =' "( "-7!   %+ ( +- 1 ("" $ 345B35/A "   - 7 % %-+"" --    ", $-" 1%+ (+-'$# " - 7%  &$--$1 ,. 

# $   !


% %   %  #
$  % !

  
 %   %   %  % 3     

!&  '( )4 567  , 1 #    * $*#"    ('+," $"     ' $ " (-&"( "   +"

"9(@$ 7$& +*@%  +,  $,"+,>  -,(:

CWP-1302-2019 (O&M) -7- "  +% !  1 "( " %   $,"+ , >   -,( "

&&&$($"+,>

-,($1#! '%$& # $$+, $*'+.

&$ *7 ' $%$*("$*+&& % $+, $"

%"

 %- ( &$ & ,   ( $  ?' %$(( ! ' %+--7 *%+    +*2+ ("( --    , # *

%-+""    - 7 %  $$#! &$ 1$

, $+   2+ #-%! $ ( ( %- 2+ $  $ * "1   ( F2+ #-%G $$*%$ ""F?%G
 $*  & 

+* -2+  1$2+- $! ' $*%$(  -" $ * "  2+ #- -7!   "

&&%    $(%-+ %$ * (" $ *  ,$+" $ "7 2+ #-%

+ ($!  $ $(%-+!*+ %$$& %+ %+-+(> 7--*+  $*-$$ " $1 -"( ,2+ #-%
    $& % %+(%!   '$"  "

%" $ %$ +($& ?'$?(  %+ %+-+(>7--*+$&  %"( % 2+- $ $&   ' $ # ..#    - 7 % '% *"  "# (" &  &$+" *$  %$+ *$"-7 " +* --7   (!   ' $ * "  - *- %"

" '% # $&   $(%-+ $&   1$ %$+     ?%   ,"*% "$+1 ' $"$&1$($ &$(  "$&% '$&% "%$'7$& @+",(
 &+ "

%"   #! ' ,, #" *7   "% $ $&   ?' %$((  $    #!   "% $ $& ?' %$((    &#$+ $&   ' $ " "'

     $

CWP-1302-2019 (O&M) -8- %$ ""- *-%"

"*7 '$"! ' $ --*  - *7 $ % --,    " % $ *7 & ,  ''$'  ' $ %%$"%1  -1
 *$#(!'' $ "

'$"$& 1*.-($ "

#"+#"$2

1/./(0 +.2

*+ 3(

*+ 3(

 !



vkd Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes Whether reportable :

Yes