Purujit Singh And Others v. Ashwani Gambhir And Another
!"# #$%&%'( )*)&" +
( ',-.#/ )&"%$#!0#&1 %'2!.
',-.#/ )&"%$#)/3%'2#/4%'*1%..
/#&#'"( / .5%""!.+ 23$!"# /"1#6#"%"%'#/& / '5)/%""!.+ 22. !/7!'! 888888
!
"# 1#6/#&#'"$'"#96"6#"%"%'1!&-##' %.#2-7"1#6#"%"%'#/& :1&#.!'2:!&!$;)%/#2-7"1#4"!"#1#*/%#3!'$#/!%%&"1!"%'"#/9& "1#!:!/2 "1#/# #/#'$#)/"+:1%$1:!&&)-&#;)#'".792% %#2-7 "1%&)/"!'2"1#!9)'" $96#'&!"%':!&#'1!'$#2+"1#!9)'":!& '" -#%'* 6!%2 ..#*%'* ''6!79#'" $96#'&!"%'+ :%"1)" %.%'* #<#$)"%'+"1#6#"%"%'#/&1!3# %.#2"1#6/#&#'"$'"#96"6#"%"%' 1#/#1!2-##'." !$;)%&%"%' .!'2%'"1#4"!"#1#%&&)# :!&/!%-7"1#.!'2:'#/&/#*!/2%'*''6!79#'" $96#'&!"%' )9-#/ :/%"6#"%"%'&:#/# %.#2%'"1%&)/"'=
>4!).!"/!91!/!9-%/ )"3"?"2@>44"!"# !/7!'!!'2"1#/&+ "1#9!""#/:!&"!5#')6-7"1%&)/"!'2%&-#%'*9'%"#/#2"#'&)/#"1!"
!.."1#.!'2:'#/&%'"1#4"!"#+:1&#.!'21!&-##'!$;)%/#2 /)&#-7"1# /-!'&"!"#!/"9#'"+!/#6!%2"1#$96#'&!"%' ":!&&)-9%""#2-7.#!/'#2$)'&#. /"1#4"!"#"1!"6/%/%"7 .%&"1!&-##'6/#6!/#2%'/2#/ &#'%/%"7%# %/&".7!:!/2 "1#..#$"/+ "1#'!:!/2 "1#/# #/#'$#)/""1#/#!
"#/"1#!9)'"+% !'7+#'1!'$#2-7 "1#%*1)/"!'2'A-.#"1#4)6/#9#)/"/%/%"7.%&"1!&-##' 6/#6!/#2 $'&%2#/%'* "1# "%9# :1#' "1# !$;)%&%"%' :!& $!//%#2 )"
66/<%9!"#.%!-%.%"7'!$$)'" $96#'&!"%'6!7!-.#-7"1#4"!"#" 2%
#/#'".!'2:'#/&:!&&"!"#2"-#!-)" +
>$//#&
"#/"1# !
/#&!%2:/%"6#"%"%':!&"!5#')6' B
!'2%&-#%'*9'%"/#2-7 "1#)/"+)" "1#!
/#&!%2!9)'"+!&)9 C+ CD>$//#&1!&!./#!27 -##'6!%2""1#.!'2:'#/&!'2"1#6/%/%"7.%&" /6!79#'" !'"1#/ D+E
>$//#& 1!& -##' )6.!2#2 ' "1#:#-&%"# !/7!'! /-!'
#3#.69#'" )"1/%"7 )" "1%&D+
>$//#&!/#!3!%.!-.# :%"1 )/"1#/!//!'*#9#'"&!/#!.&-#%'*9!2# '&%2#/%'* "1# !
/#&!%2 !$"&+ :# 2 '" %'2 !'7 *2 */)'2"$'"%')#:%"1"1%&$'"#96"6#"%"%'+"1#&!9#%&!$$/2%'*.7 2%&9%& ?#!/'#2$)'&#. /"1#4"!"#&)-9%""#2"1!"+1#:%..&#'&%"%&# "1#
%$#/&"!66/%&#!.."1#.!'2:'#/&+:1&#$96#'&!"%'1!&'"-##' 6!%2"1!"6/%/%"7.%&" /6!79#'" $96#'&!"%'1!&-##')6.!2#2'"1# :#-&%"# )/"1#/%'$!&#"1#%/'!9#&!/#'"/# .#$"#2"1#/#%'
"1)*1"1#71!3#!$.!%9:1%$1%&!29%&&%-.#6/%/""1#6#/&'&9#'"%'#2 %'"1#.%&"+":1%$1!)"1/%"7"1#71!3#"!66/!$1# )/"1#/&)-9%""#2 "1!"!/#;)#&"&1!..-#9!2#""1#%/#$"/+#3#.69#'"!'2!'$1!7!"+"
D
.!&1 "1%&9#&&!*#" "1#.!'2:'#/&"1/)*1 /!9 !'$1!7!"& !" "1# 3%..!*#.#3#. $ !
% " &'&()* $+
% 6!'5!0 " =1#"1#/&6#!5%'*>/#!&'#2 #&> =1#"1#//#6/"!-.# #&>