Chairman Central Board Of Excise And Customs And Others v. Avnish Bansal And Another

  

       

!"#$#%&'&()

*!&+,!(- #("+!.!+$/%&'#($&+#%"!/#'!($ 0'",'-+"* .%1-#2#.*&-!($"*#+'

#"&"&(#+'

3#+'0'

4(&'*!('!.!($!("*#+  #'5($#("'

)  67  8  38   67  8 9 78  +#'#("):

++!4##( *!($#+ ;!.-$4%!"#- +5#"&"&(#+' ::

::

78 -

*!..#(<#$  &(  "*#  5+#'#("  %&4&.  2+&"  5#"&"&(  &'  "*#  +$#+ $!"#$  =
>  ((#/0+#::? -  5!''#$  @;  #("+!.  $,&(&'"+!"&4# +&@0(!.- *!($&<!+*#(%*- *!($&<!+* *#+#&(!"#++##++#$"!'6"*# +&@0(!.6 -4&$#2*&%*"*#+&@0(!.'#"!'&$#"*#&,50<(#$.#""#+' +$#+'

$!"#$
A
A ((#/0+#::
!($%,5#"#("!0"*+&";2!'$&+#%"#$" ,!1# "*#5!;,#("5!;!($!..2!(%#'#"%+"*#!$*%5#+&$ !55.&%!("  +#'5($#("   
 2&"*  ##%"  +,
>=
  "  
A  !'

2#..-  !"  5!+  2&"*  "*#+  '&,&.!+.;  '&"0!"#$  5#+'('    &4&.  8#+4&%#'

/!,&(!"&(-> *#+#&(!"#++##++#$"!'6 8>6 -2&"*&(!5#+&$ "2,("*'-+,"*#$!"#+#%#&5"%5;"*#+$#+ #*!4#*#!+$"*#.#!+(#$%0('#.+5#"&"&(#+'!($*!4# !.'%!+#0..;<(#"*+0<*"*#&.#

::

*#'*+"%("+4#+';&(4.4#$&("*&'%!'#&'"*!"!55.&%!(" +#'5($#(" 
4(&'* !('!.-2*&'5*;'&%!..;&,5!&+#$5#+'(- !55#!+#$&( 8>-@0"2!'("+#%,,#($#$+!55&(",#("@; (&( 0@.&%8#+4&%# ,,&''&( ("*#.&"&<!"&("*!"#('0#$@#+# #("+!.

$,&(&'"+!"&4#  +&@0(!.-  +&(%&5!.  #(%*-  #2  #.*&-  4&$#  +$#+ $!"#$>

 ((#/0+#:: -&"2!'+$#+#$"*!"!55.&%!(":+#'5($#(" 
2&..@#!..%!"#$'#+4&%#'+,"*#$!"#!..%!"&('#+4&%#'""*# %!($&$!"#' 8>(("&(!.@!'&'-*2#4#+-&"20.$%0(""2!+$' '#(&+&";!($%!.%0.!"&(&(%+#,#("'!"5!+2&"*'#.#%"##' 8> "#+%,5.#"&(0+;#!+''#+4&%#'-!55.&%!(":+#'5($#("
2!' #("&".#$"5+,"&(+"*#5'"#50"; ,,&''&(#+

8 !.(<2&"* "*#+&%#+'-2*B&(#$("*#@!'&' 8>*#&%#+'-2* B&(#$("*#@!'&' 8>-2#+#5+,"#$""*#5'"#50";

,,&''&(#+ +!$#:3&('#(&+"&,#'%!.#!"#+%,5.#"&(0+;#!+'   +#<0.!+  '#+4&%#    2#4#+-  '!,#  @#(#&"  2!'  $#(&#$  "  !55.&%!(" +#'5($#("
-$#'5&"#*&'+#5#!"#$+#5+#'#("!"&(' ."&,!"#.;-&("*# 2!1#5#($#(%; 
?>  -!55.&%!("+#'5($#("
2!'

5+,"#$""*#5'"

8 (!$*%@!'&'-4&$#+$#+$!"#$>
A

((#/0+#::> 80@'#C0#(".;-*&'5+,"&(2!',!$#!("#$!"#$ 2&"* ##%"+,
>=
-4&$#.#""#+$!"#$A
A ((#/0+#::

*#5!;

@&..''0@,&""#$@;!55.&%!(":+#'5($#("+!$*%5#+&$&#+,
>=
 " 
A-2#+#+#"0+(#$2&"*@B#%"&('@;8#(&+%%0("' &%#+ 2&"*0"  ,!1&(<  5!;,#("  +  "*#  5#+&$    !$*%  '#+4&%#  +#($#+#$  @; !55.&%!("+#'5($#("
!'#50"; ,,&''&(#+ *#  +&@0(!.  *!'  "!1#(  &("  %('&$#+!"&(  "*!"  &"  2!'  (" $&'50"#$@#+#&""*!"!55.&%!("+#'5($#("
!%"0!..;2+1#$(!$*%

:?:

@!'&'("*#5'"#50"; ,,&''&(#+@#+#*#2!',!$#+#<0.!+ *#+#+#-*#&'#("&".#$""*#5!;'#+4&%#+#($#+#$+!$*%5#+&$!' 2#.."2!'0+"*#+@'#+4#$"*!""*#+#2!'(!0."("*#5!+"!55.&%!(" +#'5($#("
-@0"&"2!'!0.""*#$#5!+",#("-2*&%*$&$("5+,"# *&,&("&,#-"*0<**#2!'+$#+#$"@#<&4#(!..@#(#&"'!'<&4#(" !55&("##' 8>55.&%!("+#'5($#("
2!'2&..&(<"2+1- @0"*#2!'1#5"!2!;@;!0"*+&"&#'+(!0."*&' " 2!'0+"*#+ @'#+4#$"*!"&"&'("!%!'#2*#+##,5.;##+#,!&(#$!2!;+,2+1 +*&'2(+#!'('*#+&@0(!.!55.&#$"*#.!2.!&$$2(@;(6@.# 805+#,#  0+"    ($&!  &(  (&(    ($&!  3#+'0'  93  !(1&  !,!(  

8 
"*.$"*!"(+,!.+0.#(2+1(5!;&'(" !55.&%!@.#&(%!'#'2*#+##,5.;##&'2&..&(<"2+1@0"&'1#5"!2!;@; "*#!0"*+&"&#'+(!0."*&' "2!'0+"*#+@'#+4#$"*!"+$#+'

2#+#("&,5.#,#("#$+.(<-2*&%*+#'0."#$&($#.!;#$5+,"&( !55.&%!(" +#'5($#(" 
   &' %..#!<0#'-2* 2#+# '&,&.!+.; '&"0!"#$-2#+#<&4#(@!%12!<#'-@0"'!,#*!4#@##($#(&#$"!55.&%!(" +#'5($#("
*#+&@0(!.!.'+#.&#$05(!0"*+&";5#/ 0+"&( 8"!"#3#+'0'937!+!'&,*! !!($"*#+' 

8 

('&$#+&(<"*#!%""*!""*0<*!55.&%!("+#'5($#("
2!'!..2#$"@#<&4#('!,#@#(#&"'!'<&4#(""*#+!55&("##'

8  >-  @0"  *#  2!'  $#(&#$  "*#  @#(#&"    5+,"&(  !'  #50";

,,&''&(#+

8 $0#"!0.""*#$#5!+",#("-$#'5&"#+$#+'  !($"*!"!55.&%!("+#'5($#("
&'(""@#@.!,#$+'!,#!($!.' %('&$#+&(<"*!"!55.&%!("+#'5($#("
*!$2+1#$+!$*%5#+&$ @#+#*#2!',!$#+#<0.!+-2#$("&($!(;&..#<!.&";+&(&+,&";&("*#

::

&,50<(#$+$#+$!"#$=
> ((#/0+#::? -5!''#$@;"*#+&@0(!. *#5#"&"&(&'"*0'$&',&''#$

38 

78        

'B1' *#"*#+'5#!1&(<+$#+ ) #'

 *#"*#++#5+"!@.# ) #'