← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3636/2003allowed

Shanti Devi v. Govt. Of India And ORS.

2023-01-23Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi9 pages

            !"#

$% &' %( ) * +"+ ,$+ -

%.

&$-%/ +++00%11

$) 2%/)3) &.%/ ,% $ &' 

 &$-%/) +++%)0& % $)  

 

   

   



  

   

 

  !

"#$%&""'&''





 

 

"#"# $%%"

&

'

 

! 

 '  

  

  

 

  

  

  ( &





)

*





*

 

"#"# $%%"

+ '  

"#(#("'&&#   ' 



      - % $%%$ 



'

*  '



.

 

&

   

 / 

 

   ' '     

'

/ 

   0'

&

'

  

+

  



 

 

 ('  

'

  

*

 ' %- %1 $%%"

  

*  



'

  ' 

    



 

  



 &

  

.





/   * & 3

' & 4





5 

    





   / 

* 

  /  



  

 

'

  

'+ '  

&

.

.

.





7

 

& '

*

.

 

'



&

   +

*  /  

  



&



' '  



'  

 '   



  8 9

"

' -:$ 

    &



&

 

   

 * 

 

;

 

.



 *

 ' * ('  

'

'     '

<   ' 



2  '

.

 '

 

 & 

+

=' -->

4 

 & $?

&  

* 

*  



 &



*    

 &  *  '



0'

*

 

&

 &    

 -:$ ' 

 & 



  ' 



@ * '  

*



* 

5

??:$ $%$ *   

.  3 %?

 $%?

 

  8 9 ' -:$      



  ( &  *

 .@ 

&    &

  # %

(' 



' .

   



     

  



 

 

?

   

 

   ! "#  $    %  &    

   $  

    %  &  

    

 '      

(

)

* %   +! ,  $  (



) #   $      

 

  (                

 

 

   " 

# 

 '

 + 

  (

$      

#

 

-) .  %  &   

 '    

 %   +! , 

 $  ( 

)            

  

    $  #

 ) )

 

 /0  

1  #

  



      (





/0  ('2 3 4    $     

 '     

(  $

$  $( %  & #  5    

# 

(  

  (  

 6    ,"!.     

 

 

    #7 

         



  (

  

  $    , %$

  

8% 9

:)!;

    $  

    

#    $

   

#  $(  

   

 #  $

        

    (#     

 

8% 9

:)6;    (



  

 

#$  

#  7 )  

 (

<    =    

  



     

 7 

(7  8;  6

   ,"! 

    ( (     

(  #    

 ( $      





  $         #

( $  

9

 ( 

   (  $ 

 (  

  (  

 6    ,"!.#

 

  

  (      

     

2 ! &   0'

 '  

 '

5

-%# $%%?



) * + +, -.

  :

$ $%?

& 



' 

&

  - "

(' 



' .

,         $          

# $

(  $  

    

 (

 



 

 

 ( 

(            

  

      (    

#  $ 

 

 

 (

#  



   >

      #

   

#  (

    

 (  #  (  

(         

 '  $

 

   

           / $  & #       

 (



(  



#





  



 (  #

  

$  

#

  #    





    (

 (  #   

$  



 (  (

   #    



#   

( 

=   

       

  $

 

            

       

    

#



 

 $

( $(   



 

 (

     (           (      

% 9

:) $  

    

 (

#



  (  

      

 (

   

     (  #  ( 



                 

(         

 '

   $

.        

   #  $  

  #  

 :

 

! 8% 9

:);.



$   

'  

(   

'       

 $   

# 

$



  

      

 $



  

 77 8:

 ;     ,"!         $  

   07  : (7

 # 

# 

( 

.

   9        

(  

    

-) $   -      $                $(    

  ?   (

     $(  1 (     

        0  : (7

  . 

 

   (  0  : (7

 #

  #

  



      ( $

 

 $(



    #     $

( 

@  

 

  

-AA

:

BBBBBBBBB !  .  0  7    : (  7

  

  

    '

  

   $   

#  

  9

   $  +.

   7

   $



 

 C







   

($

 

 9)

  (

   

  & A4* 611,"):E:<87;

,,3

   $(  1 (  # :

      

-) 8;7  



 7 

(8%;  

$ 





 9

  77 8:

 ;  8;  



 

(8/;#87;#8&;E8F;

   (  1 $(     

-2 BBBBBBBBBAA

! %



  

  

     $

 





 

( 



     '





       $ 

  

   

  >

 

       $ #         

  '

   

     $          

$( 

  

  # 

 

 (

#      $ 



2 )

*

    *

 * 

 

  8 9 ' -:$ '

 &  

  &

 

 ' &  

 





 -:$ ' 

 * 

 

/ 

/   * 



 -:$ '

'

*

 &    

'

+/  

> 0

)1!

*

)  0

)1! 2  '  



 * 

  

 +/   0

)1!

)  0

)1!

 

& 

&

  (' 



7 

 



 +/   0

)1!

)  0

)1!.

 

.  3 '

 

   *







 

'



  &



   &

&

2  '  



 * (' 

+/   0

)1!

)  0

)1!  



 &  



' 

  

@



& '  

  

&

  

*

5

??:$ $%$

   '

5

-%# $%%?



 &

  

.





     

.



 ' & '

)

*

 ('  

'  - % $%%$

('  *

 '  %- %1 $%%"

 .



 &   

   

.





   &





1.3



-   



.





2

 

' 



.





  *+   & 

'



.





&

  ' 



*

   

/ 

 

  &

/4 5  !  # '  

 <

 '

-G 1D <

 $ -G 1D