High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/94/2019disposed of

M/S Metro Valley Business Park Pvt Ltd v. Municipal Corporation Gurugram And Others

2019-11-20Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur56 pages

!"# $#%& #

/0123%' # %&+ #

4 2 ,

5 6 #

4 2 ,

7+'%' #%& #

4 2 ,

# %&+ #

4 2 ,

; ;

5,6 #

:,4 2 ,

. ;-

!,#%& #

4 2 ,

4,5,6 7''

4 2 ,

+ 7''

=+,,

+ 7''

,) ,

+ 7''

4, +*',

!,# %& 7''

" 4 2 , '

- - <

+ 7''

7 + ,,> ", '

+ 7''

2+,

8 - <

+ 7''

)"0!$, ",

; - .

+ 7''

% ?,,

. - .

+ 7''

< - 8

+ 7''

% ?,,

+ 7''

5,6,

+ 7''

5+,

+ 7''

*+,>,

- -

+ 7''

4,, ,

- --

+ 7''

"+ 9 #%&,

+ 7''

0 4*,% 4*,,

8 - -

+ 7''

"++ ,,0 ,

; -

+ 7''

# $),,

. -

+ 7''

, ,

< --

+ 7''

!"+,

+ 7''

+?,,

- -<

+ 7''

@ 4*,, '

;

- -.

+ 7''

4,4,%?"+ 6,

- -;

+ 7''

,?$$ ,

-- -8

+ 7''

'$?"+ ,

- --

+ 7''

# +3 ,

-8 .

+ 7''

4, +&,

-; 8

+ 7''

4+,,

+ 7''

2 *%%,

-< -

+ 7''

5",

+ 7''

?"'4*,,

+ 7''

4")"',

+ 7''

4, +,,> ,

+ 7''

4, $,"* #&,

+ 7''

!,#%&7,

+ 7''

,,,

+ 7''

,&2=@,

;

+ 7''

4+4,$"4, +,

+ 7''

4+6 =',> ,

+ 7''

4,# '$,

+ 7''

4+*,

+ 7''

4+*,

+ 7''

4+,

-8

+ 7''

#%&,

+ 7''

"7** >,

+ 7''

4++4, +,

+ 7''

#4 9,

+ 7''

4,=+,A,*,

+ 7''

!4%' #%&,

+ 7''

4,,6,

+ 7''

!"# $#%&,

;

+ 7''

4++# , '

;

+ 7''

5@ +#%&,

;

+ 7''

4+4, ? ,

+ 7''

4*+/ # %&+,

;

+ 7''

, *?"+ 4"00,

+ 7''

7 + , ,,

;;

+ 7''

,)"',

+ 7''

4+ 4, +,

+ 7''

"0 7,

;

+ 7''

) ,, 4, +,

+ 7''

?'?,,

+ 7''

4 # $,?, 2=@,

+ 7''

,4, +,

+ 7''

% #4*,),

;

+ 7''

74@/*43B#%&,

+ 7''

4,"0# 0,"# 5&+,

+ 7''

6 # + ,

+ 7''

,40, >,

+ 7''

/0123%' # %&+,

+ 7''

% 4*,) ,

+ 7''

,&!,

+ 7''

54*,40, >,

;

+ 7''

?""+&,

<- 8

+ 7''

'? ?"

< 8.

+ 7''

?!$,,

+ 7''

*+,>,

+ 7''

6?'"

<. -

+ 7''

6 "*,

<< 8

+ 7''

, ),,

< -

+ 7''

%4,

+ 7''

4+5+,

;

+ 7''

4642 >3#%&,

;

+ 7''

4+*,

- ;-

+ 7''

5",,

+ 7''

4+,

8 ;

+ 7''

4 4 '

; <

+ 7''

)+*3# %&+,

. .<

+ 7''

,*,

+ 7''

7"$@+#%&,

+ 7''

,,,

+ 7''

7!A/ ""

+ 7''

? +4*,,

- 8

+ 7''

, +#%&,

+ 7''

4,%'! ,

8 8

+ 7''

" % ?"+ ,

;

+ 7''

. 8

+ 7''

,",00 ,

< -

+ 7''

%4,$ # , ,

-8

+ 7''

4 ,*#%&,

+ 7''

4,%,?'"

+ 7''

% 4, +,

+ 7''

2 '4*,, ,

- ;

+ 7''

!,#%&,

+ 7''

4,,

8 ..

+ 7''

7+0>!">#%&,

; -;

+ 7''

7 ,

. -

+ 7''

!"># %&,

< < <

+ 7''

#%?"+ +,

47-

+ 7''

54*,40, >,

+ 7''

,7** >,

+ 7''

" 7+'%' # %&+,

+ 7''

5 6,

- <

+ 7''

# +7', 2=@,

-8.

# '$, 7''

+(,

8 8-

4 ,*#%& 7''

4 2 ,

;

4++4, + 7''

+(,

. 47.<

5 6 7''

< 47 .

4,%?"+ 6 7''

+(,

# '$, 7''

4 2 ,

5@ +#%& 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

- 8

4 ,*#%& 7''

+(,

- 47<.

"+ 9 #%& 7''

+(,

-- <

!"># %& 7''

4 2 ,

- ;

% 4, + 7''

4 2 ,

-8 ;

!"># %& 7''

+(,

-; 478 <8

4+* 7''

+(,

-. 478-

,40, >, 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

5@ +#%& 7''

+(,

- ;

6?'"

, 7''

+(,

, *?"+ 4"00 7''

+(,

, *?"+ 4"00 7''

4 2 ,

4++4, + 7''

4 2 ,

- ;;

!"# $#%& 7''

4 2 ,

?!$,, 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

8 ;-8

?""+& 7''

+(,

; 478 <<

,40, >, 7''

+(,

. 8<

4*+/ #%& 7''

4 2 ,

< 8.

4*+/ #%& 7''

+(,

5+, 7''

+(,

"+ 9 #%& 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

;

!"# $#%& 7''

+(,

+ 7''

4",?"+ 4, +,

8- .8

+ 7''

45 !$,,

8 .

+ 7''

227' +#%& '

88 4788

=+,A,*, 7''

+(,

4, +*' 7''

+(,

8. <

4+ 7''

+(,

8< 8

4+ 7''

+(,

4+ 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

;

4+ 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

;

4, +*' 7''

4 2 ,

;

,, 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

; 47;

74@/*43B#%&, 7''

4 2 ,

;8 47;

74@/*43B#%&, 7''

;; 47;;;

227' +#%& 7''

+ '

;. 47;;

"0 7, 7''

;< 47;.

,&! 7''

4 2 ,

; 47;;

4, ? , 7''

4 2 ,

47.<

*+,> 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

47.<-

2+ 7''

47;-;

54*,40, >, 7''

4 2 ,

.- 47;

*+,> 7''

. 47;-

54*,40, >, 7''

.8 47;-

6 "*, 7''

:,4 2 ,

.; 47;

% ?"+ , 7''

4 2 ,

.. 47..

4+ 4, +D4"+4, +, 7''

.< 47;-

"7** > 7''

. 47.<;

4")"' 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

< 47;

4, ? , 7''

< 47;-.

54*,40, >, 7''

< 47;;

,7 7''

<- 47;-

,7** > 7''

< 47;;

4 # $,?, 2=@ 7''

<8 47;

4,, 7''

<; 47;8

4+ 4, +D4"+4, +, 7''

" +,

<. 47;8

*+,> 7''

<< 47;8-

#%?"+ + 7''

< 47;8

% ?"+ , 7''

47.;

6 "*, 7''

47.;8

*+,> 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

47.;

7 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

- 47;;-

,&! 7''

47;8<

2 '4*,, , 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

8 47..

)"0!$, ", 7''

4 2 ,

; 47.;.

54*,40, >, 7''

:,4 2 ,

. 47;.

4,, 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

< 47;<

7 + , ,, 7''

47;;

4++# , 7''

+ '

47;8

4")"' 7''

47;;

4 # $,?, 2=@ 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

47;.

7 + , ,, 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

- 47;..

"7** > 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

47;.;

#%?"+ + 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

-8

8 47;;.

,7** > 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

; 47..

4 4 7''

. 47.;<

2 '4*,, , 7''

< 47;;8

2+ 7''

4 2 ,

47;

)"0!$, ", 7''

47;.

7 7''

;

% 4, + 7''

% ?, 7''

- ;.

7+0>!"># %& 7''

" 4 2 ,

;<8

!"# $#%& 7''

8 ;;

6?'"

, 7''

4 2 ,

; ;8<

?""+& 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

. -

# %&+ 7''

4 2 ,

< ;-.

7+0>!"># %& 7''

!"# $#%& 7''

4 2 ,

47- ;

?!$,, 7''

47 8.<

7+'%' #%& 7''

4 2 ,

47.<8

7+'%' #%& 7''

- 47.<

/0123%' #%& 7''

8.;

5 6 7''

4 2 ,

8 8..

/0123%' #%& 7''

4 2 ,

; 47-

4, +&, 7''

+ '

. 47;

@ 4*,D@ 7''

+ '

, , 7''

+ '

<8;

4+4,$"4, + 7''

+, '

- <

,4, + 7''

+, '

- 47-

,4, + 7''

4 2 , '

- -

4+4,$"4, + 7''

4 2 ,

-- 47-

)+*3# %&+ 7''

- 47 8

4+5+, 7''

+, '

-8 47

4+5+, 7''

4 2 ,

-; .

"++ ,,0 , 7''

4 2 ,

-. .

#4 9 7''

-< .

"++ ,,0 , 7''

+, '

- 47;

4, +,,> 7''

47;

!4%' #%& 7''

+, '

4,%,?'"

7''

47 -

4642 >3#%& 7''

- 47 -<

4642 >3#%& 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

+, '

%4, 7''

+, '

"++ ,,0 , 7''

4 2 , '

; 47- 8

'$?"+ 7''

+, '

4, 6 # + , 7''

+ '

< .

#4 9 7''

'" ++ C"+C ()"

47<

% 4*,) 7''

# &4 (4 7%>, 5 )"' 7+,4, +(7%( 4, 6(4 7%>, 4, ,) 5 )"'(7%( #"!(4 7%>, 4 +75 0,%6(7%( 45 5(7%( 7 ",,'

(7%( 7+67 %?4(7%( 6*,,(7%( %54*,4,"(7%( 4,(7%( 0,%4, +(7%( $4*,(7%( 7 ",)"'(7%( ?# (7%( 4*'(7%( ,' '' &$,4,(7%( ,"' ?6(4 7%>,

- )'4(7%( ,'

% ' # +54*,(77)(2

! , (,"

'' ,0% %% " 7

. ," /> , *" 4 7'' 0 , "' ( )"

+>,'

%' ($*,*,5"*+ ' 0 , 7 6"*( )"

+( - <

<(%>,,,5"*+ ;

<'0 ,%6"* 4 %()"

+( *," , ' , > (>,' >*,''

:,,%++,E" , (, ( " ,'"%%,(>"0 $" > - :, "05 + , '" ' , *, > 0"-

%" %* )>#, (:,4,( )"

+:,' + , '' , ( 0* , > ( " , *'

%*, %"0 ,%6"*

4 %()"

+($* , ,, > ' ,"'

' ">,, %" %*)>#, (:,4,( )"

+(+* *, ,'

' 0*" , *'

, %*, 0 > , '"

, ,(>,

$*,,%"" 4 <7 ,2 7 *>,+";(-

- 0 *("%0C# +5"> "*, * , , 4 2 ( "' +(, %"", *,+ + *,' "'( "" , + /,"(>+,,' > '% ,"(>,,>

' ,6+0 , ;C . 3 ,>' ,'

,%* C ,>

/0,,5+0(,'

,> ,>0' ,"'

' >,, 4"0E" (>,,#"50 *++ & *"7 8-0* (";- - 88( + * ,>*,) +#, ()>#, 0 ' ,+(%,"*,,#, % $' , , + + "%* ' , '

,%*:, > "+ ,#"50 *++& *"7 ;

+ ,'"+" ,9' 4 * 7

;

,> 0 8

< (,'

,%* "

%' 0 ,7 /) ()"

+ !"

# $%& "!'("!')'!

+ ,

8 ,* ",,'

> > "%*' , +"

*0";

8$'

; 8 ",, >,, (' +$*,

', :,">+

<;7** %* , (''> 0 , (>,+ ,'' 8. <.4 * (''> 0 ,%++ (>, +,+ , ( )"

+( % 8 <( ' ,

%":, , ()"

+(>,* 0 ,++ ()"

+(>,% < * +,+ , (>,, " ,, '

' 8 /,++(*, < (,) + #, > '0 ,"

(0*.&/01/2&3 /224 >,, > %" + >, >

2>% (&/40&35440 - "% "!

+ (' " &

-''-&$"! )!6 &$ 7 & "!'8 0* 0 , ) + #, (*, 'A# ;.

> 8

>, , $''

* *,"

, >, > *%*'' ", ' /,++0

(,+%>,,"' (>,, ", ,"> $* , ,,> ' ,"'

' , 4"0E",+ '*0 ,%

;

, %"", 0 < ,,,, + ,%"

(> '0*A#.

. !-$%"! -$6!

"&3 !+ $ $%& "!'> ,"

0 > #"0/ &*$*

,*% ,E" ,+ +"-

' +"

*-.

.$ + (>,,> %,) +#, ()>#, , C

>%,"' +(, > +5 + %%* % " %" 0"

" (>, "

, $* ," +" ' , >,) +#, )>#, (>,,> % >, , "' ( 0 % "

7%!, ,"

(>,'* ,> '(*%, >* C F

!"# "$%&'

(

)

+ ) (

; :, (,+ >$"' , *0 ,% 6"* 4 %)"

+(>,," +0 , 5"*+ 0 ,+,%4"

("!')' )$-*-9 &!9&!

-&$ )!6 &$ $% & "!' ! ++ 5"*+(

<%" 0 ,%* (>,,> ( > ( *,' 0> '% ,

'%" *,%""

4 <7 , 2 "' 7 0 , )"

+(+";(-

- *("%0C,+@" , , > + * + ,' "'( > ,'( "" ,0 ,' G . 7** %*,5"*+ , "

(,"' >,4 2

;

%''(>,,( 0%(> ' 0 , 7 6"*()"

+(0 ,++ - <

<( " >,,5"*+,%%>*" 4 7'',%0'

< &4 ( 4 "(0 5 )"' 7+,4, +(7%( $( *",, 7 6"*,>,"",(>," >*,

< '

0" >(>,>*''

% " " . , % # "

/ *",, >"',''> >,,@ +(7''9)( H&/("-8 , %# "

(,' , '

%" 0 , %"", ,>,, ,*, 0* 8 ,%0 ','' + (# +5, (>, '*, , + ,/"0+,' "0" "-8 , %# "

(,7''"

," ,"+0 ,''(,+ ' ,'' , '( ' , * ,

5" + / "0+ , , ' 0 , 7''"

"$>,>'

'0 ,+:, 7''"

"*,,%'' + "0C" "-8 , %# "

0* ,G''GG 'G ' *, * , (,' *'

, ,%" 0 ,%* '

%' !"

# $% & "!' (' !

+ >,, , 0 *, ,+%">,"% "*,* '

% ,' + (# +5 + ,' ,9' / *",,5"*+

,>, ," ",%, ,0" 0 ,> / *",

%%" 7

. ," /,**,5"*+ ,7 6"*()"

+(- <

<, >"', '' 0 ,"'' (, + , ' I) -

!-: "

- +; %:,"(, >"' > " 0* >,,'

:, ( *" , ,' (, ,%,*,5"*+ ,*" 47''> # ( &$,4,( "'' * 0, ,"' >",,%% +0*" 47'',0 ( >, "

, *,,7 6"*, "

* %"

,"' ,*,0 (, (> 5"*+'0 , 7''"

,"0 >,

?6( 4 "('' *0, , '("'' , 0 , " ,"'

/,%, " ,' >,,

,%*, "*,,'*,%%

>,+'"*5"*+ '0 ,7 6"*()"

:,5"*+ '0 ,7 6"*+'

,07, (,"

"0 " ,>,F, " '

* 0 ,

%"", "0'F''J,'' *,' , ! ,7 6"*(, ++ ' ,+ *,'',**,5"*+ , % 6"* 4 % )"

+( F-

. ) / -0 - / 1 2*2 3

, 7 * ,+'"*5"*+>" C '' +# ;. ,+'"*5"*+ " C F45 26(7 / .2

3 $ 826(7 / .2

) )

- 7' +,(* * + >,, * % ,>,7 6"*>,,'' ,+ >,,,''" " . , %# "

>>:,''> <8

< "

<>,,'' % >'

>"*, ',+ ''>,'' " " . , %# "

,,0", " ,' ,* ",,' > ," :, (0 .

<(,,, %0+' *,0 0 +"(>,> '

*, ' , "

2, *"+ <

, *"+* ;<

<5"

,+ <<

:,>,5"

<>,,,"++,

' *, '

%" >,,( (, 0* , + ,'" ++ ()"

+(/' ,,'

*> '*0 ,+, *,+ 0**>" ,#"50 * ++ *"7 ;

:,'' " "

. , %# "

$*' + %>' *>,,''- <

<, >*+ C F9

!)4

) '

(

( ) ( ; *)

0 %

<# 9 <#5 *)

0 := >)

* ) ))

$ ?

?=:& )

<# 2:?9 <# 2 :

, ! '

:, *'0 ,7 6"*(>, >*,'' %(,>$ 5" ''

, * > ' "

:, 4"'

+ "

5"*+ < -"'

-$6 - '

< -"'

, ! -$6 ("!')' =) -$6 $%& "!'>54/?8@ )9!"

&)! '"'0A2(>,*>,,'

% " . , %# "

," C

:6 ?5

)

:6 ?5 $ !?'

:6 ?5

;)

)

# : ?5 ###### :% " $+ ) 1

;

A !:954'

: 6 ?5

;)

) ) # ) ?& ( ) )

?='

######

8- :4 B ( )

@ *3

/ - !?=:='&

:6 ?5 B

)

8 / 5"*+ , 4"'

+ "

, &!9&!

-&$ &3 %!

' $% $& "! ("!')' !

+ $% & "!'>54/?82 )9!"

"&)! '"'@@A," C

)

###### "

!' *

) :6 ?$"

!' * :6 ?% )

)

; @ +,0%(0" ,,0 % , 7''"

, ,F

* ) ))

,( >, >* , '' %( 0" *,>:, 7''"

"*,,%*% "'' " ,' ,, ' % 0"(' " >,,$ ,' (%%* ,"*,"$ (>,*,@ ,$ '(,>

8 ' $*,*," ,,>,

%" ,> ,5"*+ , %"

. 7' +,0%(,7 6"*,' "$>"""'

0 *, 4,# ,(%6"* 4 %()"

+(, >* C 8B

26 + )! '

. ) 2

) ( ) :

& ?=:& +) > "

+ ) . )

)

) )A

:?0 26(7 / . 2 .27 =% ::

:9&=

)

0$!2 > '

+> "7+ . ) ,

< :,"

" ,> ,%"

0 0 '

%"0 *

4# +5, ) +#, ()>#, , (">,,,0"0 , %""

88 * , + :, * ,> $ $>* ,>,'

0'(>,*, :,

*" ,* ++ 0 ,7 6"*(>,,'' , (>,'*, +'"*5"*+ 0">

E" (,' (0,> , ** %*,5"*+ (,

%>,*" 47'' >:,+'"* 5"*+ '0 ,7 6"*()"

+( *>,, '" " . , % # "

,+ +0$, 6"*()"

+(>, ,%'' *" ,5"*+ , "

>,'' " " . , %# "

,( *%* "'' " ,+, 0 %+ , 0%>",%0 *,+ ,,'' E" 0 + ,% 00 , '

4,+ * +' ,"*,"$ %%* *"+0 * %%( 0, ,'' $"' , *0 , 6"*( )"

+(,+ (9'"

/,++(,' ,''0 , 6"*(,' , 0 +* * , ' *,,(%+"' ,*

:,' '' 0 , 6"*( )"

+( <

54//54/2 >

+ A,, '$*

K A,, ' 0