← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AD/39/2020dismissed

Suman v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-05-10Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill,Mrs. Justice Ritu Tagore12 pages

  

   

   





 !"#"$% & ' (' 

)******



 + ,#-# )

    

 %

./ )'

) /) // ./ )'

)    

  

  

    

  

/) //0 '







  !

" ""  #"

$%&'$&'

!(   

)

*") *" + ,!(

!  -

  " )

.%/ $

.01 0&/ ,

)

.12



 $ 3



(  #



 

42 5&$ $1&%$&6 )

.%/ $

0&/2 "



  !

  ,

 

    $1&%$&6  !

  !(  

7 8 

  ",



 

 

  

 

 

$  !

" 

                 

     " ( 

  9  !

       !  !( 

        

 $6$$&%

 "     ,

 

  ! 

!

  

, ! :  

$ .



&&%$&6



 

"    





!



" 

 

"  

 ;



/&%$&6

 "

    

$ 



+ < ,  ! +

3 

 

 !

 

  

  

 ,  

$  

 ( 

    

   "     "

( ! 

)+ 

 

, $.&%$&6



        

 - 

 2

 "

$

  , 

",

 1 425&$ $1&%$&6 )

.%/ $

.01

0&/ ,

)

.12 "

   )

=

>

 + !

 

 8,   ( 8 

<  ? 

 + $1&%$&6 "  -

  , +

 

( )



  )

 /1     ,       )

        

 ,   $0&%$&6 

$,  



0&6$&6   !

     ,           >

    



!,



 

 ! )

.01 .12 !

"4

  )

%.  ,   "

!

  " )

.%/ $

.1$ 0&/2   ,   " (   

8 

 (

.

1,

!

  

 0 )



    )

 ..       

$  , ,



 



"    

 



    ( 

 

 ( 

  ,

# 

(; 



 ! !(

 

 "

!



 ?  >  +@

 +@>

  A     ,

 



=    !( (

 

 < , (

    <  /&%$&6    $$&%$&6    

 



!(

" +   





 ! )

.%/ $

.1$

0&/ 2

  B

  =         

 ! !

" 

C / 





 

 

      





 !( 



$ ,  -

  "  "

""  

   !

!( 8 % 

"

!



  ,



*  ($&$&!

   

" ( '&1$&$$  ! +

   DE2>') ,  # -

  



  

7 

(  "

 #  ,

-

  

   

7 

    

, -

 $.&.$&$. 

 # $1&1$&$.!   !   

7 

A



(,



1   

   

7 

 

 "

,

      !    

7 

 $1&1$&$.  ,

   ,  

 6 A  

   

 

 "

 

 "

(

 -

"

$  "  

2

 "

 "

      



 >!$&% "

 

, , , (

<  /&%$&6    $$&%$&6    ,  !(  

( 

"    !(

+  ,  

  )

.%/ $

.1$

0&/2  ,

A  

   >5

F8%(!(=&> # ,  )

)

D

 >5> 

4)A !

  A  

 !



  >5    >5 

   

 

    8 

 

"  ,

  >5 

    

$   



( ;    



 -

  2

 (

  ! , #"

 $%&'$&'!

 

$!  



  " !

 

"( ' =    

   

 

  " " ,

 !

! ,

" ,   

"

#"

,!(

!  -

;

 







 &   ,



 !

42, "

 

 "



!(

0

$  " (  

    

 

  !

         

  

$6$$&%2 

(!    

  

$ 

   

 $6$$&% 

 !

     ?  + 



      +     



(!     ,

 !

$6$$&%  ! ""!(

$,

   )!  

 8 



2

,  ,   !  !( 

 

"  

)

  

 

 

"   

"

$) 

"  ,  !(

$   

    

            

$           

  /&%$&6  

 < 4   +

 , 



,



$    ! !

"""!(

    

" ! 



 2 

8 



        ",

 " E +  = ) 

,     ,

) 

  )

"   "&6(  ! 

  "?

 

 " 

!



$.$&&

"

  ("!(

 )

< ! 

(

 )

/

(   ",

E + =D 

 #("

 E +  =          (

"      !    8  (   

(    ! 

 !(



 

) 

""

(  

 (

" 

 "

$,



 

  8 

, " (

+

",

   "

   +,



 



 5 

 "  !

   ,     

  !

         !

"  (  

 

"

 

 

, "", ,  !(

$ ! 





8 

  !



 

 

  !

8 !(

$" 

"+ 

"   ,  

    (, 

   ;  ,  

( 

 

    

      

4    ! 



( ,( 8,   !,

  !    

    +

;

, + 

  

 

,

( +  $ ;

"

(

 

   !!

 

(  8 !# 

(!

%

(

, (  G



"- 

(9;

( 8 ,  =%



( - 

(, , 

  !

  

  (     <



  !  #"

? 9!)



 

       ,



 

 !



(!  

( 8 

 

"

 +

!

F

   "



 

#,





 







 ! "  ,

"

,

 !

 ;

-   



( 



!

 !! ! 



"  - 

( 



"    

        ?, 

  

( 



 



 

+!

 ;? H!) 

      !"

# $ %&'' ! 

( 

 !



"- 

( !

    $$

  

 )  

>E )

; >  $&$6)

$, 

     



  





    

      

 

 ! "

 # 

"

     $ 

   % !      

& "

 & 

  $ '

"

('

  



$   

 

   )

  "



$   

  

 

  

   

6 

$

  '

 )   

('

 

   

  

  

    

  $  

    

   

'



   *  



  $ 



 '

 

   "

  

"

  

  '  



 

  + 

      '





  

    





 

  ( 

  )



 

'

 $  

$   

   )

  

 

    

, -  '

 "



 $     '

    

 "$

  '

    

  

  

 $$    

( 

  

 $  

$

,  





$ '



 

 

"

  

 

 $   

   

    

 

 

$ 

 

-

  )

 $    '







$  

$ '



    

$ 

    

+  

  

  



 

$ 







 

'

"

+  

   

 

 "'

 

 

 "

 .'

 

$   

   ( 

 $

      

 

   



  

   

   

   ! "

 # 

$  



 '



   '

     



"'





 )



  

$   

    



  



    

 

      '   '

    /   



 $    

'

    

 



 '"



 

  '

 



$    $





 

"

  

"



   "'

 

"

 #

0  



 1  1 2+ $ 

 3'

455 504     $ 

 '

          

  

   "'

     

 



'

$ 

 

 -   

$ 



   

 

 

  '

 '   

 

  "

('  *



        ( 

 



   

 $ 

  '

 

'

$ 

 

 -7 *



 

$ 

 

 -    

 

 

  '

 '   

    "

('C .     

 "

 

, 

"( ! !   !

F   !

 =



 ! - 

(



 

  (

2 "

 



, !

  1 )  (

( E + @=

(   8

 

=E + 

 

  ( %&& 0&&

  (

",

?    

  ",



:,

   (

  ",

?    

,  (  !  

"  ,

E + = 

,

& " (  

"      

     ,  !   

   /&%$&6

$$&%$&6!  " (

 !

!

"

"  E + = 



"2

  ! !

  ,  + (

  

,, 

 ,+ ,( 

( ,

    

 !

"

  !(



0 

# 





( =$)2 + ,



8 

8

( 



(  < F



  

8  ,

    ! +  !(!(

  ! 

  



 

  /  >5 F8%!(=&> #  ,  

   82 , +   , 

 8 

( 



$

" >5



$,





) , 

 ( 

; 

(

!(

 

 "!(

       





(

 +

#( ,   8;"

# !(

  "

 ! " "

 "

!(  8 

 

  8



   !



 % 



 !(

  

(

 "

$!(  !!

F   (

   !

!

;  

  

( 8,  !

  

 

 A  

 

  

  !    

  (    ,

   



(  



 " 6

 



  !

 "

!



 -

   ) (!   , (!

!

! " 

" #"

 -

 ? 9!  )  

"("  (    )   *+     "*

 " % &

 IJ -

!(   ,  ,  



 ;   , !#



#"

 -

 (

 

!

 

"

, #"



! #"

2

 

,  ,



!



 (

" 

(

 :!( 

#"

 ; 

  !





 " (;  

 

, , !   ;

  -

!

 





;

 





!+

 ,,  

",

#"

 -



!(  K ' 

"    !  #"

? 9! ) 

)

 # $ ,#-# 4"# ,

   6 

,"5"$ 7 6,





!

,

$

"  -

 

 , + !( 



!  2



 ,

 -

  

!

 (

 , (!

!  "



  $& A  

  

 



 "

! 

 ( " 

(



(

(

"

 #"

 $%&'$&'

!(  

)

*" ) *" +,    (

!(

 $ 5  "

! 

 $$ ;

  ( 1 (

      !   

-

 

 (

  

   



  

"( $. 

"(  



  /) //



   

& ' (' 

)

=  +

"7  L 75 =  ! L 75