The Station Master Amritsar Railway Station, Amritsar v. Shilna K And Others
!"
# $%&%!'
( ))*))* + %!'
& , -,% & , %./ %!'1 -,% & ,
****** 22 ..
'
3 ,&4& +%.'
5*
'# ! + ,&
****** &2!'# ' & (
67 * 5
5 1 *
, . )89) !"# ! $ % & & '!"# ! $ ' % ( ) $ )! $ * + , ) - . &$ & $ /)0 ,. & !( 12#% *$&
12#% *$& )3 ! 4 51&6 ! ,67. /& ,/*.
/
8 2"
25/) ) 4 51&6 ! 6 2"
25 )
22 & /& *! $ ! & $( *! $ $ $ 4 51 & $
) &
! & $ 8 22 & /) $ $ & $/) $
3 $ $( $ !! ) ( ( )
&) 9 28 2 25 / & )3 $ 4 51 $( )( ! $ $( ! ) 3 ) $ $$
! 7
)! & $ & ) 3 $& !)9
$ $ &
& ) !
6 & ( &
5 $ $ $ ! $ ! ( / $ ! $ ) &
$ : ) &
;
6 ) $ % < & $
!
#$
% = $ > & )! (
$$
) ) > ! ) )! &! && !
( $ 3 ) $
&
$! $ ( & ( 9 $& # 2 # < )! ?/
! !
$ % ( '=) *9 $ 5$( &
$ # ;5 3 $ /
$! 5) ! &$ + * ! ?/
&$ 9 $& )! (* 522222+ & & >
5 ' *$ /)
$$( 9 $& ? /
$ &$ 9 $& )& $ )!?/
$$ ) ) $ $( ( (
$$ *!$
() ) 7 & ( $ )! ) )( <(
(
!$ $ 2
& < &
/)0 ,.
$
& &
$( $ !! ) !&
$$ )
/ !+ ) )!&
&
& $$
. ! ). !
. ) !
@ $ & $$ &
: A& $
.
= ! B .
=
! B .
= $$ & $
!&
3 )
& !B (.
= &$ & ( &
!
& $ ! ) ) (
,& . ) & ,
.
$ !) ! ( &
3! )
)! A ! ! A& !
) ( )!
&
!"#$%$& '())( $
''''
''''
''''
*+ , -, ( )
(
* +)
(
* ,--./0)1.#2,--./ 3$ #4,53/65 3 "
'
2 , /
7 ,
/ '
"
7 ,
/ 8
%
3 9 2 :
'
"
"
'
% " %
"
8
" % ($ 8*;
) +$ 8*;
) ;
8
"<
= * ,-->/-?))##6 )
;
0< @ +!A ,--#/63
B " 2 :
*
"
"
"
"
9
"
@
"
B
"
&
'
"
" "
5
"
C "
?+ ?- 0)#1,53/6 >
"
" 3
" @
D
E
" *
'
"
'
B
'
"
&
"
B
" '
(
@
'
"8
B
F"F
"
*
"
'
B &
"
&
B
&
" "
'
2 , /
7 ,
/
'
"
7 ,
/ , / ,
/ "8
% ,
/ ((
B
) 3?
3 9 +(
B
) 3 ?
3 9 .!?))3 >12,.!/!!
$<1 6
"
8
0 9 5 )
("
2 4.:G
"
7 '
'
(
* *
* 8 % !(
"
"
?
"
'
"
0
B
"
* "
A
B
&
B " &
"
"
;
'
*
B
"
" "
B
" " 8
B
. , - #( H<
CB +-A.! !!6 ""
" "
2 B "
"
B
"
"
I
&
B &
? " *
&
*
B
*
""
"
*
&
B " *
@
*B &
( *
*
"
"
" % 1B
"" =
( ?
;
B
G (
"
B
"
*
B
"
"=
) 2 *
0
"
"
..
"
" *7
" .4
"
# *
J"
*
"
. B
&
*=
* 0
?
)
?
F
% >B) 0
?
9=;=
K ?
+9=;=
K ?
,.!/?3$#4,?
/6
@ "
"=
K ?
B
"
B 2
!4:0
"
"
B
"
"
C "
"
&
B '
"
"
*
*
"
B
"
:% ,
/ 4(
"
B"
B =) $)
"
" "
-;
""
*
*
B;
5
5
"
"
''''
''''
''''% 1 ) ! ) ! $ ! ) ) !
)!& / 2 11
!"#"$$$ '&&
) ) )!
& / )( $
''''
''''
''''
#-B
$ 8*;
) ;
8
"<
= * +$ 8*;
) ;
8
"<
= * ,-->/- ?)) ##6
'
B
*$ 8*
*
8
"
B5 )
+$ 8* ;
) ;
8
"<
= * --?)) 3 G 8#!2--0)<>-6
B ) "
"
"
"
B)
A
+G ?
,4>!/3$-A'
# L
)*H)3,-#1/3$#>2,-#1/0
A$-!
,)0/6 2 4B&
"
B
B
(
"
B
, / 8
"
7,"/
7 , /
7 ,/"
8 B
&
"
B
"
"
"
&
"
7
"
7
(
"
*"
B"
"
"
"
"
8
( &
8
'
B"
"
* "8
"
(
"
&
&
" =
(
C
C
"
C
7
- "
(
" *
" "
"
)
9
&
"'
'
"
FMF
?
B
" "
"
8
? - ))
$
4 ))"
F
"
(
8
"
"
"
NNN !G
"
'
"
"
'
)
"
'
" "8
" " '
"
(
?
9 G
+?
9 G ,-/ L9 ,)0/6B "
"
"
:
NNN
-(
"
B
"
"
'
" '
&
'
"
"
"
&
'
% 1.(KL
" "
*3< G 3 ) +G ) ,-1>/O9 >!2,-11/ 3$!1> ,)0/6
2 :B
"
"
(
"
*
"
% 0
*3< 9 A +9 A ,-14/3$!-.,)0/6
"
2 :
"
"
% 13 5 L) )
+5 L) )
->4O9 ! 2,->4/3$!4# ,)0/63 ;$'
"
"
*
(
"
"
*
*
" " "
2 ( ? ! "
*
"
&
E
"
"
" ? #4 "
? !B
*
*
"
7
=
% 1(? +? --10)- 2,--1/ 3$ 442,--1/ 0
A$4.,53/6
"
*
*
8 ) )
"
)
B)
*"
""
* B5 3
"
*
* % (
"
B)
(
B "
* 3 5 " 2 ( ( *
"
'
"
"
'
'
&
"
"
'
% 1 ? +? --10)- 2,--1/ 3$ 442,--1/ 0
A$4.,53/6
'
'
*
'
G )
;
9 )
+G )
;
9 )
,..!/3$ .#>,53/6B
F'
8 "KL?
) $"
) ) P *
+$"
) ) P *
.40)> 12,.4/3$#-#2,.-/0
A$ .!,KL?)/6
"
2 0
"8
" 2 '
A
*)
+A
*)
,>1#/
L9>#2-#A$4.>6 ; *H " 9 G ""+; *H5 "
9 G "" ,411/ 3$ 53 - 6
D
;
'
8
CE2B
) A,44-/ 40
'
) '
" ) 0 -!>? 0
"
"
"
&
"
2 '
P
)3 5
+ P
)35
->.0)..!2,->./3$!.,53/6 '
G
+G )
;
9 )
,..!/3$.#> ,53/6 3$
- B
"8
'
"
& 2 G
9 $ +G
9 $ ,4>4/3$ 0)! .
,53/6 (
!
*
"
2 3 B
<?) ;
+;
) ) ?
,$
/.#0)> 2,.#/3$ !
,KL?)/60)
->D
EB
% "
" B
? =
%+B
? =
3
%,.1/>#)3<462 D(
0 *
9
" 0 , / 0
9 ,
/ 0
9 ,
/0
, /0@
"
9
E #0 *
*
"
2 '
9 A 3 9 )
+9 A 3 9 )
,../0)##.2,---/ 3$>-,53/6
5
39 )
+
5
3 9 )
,../0)1-2,.../ 3$>>1,53/6 '
G
+G )
;
9 )
,..!/3$.#> ,53/63$
- !.( "
"
"
"2 '
? 3 3 +? 3 3-4>0) !2,-4>/3$!4.,53/6
"
;
G
) )
+;
G
) )
..-0)4>!2 ,..-/ 3$ !4 ,53/6
1 B
&
& 0
F*
5 3 A ?
* $ ) 9 L+A ?
*$ ) 9 L-!0)>!,53/6B
"
"
(
D
"
'
+
6
E 2 G
+G )
;
9 )
,..!/ 3$.#>,53/63$ .1#
NNN !.5
0
+0 ; 39 )
->40)>42 ,->>/3$.!,53/6
8 8
"
"
'
" (
8 8
B
"5 3 ) 0
8
5
+5
) ) P * -44O91.2,-4>/ 3$1,)0/75
) ) P * -4-0)# 2,-44/3$.!-,53/6 B
"
" ' G
+G )
;
9 )
,..!/3$.#> ,53/6?
@F
&
"8 "
" !A&
"
2 & '
2 G
+G )
;
9 )
,..!/3$.#> ,53/63$
4 3 5 !B "
"
0'
&
"
" % 1!(P* ;
+P* ;
.O94> 2,./3$.> ,)0/6 8
" "
)
B) "
2 :B
"
"
'
@ "
"
"
"
*
'
B<
(
( "
"
"
B
<
" "
(
8 <
5
% 1#0
" ) ;) ?
+;) ?
,---/!?)) >6 ?)) ,
F"
8 / )
;
)
2 9
@
*
"*
8
"
,9 5
+9 5
-!> =-21 B3$!4!,)0/6O
?
+O
?
,-1#/3$..!,O9/6 ;
*
"
) )
+;
*
"
) )
->=!>6/ B J
"
"'
"
B "
B J
8
" '
"
*
( ;) ?
"
+;) ?
"
0($ -11 ?) >#.6
*
4. @
) ) *
"
B 3
" *
* * D+B6
"
E Q
3 (
" (
" "
*
" 8
F"
"
"
( ;
) 8
G
'
"
)
% B
"
8
R
;
) R ;
+R
;
) R ;
,.!/1?))!2,.#/ ?)),) / ->2,.#/ ?)) ,) / 4-6 ''''
''''
''''% ;
)
& ( $$ ! !$ $ ) ! !
= 3 ) !
) (
&
'= $( &
$ # ;5) & /)0 ,.
@( '=/3
&
$
5 7( $ ) !
/) 0 ,. A
:
D B
)
0"
L
CL ,LL/"
E # < $ $$ ) ! !
% !( ! & $( ! ! $ $ $ & ! &
! & + & $ 8 & 7 : $$ /)0 ,.
7$ & ! $ ) $ $ $ 7 ( )
!
&
$( )! -
) !C "
* )& $)( & )!7$ *
-.
!"##"" $&"
''''
''''
''''
>(
9 (
8 " *
?
*
"
(
9 " "
( *
"
0
"
0
'
*
4 A
"
*
*'
8 "
* B"
*
B
*
% (
" " *
(
"
"
"
9
" *
-B
A
"
$
I +,414/ 53 .2,41F> /
A$$ 69
*"
<
"
2 B
"
*
*
*
&
% .B '
"
F
( '
"
20
"
% B
"
"&
A
0
" 5 3 ) "
)3A ) 3
+,--!/0
A$# ,53/6B
(
) 0) 9 ) )
3
?
K (
+,--./?))1 6 9 G
?$B) $ "
" "
+,-4>/ ?)) !2-4>?)) ,) / !46
$
I +,414/ 53 .2,41F> /0
A$ $ 69 "
F < 9 )
L
9 = (
0
)3 +,../?))-2..?)),) /146 (;); K (
+,-4>/?)) -#2 -4>?)),3H?/ >6 ) "
" 2
"
"
7
"8 '
$
I +,414/ 53 . 2 ,41F> /0
A$$ 6 (
9 '
,$
I +,414/ 53 .2,41F> /0
A$$ 6/ "
% B
'
9
"
&
" "
F9 ( = K
3 3G
0
)3+- 10).42 .#3<)42#!3B4-6 )
"
'
(
"
"
B
"
8
" "
B
*"
B )
* *"
F
'
* !B )
" O " $ 3 5 )3R +-.0)11243<)--2 3B6
"
A
F
F
" 8
B "
"
"
9
#(9?A9?
9 8+,---/-?))6
9
*
B )
9
" "
"
&
*
''''
''''
''''
&) ) )!& ,2
35 6 -!"##7% '"(
''''
''''
''''
4B
"
8
*"
< 9 5 ) $
I +,411/3$A'1#69
A
"
"
,?
B 1A /
CFI
B -
3
CFI
B
" ?
8
(
8
B
,
F
/
'
, 0
<
AR >! 1 / .0 "
"
"
*9
*"
<@
$
I +,411/3$A'1#6B
B
B
9
*"
<
"
:
"
*
*
*
&
%
" 5 3 , )
</ "
F
$
I +,414/3$ 53 .2,41F> /0
A$$ 6 $
I
,
/ " "
'
B 8 "
'
0
F *
"
'
'
% ?
@
, B ";
<!A !>/ B
B
*
"
0I
" "
%,I B 1A ./ B
8
"
!B"
2, / B
" "
*
,
/
,
/" "
, B ";
<!A 1>/ #0 ") * 3
,B ! A/2 B
B
*
"
" '
B 8
% ''''
''''
''''
>((
*) 9
?
) ;); K (
+,-4>/ ?)) -#2-4>?)),3H?/ >20($-4>?).416
$
I +,414/3$ 53 . 2 ,41F> / 0
A$ $ 6
B) " 2,;);
+,-4>/ ?)) -#2-4>?)),3H?/ >20($-4>?).416?))
!
/ :(
" "
% ''''
''''
''''
!.(
$
I
"
0 3
" )
A !!1
"
"
"
"
"
5
"
?
( "
" "
F
''''
''''
''''% 2 < ( )( ) &$ 9 $& )! ? /
* ! $ &
& ) $ & !
5 ))*))* ' = 3 $+
D = * ) >