High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/1820/2017disposed of

Gopi Ram & ORS v. Sumit Kumar Land Acquisition Collector Urban Estate Haryana Hisar & ORS

2017-08-25Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill3 pages

!" "#$%$&' ()(%! *+

&,-."/(%!$#" 0"%1 $&2 .

&,-."/(%!$#"(/3$&2"/4$&)1$..

/"%"&!'

&" /!1"5"!$!$&"/% / &6(/$!! .+ 22. /7 & 888888 "

# $% 1"5/"%"&!#&!"95!5"!$!$&1 %-""& $."2-7!1"5"!$!$&"/% :1%". &2: % #;($/"2-7!1"4! !"1")/$"3 &#"/ $%"2$%!1 !$&!"/9% !1" : /2 !1"/"

"/"&#"(/!+:1$#1: %%(-%";("&!.792$ $"2-7 !1$%(/! &2!1" 9(&! #95"&% !$&: %"&1 &#"2+!1" 9(&!: % &!-"$&)5 $2+!1()1!1"/": %2$/"#!$&-7!1"/" "/"&#"(/!!5 7!1"

9(&!:$!1$&&"9&!1 /9!1"2 !" : /2 !1"/"

"/"&#"(/!

..")$&)3$. !$&!1"/" +!1"5"!$!$&"/%1 3" $."2!1"5/"%"&!#&!"95!

5"!$!$&!$%&!$&2$%5(!"!1 !!1"5"!$!$&"/%1 3" ./" 27 $."2"<"#(!$& !1" : /2+:1$#1$%%!$..5"&2$&)-"

/"!1"(/!-".:+%!$..#&!"95!

0(/$%2$#!$&1 %-""&$&36"2 1"/"1 2-""&.! #;($%$!$& . &2$&!1"4! !"1"$%%("

: %/ $%"2-7!1". &2:&"/%/") /2$&)&&5 79"&! #95"&% !$&

(9-"/ :/$!5"!$!$&%:"/" $."2$&!1$%(/!&=

>4 (. !/ 9 1 / 9-$/ (!3!?!2@>44! !" /7 & &2!1"/%+ !1"9 !!"/: %! 6"&(5-7!1$%(/! &2$%-"$&)9&$!"/"2!"&%(/"!1 ! ..!1". &2:&"/%$&!1"4! !"+:1%". &21 %-""& #;($/"2 /(%"-7!1"

/- &%! !"% "5 /!9"&!+ /"5 $2!1"#95"&% !$& !: %%(-9$!!"2-7." /&"2#(&%". /!1"4! !"!1 !5/$/$!7 .$%!1 %-""&5/"5 /"2$&/2"/ %"&$/$!7$" $/%!.7 : /2 !1".."#!/+ !1"& : /2 !1"/"

"/"&#"(/!!1"/"

!"/!1" 9(&!+$ &7+"&1 &#"2-7 !1"$)1(/! &2&A-."!1"4(5/"9"(/!/$/$!7.$%!1 %-""& 5/"5 /"2 #&%$2"/$&) !1" !$9" :1"& !1" #;($%$!$& : % # //$"2 (!

55/<$9 !".$ -$.$!7& ##(&! #95"&% !$&5 7 -."-7!1"4! !"! 2$

"/"&!. &2:&"/%: %%! !"2!-" -(! *+

>#//"%

!"/!1"

/"% $2:/$!5"!$!$&: %! 6"&(5& B

&2$%-"$&)9&$!/"2-7 !1"(/!+(! !1" /"% $2 9(&!+ %(9 C+ CD>#//"%1 % ./" 27 -""&5 $2!!1". &2:&"/% &2!1"5/$/$!7.$%! /5 79"&! &!1"/ D+

>#//"% 1 % -""& (5. 2"2& !1":"-%$!" /7 & /- &

"3".59"&! (!1/$!7

(! !1$%D+

>#//"% /" 3 $. -."

:$!1

(/!1"/ // &)"9"&!% /" .%-"$&)9 2" &%$2"/$&) !1" /"% $2 #!%+ :" 2 &! $&2 &7 )2 )/(&2!#&!$&(":$!1!1$%#&!"95!5"!$!$&+!1"% 9"$% ##/2$&).7 2$%9$%%"2 ?" /&"2#(&%". /!1"4! !"%(-9$!!"2!1 !+1":$..%"&%$!$%" !1"

$#"/%! 55/$%" ..!1". &2:&"/%+:1%"#95"&% !$&1 %&!-""& 5 $2!1 !5/$/$!7.$%! /5 79"&! #95"&% !$&1 %-""&(5. 2"2&!1"

:"-%$!"

(/!1"/$&# %"!1"$/& 9"% /"&!/"

."#!"2!1"/"$& !1()1!1"71 3" #. $9:1$#1$% 29$%%$-."5/$/!!1"5"/%&%9"&!$&"2

D $&!1".$%!+!:1$#1 (!1/$!7!1"71 3"! 55/ #1" (/!1"/%(-9$!!"2 !1 ! /";("%!%1 ..-"9 2"!!1" $/"#!/+ "3".59"&! &2 &#1 7 !+!

. %1!1$%9"%% )"!!1". &2:&"/%!1/()1/ 9 &#1 7 !% !!1" 3$.. )"."3". &"

# '

$ ( ( )*)+,- &.

(

' 5 &6 0 $ ( =1"!1"/%5" 6$&)>/" %&"2 "%> =1"!1"//"5/! -."

"%>