← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/1853/2017disposed of

Manohar v. S.K. Gulati, Ias And ORS.

2017-07-17Mr. Justice Krishna Murari4 pages

 

        

 !"!#$%&' ( #* ,

-" .*./%&

!(. *+" , "1#0#  )$  23)  .)). 44 

+"# $4 )+1 5.# 5(06

+ !#+ 44 

* 1 *+%7* !#"

 #  1 !# * " "%7* & %# *!#7  # 1+ 0!#7" !#"

" # * 7+%#0

*+0+0

0 +'( "# 9# 81&!0:!

* ;!

* ""!"

#  %#"&+ !#+(* 67#

*+%7* *+0+0

0 +'( ""0!#;

<== *1+

!61 *>%078# + 0" "&&:"$4 ?# * !+ %8"

# "( *!":+!

!#!" &&:0

*+"1#0# +0!+  #"!0+

!#*!""+6! "+8

"+6! "*!">%#!+":++7%& +!@0 ""

  A+ !"9 ++!0% :!

*!# :8# *"+8 *0

+ !1  + !!0 1' *!"+0+ .!#  *8 !# "* "9#0 !00( *1#0!#7 )"(! #'( &""

#00!"1"0B %#"& + !#+ "%98!

* :+0 %"0 !#

96"

!0+0+?

&&:0B:%&08 #

*+"1#0# ++C%!+0 #"!0+ "  &&: * +7%&

!#  *!" "+6! "+8 *0

*"+6! "*!">%#!+":++7%& +!@0  * 6 * +0 %#"& + !#+  %+"% 0!+ !#" 1 ""0 9' .!#7& # *  *!" %+  # 

968# !#0(  !6!"!# & +"

 ! + * " #"!0+0

!#9% !#6!: *!# +!8+0+ ""0!#;

 <=4"*5'

7! # *+-".

+'

#0 +"( * * " A1+""0 *!" !# 9!&!

'  1 "" # +0+ + +7%&

!#  * "+6! "  !#+  * 1+

!6 1   +0+1 ""09' *+"1#0# !" "&&:"$4 ?  !" 1+ !##  9"+6

* #29& !6!"!## * %#> 9 #0 +'

!7*%+ ( * #0!7 +*!#;

 <= &0 "7"* '

7! # *+-".

 +'

*+"(* ""0 #!# +!8+0+0

0D<( *1+

!61 :*! *!" "&&:"$4 ? 6!#7 * +0 & +#0 %#"& + !"( 1+!8   ! : "

!"!0

* !81%7#0 1&! ' +%#" # * 8 #0

  * #"

!# & # *

 >%078# !# *?. +

+'(.

/ +#

*+" -"  6! #0  *+"B( E<F = .   #  %+ *+ +7%&

!#  "+6! " %#0+ * "

!0 1&! ' "* && +8 !# "

'0 !&& * !# & 0 !"!#  * +7%&

!# +0+"( ! #'( 1 ""0 +&!+ "* && 9 "%9> !# &% 8 *:+!

!#B)+6+( !#&!7* +8# !#0+0+( **!. +

6+#8#  +'

6!0&

+<G4.

D< !#"

+%

# %+ *+ +7%&

!#  "+6! "  81&'" "* && 9 8 0 %#0+ *"

!0+7%&

!#1&! !"!""%0G+6!60# +  +<<= &"9#!#"

+% *+%#0+

 +7%&

!# +0+"( ! #' !""%0 +&!+ "* && 9 "%9> *!# &% 8 *!6!&;+!

!#" # 6!:  +8# !#0 +0+ 0

D< 1 ""0 9' * #29& !6!"!# # *  !7* %+ 964 !

0 !#"

+% !#" 0

D< +8 * *! . +

 6+#8#   +'

( "+6! "  .* #*

## 9 +7%& +!@0B  + * +!#7 %#"& + !#+( *!" %+  !"  #"!0+0 1!#!#

* +0+ 0

0   +C%!+0 +"1#0# *+!

!"  #"!0+

!# +8 * 0

( * "+6! "  *!" >%#!+" :+ +7%& +!@0   6!#7 #"!0+0 !#+6!0+0+ ##A%+ 4( *+0+*

  9# 81&!0:!

* !#+!"# "

!"!0:!

* *+0+0

'( #0* "7 7+!6 # 

!

+%#" # *"1!+!

+0+ 0

0  ( !

 :!&& &:

'" 9 1# &&#7 *+0+ ##A%+ 4*+0"# 9 #':!&&%& 0!"90!#  *+0+1 ""09' *!"%+  * 6 &" #"!0+0 * # !#& +#0 %#"&+

*+0+"+7 +0!#7"

'!#7 *1+

!# *1&! !" 6!#79#+ !"0 #0+> 09' *.!#7&# *(!

:

"8 #0

+'

*+!

'  1 "" * +7%&

!# +0+  +8 *0

"+6! "*!">%#!+"* 09#+7%& +!@0 .!#  *!"%+ "& *!# +1+

!#G & +!!

!# +0+ 0

0  +' (   1#( # "5 * "

!0 !# +1+

!#9'!&!#7 "1

:+!

!#:*!& * &&#7!#7 *+0+

##A%+ 4(

*0:!

* * # !# * #  1 !# !" 0!"8!""0 :!

*%  1+>%0!  +!7* " !& & +#

!6+80!" !& 9& *!8!#

+0 # :!

*& :9' * &&#7!#7 *+0+ ##A%+ 4 %&' ( E)).F "

#> '   ;* *+"1 5!#7G+ "#0$ "G ;* *++1+

9&$ "G