← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/328/2019dismissed

Vijay Singh And Others v. Shiv Sahai Since Deceased Thr Lrs And ORS

2019-07-23Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill9 pages

     

 !"# #$%&%'(  )

 

        

  (*+ , ,,,



  !    ##### ,,,-  !$

$ 

& "

 '

!  " ()%)()%*!

  

'+ , !- !$  (.)/()%/!

 , 0"" "

     "" 

1 "  

""  $    

  

 

!  "   - 

"" %()1())%!$ !!

  

!$

    

" 2  !"

 

$

!$3     4 $     $ 5  (.%(%1/(

 '



53 6 !0  ! 

7 0 2 

7   $ 

        5 !$

2

! "" /5,    "" 15    8  9   $

$  "  :            

 ;<=%1 " 0 2  = !         ;%)*%1.1          $   :

$!    !%/=1 ""

5  "

    $  "%/=1 !   "" ;

*! 

  %;=%) " % *      .1%* (;)/%1/&"2 $     "$ 

  "" ;

&    %1=" . 1      (;%(%1//>    "2 " 

 

"" 3  ! " (.%(%1/(!$    =

  >      $                  %/).%11/>  !   

 4 !  5  

 

"2   4

 "2 $    "    3  *

0 2  !

$!""

  4  %/1=%)  <* "(;)(())%   &).. "(/%(())%$  

 ""$ 

     +  $

"     5    $         % 

 &        $   ""$

 

   "?  $ "" 

""

""  $  + %()1())%! "

  2  $

 "     ," * <

  $ $

"      $ 

 "", $ "

 ," .

%<! $



""!$  $

$ " 

&

     $

" -    !

 $ $" '

%  %()1())%

 &);.  !  

""@8

( ""  "

"

"

@

; ""    @ , & ""

 " "   @8 , *   "

 5  5

" @8 , <  





.

  @8 , . ""

    "

!@8 , / "

     A  3 ! '

  %*%(()%%!

    ""     

     ""    $       

!?

  "   !  $  $  5   +    

%*%(()%%!$   $" $ "

  $ "

 (;)/%1/&? %5   "$   $  ? !$  !  " ? ! $  > 

$

'

(.)*()%*!$

  

       "  "

  "         4     " %5 '

    "    $   !   "

  5

    "?  $ "

>  "" 2   ?   !   ! 

    

   3   .

%<

"" " 

&())%> 

$

""    $ $   ? "  "" "

/ ""$  ""$  $     

!?

" $ 

5 >   

%()1())%!$     ! 

 



"" "  $  

, !  

(.)/()%/   " !   " "

    %  !%;)<%1/;!      "

  ",95*5B

>  C?'D! 

  " " %3  "  

(;)1())%!$ $  



  "

 2  ! 

      $ " 3      $       "       ""5     

 3    "

 

  "$       

              ",95*5B > ! 

  5$   "? "  $ "

,95*!   ?

   " 

 %5  C?,D3   " ! "  " %5

 !  )%)*%1<<,95*!

 

   "$ "  " %5 !

   )%)*%1<<> ""!

! 

    "  " "

  "0

  !    "0

0

'

  $ 

            !   , !    )*);%1<& "

 $  :

$! "

 

 

  " " !    " " $ 

  !$  

" "    

   "0

  

           "    0    ,     !





, !  ! 

  E%( 8

!  ",95*B > 

$  

 



    "  $     "   "      $     )%5)*5%1<<  C?  ,?    "   " $ 

$ "  ")%5)*5%1<<C?,F    "    "

 

 "   $    A

0 ,$  (%5)%5%1<&  )*5);5 %1<&3 $  

  )*5);5%1<&   "

    $    0

 

   " " !

   " "> 

          

"    C?  D       "     " "    " "

)  G    "%1<<3 

$    "  "   

 %1<<>  %$

%1<< >    "  A 0



"

 

$     %1<&



 %1<< C? H 

   "     +$!  $     &      

$   A 0



  %(<3" A

0

  %1<& 

$ "   

 "()%*@ " 

$  "   $



 $  "

 "" $   $ $



$"   

 $  " >   $ 

   "

!       !

 

"

  

"      $ :

"

  $

$



$ 



 $  "  %;  "   $

   

 ! "

 9.A%!

 "  (%5)%5%1<&3 $  "

 $  " 2  %       6  (;5)/5%11& "

"    2  %()%*I "

"  



4 " " %5 $ "

"  ()%*    "!"

 "

";( "

    B  ?

 5"

  

       "

  %()1())%!  "



  J  '

    2    !  - !     

       $ "    !  "$  $   

""3

"          "  ?  

, !     

 $ > "" $



    "

  2  > 

$  $ "" !    $ 

> ""  5"

   

 "  $ 

"  - ! 

" $ 

 7=  0 7!  %/).%11/!   '+ +, !- > $ $   ? "  ""! !$> !



     !



 

   "  ""

" 3  " 

  '

  



.

%<   

 ""!  $

$ " 

$  $ "

 >        !$  

&!$

  " " 

""   " 

&3 "       % 

 & 

        

 "



 ""! $       "



&3   

  

.

%< 

"" " 

& ())% $""    C?   

    

   

 4  

     ! "

  !  > !

'

  $      " ""       "

! 

  4 "$   4 "$$     "

      0

'

  $!"

           "     !$

"

  "

    =    $    "          

!    ()%)()%* (.)/()%/ 

'+ , -



, ! ! 

 ! 4 !  $ 

 1,,,2  )

  345# &67!'

2 A 

HAB    HAB