Amit Chopra v. State Of Punjab













 

 





  

    ! 

 !

 "#$%&  

    ! !

"



%"#'&&# %(%%  

    ! ) !*
+,-

 #

 $%
 &
 &
 


' %
 ./)% /(!- !0*   .1.'/  2

3 

/ ./ !- !0*   .1.'/

4 

/ ./  - /),/ !0*(%- 

!5 /  



' %(


 6%%!%!0 &7** %! * 3///*+8  '/
!! / /

9! * 
-  - 9- -
- 4- 3 8:

*

-
9-
1;8! *
-
- -

   *- 3 3!!!%<7!%*  )1)0- %* - / * %%   !0 +8 -, 7&7 !%,=, *!/
/ $!*% 0!, 0*!,* 5 / /

/6,=! +8 ->! >1 -,*=0! ?  %&%, 0%0   ***  ?/ $! *% 0 !=         +8 - =*  !*!! 



 

  


  !
 "
!
#$$%



&
!
'(%


)

 
 !


 
!
&


*



!

+







&&
& 

&



,! 
)
!


* 

-!
%#./

0
!
%12$


!
3.#

! 
!
#1$1

*

!
4* 
%%32

 +
!
'#.3

)* "
!
#2/3

*5!!
!
#%'%


6
7!


 
#%#$6##6%/%$

+*
/%8//
!

!
 



&


+



 
!

4 
*

) 
!!  

) *&
6
#
9!
:
4 *

9

4*  
9
) 
!!
7 
4 
*



:

!*


9"
4 
9
) 
!!
7 
 !*

9"
4  9
) 
!!
7 
;5
4!

<5
,
9
) 
=*   
4 
*

<


) 
 "
!
:
 

 &
!
9
) 
)

  
4* 
:
,

!
+ !

;5

 
,
9
,
>* 


)


)

"*
?+ 

95

!
4* 
9
!+
4!5


-*5*
< 
9
 !*"



!&


! 
!5 


!& 

-!



!!  
9
0!5!
9





!
@
!



-"
!
9
= !
!



 !
9
,
-


<! 

!

*



&*

 



+*
$'


*5 
&



&


 *&
6%
! !

!
!


A
) "
!
9


<!
)




9 

&
!
A


&

9"
!
9
4 
 5!
66
4!*



-&


!
A
-*

0 +
!
9


<
4 
66
4 +!
  

!

&
!

0 &
!
9
;

 
7 !


 
!

 

!
9
)* *
7 



*
4*  
; ! 
-

9


 
7

!
66
4 +!5


3.
*5 
&


 &
!

!
*

!


  

&  
+

!
!


!




 * +
& 
 

&*+ 6
!













&

* 

!
!








+*
%/%3
  





+!
!

*&




"*



! !6

! 


   !






!



!

&

4 
*

!


!
+


*5 
&


 

!





 
&


!
+


"*



 

!



 



5
!


!

 




*
4*  
; ! 
- 
9


 
7

!
66
4 +"


"*




9 

&
!
@


&

9"
!
9
4 
 5!
66
4!*



-&


!
:
-*

0 +
!
9


<

4 
66
4 +!
  

6
!
 

 &



&



!

 
&



*
4*  
!

 
+




 & 

!

* 
 
 &


 
* 

-!
  !

! 
!
#1$1

)* "
!
#2/3


 
 !

6
<!
!

"*


&



  

 
)* *
5
 
 &

+


 


 6
!
!

&



"*


*

+*


 6



*
&



!

&6
* 
!

!

+!
!

*& +*






!





 & 6
*

 

+!
!

*& 
!
5




!
!

6
!

! !

*
4*  
; ! 
-
9


 
7

!
66
4 +"

 

9 

&
!
A


&

9"
!
9
4 
 5!
66
4!*


-&


!
:
-*

0+
!
9


<

4 
66
4 +!
  


"*

6
+

&

&




 




!  6
-  !




*
$/%
$/2
#./
$%$
$%'
#'(
#'1
 
%3%23'31




*6
!

*B
  




!

&  
+
!
!

*!

 +
!
'#.3

 

  
 


=9
6

+


6
& 

& 

+ 

* 




!


-  

  



6
 








+


!

*!


6
-

   !






+* 

!

&6



!


 

 


 #$6##6%/%$

!



4 
*


 /#8$/
-6C
$!*%0!% +8  *%%,0%= 7=*!==7
5 / /

   !!%    7@  %* *0!  *%==7=* !*0! ! */A%%  % - =  *0!      ***  ?/ ?%,- !7 07-  **!  

!!*%7*1**!;,== %%%7!%, ***?/B *1**!;,C!-

!!*%- =  !     " # $% &- ! %"#'&&# %(%%!!  ***?-,!0!!%  **!   7 5% 7  , % " # '&&# %(%%/

$! *% 0 0%, !   =,=%* *** * *,!7!?% ==7!0!!**!==   

*  0 ! , 0  * =  *1**!/

$!*%0!***=*& %*-=!!?%==!7!== =,**!=/ / +-7!*!- 07*%*%%%!!/=0-  %   >*!  **%! ,      *70, !/

*-%! *%=%7, !!,*%-*- %!? *%* % !/8%!!,%!

 *%   0!* ! *  %7    = ***!%!*1**! ,0!7== */$! *% % **!!   %, =  ?% = = ! 7 =* & %*       / $!  *%-=0-! ***?-  **!&%7  % " # '&&/ $!  *%  %  !!  07   *  !  *% ?  / $! *%-=0-7*   "#$%&0%0!* ! * 
 8 =  % " # '&&  0%0! *!(%7 */

9/ 80!%!*% !! %0%*!/

  !! ,  %!  *%-  ***? **%== !7-=*&%*!!% 7/ 6-%! *%%-*! =     7 =* = 0%0!   ***  ?-  = , !      0*,    ***/ 6  *   !  **!   *!!*%

!,*1**!;,-=!     ***  ?-     **! ! & %%577, %"# '&&*  / 4/ 8 *!***-!0- *%%,  % !   -   ***=%!0 %- %=%!&*!%**%!/6!  >!** %/6 *  %%=! !    !!  %    *    % 5), .7/ =0-   ! *%,70!0%%*! >  */

3/ '!%  !! -  *     ** %- =%!%,*

**%% %*/

 



' %
 

)*+,-+.
 (


 A&75!  D5' A% D5'