Kulwinder Kaur Etc v. Shivji Ram Etc
!
"#$%$& '()* "
+'(+"
,+!
$$$$$$--))"!
.+!(!
/, 01 2 3)"
,+!
$$$$$$$ !- "!
4# 564 $ / '
6/ +!"# 4+$!,*" + +7 7
+--))"!$ 4+$/(8, +!,"/ "9,7 7
++!- $$ $ $ '
6/ $:
6;
, !--) !-+ ++ 9 "!*+ &$&$7-!!
<34 + " ) 2!+ <(")7 ): "!, +5,+ <(")5;70 *, , ) 2--) ) <3 ) 2"!--))"!*! !2 !! $ !
!+, "$&$7("1< 2 (+ *"
+<,"/ "9,*!-+!" (+" "9- "
/ *) ",+
0 ))9 ,8=8 *) " "" "* ,- 8 "9 (37 "
< ,+ > )8$ => +/ "9,) "9* ,/ +21 / "9,*+ )!
-+!" (3$ => +/ "9,) "9* ,/ +21 / "9,*+
" 8 ,,- +
+ $ ", ,+!
7"+ ,<
1 "
+ '(2+7 +<,1" / "9, *! !" "9$ ,3 *+ , 8 "9 0, )!$",2"*, )7 "1- $%?&7< "9 + 0"<3 )"!,0"3 (,79 3+!7 2$*!< "9 + 0"+!,)3 "9) 9")3"
, +<,1"/ "9,$*!< (?$4$! +!()
"7 +<,1"/ "9,+ 0 "1(+ ! ", 7)9!
,+-+!
,<
3$ => +/ "9,) "9* ,/ +21
/ "9,!+ 8 "9 +
"1(+ $, + 0+
1-) 1-!- +"*3 2!- $ ",<! !
!2"
=> +/ "9,7 $ $&$7("
+/ "!%7@&7@7? *!
+9 !+ // +7> )87 !+ + >-(+$(+ "9 "0! 9 "7
+ 0+
1-*! " ! ()< ,"
"
,*! "9)3 ,))" $ +<,1"/ "9,!( (2< "1(+ ! " 0 ) !- )7 > )8 "$&$$,- !2 +2*!9 ( $*!!
, *!9 < (3+!"
*! +* "92 ",)3!)+3
!$7A 2("1< ) -+2"$ !$7A*+ " (++ , !+2"$
!- $7 *"+
1-7 " "$)!
" "0 )02"
1- " "$
!- $7 + 0+
1-7)!
" "$ !
! , )! ) 2- ",!<" ) ) 2 "$ => + / "9, "
/ +21 / "9, + "+!
* "!!$ , "!(+" 2-"3)!
" "$)!
"
,1-*! + 0"+!,)3"
"9) 9")3<3 + 0+
1-$ + 2,-) "9!7
)) * "9 !!(!*+ +2 # $ =,,+ ,
+<,1"/ "9,
8-) "$&$ (+" "9
/ +*) ",+
0 ))9 ,8=8 *) "
"
+ )(2- "+ " (! ( +!,"
"9) 9" + 0 "9
1- $%?&<3+!- " $7 !
!
B $ =,,+ ) 2"! + , )9) , +! -"
" (-
7 !
!
B
$ !!(! $"
-+ 0 *,2
) 2"!" ) "
2*, 2B %$ =,,+ + 0+
,
"
"90, )*!"
, ) "9)9) 0) + 0 "9) " , 2
"7 !
!
B $
) $ ,+ <(") + ! (!! "9, 0 " ,) ,"
3 * "!!*!C2 " 7,+
+7 !"
-+ 0 , "
8-)
( +!,"
"9) 9" + 0 "9
1-<3+!- $$!!( ,7 ) 2- "*! !2 !! $ ,0,+ )+" ("!)
+-+ !"
,0)!
+ ())3 ",+ (9, )$ +!
))7, !
(+ ! *,,+ "
8-) * ,1- $%?&7< "9 + 0"<3+!- $"
*,,+ 1-*!< "9 + 0"+!,)3"
"9) 9")3B , + <(") ,! 8" , 0 * , " 3 * "!! *!
C2 " $ ", ! !7 -+ 0 !7 ) 2"'()* "
+'(+--+
! =$ "
+ 8,2 --+ ! = -+ 0 !)+3 +
$ ")( 8 )37 => +/ "9,"
/ +21 / "9,*+"
C2 " <3 ) 2"!$ *7 , D(! " ! ! *,,+ " , <!"
C2 "
3* "!!!7 ) 2- ",! < !2 !! $ , +-)3 ""9 0$,
(+ ! ! 0+))
(2"+30 " )!
!*,,+1-*! "0 )0 " " +"
$"-+!" !7 + 0+ *"+
1-
"
--+ ",* "!!< C "3 "$ +
% "71-*!) !- "
*!8" " - !!!!
"<3- ) $ ,+
+7 " 3
1- !!<) !, $ '()* "
+'(+ ) 2" ,+!) *!"
-+!"$/, !,)-)!!) 3"
,+ "< ) 3 -+
( * - )
)! ""
<8"9+ ("
+ 0+! "9!
9 "!,+$ " + (*,,+ ( 2 0, ) " +"
7, !
(+ ! C2 "- !2 +2+- +
$ ,- !2 +2+- +!, *! , , !(
+
"1(+ ! ", 7)9!"
,+ -+!
,<
3$ , "1(+ !+ --+")3 (! <32 +0, ) "$- *" <3+!- " $ *! ) !- $ (+ "9 "0! 9 "7 - )
("
( , +!- $*! + 0 "91-$ ""3 !71-*! "!(+ * , +!- $ "!(+" 2-"3$ ,)+" ("!)
+ "!(+" 2-"3:+!- $;
,!+) (- "1( 92"7-!! <3)+" ( )49 !+! )!!7 > )87 $$7*, ,!, *!, " + 2 ")+ )7 ()< ,"
*! D(
+*"
C2 "
3* "!!!$ *0+72
,0 *,! 1( 92",!"
<+ "9 "2+ !
-+!" !$", -+!" !7 "0 )02"
1- ! -+ 0 2 , , 1- *!<"
" !- $ ! 2 )3 *" <3+!- $ *"+ "!(+ * ,+!- $ "!(+" 2-"3$, ,!-+ 0+!
- ) 71-, ! +<,1"/ "9,7*, *!!"
"9 8 ,,-,"
)!
+ "9, *"+"
+ 0+
1-
"
--+ "* "!!< C "3 "79 ! !, *, " !
-+ 0 $ "
"
"--+"
+ 0+"
*"+7 0+! +" ,! < +*"9 "!,2$ "9)37, ) ,
+<,1"/ "9, !+!()
+!,"
"9) 9" + 0 "9
1- $%?&7< "9 + 0"<3+!- $$ *7 2 "9 D("(2
"7 *!
2 )3* +8 "9 "("1< 2 (+ -+2""
*! (3$ *!9 "9 !$@A-+ 3*9!$,1 < "("1< 29(+ !
+ +)!! ","(+
-+2""1 <"
,+*+)!
," !
, !<!
+- " "- ) !+9()+2-) 3$, *!3+!
9$,+
+7, !*9!-+2 ", 2! !$7A$ !$7A +
"
((+-+ !- !7 + "9 <E$ ) 2 2! !$7A$A%, $$ !$@?@A ! ( !-+!
") C-"!!7" "
2 2! !$7FA$
+ "99
!
3+!72() -) +
F !--) $,2
2!
!$FGCFH !$%77F&FA$ !$@7A "
("+) C-"!!7) !!
!"
) !!
+ (2+)) * $ ,2++9+ "9)) * "9 + (2*! + <3 * ( 9" ,
"5<)/(-+2
(+
"
"492 "+) "!(+"
$ 6 $ .+!(! "( 2 ) ! ,(,+( 2 "
,+!7?:%;
:
0 );7*,+ "*, ) + "9,1( 92" " ")"!(+"
$6 $.+!(!+"3/, 7:@;F/
F?7, " , <!+0 !("
+# 5?$@
"! ( " " ,
, !
(+ " +"3 /, :!(-+; ) * , , 0+ (! , ! ("
+ *, ,
" ! <*+ " , !$ "
,! , ! !6 !!
+ (2$ ")9)-+)" 7I + (2J ! 2-"
(!+2*, , "
2-!!!5!- (!) + (2575-+") + (257"
) ) + (25$
F ,+ 9, + (2* () " )( , 2-"37 +7,)-7
+79( " 7!
) "
"
, *, , !) !! , ! 2 )3$= ,+!- !- (!7 * ()
" )( !C()+) "!* ,, !- (!:
1!,"
+!0$ 1< +/ "9,"
+!$:;&/
%;$ /- (!) + (2 !9"+))3 " !+ 9,!-+ " "9
,+) "!, -
,(!<"
* *, ,)) *! , !(+0 0 "9 !- (!
+ ) !!
I 2-"37 !
37
-+ "7
"7"
, ,+ "0+3 "1(9) +) "$J:) 85!6* "+3:, $&@&;$ +") + (2 !9+" , , ) (- ",-+2(+
,
-+"7
+ ) !!
I-+") 7 -+ "7
"7!
37 ! -) "79( " "
+ " "9$J ) ) + (2 !,+ 9,
,-+"! " "
, !
" ") ,
, ) $" ") "9 , ,
, ) (! 9+!, 8"
9 "3 , -+"!"
2 )3
, $,9+!9 "3
+ -+" ! ) !!, + , ) (+ "9, +) 2$ , ) +"+ 0)(
+, +) 07
"7 2-"
"!, -"
, ++ ) "
, 2 )3(" $
+ (2 !!- )-+ !2+ ) "9 ,"9 "9"
+2!< ( , !(! "
* +,
() +) "!, -!$ 4
+"
1(+ !
"!* +) 0+,0+ 9" > ,,0)(
, ) 5! + (2 + C ! , 2 0)(
,
"*+ ", !
, ,
, ) $4 ! 1(+ !
"! ,+
+ -+2 -+"! < *+
"("
+) !!
+ (2 ", ,
, ) $ ,2 ("*+ ,-+"! !
+) !!
) 07
"7 +"
2-"
"!, -
,
, ) $ ,4 +., )! !<" ))9 !) " 2 -+ "9+) ,0 2! +, + 2 ) !7 " !!
9"( " ) 2!$" !*,+-+",!) !, +2 "
, ) 7 +("2++ !
+ (9,+7,-+"!+" )
<*+ ) !!
+ (2("
+,,
) )
@
+ (2$ +")
+ (2 ! *+ , ) +" *, ) !!, + -+"! "2 +0, ) "!("
+, $5 "0 *
1( 92"
"5<)/(-+2
(+
"
"
492 "+) "!(+"
$ 6 $ :!(-+;7 , ) +"
$$ ) 2"! $ %7+" ) + (2,+
!$%7A ,$!!( ,7 !$%7A , ,+2 "
+ ) 2"!
+) !!
) 0
"+)) * 7*, , 2! !$77A$ , ) 2
2! !$F7%7F&FA$ "9)37 ) 2"!
+" )
!$F7%7F&FA) "9 *, "+!,+
@E-+""(2 2,
) "9 ) 2- " ))+) > "$ (
2
"7E!,))9 --))" $'()* "
+ '(+7*, ! +(" 3 3
+!"
+2 " "9E!,))<D())3 !,+ <3 ) 2"! $ %$/ " 9
2 "
+ ) 2"!*! @ 3+! ",3+*," ) 2- "*! ) 7,+
+7,32 9, ,0< 221 +"
*$/ 2
E!,))<D())3!,+ <3 ) 2"! $ %"
< !<(+! ,2) "9* , "+!$ "0 *
+9 "9 ! (!!
"7--) !)) * $ :'
6/ ;
$%$& !18! =,,+!-8 "9 + # !
=,,++- +<) # !