Avtar Singh v. State Of Punjab And Anothers





 
 
 

   






 !

"#
$%% 

      

  
 

 



 

 

   ! "#

$$%&'() % *(     "##$+, $ %&'() % *(#-

  .  (#  +- %&& ( $&'()   $%+! /% *(#   

 

    1# $$"    #   ,   - (    (  #  2+ 3  & &
4 5 6
789+:;< &#(&(*-+ # & -++ ) #(&  "# *('

) ,$$ #(&(*#--$$  +#( 3%,#/3# -- $-*&/3#- (#  $(/ & &

#, - (# &)(+-*(#  "/*(# 1(+( = 
66,#*($$(, "(&, - &:

> 1(+$*(# (. +) ( (,#  ) (  ,    .  +-(  #  --$ (  & & 
?

;

6?

 89+  :
<  *(  '($+ 3     +/ &  /3  # - (*($$(,&/3 --$ (& &6;

4 6?89+ :6<%  ,# )#  #   /  *(, &&  (  #  1# *  "

  ( 6@ @ 6589+:@<

-++ )(# &(&% ** & '

& &67 6 66(*# 9)+ '"

%1 $,(.A '

( ( 
%BA8<  % +! /%# /* $& 1(+  ))(& "(# & ** & '

%# $  --$ (%,# )# ,  ('&  /3  #  - (  & & 
?

;

6?  89+  :
<  & 6;

4 6?89+:6<%,+&(#- ( #- (% /3#  %# &()(-$&63 (*'

) &%#*(%, (  $&*()( &  (*(#'($+ 3 % - 3&*(/3#

  " &  #  --$ (%  ,# )#  ,   +/ &  /3  #  - +/2+$3%  #     ,   , #& ,  /3  #

    #  $ "#  (*  # , #& , $(*# & --$ (%#  ((*#)(+$*(# - (  #   #  '($+ 3     --$ (  +/ &  /3  # - (# '

"(/&) && &%#*(%#- (%(9- 3 (*#( )- (&%,(+$&/&&(# '/'($+  $3 &%#+% #&  $(& ,$$ # --$$  +#( 3C(&!) "# -- $ ++  /$%) (/ ))-&

(# "+%,# )## / &/3#)(+$*(# - (% # #- (# & --$ &*(* '3 C$ '+&# $*-$(3)#,# )## /!)&(#"(+&#   2+ 3, -& " "

# ,# # &2+ 3((& $ &3 )()$+&&%,#/3#-+ # -(&+-(#- (, *( )('3(*

?%?5 :

 %#+%)(&# # (*(!) ((*#

& --$ (*(* '3 C$ ' ++  /$

# )( ((*#)(+$*(#- ( "

) ( / ))-& )#)(- +#( 3# ( ))-&# &2+% #- (& &("  "#*(-()& "($ '*( - (&(** ' 3 % 3/ -#($ )3(*# ('(*+! /,# )#2+  # --(' $  ) ((*#)(- +#( 3*(+)#$ ',# )#  -$(3,(+$&# '(+"#

-+ $(*#- -:/((.,(+$& & ) # #(&(* -+ #(*&  $# /- & "

#- (/) +(* #  /)*(&+3 *#($& " "+$ 2+ 3  (# )#( ((-  ) -  #2+ 3 *#-((*#2+ 3(** )%# - (,  +& #(,) +( )(+/ # -$3 , "

, #  - (&(*
5& 3/+(-$3, ) '&  ( & # * )# (-$3# /* $&/3# (# &#(,) +( ) &% #*(%#)(- +#( 3# % # /)(* 3-$3*(# - (%&) &&(& # *('

)*( /)*(&+3 # --$$  +#( 3# )(* &# &(&(*-+ #%  -(& /3#-+ # " +#( 3%,# )#) (/* +$&, #  /)*( &+3   :)(&+),# )#2+ #)(- +#( 3(-   (&  * & ( # +(3+$%*(,# )# -+ #)  / -(&

D &)(+$*(#- ( # #-+ # (*&  $ ((# # #$ "#(*#* )# #- (#  )(-$&6
3 (*'

) &%#*(%,  $&(#" (* - (  +--((*# )( (%#-$ )$ )+-( !+&"(* # 1(+ #) (* '(
)"

**+,(
-  .
)+ /*)
'!
'

 0

+1"
"

)+!%6
58?<  @
=  -+ $(*# &!+&",(+$&#(,# #1(+#  9) & & ) (,# $&+) "#-+ #(*&  $(#  (*  )(-+$(3     .- "    '

,  #  -)+$   * )  & ) )+ )(*# &) ,#'

&), /(+"#()(&,# )# )$ $3#(,# ## $#,  / " +, ##&) &- D $1# &"" , $ &  +&) ) )+ ),# )#, /3(&# )(($,# )#$&(#  /)*(&+3

  ) ,#(+)#-$ # / .( 3 '

&)# //(+"#()(& #($3-$ %,# )## / . /3#- (*(#  /)*(&+3% # * $3) )+ )% ,# )#-$ ) (/2+ &, ## (*# +  (% -' $ D $ 1# &"" , $C) 8+- < # (%#*(%   "&/3# 1(+ D $1# &"" , $C) 8+- < &#  ($ &&(,#  ,(+$&(/ --$ ) /$(#)  # & # /)*(&+3(*  -$(3,(+$&/((*#" ' )(* :)(&+)%*(,# )#(& (*&  $) /- & &%#*(%# 1(+ (*#'

,# # -+ #%  -(&+-(#- (% *+$$3!+ * &,# )#&(( ) $$*( 3 *)

#, - (%#*(% && &

2+/+1
$3

 -0



40

.

 B##- .

"

 (& E ( B##-( /$  E (