High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1022/2003dismissed

State Of Haryana, Etc. v. M/S Universal Poultry Breeding Farm Hars

2020-03-02Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal21 pages

!"!

$%& '% ()'

++ ** , %"("

-" .!/ %"* (* %& 0%

!) 1%2

% "+

!"!

# 2 3!"' ++ **

, %"("

.!/ %"* (* %& 0%

!) 1%2

!"!

# %

, %"("

$%&

% #

% 30%% * 5$%&

++ ** !

% (+2 5(+ % /

% "'

7 3(2% /

% (7'+* !)' /

% ,!"'* 5%) 8%6 /

++ **

% %( :! % /

% ;'!"'

7 '(** /

% 2!

:! /

% :, </ /

% % "+ !

% (

3(2% :!* % /

% : /

% % "+ !

% '!* % :! % /

" (+2 %!)* /

% % "+ "

% 5(%/ ))%6* /

%/ !

% $%"' 0() % /

++*!

9 = !

% "'!"' 5(+ /

++*!

! =>= ! ????

0& '!" 4()2 "'** "

!"+ "

@( " %!"

%2! * ()' '!" (%

(* '/ !"+

)(*%

++ *" "!2+*& ;& ;"

%/!) ' 4()2 +""

;& '!" (% 8 ==> ! = %"

!""( !/ */ % 7

+!) ! /!

!2+

!""( !/ */

4()2 +""

;& ;%

% :() '!" (% '"

"! !

++% +%!

A2!

!% !""( " !

4()2 +""

% (+% (% 4()2 " !

;& * %

* +% " B'

@( 6'! '

" 4(! !"

' C9 ;!) *

6 % !

" ;

( !*!D

"(%+*(" * *% (

+% /!"!

(4; (%!

& E B (% " = !

;

%% " C = F +% 2(*)

$%& !*!) * $ *!) = !

;

%% " C = F 6'

% '!" * )* '

!%" %

* % %

%2! "(%+*(" "

6'!*

7!)

* !'

;& = (* ;%

( %!

" % 2 %

%2!!) "(%+*(" * "

!%"

;!) * 6 % ;

"(%+*(" * 6 **" ! %

$%& ) % ;& =

(

2("

;

' ;

$%& % 6'! ' %2" +%

$%& (4; $!2 '* % "' .!

B %%!

%& '!)%' 6" +%

(4; !

' /!

;%!) ;

( )%%!" %

%2"

) * " +% /! ! !%

!/ %! !+*

*! & * )!"* (%

= +% /!!) % !*!) *!)"

)%! (* (%* * B'

+(%+ ;

6 %"'!+

!** % B'

= *&" 6 +%

% *% "(%+*("

% !

" ( !*!D 1 +(%+

!"!

+% "

(* ;

" 0

= (* " 0

(4; (%!

E B (% " (* " =>

;

%% " H => (* "H 6'! ' %

" ( %#

$ $

$ % &

$ '

(

" !

) $

( $ $

"# $ *

+( $

" % &

' &

( ) %

* ,- $ ) ./$

" (

+" % (

1 2 3

12 3

!1 '"

4 -

$ 12 3"

12 3"

12 3

$ 0

5 " (

( (

& "

6 6 4 (

9 0

$ (6 :1;

0 < 2 !=7

$%& 6" %/ ( * )!"* (%

$%&

(

I = I B'

6" !%"

+(;*!"'

! $%& 5 %2 5D

JA % %!%&

% = 9 ++

& 6" " C ' & :(%& =F

$%& 2 "!)!! ') " % = 1

+(%+

!"!

+% "

= % * / 6'! ' %

" ( %# , (%- *. -% ./% 0% +*10*-*0. .0- -0

//(- 2%132 & >

0 0 6 0 7+ ?

!=@A ( 6 $

(

B 0

" 4

" 78

$ "6$

& 4-*.5 0/ 2%132

$ $ $ $

$ $ 6 $ $

B 0

$$ $$ $$ $

" 4$

6 $ " 7

0 <

$ $

0 < 0 <

C) $

(

$ $ $ "

%1 .+ 4*.5

< ( !=7 0

< ( !==

( " 4

@ 0 < 44 0 <

$ ( (

A $ $

(

= (

( " 7

(

( ";

9 %

!2+*

+% /!"!

$%& .

!*!D (%+*("

% % " '

=> 6" *"

%+*& ;

/%!

(" +% /!"!

= !"

!""( 6'! ' %!"

"! % '!*

A2!!)

"! +% /!"!

" '!" (% 6'!* !!) 8 ==> '"

*( ' ;!) * 6 % !

" ;

= "( ""!

+ " ( %!

" ( = %

@(!%

%2!

"(%+*(" % "

!/ !%" B'

%+%

!" ;"

(+ % (* % !) *("

;

= 6!

=> (* " '

++ *" 2 (+ % '

%!) 7

+!) ! /!

!2+ !""( !/ */ * % ("

$%& ' (+2 5(+ !

% /

++ %"

% ! 6 @(

""!"

(% 0

*" 6

7! ()'

""!"

(% %6

/%!

+% (

$ I;* (+% (% 6'! ' '/ ;

%!)

!""( !/ */ 9 2& ;

' 6'!* !!) 8

==> '!" (% %2 ** 6!) @( % 4(! # *

0 < ( ;

) !" "

A2!!) /%!

(" 4()2 " 6'! '

'/ ;

;% ()'

'!" (% 1!%"

4()2 %

6'! ' ;

2 !" ! "

1 $ 6.7 8 9 4

# '

:;9 & (( :

"! 4()2 !" ;"

%+%

= 9 "! "

* 6"

*% "(%+*(" ! & % => !""( ;

(% 6"

%+%

*("

;

;!) * 6 %" "( ""!

'/!) + (%!) + %!

= 6" ++*! ;*

4()2 6'! ' '" ;

% *!

(+ !" ! "

+ 5" < 4 < ' 6 ::9 & (( ;, 9 '!" "

( * /*!!

& * )!"* !/

;& /%!

* )!"* (% " 6!

' /!

) * " "+ !!

! !%

!/ %! !+*

*! & 2 (+

"! % "

( * 0 '

$ I;* (+% (%

A2! /%!

" ;& (%%!) 4()2 " (+'

( * /*!!

= $ % ! "! 4()2

*("

;

;!) * 6

!""( !/ */ 4()2 %

6'! ' ;

2 !" ! "

# 4

# '

; 69 (( & 9 "! 4()2 * ! '"

%( 6" *% "(%+*(" ! & % => % /!

6 ++*! !* ;& '!"

" 6"

!"2!""

$ %

* 6" **

( .

!*!D '

!)" 6 !!

%( 9 '

$ I;* (+% (% * '

!" +% /!"!

( $%&

+ "(%+*("

%2! ( (4; $ % !

"! 4()2 " 6 ** *("

;

6" % +% ""

A2! ;& (% 4()2 %

6'! ' ;

2 !" ! = % 69 $ 3% 4 / (

' 8 (# ' 6 ;9 (( &: 9 '!" "

"(;"

@( +(% '"

% %

;!) * 6 % ' !* +

( %

= !

7!) /!

* ! '"

;!) * 6 % 6"

*% "(%+*("

8 2;

% = '!*

%+%

I = I

" I = I $ I;*

(+% (% * '

* '" /

* 6 '" %!)'

9 "! 4()2 *"

@( 6'! ' 6" ! 6"

!% *& !

4()2 %

6'! ' ;

2 !" ! "

# 4 8 '

; 6&9 (( & ) 9 "! 4()2 )! '%

;!) * 6

!!) )

24 %!

& !!

!)" ;& +* !) ' "!

& '/

!( ! + ""

""!

"(%+*(" % "

!" % @(!%

;

%2! B'

"! '** ) 6" % + ** ;& $ I;*

(+% (% $ % !""( +% "

!% *& !

4()2 %

6'! ' ;

2 !" ! "

#7 +" 6 9 4 8 '

;

69 ((

9 "! 4()2 * 6" *% "(%+*(" ! '"

;!) * 6 % ! & % => B'

% ++*! 6" !* ( % (*

=> (* " "

7!) + %2!""!

( *!!D

"(%+*(" * !(!) ! !% + ""

""!

)% ( '

& (* !/ !) *" ! 2 % %2 9 6" (% % *!2 ' "

;!) * 6 % '/ ;

24 % B'

(% + **

6'!*

%+%

*& !"

% 4()2 +""

;& $ I;*

(+% (% "

<# % 69 # 3# %" 4 < 69 # 3# %" ' 6&

9 ; (( )) % (* % !)

"! 4()2 !

!" ++%

' $ I;*

(+% (% 4("

A2! ;% 4(%!"!

!/!* (%

= '

* ' 4(%!"!

!/!* (% !" ;%% B'

!" &

% 4()2 +""

;& $ I;* (+%

(% "

4 + ' 6 ,9 (( ) 6'! ' !" *"

*& 6!

' %

%+%

!" &

% 4()2 +""

;& $ I;* (+%

(% "

. +7 4 8 '

; 69 (( B'

"! 4()2 !" ;%!

% +""

6" %)(2 6!

' %

*("

;

9 6"

"( ""!

'/!) + ;

;!) * 6 % B'

!/!"!

0 ' 4()2

'!" (% *!

(+ ;&

*" 1!%"

4()2 !" ! "

# # 4 8 ' &

& 69 %(% 6("9 ) 9

"! 4()2 !/!"!

0 ' 6"

"! %!) "

' "

;!) * 6 % ' ;

24 % 6' !" !

* 6'! ' '" ;

*% "(%+*(" ( = 9

"! 4()2 "

A2! !

*("

;

% !/!"!

0 ' 4()2 ! +

1 4 8 ' &

& 6 9 1 $ 37 = ,,'

!""(

A2! 6" !

;!) * 6 ' !

2!) !

= ! $%& B'

!/!"!

0 ' 6'!* *&!) (+ /%!

(" 4()2 " +""

;& $ I;*

(+% (%

;

* '

6 %"'!+

* *% "(%+*(" '" /

( %

;

& %

%2! 9 '!" % )% !

6!** ;

!2+

' B'%

:()

'!" (% "

=7 > 4 8 '

:: 13= & '"

A2! '!" "+

( /*!!

& %" =

"! 4()2 !"

+% ( " ( %# @"

C@ @

"( 6

$ ( " @

6 47 ( 5$ " 47

( DE88 !F/"G 4 ($(

47 4 !F4"(

$ @ 47

47 4 !F4

6 47

47" 4" !F4

@ ( &

0 < 0 < 7& "3 6 0 < 0 <

7+"F" !=@"* @ 47

"8H # =F4/(2 8(F/I4@@ ! ="!"F/ )1

J2 K

1 (JK " B L $

I @ 0 < 44 0

47 J 1$ <J $( !F4"3

I 0 < 0 <

47 J 1$ <J $( !F4

$ 5

3 ( !F/"L ($H # "//74(288F/I777+! 4!" +"F/

5 $ $

@ 47 J 1$ <J $( !F4"8 $ @ J1$ < J $ ( !F4 6

( 7+ ?

!=@

0 < 0 < 7+ ?

!=@ $

> 7+"F" !=@

47 J1$ <J $( !F4

> 3 ( !F/"L !" # $ ( (

@ 47

$ 47

4C" " !F

$" 4 ( DE88 !F/ 6

(

47 4 !F4"

* $ $

47 $

47 4 !F4 @ $

47 4 !F4

47 6

0 0 <

7+F !=@

6 @

!""( 6'! '

"! % !" 6'

% ! /!

;% 4(%!"!

" +% /! ( %

= 6'! ' !"

" ( % !/!* "(!

!" 2! !;*

# &) % 0/ =2%*+*(-*0.

# 1 1

( A

( &

) 1 1

" 4 # ) 1 1

( &

2! !;!*!

!/!* "(!

!*!) E6" '" ;

A2! ;& 1!/ :() '

'!" (%

8 4 4 > '

,) 1 $ 8 ;

A2!!) /%!

(" 4()2 " +""

;& $ I;*

(+% (% ! *(!) 2 (" 4()2

$ I;*

(+% (%

> < 3 4 $ *% ) (

;& ;& :() ' !

6" '

* ' B%!;(*- (%

(

( % + !* (

(

! /!

+%! !+* (%* 4("

% )!"

(% +% " %!;

(

+ !* (

!/!* (% '"

4(%!"!

* ' !/!* (% '" +%!2%& 4(%!"!

% ** !/!* !"+(

" " +

!/!* %

(% B'

+% /!"!

A *(!)

4(%!"!

!/!* (% '"

;

*& "

%( ;

*!) '

4(%!"!

!/!* (% "

% A2!!) !/!* !"+(

9 +% "

;

( %!

" '/

** 2

*("

;

= 0

= +% /!"!

= ++*! ;*

' % )%

% 6'! ' %2" +%

$%&

"( ""!

+ ;

= *("

;

= (* '/ (** +*& 2 *& ;

= '" ;

! & 2 %

;

%!)'

!%"

;!) * 6 % ;& !'

!** (% % *("

;

% " 6!

' ;"

!/ *("

B'(" *("

; '"

;

+* '!)'

% + * '

% +% /!"!

" % (* % !)

*("

; !

!" ++%

+ !) %

%2!

"(%+*("

% !"

/!") *& !

(*!

" ! 6'

* !" @(!% ;&

!! ;& '

!% ;& !'

JA +

(*!

" "(%+*(" % "

6'! ' '" ;

;

I = I *"

"(++ "!

%+%

!** (% % % !)

(* " %2 (

= "

;

!" ++%

' !)

"(%+*(" * !

( = !"

*& 6'

2+*

! % 6!

(* " K;(*!& 2 '" ;

(

;& **

% '/!) ;

+( ! + ""

""!

B'!" !"

+ (*!% +% /!"!

( = (* " %2 ( % 6'! ' '"

;

6& 6!

' ! I = I " 6 ++*! ;*

$%& 9

$%&

= "

;

+% /!

"(%+*(" %

* 6 % / " 6!

2 **

(2;% " % ++

& ! "

% 6" *% "(%+*("

" + %2!""!;* % ( (4; E6 % 6!

' % "+

% *% "(%+*(" ! $%&

"( ' *% B'(" +% /!"!

= ;%!)" "!)!! ') 6!

' % )%

!) "(%+*(" * $ % !'

;& '

!% !"

"/ ;&

= "

)!/ (** +*&

*("

;

% 3 0%% * % ("

* ++ %!) ;

$%& '" %6

4()2 +""

' ! 8

$%&

% ," '!

B*6%

%" ! >

' !

"(!

;& +(% '"

% % 2 2 '%; ! /! !

'" ;

* '

"(%+*(" * *% ! '"

2 '%; ! /! / " 6!

& ! = B'!" (% '" % (**& % 4()2 +""

! "

B*6% (+% 9 2& ;

' ;

:() 6'

! "

B*6%

(% 6"

;

= 9 %)(2 6!

;!) * 6 % +% ! (*%*& 6'

"(%+*("

* '"

;

( !*!D ( = 6" %!"

'!" "

) !

2& ;

* /

$ I;*

(+% (% "

/ (

' 8 4 > +" ' 6 , (( :: '" '

* '

( = !"

"(! !

(* ""

%2*!

" "+ !!

! (* " % (*!** !"

!) * !

( = %" >

"! 4()2 %

" ( %# ="

2 @4+(4+G4+1 < 2 !=/

2 "2 @

L L

4+(

2 4+G

5 $

"2 4+1

L& L L

L L

L& L L

L "

+( (

L L 5

$ "

2 4+K 2

5 L L

+!) ! /!

"! !" (""!

!" *% '

2 '%; ! /! '

% "( ""!

* 6" % @(!%

;

%2! ( = '"

* )* '

!%" ;

7 +* ;

= 6"

$ *%

"(%+*(" % ! '"

'%; ! /!

$%& ++

& ! =

+!) ! /!

"! " '!" (% !" "

(%% !!)"

%%!/ ;& ;

(% ;

* 6 $ ;

++ *" ;

%!) % !"2!""

%!)*& 6%!

;

%!) 8 !" *"

!"+ ** + !) 2!"

(" ++*! " ! & % !"+

! /!

;

"! 4()2

0 !"#!"$%&"'()*+,$"'%-*"./ "%,- !"#!"$$"&-$#'01"/ "%,-