High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/2151/2008disposed of

Shri Niwas And ORS v. Paramjit Singh Aujla And ORS.

2017-02-13Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh8 pages

Pooja Sharma 2017.02.17 10:53

!"# #"

$#% &'

" (%') !"# *#+ !# "

## ", -./ 0!12 "#

"#+#"

# -*##"

.) 0!!)30% '

4 #"

)#!6

4# #" %"

" + 8#" ""##+ !# "4#!

#2"#!"#(%) 9#"# #1 2#

!"( ""#& 8 "#&

&%&#(%) ) (

2# !&

4)#""##(%) #&+)8## "#& '%!(&# "

: ;4)#"#+#<%"

!"# $ %$&!

' ()(

*&+,$&!

' (

=/* #

!+#"

+#!

!+# 1# " "# #+!%2#! % !#, > 1 "# 41#0"# +#!

" ""##+ !# ""2 !#"#2)

& "#& "#+) 28?

"%2"

= #)) "#) (" "#'%!(&# " +#< %" @& !#1 A 2 # %+ / B#

#0 "#

#2)

(#4# )#,!#"#& "#) ("

"#'%!(&# "# !##!48"#+#<%" @& !#1 A2 %+ #2&+#"# " %" "8 ))+ #))# #!

+# (!#0 "# %# ""#!##

41#0

< & " &"#!

#2# +" 2#"

#!2+8 !# / 4#"8 ( "#! " "# +#"

# " %4& "

#+## "

?%++)#&# "

8 #+## "

" %++)#&# "

"# %4&

"# %# % !# # ## 2#

& " &"!

8 +#! 22!

()8C 1 "# ++"% "8 ( 1# " "# +#"

# "

)# #+## "

?%++)#&# "

8 #+## "

" %++)#&# " "# %4&

"# %#% !## ## 2#

+# ! "

& "

&"#!

( "#!#0"#+#"

##1#!)#( ) "

2# "#!

%+ "##+ !# " 2&+)

2# !#+ #!48" %""##+## "

!#2 !#! !"#2&+#"# " %" "8+ #!+# !#!

"#! 7

"#( !"#(%) 0 ## 0"#2)

) ( 8 "#&

&%&#(%) )###

#1 #! +# ( !# #( !

( "# #,!#"#&

(# "#

)+ #!

7 D# (( #1#!

""#

!!#!

"#! 7

70"#+#"

)#!"#+## "2 "#&+"+#"

"#2 "#&+"+#"

%#!

!#!#!

"#!

!##!"4## ! ) (

"#"#2 #

!'% #! 1 %!

70 )# #! 2% #) #+ !# ","

"# "%2"

& #+ !# " 0

+## " "# %" %4& ""#! " " "# #+ !# " ## "

)) ("#<"# !"#4# #

8&# " &

&%&

(# " "# +#"

# 48 !& ""

( " " "# "# )8 "% "#!

+# 1#4## ( "#!" 4# #

70 )# #! "

"# 2% #) %4& ""#! " " "# %)!4#( "#!"#&

"#+

##B##

70-=E ,

)#!48 "##+ !# ","

"# +) ( #2!!#!

"#!

/ 7

7 %"# ##B (+#&

% !#"

(( 1# 4# #" %"

7.##+ 1 !# "#!

7+ #!48"#

D# 2 /

70" !'% #!"#2 # #!

" ("#

"#!#2

/ 7

7 7 E0- , E

)#! ) "#2 "#&+"+#"

#1 ) +2##!

( "#/

#!# ++)

!"##

0)# #!

"#2% #) !4%("""# "

2# %"" ""

)#!/ EE,E E

"!#

) / 7

7 "

)& !#2)# "#

"#"

: A4)#"#%+#&# %"!

! "+ 8!#

1% "##+ !# ""# "#8 !" 2&+)8

""#!#+ #!48" %"#2 #2 &#%+ # 4# #: ;4)#"#+#<%"

!"#2 "#&+"+#"

!'% #!"

"##F%#" )# "#+#"

"(#" "%2"

"#( !"( "#&

)#""#

E #+ !# ""## ##

"#-=E =,

)#! +) ( #2!!# #<%#, ", #<%# "#!# #!48"#2 "#&+"%"

#<%# , "# !# + / E==

70 ## #<%#, "#!#+ / 7

7 /# "#+#"

#%4& "" ""#+#"

1# "4## ( "#!4# #

"( 1# ""# )8 "% "#!#&+)8##

B "# &#!#+ "&# "0 ## 0)# #!"

"#2% #)%4& ""#2

2 !##! 1 %#!

48" !4""#2)

& # #1 2#

( &

)# )# !84## ( 1# ""#&" )"# ! )# #!"

"#2% #)" ""#2 #2 "4#

"4# "+

""# )8 "% "#!#&+)8## "##+ !# ", #+ "&# "/# #!"

"#2% #)%4& "" # "#2 #

) "#!

# ( 4# # : ;4)# "# +#< %"0 "# ))

( !#

#!, >## ) #4# (!

+#! 48" 2&& !# "# B# 2 1# # 2#

2" #4# ("

B# & ++# ) =7

) #2"#!

""#!#+ #!48"#:

( %" 4 !:

E 77 #

D# 2 #!"#6 "#"

#2"#!#+ !# "" 8""#+#"

8 "##(%) )#48

< "# 8 ""#&

"#+

#2" &"# "#

( "#

+#"

#=E 77 "

%"#!

#2"#!" " "#+#"

# ))(#" "#4# #

!# #

2# "#&

# )) 4# +

! " "# +#"

% & " "# %4&

2#"

"#2+8 !# "

) &# "

#!" "" !# )) "# "

")#"#+#"

#" 2)

&#(%) #1 2# "

)) 4#+# " "# #+ !# ""!

+# #

""##1 2# "##&+)8##

! " %)

)) F%

4%" )# ! ( "# #+ !# " ))2&+)8

""##F% #&# " "#"

"%"8 +1

) B# !%"

) +%"#2"0 7E (( #1#!

" " !# " ) 48

+#2

)/# 1##"

)#!4%""#+# "#!# "#:

(%"

8#!48" %"# #"#%)"

""#"

"#!+ ("#&

)#" ))"##+#"

&"#!

"#'%!(&# "

(%"))"# #(#""

("#&

&%& & 77=

! - : -% ' )0 )# #! 2% #) ( "#

++#)) " "#!% ""# "

" #2# "!#+ #!48 "#"

= ##48

"## # (""# !#2

"#2 #2#"

80"

!"# $@& #1 !"#0

=E 02#&# 4## +#+ #! !481 "%# "2#&# "##1 2# "# +# 1#+%" 8# #1 E

= ))4##(%) 9#!0"##&+)8## %)

))"#&

&%&4

"#+"

++ "#!G )) 4# 2#"

#! 48 "# 2&+#"# " %" "8 " "

= %+# %&# 8+" ##2# "#!"#"

"##&+)8##

#1 " ))4#"#!%"8 "#!&

" "#+ "&# "

)#2 !# (" "2 # 2#&+)8##0"#!# #!48"#%""4# &+)#&# "#! )#""# !+ ""

%"#!

#2"#!" " %"# ++ "&# " ))4#& !# #<2#+" 22!

2#"#2#&# "4##

&#! !"#"

4 "

"#!2 !# ("# #(%) ))"#+# 1#+%" 8#

#1 E

=0"## #0 %# %)+%+#

))4# #1#!48 "# #

""# &+%( #!!#-#0"## +# # )# !8(#""

& 77="

)) "4#++#"+%""#2)2B4 2B : #1#0)# #!

2% #) "#!%" "# "

""#!#2

2%"

"#2 "

$H &# ( 77=

"" 0)# "##+ !# "

"#!% ""# "

""#!#2

"#2

4$#1 !# ( 77= %# %)+%+#

))4##1#!48( ""##2 # &# "#!#2

"#2 @& #1 %+ *# !##!48"# "

"%"

D# 2)!"#

#)! "

2%""#"" " %"#"#&+ 8?

!2 ++ "&# " )) 4# & !# !-+ $!- '!+ $*$ !" .$/0 '( & "

*& ( '* & & 23244556 "!

7.1 ,8 ,!$ - &! $!

9 !9!( ! ,$ " -, ' ' & 9((&0 ',7'!.

( (9!$&$ ( 1 & 7

,$7 '*,$,*.*9 ( 1"

!*2::6,"!

'1(

'$25 ( '( +, (!" '(9 (!$(* $!-0 7.1 ,8&,$ *(!" '( '*"

*&0 '

!" .$/0& &23244556 $ -&!$!

",$& $ * , ,$ '(991($& '(* &,(*,((& !# "2": #1#0" !# )) "4#+#2#!# "

%"%#C "#!#!

"#!=E

+ #!48 : ;4)#"# +#< %"0

&# "

#!" 2#"#31# &# " 4 )# !8

&#! 2#&#!

= "##1 2# #&+)8##0

""%("++#" "# ##

""#!#+ #!48 "##+ !# " # )# !8(#""

("#&

& 77= # "#) "&#" "# 8# "

)!##!" ""# #1 2# #4##(%) 9#! "#& "#2#&# &#!48 "#"

"# 31# &# " !

"#!

= ! 48

( &# "0 "#

) ##!

#! /# "#"

"#%4& "" ""#+#"

# 1# 4## ( "#!4# #

!# #

) (

&%&#(%) # 1# )4## +

!""#& ! " !%# "

!"##+ "&# "/# #!"

"#2% #) )%4& "" " )87 #0 1#

)#!6= = 77 #(#""

#(%) 2 )#+)%

2##1 &"

&#""

22!

!#2

: ;4)#"#+#<%" )++# ) =7

# ## "+ "8 = = 77 #/ D# 2 / 7

7 #!"# ))

(!#, >"

2# &"

#+2##!

(4# #"# "#&+"%" ))#&

8#!

))"#

)!#2

"# ) " 2)

#!" ""

%)! "+# "# #+#2" 8% !#"

2 4## 1# ""#2 "#&+"%"

"#"#!#!

7C 6 )#!

!/0

&# "

#!" "4# #

" )) 4#( "#! &

"#+

##B""#+#"

"#2 "#&+"+#"

D""#( #1 2# #

"# #1 2# ( &

&%&

(# "##(%)

"#&

1#4## #)1#!" )8"#!# 4## #!4%"%4#F%# ")8 #1 #!!# )4## + #!##

)#!4# #" " "4# #

" 4# ( 1# &+)8 !

%#! " 2 !# "# 2)

& # ! ++"% "8

( 1# " "#& "

)# #+## "

%4#F%# ")8#2 # 4## 2 !##! !"# #1 2# 1#4## #(%) 9#! !&

)# )4## ( "#!" (#&

"+2##!

""#2 "#&+"+#"

0# 2#"#

#! : #1#0 2 #"#+#"

# #"

)) (( #1#! #

"#( !""# 2)

& "+

" )8 "% "#!#&+)8##0 "#8 # ") 4#"8"

)"# +++

"##&#!8 ; < +'

6#"#+# (?# #!

I# 6#"##+"

4)# I#