Ranbir Singh Rathi v. Zile Singh And Others
!"# #$%&%'(
'
) * + * +
,-!""!+%./0
! " #$ %& &#%'(
( "
) "
%
) *
++
" , -
&
)
"
(
. / 01 .
! "
" &#%2 (
" &1&#%2
3 ( %
( %% %# &#%2(
#0 %% &#%2 #'
%% &#%2
(4
%
5"6 .(
( "
(
#0 %% &#%2
) "
7
#'
%% &#%2
(
"8 0 '%
4%9:%
++ %
( ( ;
"" (
#1 %# &#%2 )( %% %# &#%2( "")
(
; ""
)
( "
< *
++
(
:
%
(
5 )
! "(
%:
3. 4%991
4 * "
( " (
( "
3( ( , -
*
( = "
4 &% 0
4
%
4 ! " "
"
)*(
( "
(
(
"
*
"
=
(
3! "
#:
#2 &#%0
"
"
$
4
(
( (
"
( ( 7( "
>
"
?<; "" ( )
"
"
"
@(A
(
(
-
" ( *
1
(
" "
" > ) (
?<; "" A
4* "
+!23!2!2$/!2!+%./
2!24+56/ !2&/!+%./"/#2& &##1 1
219 (
-( " "
(
8 "
( "
( ( "&:
%# &#%2#2 #'
&#%'(
( )
( "
"
. . !
"
4
3. 4%991 8"
"
*
'
(
B8
( % "
- (4
( *
"
(
"
7
( C
( %
-C
7
. !
* "
8
8+2##2!,!#3394#"52%.
%$#2 &##9 '
20$
7
5) @ 4 "( (
"
5)3
"
( "
4 =
( '%
4%9:%
%#
4
4
"
8 % '% =
3
(
(
" C
* "
3 ( = (
%%
. ! D * "
8
52-!-+%./42#&%3%.
%$#20-#$"%2%:5!-0 -$6 *#/2!0 %&"2%$"+!.252 &#%# :
121 (
!" ( (
"
8 "
( (
; = *B8 > /
4 " '#
4 2$ %
4E
/
8" " 2$ %
4 '#
4
"
(
<
(
= EA %&
* ,
""4%991 212$'#
* "
(
(
4
( 2$ %
4
'#
=
, -( = "
%0
;
(
8" "
4
"
(
( (
( = ( "((
= "
%1
-" . ! * "
8 /"!&/"/25./*&4+"!"#-#$"%,,%&&%!3 "/#2&
? :$1%&#%$ ;F. #9 #9 &#%$ (
!"
3( (
(
( * "
( =
D D
4
3 *4%991(
%2$
(
"> A> A
" (
"
"
; 0 %
( " (
( D
%:
-"
52,%"+%./4!<=5,!2!3"/#2&
? &%:&#%$ %# #'
&#%' (
.
?
.
*(
4
* ,
""4%991( (
(" = (
"
%$
. ! "
-(
"
"
* "
(
= * "
%2
7
. !
> %
- * "
!<=5,!2456/"9!2+%./!3 "/#2& &#%2 %
09& ( ( "
!" 3 7(
@ %2$
3 *4%991 = (
'%
4%9:% '#
* , ""4%991 =
(
3 " ")
" = (
3
%'
. !
* "
* "
8%39!?!"%5@"!2&4 /!6"%!2%!9!62& &##$ %
2&2
( (
; $; 2
(
" ( "( (
+ + )
%9
. !
"
3 "
" * "
*
D
4"
4
* "
" * "
"
* "
(
* "
( (
&#
@
2'
3 . , %991 && * "
" (
= " ( =
8
( %2$
3 *4
.
"
" = (
&%
3
"
"
-
D
* "
C (
= (( (
* "3 " (
() 3
" (
* "
(
3(
(
* "
""
+!23!2!2$/!2!+%./ 2!2&) *
D(
"3"
"
D
(=
"
" ( ( "
&&
8 % 0 %2$
3 *4%991(
(B8 >%2$ #"#2,%!"% 4!-%3%"9 #-#$"%#A5%29:9<53.# !3@2$#352# % 7
"
" !" " !"
" G
"
G " =
=
( = ""
(
*
( (
"
=
& 4 * D
( B8
(
"
"
(
"
C
( " "
4 8 % (
"
"
"
=
"
DDDDD DDDDD DDDDD
3. 4 %991 (
%:%$0&( ( (
0&
/# $"
1B8 >7 -#$"%@#"%"% % ? "
" = D
" ( "
%1
& 4 =
" "
%'%9&#&%&&
(
0 4 *
1 4 8
" (
(
(
= C
" (
%9#'
; #-%# "/!",!9:#$-!%,#3:9"/#@#"%"%#2 88 % 4 ""8
C
"
&
D + + "
( "
;!H %1 DDDDD DDDDD DDDDDA > ?#2 " ,!6# 25-#& 2#.5-!"%. "/# #-#$"%
,#,:#2& % -
! "
"(
, """)
( "
"
" 4"
B8
F DDDDD DDDDD DDDDD
>
" "" * ""CA
DDDDD DDDDD DDDDD
*
C
)
" ( (
! "
" ") ( 4") ")
! "
& 4 (
"
( (
" D
A
/#3# %4%-2$#352#
> 23#2 05-#' > @@#!2!$#0 #"$0 ,!9 :# % @#2&0 :9 2#$.%!.#"2:9@-#!3#2'4 = ( " " D (
( D (
"
"
I
" J B
"
A DDDD DDDD DDDD DDDD DDDD 23#2;05-#7B8 7 8#2% %$!"% @-#!3%.& %
( (
"
"
= (
&
"
(
()( (
"
")
(
(
(
I
JA K
( 0&
4
3 . , %991
" ( 2'
. !
(B8
1 >(> -#$"%@#"%"% % ? "
" = D
-
& 4
. . . ( ( =
"
( ( ( A &0
4
( .
!
=
8
( 8 & 0&
"
( %###<8
7 2' "
< " C ( 8 & %:
4
%'&&
(
" '%
4%9:% '# 4 = D > (
A
8 % %:
34
(
" ( = D (
7
( "
"
4 (
(
@
'%
4 %9:% = (
3 *4
8 % %2$ 4
"
" !" =
=
"
= "
D
3 . 4 ( (
" %###<8 0& &
"
(
= 8
(
8 & %: (
" *
-
* "
" *
)
* "
&1
7
)
"
.)
*@ "( 3 (
'# '#84 '% '0 '1
4%9:%( (B8 >> -#$"%@#"%"%& L? =
D (
; I>
%./52"""29#-#$"%@#"%"%& L
-
*
3
*
3
""
"
" B
(
3
-
3 "
* (
3 J >2#&#"!"% @#"%"%& L
4 = " "
I8
J %## %#%
I3 J
I( 8 "
"
( J +5:&#$"% ,%""#3DDDDD I
, " "
"
(
J > DDDDD DDDDD DDDDD I> "#"& @#"%"% L
4 L
" (
C
"
""
""
C
" (
%9#' :
( %9#'
B I (
"
"
J
4
D
"
"
J
4 " * "
'1
#-%# "/!" ,!9 :# $-!%,#3 :9 "/# @#"%"%#2 ""
"
"
&:
;
"
(
"
(" (
("
) %
( ""
8 2 %&0
%9:%4(
("
(
"" " '0
4
( ( =
8 % '0 ( 914
, %9$%
> &$
* "
+!,!" !-!62%&/!!3!"/#24#2.##2!3#B!3"/#2&
%9$9 0
&0' !<!2!%4+,"3%2!#/25!3/%!3 !"/#2 %92& 0
':# = * "
(B8 >9 3
(
3
"
"
"
"
( " 7 * "
(
"
"
-
3 -
(
" "
,
3(
"
")
7
"
7
8
(
)
/
()
3
%#
(
3
(
-
8 % '0
4
""" "
"
-
"
9184
"
"
"(
= " ! 8 % '$
4 -
"
( "
4
!3 2&0
%4%-;1 +'
1+1> 2 4
!!
"#
(
)
7
" ! '$ %
4
"(
> '% '& %%2
4A -
= (
" '0 %
4 ?8" (
'0
4 (
= '$ %
4
" ! '$
4
8" ( '0 % &
4 -
/
= "( "
> A = *
'$ %
4 "
%%
3 "
(
( "
,
" *
"# $ !!% #
M
( (
* "
3
-
3
( (
4 "
* "
*
"
(
"
* "
+ (
"
&2
3( .
!
( (
@
D8"
" '%
4%9:%((B8 >8 % ") "
"
8 % %## %#% 7
"
3 *
(
"
4 8 % ( 1: "
A
@
(B8 >14 ) '%
( " 8
"
"
412%9$$
% 0 ( ( 8 % (
= 8 0 ( =
8 %
" B
=
<
"
> A> AC
" >A
C
" > "
8 % %## %#%C
& "
3 C & " ( 1:"
"
(
= D -
'$
% (
>3 "
( "(
'%A
3
* "
=8#6!"#&?!2!!4 #66!,!2!&%,/!#33% 47%9$9 '2& 565,3#4!2!% !3!44*!-%"!2!%%&/2!
%921 &
%00 ( (
B8 %$
/ ( 8
"
-
(
( ( " "
"
(
DDDDD DDDDD DDDDD >%9 ;
(
=
4 " ( =
"
" "
" >A
"
"
3 "") " (
D
&# 7 D
'% % " 7 $ ' !" 1
B
1#9 >( -
3
(
N )
""
" (
" 3
=
(( @
"
>"A
((
( >A
> A> A( ( DDDDD DDDDD DDDDD >&1 -
" -
*
D 7( 8 % (
77777
*
'% %
" (
&:
7 (
2828&##'
(
(
3 "
/
8 % '%
3
(
"
" &'
( (
(
" '%
4%9:%
4 (
"
"
&9
3
(* "
) '%
4%9:%8 & %:
3. 4%991 &1 F && * "
"
>
( A / (
D 3( %2$
3 * 4 %991
.
4 - * " 4 > =
=
( = ""
(
*
( (
"
1 = A
(
( ( = "
(
'%
4%9:% '#
* , ""4%991
= 8
< " ( "
3 =
3@
34
(
" (
= (
"
3 *4 ( (
"
0#
;
D
3 *
3.
4 4
8 & 0&
3 . 4 %###<8
"
( 0&
3
" ( %:
4
7
( ( =
8
%2$
* 4( (
0%
7
@
"
* "
'%
4%9:%
= "
" '% (
@
( * "
D
3( (
@ "
'#
*4
* , ""4 " 8" (
2$22 %#0 4 - ( '# 4( (( 2$22%#0
* , ""4%991 B8 >2$
2#&#"!"% @#"%"% % 4 " "
8
% '9
, - ( "
"
)
;
& , " "
"
(
!2"%#& " "/# @#"%"% 4 * 88
(
"
"
"
(
"
C
( " "
DDDDD DDDDD DDDDD %#0
+#$52%"9 2$&"& % 4
"
, - ""
&
, -""
" DDDDD DDDDD DDDDD '# 2%!- #-#$"%@#"%"%&8 % -
, - " ( "(
2$ 22 %#0
)*! 84
, -" 8
" '2
& /
"
, -
"
"
;
, -"
"
0 4
( " "
, -(
"
""
* (
" "
, - *
)*! #8M
8 '$
""
D
, -(
""
" "
1 -
, -" "
( "
"(
"
" " "
("
"
( (
(
: -
(
*
"
, -
*"
( (
$ , D "
( D" "
(
, - '#
* 4 " 8" 2$ 4 ( (
34
> 0&
"
= (
* "
(
= 8
" 4"
. . !
"
* "
"( *
"
* "
%$
(B8 >%$
/ ( 8
"
-
(
( ( " "
"
(
A ( (
@
* (
D
( '#'%
4%9:% = "
4" * "
( ( ) " (
= (
M
* "
=
3
* "
=
=
(* ( (
= * "
= (
(
* "
=
* "
3
"
(
" %2$
3
*4
3. 4
(
= (
= * "
( (
7
* "
8
" ! !
7
8
8
"
= "
"
D "
. . !
"
"
*
3
8"
(
"
""
* (
4
(
* "
* "
( "(
=
D
4 %9:%
"
" !+ )
"
, - "
4
8 1 %:
3. 4 (
(
" (
-
%:; $ 8 & (
"
(
( ()( "
8 0
")
( ( 8 1
7
%
4 D 8& (
(B8 >8 '
? %%%
")( "
G,7M7, 6-3, ,-7-7;?,4-!K!4;?;?-37 %% 46;M;
-;,&#%2A ( 8 & 0 %:; $
%(
"
(
(
)(
( ( ()( ( ( " "
7
-
- ( = " (
(
"
- (
"
"
( (
0:
7
. . !
( (
>
A (
<
"
%
= ( ( (
8
/
(
) (
"
" "
( ( "
"
* "
0$
M
(
(
7 D
(
(
%% %# &#%2(
%
; #1&#%2
7 D
%: 8
8%&G"
1 F ")
.
"
"(
-
" "
( (B8 >; 7 "( " 8
"
!OA DDDDD DDDDD DDDDD >4" 7 "" "
" %
( (B8 >8 '
"
")( "
G,7M7, 4-!KK!4.;?-371 46;M;
-;, &#%2 , ;?,?-A ;
D
"
(
; 8
8%& G"
81 + ; =
( (
" " " (
"
. <?
<; "" (
<
1 (
- ( "
+ "( ** 0'
7
"
"
(
%
"
<-
*
(
?
4
"
"
"( "
( *
8
( (
H
1#
= )
(
7( (
7
" (
<)
(
(
( ( ( ("
"
?
!2$/(0
* +
% /
) < E & /
E