Employees State Insurance. Corp. And ANR v. Enkay( India) Rubber Co. Pvt Ltd.


 



 

 !"

#

$ %&'(

)* 

! +,!

,&, !-! .

,   && ''!

/  !0(1!23+44 ,%&!(5 6%

  &!2 !

7"

)67*76*








 

  

  





 

 

   !"

%'

!*!8.9 
 


 


 






  
 




  


 



 

 

!
 
 
" 
  


 


 "  
# 

$ #


% #



 
"  & # 

'' ('

) 

 #
$ #





   
''
* 

+
"


,-'
.   

  





 
/

/

" 
/ 
   


#




# 




/
#

 

 





 

(01



 
 


"


)1
  



 
'2' 3


# 02'23' (0'

'


 
#-#



 #





  



 








#

  
/

 # 








 

/ 
 *#
#






-







#

  #





" 




/ *#




 





4 
/ 





/

 #













/



 *

    
 



 







5 

/


" 
- 



 3'23' (6
/
#



 

 








 





!
 


 
   3
 (0'
0'





  


#

 
  




 
" 

 

(


  #
 

 
/ 
/




#

 -

 5  




/#
#  71 
 
 



/ 

/ 

#
/





 

$8   


/ 
 
9


  :
''

/
 #




  

# 


 
#






#-



8 -  

/ 

8
-  
"


)1








/'''

2'2(' (0



 
 

- 
 







-


 


 -  



 




 



:



4 

/
$  


 
 
 0










&- 




 
/ 





  








 
& #  #






/
 #
  
 













/
$ 


#8
-  

 
  




/




  




 

 

 



 
/






  



 

 #







 '

'

;
 -#









1 " 
 



 

 
"  



/ 
 



#


- 

 #
 




  


5 
 -#
 

 
/

/

 *


 '
"5 
 
$
/



/   


 



 


 
/ 

  -#


/
 
 
 


 

 



'


#
 



/ 



  '2' 3

02'23' (0



 -#



'2(' ((
 / 



 
 
-
 




/
#

 

''
02'23' (0 '

6'

< 

 

#



/#

/ 
  


% #




!
 
" 71 9'

=

 #
/ 


#


- -




# 



6



>
?,, '

=





>
?,, 0'

+ ':

;

3'

@ 

#
/



 

/ 



  
" 

-



 
 3

 (0
 -# 
 


 

- 



3'23' (6




 -#



'2(' ((

/ 

/
 
 

 



/ 



'



 " 
 



/ 



 
'2' 30
 02'23' (0
 
/

 
#
 

/ 
$ '


('




/


 




/ 




" 
- 



3'23' (6
 
 /


 # 

" 


#
 
-
#

(( 





 
/


 
" 



 " 
 

 

#




 
  /


 
 









 " 




- 



3'23' (6
 -# 


 



'2' 3

02'23' (0
/


 '
'



 -#



#
 







 




 






4  

/ 
  






 *






/ 

#

9


- 
 

*


 


 
/ 




:'

A/- 
-


/ 
 





   

 6








-



 
/




9

:
  







 
 
 '

'

=
#



#
 

" 



 



 #

 
 

/ 



 -


"  

 
" 


#
 
#
 


(61B

 
 

 

 


" 
 







 '
A

#



$  


+#

4   /




- 



3'23' (6

$   / 
 

'


 


 

" 


 -
    


(61B


 

- 




 !
 

 
/ -


(014

"


)1



/'''
2'2(' (0 '

2'

-


 -#






 -

 



 

  
 



 
/ 

-   














/

/



" 
 
 


#







 #
 

" '
A




" 
 
 
 

!
 
"  '

'

B 

" 
C '
)* 
 


 # "



1" 
 
  

#


- 


 

#



$ #


  " 

 



/

/


 
" 

* ,&, !5*!

.0+%,  22(

""
6


/ 

/ 


 


#


#



-
 

 -










  '

 


 
 


$ # 
 







"


#
  



$ 

 
 


 

'
.



 

 




$ #


!


 
" 





 
-


#





 






 



 / *#










 
/ 



#- 



 
 
 *#







 
 

" 
/


/

$  








-
5



 



  


" 


 
/ 



'

C '
 
 


 -#


 & # 
A  
/ 








-



   3

 (0





 -#





4 
/


/ *#





 










" 

 

 







 




& # 
 
-
/
 




/ *#
 




4 '
'


 
C 'A 
## /



#


  


 
 


  
-
 
 "


)1
  #

(01





/'''
2'2(' (0


 
/
#



 





 



-



 -

'


#




 


$ #


1  
B


" 

%&'(

)* 

! +,!

,&, !9 .!28,.57< '%2, % !

6 2!2! .

,  +
 ( ,DA
 '
A

 
 
 
 
/
#





 





4 

+#

? E4 

A 




=  -
 



-

 

F

?


  -

'
.

  
 






 '
0'

B 
  #

#

 

" 

 

 
 
#



 #



 2

 
 
@?
 






5 






 
 /
 






  


- -
#


 !


 


#








''

+'

06E1
 '
B


/- 
/ 

 
 

  


 

$



- -

 










G


/ 




/ 

$ # 




!
 
" 






/


 

 

'
"5 






 



 

5


/
/



 


" 
71 = 







 

-




#


 
 

 

 




 
/ 






" 
- 



3'23' (6


>
 =





"


)1


 /'''2'2(' (0

 

(01


 - 








 


 





/ 

 >  = 
/



 -#

 

/ 


 




&- 

4 
 
 6





 -





- 



 


 


& # 

 






 
/ 

/ *#

& # 

/ 
/ *#






4 > - =




 

- 
 


 9

:







>
 '

-#
  

#


 


  #
$ #


 
" 


 

# 
/






" 
 
#






 


# 

" 

 
" 

 
/
 


 
" 




  



/ 


#


/


$

/ 





 


#



#



 



#-


-


  
 

#

-



 

 

'
?



/

 








-






" 
 
#


/ 




 
 -#

- 

#

-

/ - 
 

 
/





!
 
#

 





/



#






  


'


 
 
1 
/



#  


#




- 

/ 


'

6'

A/- 

/








 
/ 
 
 
- 
#



 






 *

  
/

 



/ 


 


 /


 

  


 '

 
-


   



 
-



 
/ 




" 


 

5 

 









 
  
 


  
 


/


/ 

/

 








  #

5


$ 





 
 *


" '

+ 

#


0 0


 
$ #
""
  '

3'

?

 

 

#

 

 

 
#
 


 
 

  
 



/ /

 




 





 
/-  

 
 
G



-
 

  
  
  








 
/ 


 G







  



'
C '
)* 
 






" 



 


$ #

2( ,!26 25 8!',

,9 %&'(

)* 

! +,!

,&, !!2 .

, 


(
0
""


 / 





2'' 

 



  %  
 3

#
 ( 
/ 
 



 
" 

''
#





%  
 3

-


6


 
/ 
 


#

 
 #'
-



 


" 


 (6
  




 



 
 3

 (0
 
   


/



 



-
#

 
%  
 3

%
 (2
/

#


-
 




 



/ 
 
''
3'23' (6'


A
  #
 


/ 

 
  




!
 


/  











 
'


 

/
#  






 




 -




 


'

"5 

 #




!
 
" 
  
#



- 

 
5


/


 -




" '
('

;G
#





C '
## /



/

 

(01
 

"


)1



 
 








 
/ 


/'''
2'2(' (0'


 


 

 



/ 
  
 


 6

  
-
5 #





 * 

 
/





!
 



 


 

 

 



(01
 8
''

/ 


 

 






"

&-  
 

 
'
< 








"   

 





 

 

 
 


"


)1'

.



 



 
 

$ #


1  
B


" 


 

 


 / 

/ 





0




!
 
 

 

'


 33


 -

#


" 
 


9



-






:




 






 
 



   
+

+  

 #


/

 

 
 
 

   

'2' 3
5 




 -

'
 " 


 


3


&

"



 (



'

'

-#
  

-

 

 
 
   

 
 






 


-





 


 
$ #



G
  



-/


5

$ #


 
" 

7< 8%%

!7'' 5 8!',

,9%&'(

)* 

! +,!

,&, !!2! .

, 



'

""
  '



 
 
 





/
- 










 

 




/
"


)1
/ 
 
/ 
  


.  '

/ 




 


3


&

"


 -
/






 
 




 
 


/




#
- #
 # 


/
5  

 

  
 

 



'

/ 
 


 
-



/


G

"


)1



  /




#    


/ 

 
 
3


&

"



/ 



#

 '


 
-


 

/ 
 



 
/ 



 
 

- 



 



 
 
"  '
 '

A

#







#




"


)1







  



$ 

-/


  -


 
#



 
" 



5




 -



'
2'

"#



   


/

 





" 

& # 
/ 




/  #


   #
 

 




/ *#
 




4 
/ 







 

 

#  






"  
 

 - 
-
 










&- '



#



$ #


C '
 


 



,! &,  ,&, !    !2  5  %&'(

)  * 

! +,!

,&, !!2! .

, 22

""
00 
 


  

 
 '

 
 

 
/ 
 








 
,


/ 









/

 

 

 
/









/ *# 




C '

/ 




.  

# 
 

/


$
 
#



#
 


 / 





 






 



/ *#





 
-


 

/ 


/  



 
 
 *#
 - 
-












 '

/ 


 





 
/ *
/




#


 


 
/
/

 
 





  
 *

#

/  












 
#

 

 #


/

- 

 

"  /
 /
/

 -

1
 





  





/









-




/ 

/ *#


 

/

 - 
 



 '
'

;




 

 





-  /


 -#




 


"    
& # 
/ 

   #







  
 









/
/ 


4 '

:

A/- 


 


" 
-
 
- 


 
/








$ #


 
  


  




/ 

/ 
 
 - 


/

#

$ #


4-
B


 
,


A#
" 71 92'
;/







/

$ #

/



/ 
-





 -

'

B 
/
 




" 




 




4-
B


 
,

 A#
" 


 


 ! 
"

-'
   
 

#
$
!0'

5
 

4-
B


A# " 

 
 
/ 

/

 

#
 




   



 
) *

  
 
,


/



/ 
"




 *

-














- #




/ 

- 


'


 
 

/
- 
 
/ 



 / 

#- 





=
B#

&- 



 
 

#- #








"




/ 


/
/ 
#- 


  

/ 


 
,


 
/


 
 

5'

/ 




4-
B *#
 #
+ 
+ 
%'
 
-





/ 
#- 




 


/ 
    


/









/ *#
  


















/



 
,


 '
4

#
/ 
  
-







-  



/#
 
 - 
/ 





 

+  '

 





/7 9


H
 
 


 
 # 





 

*
  


$ '

0



 








  








;

  '



-

 -



 

 






 '
 
/

 









/




 
/



 - #


'




 

 #









 




 
/ 






 


 

 



  


 G



-  




   *#'

 










 
   

 -

  



   
  






  

  






/


 







'
    


  

#




 /
 

 




 

   






/


  

 '




 
 


 

 



  '
 



 


 




  


 



 
    




  
':

'





-/

 
 - 




 

- #

-






 



/

  '


#


   
- #
   
 





 
  
 
 

 -#


#


#
 

 
  -

 




 /






 







 -


  
  


 
'
  

   



  


  





 

/
 


  /


'






 
 




 

 
 

B 




 #




 












 
 
 #
 ':



  




"  '

< 




 
  #
$
!
 



  
 
,


A#
" 

 
/ 
 




/




 
/ 










/




 
/ 






/ 




#





 


/






 

/ 
/ 



 
/ 



 '
?
 

 

#
 
/




 G


 
 
/


 



 
$ # /

 
-



/
/ 
/ *#


E



 
/ 






 







  


 
 


 
''









  
-
 
"


)1

#







& # '

A







 





  




$ #
/













 
4 
/ 


/ 


 





5
/ 
/
$  '
0'

A/- 


 


" 
/ 





  
 






-
/ 
/ *#
/



 
#

 /







- -

 
/


/ *# 




 '
A

 - 


 
" 
 >,' 0,, 6 25*,&, !




3

""
3 

/

 


 
71 9%%'







/ *



  



 








#
- 

$  


 





" 

! 
"
&"   
 6
''





# #


/

/ * 

  '



 

-

 



 - '





  



#



  

/ 
 




#
-'

 


 
 





-



'
 



/

 
 - 
'


/

  



 




  





 #



  - 

/ 





 /  






 

'
=
 
 
/

  


 
/





 


#












 
 
-









'



/


? 
A#
" 
  

 

-
''




 

 # 
   


  

4/ 



 
'



 
 

" 


 

-

#
  
? 
A#
" 
$ #
 

# 
-


#
 




 ':

""
   '





 
 
#




 




 
4 
/ 
- 
 
/

   # 

& # 

-1-  
 
/



 


 $  


" 
 
#


 

  /



/  






 



-


/ 

 




/ *#





4 
/ 

 









 - 

#

/ 
- 












   #



A  '

= 

#



 - 


 G
" 

*+ .

,!

8 !

5%&'(

)* 

! +,!

,&, !


22

""


 



 




/71 '

'
 

 
-'

 

 #
 



 
( 
)  * +


,+-,  -'

 
 .
/

-'
# 0
  

0

 
-'
#' $
!

/
 -
G 

 

 G 
9 :



 

 







/
9 :
 5  
G

 #'

= 




-

 


#




  
 
/

 -




9 :
 
 



-
#
 




#-#
  *#

# 


'



 




 

 -#

G
/

  




 # 






9 :


 


':

6'

  


 


" 

 # 





" 


 



-
  





/ *#






4 
/






   #


& # 
/ 
/



    
#







/ 

/
$  '



0
5



/ 

 -



'

3'

#

#
/

 
#



/



  


/
/ 
/ 




 
" 







4 

#
- 








#


  '

 
 

 







% #

  " 
/


  


 


" 



#



 











 








/

 

 

 






  71

9

:
 

 




/ #


 
/

/ *


  




 /





 /

  











 / *


 


 



/
 / *


  




/

/ *










  




 / 8


 /






 #

 









  





 
   -









#

/ * /

  




/ *


  
 



/

 


/ *
 
 

 



 


  



8

 /
 -

 




 










 
/
/

  /
 -






 
 
 


 

 -8









I
  

 




/ #


/ *
 /


 


  












 
/

  

/
  


 
 
 









  



 I
 
# # 



#



# #  





 3
6

 3 

 

 #  




8



  J1




I
 J
 -


  


 8
 I


 




/
/ #
G  #  

- 
/ *
G
I

G 
 

J

J7 , - 



/
/ #
G  #
 
 - 
/ *
G
I

G

 

J






 

##


 















 8J:







-
 





/ * 
/









  




 - 
 









/ #


-

 
+'322E1

'
;#
 






 
 /
 




G-



/ *#
 




 4 
/ 

/#
/ #

+'322E1

'
A

 #





!
 
" 
  




 




5


/




  -



'
('

"#



 #
/
# 




 


 


 
" 
/
#


1 








 

$

/
#



  /






  

 -#



 #





 
 '

 




 
  


#









 
  




 - 


/

-



#
 

" 
 /

# /
#





/

 



-
  
" 
 

- 

 

 
" 

 
#

'

#
 



 


 
/ 
 


 
   
*








" 

%  
2
/- 
  
 
 -#

 



   
 - 

 

" 
 /
 



 
#  





 
 


-

/


# " 



'
A
- 

 
/
#  
/ 
 *








9

 

#  :
/

 

 '

"5 
/

- 
 -#



 
#

 
/
#  
#



/
 





" 
 /


$ 
-
/

#

 
#

 -#


  
" 


 '

'



-/


 

-



 







" 
 

 



  


 

 

 -









 
(01







5
  
#

/
"


)1
/ 

 '
  




/
/

/

5 


+'6222E1


 #
$ #
 





!

 
" 

'' (


 





  

 
 
 
" 

 '

 1


 # '
 176*3 

4 ,

9#

$      =
  E *# >





K =
  













>






K