High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/922/2023dismissed

Ganga Ram And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another

2024-03-21Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra10 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND

HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

! "! #!$ % &!' !

( ) & *+,-. % /0%12. )*2%&) ,)1)

)*2%&) ,)1)3 / ! " " # $ %&' ( ) *# +,- '. .

/0 '/'' # $ 0'0 %/1 %2& 3/1 ,( $ - 4 $ 5 #"*# 5

6 # 5 +,- " " 5 " 5 '

# 6

5 5 - #5 ' " 0 /'

/3 '/'

, 5 5 #5 5 5 ) (#

#" - #5

, 5 - #5 " $

#" # " # #5 " # 5# - 0 ///7 # #" 5 5 # 5 ! 5

5 $

" 5 $

8 " " # " -) 6 "

5# - ' 9) 5

# " " 5 (*# 5 5# - %////7

# 8 " $ 8 "

5) 5

: 2 / '/' "# /.// ) ' $ 4 5 5 ; #" - #5 #

# ) " #

# #

) # )

< '3 / '/' #" ' )

# 5 ! 8 #" $

5 " # $ ) # +,-

# - #5

-5 $ 4 -5 #5 # "

# *# # ! #

" 5 5 ## 5 # $ .0 (

55 5

! # *# +,- # " # " # " 5 6 5 - #5 5 #5 "# 5 "

/2 '/'/ " " 5 # $ 06 #

" " 5 5 - #5 " 5 , 5 *# 5 !

' 5 - #5 5 5 " 5 "# 5 " # 5

55" 5 ' = 0 #

5 " 5 " !

" 5 # 8 " "

$ 5 5 " <

+,- ) " #

" " ! # "

9 $ # # # # 5

*# 55 #"

# $ 0'0 %/1 %2& 3/1 ,( !

5 ! # *# +,- *#

5 " 5 #

, #

$ # "

# 5

" "

) 5" (#; # $ %&' ( #

# #5 ;"

$#5 (#

(# !

8 # $ %&' ( (# 8 =

" " (# ! # # # "# (# 5) # 5 " # ( # " 8 "# (# ! ;"

$#5 (#

4 # 5 # 5 "

# #5" 8 # $ %&'

( "# (# # # (# " #5

# " $5 5 # # # ">?

5 + ,5 - 5 ) # 5 # 5) # #@ 888 888 888 888 >?

5 +,- 5

# 5 55 5) # #@ 888 888 888 888 >?

5 +,- 5 "# 5""

" # # # # # #@ 888 888 888 888

5 >?

5 5 5 7 5 #

# # 5 ) # 5 # #

- # " 5 !

#$$

$ ;"

$#5 (# " (# *# 5 5 +,- 8 # 5 5 # 5# # $ 0'/ ( , # # 5 "# " 8 # # =@ >? # # >? "# (# - " 5 %& '() (%% *()"

" (%% % $

, - " # $ %&'

( " 8

5 "

# 5 " #

- # " # .

% %

/ % 0$$ ) 12"

3,, 8 (# # 8 # # $ %&'

( (# 5") # *# *# "

6 # " # # (#

8 # $ %&' ( *# 8 # , 4 / 5+") %

% $$3 3

-3 8 (# # # # $ %&' ( # " 8 #

# 8 # "

*# 8 ! " # # (# 5 , 6 )

/ % $ ( ( ) ,, A"

$#5 (# B# 8 # ## # C " (# # " 5 5 # # *# ! (# 8 5 5" " #5 "# 5 5 C # # " # # " # # *# 5 " " #" 5 *#5

# $ %&' (

" *# " ="

# 7*# 5 (# *# 5 7

# < (# *# 5

7 5 8

# 7 #

, 85 # +,- ="

(# ) 8 )

# ! *# *# " 85 ) +,- 5 5 *#

(# 5 +,- 5 ! 5" *# 8 # $ %&' ( - " 5 " 5 "

$#5 (# +7 !

% 0$

8 3$ 4 "

)/" %

/ 0$$

) 9- A"

$#5 (# " 8 # $ %&' ( *# 8 # , # # $ %&' ( #

" 8 #

# 8 # "

, "

# ) " #

, #5 " 5 # (# *# 5

5 75"# "

" *# : " #5 , 5 *# +,- *# 5 " 5 # - '75 5 "

*# " " 5 # " # *# 5

5 5 # " !

" # 5 55" "

: "

" 55 #"

# $ 0'0 %/1 %2& 3/1 ,( " 5 # , " 5# " #

# '% / '/'0

" 5 " (# '.

/% '/''

#5 (# # *# +,-

*# 5 5 ! 5 ! " # # 5

, " 5 " 5

! 5

(MANISHA BATRA)

JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No