High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/2359/2013dismissed

Satyawan And ORS v. Surina Ranjan Ias And ORS

2015-01-19Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

! "

#" !

$! % #&' ! &"!()"

"!"

*+,# -#./)01 "

2"("

#" ! - /))-3/4

#0#- 5 # "

# 66 #-") , 2" ( "!"

!)#!(!") 6

, 2" % # 2"-#+2

'%)+7"

")" ")#5 6 -")!

7 ,", #"

- #1") 2 2"1-#7 2"("

#" !,"

2" % ! 2 2) ,"" ((# ") ! *8 "12" ! # (% !%1" 2"!"-"1 #( 1"!!1)%1 ")# 2"

)!%12 *8 "12" ! 2 " "((# ")#!%,!"9%"

( 1"!! !"-"1 #2"-)#

2" "

)

: - ") !

) ( 7 ") 2" (!

"!! 2" "!!%12,""

1!#)" #2!,"")"#")

2"7#!(# " 20#+,""((# "))!"-"1 ")( # #(# #7" 11 )#+- 6

)# "1 #! " "#!!%")#&!2<-

1!"!%( 1!#)" 2"1-#7 2"("

( 7 # 2"(!

"!!#11 )1" 2- 2" #!

1 "7( ("

# 2! ,"" #-") !!"

#+ #-- %- )#!,")#"1")=17(-#1" 2")# "1 #!#!!%"), 2#!% # &!2-<->!1!"!%( %!"- 2"( #"!20",""2" ) % #+ 2"1% !" +%7"

!# 2!+"%1 0"

") 2 # ( --"-( 1"")#+!#"#5:

-")!$#' @%7 2" $! " 4 2"0-#)#

2"!"-"1 #("

##+

, 12 *8 "12" !/17"%( !1 % )0#)" 2"'%)+7"

) ") ? :!%12!"-"1 # 2!,""2"-) ,",)#- ) )# "1 #! " "#!!%") 2" "# 2"7

" "1!

2"!"-"1 -#!

#! 2"1 "

# #!"), *+,# -#./1%!"- 2 #< ? :!-! 2" 1"1 ")(("-!/ (" # 2"'%)+7"

2"<" ")#+-"*%)+" ")" ")#5 :

2!,""!

") 8" 2 !# 7 / 2#!% #! 2"1!#)" ")(## 2

#-- %-)#!,")#"1" 2" )" !(!!")#&!2<-!%( #!7)"% 1")")- / 2"!"-"1 ##! ! 2"

, 12 *8

"12" !#!11" ")2!,""2"-) ,",)#- , 2"% 0"

2%+2 2"(" # !%12'%)+7"

7 20",""!

"), 2"-" ") <8"12!

#--# 1 ,"1!

%") 2 2"'%)+7"

# !"- !

!2")

8 0# %" 2"# " #7 )" 2"!"-"1 ""! 2"

%-)1"

#- +# ,""

! 2"# !" 0#1"! %-) ,")#!("!") # 2"7" 2#-"!)# "1 1!"9%"1" 2"'%)+7"

")" "),

! ) 2"!

) 2" "%!"-# 1!#)" #+ ( 7 # 2"(!

! !

"!!#!'%!

#")! 2"# 0"

!"-"1 ## 2"

!*8 "12" !2!,"" %) ,",)# - 1!" 1 "7( #!7)"% 4"1"/!7"#!)#!7#!!")

#7(-