Bishan Chaturvedi And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another
!
" #$
%
!"#$%&!"!$ '"
& '( !)
* # '(!+,-)
* # ( '(.%-"/)((()$( '("-",)
* # %
(0( "!$ '""() % 2
#-
"
* 340 ( %$/# 5/ # (67
3(8(0907
"
* :0:)3;4 )396 :3 /
-* " )< , -)
-- 2 5 % *
// # , 2 #
* ,% ,
0;(77(0907= > 0?(
5 @/ /
2$* ,%- %
(0
/ * ,,
( @
) @
# % *2- )#--$
$ -
% )@*%% # , * ,% , 2 # , +/ % @ # 2$%$/* #
/@ - #- > * 2 #% * # ) 5 -- 2 5 % *
// # , ,$ 2
5
#A*
74(3(0900 *
%% 2 # --5'/ B$'/ # * / )*
# ) --5'/ B$ '/ @- *
% ( %* , )-
') %
79(8(0900 (< % - >
/- #* ,%-C>,,)A # %
)!
"*
- /@ #. *
0(8(0900( 2 # )-
') * *-
% %%
* ,% , --$ **
% * # **
@
*-
*-,
##
*
-
* -# )%
*
% 2$-
') 2 - # $% # 340( ((@ -
@ / ,$,+ *
),$2 * $ /
## * $
%
2 # #$ @ * #A* ("
* :09( 5--$
# *
)@*% *2
# * ,% / # ##
-
.
%/ @ # ## -- /
-$* ,,
#*2
,*2-$
%
* #*,-% * @ - #- > * ( D2-
* "% ,2 #* *- /
B.S.Joshi and others State of Haryana +,(
* $-.(/-(
# -- @
2$ -- ** #1-)2+($3,+ ,(4$5-67+,(8
0*9
- @ % %
% *
-@( # ) D2- "% Gian Singh :State of Punjab and another 99 $-.(/-(* *#
- @ - -@
2$ "% # 5/ # State of Haryana :Bhajan Lal89;;$-..9$**
67 # A /,
&
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
( $
(-(
.0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4
%%-$/ -@
2$ D2- "% %- #A /, / )%% @
* ,% , * #
/@ -
-$2 #% * # 2$-- @/ ** %/
%$ # 2$5/ @ - */ # A* )@*%,-$ 2A * # - /- */
"
* 340( -) # * 5 -$#-- @ ,2 %,
2$A *-% *
)
(67
3(8(0907
"
* :0:)3;4 )396 :3 /
-* " ) < , -) --
2 5 % *
// # , 5
5 2 # * ,% , (
$ -- , 2 2$ , * # * ,% , *
# * 2 - @(
-- @
"!$ '" "# <!
-*+$ < % +/B
& B <
% 2- & B