Shiv Kumar v. State Of Haryana




    
 

 !

"#$#%&'((


 
    

  &  )* ( +


,  





    

  
 



!

   

 "
 

####

,  
- $%    &

 '

 

   



( )

%   

  *+,  - -  



)./0$  1

1(  

     )* ,2,2  &


 4

  5

&   20 2* ,2,2  &


& 6  4   

  

       &        789 :+.  )3 2+ ,2)+



  ).0 *,2 *:/ *:+ */) */, 32: ),2"; 8 

 -

)+:2$  1 8 -1(   
    6   5   

,

;

            

 

   "    & 


&6 4  

 

    

 &           

    &   

","

,* 2.

,2)/  &. 5  5   5 ;
 

 8   5    )3:$0(

  & "    & " 785 



%    5  

     ,2 2) ,2,2  %       

   &  

    &

 5

&  <  
 ):/$,($ ($(

55   

    *:/

&   & 5     &  5

&        ):/$,($ ($( 

 5 

<

=

 
&  6  4     5          20 2* ,2,2 
      

 & 


4

  55  5           )* ,2,2          )* ,2,2


4

      <  &  *:/ 8 -&       &          5&

"

    

     


&6 4   5 

 

 '

  &    &



              

                      )* ,2,2   &


4



*

%  &

 &


  -  

  &5   
 ! >  
  


     

  

 5

"0"

 '



8  



  

 &



 

-   

  
 

  -      

 

:



 

-    &  


4

        *:/ 8 -   

 &

  78           *:/ 8 -5   &

   

   

 &    5   ?   &  

 

  &

 "
 

% 5 

  ,2 2) ,2,2 5 

   &      2* ,2,2

   5

& <  ):/$,($ ($(

@

  20 2* ,2,2 &

5     &


4

     )* ,2,2 % <

A    

B 
):/$,($ ($(5 

&1&


-    
 

 

 !55  &    
"# $ %  &$

' (' 
):/$,($ ($(5  &    &   & 5    


  *:/      -

      

&          

):/$,($ ($(

5    &      5 

?

&  5<

"*"

   &1& - 

 - 
)%



* + $+ + ,

- +

.

=


4

        &  

  &  

     5  > 

 &  7     &

  5                 )/ 2:

,2).

 %     )* ,2,2     

     &         20 2* ,2,2  &


&6 4  

  &



/

@    

  
 


  -     &                           *:/    -

       

@    &  *:/ 8    %   

&
):/$,($ ($(

  

"

 &  5

&      % 5   

   &  

   5

&  <   ):/$,($ ($(

=


&6 4  

   5   



   &  @   20 2* ,2,2 &

      &


4

       )* ,2,2 5                  

  %



   & 

+

):/

            

&   <

"3"

 5  & 

       

  "

('% -

/++,+-++0-$1

+/+ 2  
   

      

         

  

  

  

        



        ! 

       

   

   

   

 



         

  "   

               

"    

      

 

#  $ 

        



              



   $ 


%  &  $ 

            



            

'      

                           $ 

  "              (     '                 



 

         

 

$ 

 

'  ) *       $ 

          

       

                                      +        

  $ 

                

      

            

    



          

         

(    

      

                     

            

   

  

 

                                  

,  ---...       ,  (     $ 

              

        

           

      + 

 

":"

        $ 

           '             

            "

 (  $ 

          

     /,  

         
0

 .
1  

      

                

               

 
0

  ..
.

  + 

    

  

     $ 

 

+                            

       

                         $ 

                      "

      
*             

 

                      
 %23         

    % 

  

         

  "  

        

"      #   $ 

     

    

    

0  $ 

   

 # $ 

  $   $ 

 





      



               



   0  $ 

     0  $ 

   

        

              

        "       

      ( 

             

            

               

  $ 

    "   ( 

                  

  

        0  $ 

               "

       

       

       %) *                     

  0  $ 

  



  #   $ 

           

"/"

         

        



  

 



         

  "  

       
42$ 

          

       

     
5  2   $ 

        ,  #  $ 

  "     

      

    "  , #  $ 


 .

      $ 

   

  

        

    

              

  $ 

   "     

  

    

    



"  

      $ 

   

   

              '         

           


 6       

   



            7  #                 

         

       

    

       

         

      

 '    

           
.

*:/ 8 5 

  & 5

  "

81 

      


        

    

                      "    

            

          

  

   

           +     "

         +        

 

   

          9     :               

      
; )2

8

  

       

   C  &             

&

"+"

 &      &   *:/ 8 % ?  5  &        &  *:/ 8 -  &    &   &        

?

&   &    


  &     

 '

        

 ))

%  

           ?       5

):/$,($ ($(

&       

"

     *:/ - ):/$,($ ($(

&  <    

"

     

%  &      &  

 &     <

A  & 5        

B
):/$,($ ($(

),

8
 



   ! 1& 


 -   

    ?    

  <

A  & 5       

B  < 

0+: 8 - & 5  

8     5 

  5   &  0+:

32: ),2; 8  5   & 

    

6 0) )2 )..+  5  

    &           2, 2) )...      &            

     

"

  5    & 5<     ):/$,($ ($(

"."

%  5 

& 

4

9   &     -      9 ,,    )...

  %

 
4

     0+:  8 -            &      )2  

   
 ):/$,($ ($(

5 &    &      5  

       )+ 2+ )...

%   -     

 
):/$,($ ($(

 

    &    &         &  5  

          

 

5   ):/$,($ ($(

  5

 & 5    

5   ):/$,($ ($(

       &

  
4

1& 


- 5    &   "

8
1   



  

   



   

     

         <   =

<    $ 

    

                    >=  
1   

     6=  
/      

          =

          >= 
.

     <       <         =

   

  

         



  =

 
?

 7  4@6             

      =

  
&        

  =

  
/           =

 
1     

         7 

6!%         

 

       

           (  %      ( 4     

   


.  

 

  

")2"

         =


 ?

  7   4@6      .

  *

  ,    



   =

 

            =


;

)0

8 3 1+ +, 4 ++,

( 

 $+(''  9 ) ,5

 23 2+ ,22*   9 05 

 2/ 2+ ,22*

   02*"; 8 - & 5 5      &      /  

  &  5     <       

%       

   &  

   & 
):/$,($ ($(

   

"

5< 55 

> &

4   7 -  ;  & 5 &

  
4

!  

%    &

  
4

!   5    &  - 

   &  ):/$,($ ($(

 

&    

"

&      1& 


- 5     

  &   "

85
Where minimum and maximum sentences are prescribed both are imposable depending on the facts of the cases. It is for the Court, after recording conviction, to impose appropriate sentence. It cannot, therefore, be accepted that only the minimum sentence is imposable and not the maximum sentence. Merely because minimum sentence is provided that does not mean that the sentence imposable is only the minimum sentence. The High Court's view in the impugned order that permissible period of filing of challan is 90 days is the correct view. Contrary view expressed by Jharkhand, Delhi and Karnataka High Courts is not correct. Himachal Pradesh, Rajasthan and Punjab and Haryana High Courts taking the view 90 days is the period have expressed the correct view............"

"))"

)*

8 
"# $ %  &$

' (' 5 

 23 )) ,2):  789 .0:

,2):



,/ )2 ,2): / )0$)($&($(

-

 ).++ & 5 5     <        

     5          

-

 )..+& ='  =' ' 

,2)0 -

"

5  &      ,* 2) ,2)/

%

 &     5  & 
  4

   ,2 ), ,2):

   &  5  & 

  -   5      

         &    
 ):/$,($ ($(



  

"

5<  5

   

 & 

  - 

   &  5  

%  - 

>  &               )) 2) ,2)/    

     & 
):/$,($ ($(

    

"

5  5       5 

    &  

  

"

5<  @    5   & 

%54

;

    1& 


 -      1&  

 4   ;

='  1& 

4

 - 5 

 )3

1& 

4    ;

=' 5   5 '


 



  !         

   &   ):,$,($ ($(

 



"),"

  

"

5< &   "

8%
                                           
0+  

           
0       

    

    "     A.

  

           

 

 

 
?

     B                

      

  

   
.

   

   '   

            


&

       

 ,      7  6!%  ,
*
,
 

     

 



          

     7  6!  ,
*
,
         

        =

  
; ):

1& 

4

 - ' 

    & 
):/$,($ ($(

     &   "

8%=
1   

.            

  

 

       

 



      7  6!%   , 

      

    
&         B              

    

     

  

     

 
&

           

  7  6!%   ,  

     

                  

     

    



   
.

    

       

      

  

        

              

      

  CC;

)/

%   5 

1& 

4 6

 '

")0"

!  = 5    
):/$,($ ($(

5    &    &   "

84=
.

       

 ) 
 .        

         

    *

  ,

 2>@@  B"  B"

" 2%=4   

 

  

   2

 

  

            B" 

B"

" 2%=4  

( %
7  6!%   ,     

           

       

               

   (   

          

      

             =

( 4
.

         =

                     

   7  6!%    

     

 

 

6=     

    
 5
&      

   

                

 



 
; )+

%  55

 >  1& 


- 
 

 

 ! 
"# $ %  &$

'

 ('           ):/$,($ ($(

5 &     $(  & 5 $(  & 5      $(  & 5    D  )2

D5 &



 A  )2

 

B 

      & 5     

5 & < 

).

   *:/ 8 - &

")*"

5    5 5  < 

      

  & 5     5   
):/$,($ ($(

&       

"



 )/0$,(

   &   

   

  

"

5  2/ 2* ,2,2 & 

< 

&       %



  

   &  

   & 
):/$,($ ($(   

"

5

&  <  ,2

8 
)%



* + $+

+ ,  - +

.$

  &

-  ( 5

  ,, 2+ ,2)+ 5  9 )+,,2)+ 



 *,2

5
0* 8 -5
 *:/ 8 -5    

  

   &  5   

  

"

5< 5 5  



&  &      5     *:/ 8

1& - 

 - 5

  &  
 



 ! 
"  # $  %         &$   

'       ('

  9 ,3   &1& 

4     ;

 ='

       

 5              

 *:/ 8       5 & < 

")3"

    %

 

 >  1& - 

 - 

   "



      

             

               

      

  $+$ $++-$1 +$+ 5++

 5+ 
2 

      / D    7   ,            DE '

, 

7

D DE " F

* 7

D   7  56! .*,  

    /   $+$ $   

   $1 +$+       

             6=    >= 
;    ,)

5

5

 8

5  5 '

&1& - 

 - 
)%



*

+ $+ + ,  - +

. 1& - 

 -   
 



 !

1& 


-  

   <

A   B5  #./0#$%.

% $123!4 

%5

0$ %!.0  %!

$123!"6 0%35 1$  %"

$ 071#"1/2%#$1.

% "23!4

#./0#$%.

%  0 "3

0/ 0#! 

%5

0$0.0

%     5       &1& 

4

 ' !   &  ,   02 5       

 

 "

87  6!%   ,     

           

       

               

   (  +-  1 +0  /    $1 +$+  +  +

/ ++- 

         =

(;     ,,

8 5  5 5&1& 


- 
 



 ! 

"):"

"# $ %  &$

' ('  
  *:/      8 -  5     &  5                

          

 %"

$/2%#$1 7# 13# #./0#$%.

% 0 %537 $ %

%"

   
):/$,($ ($(

      

"

   

   & 5 

5

    & 
):/$,($ ($(

& <    

"

,0

8   5      &           2* ,2,2      & 

 
&  6  4   

  

       &           

     & 
):/$,($ ($(

    

"

5< 

    

   &

      &


4

      )* ,2,2

,*



 
  4

     <   

 5 

      20 2* ,2,2  & 

 
&  6  4   

 

4

   &     

 &  

  *0.$,(      -

   5     



?

       &  
 

          

         5     5 

    ? 

   &     

   &   &   

")/"

,3

- ?               )* ,2,2   &


4

       

   & &   

,:

    

    &          

&

'(( $

,  
(     E  '

   C9 E

  &  C9