High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/238/2016disposed of

Harbhajan Kaur @ Bhajan Kaur v. A.K. Sinha & ORS

2016-05-12Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain3 pages

"#$ %$&'(')* +

* ,- .. - /$($)#* /"/0')%$/.')12"'3%4&"#$ / /"/$(25"6(2"73%4&"#$ /#2$8$#'#')$/ /."/4$(2 "7'93%4&"#$ //$(8)%$)# ":$(2')%"7 "/"(($%;<')="&#'))#2$8"/# #2$/$(8)%$)#(")%>'#2"

1/'$4")&$#2"##2$/%$/8"(($%;<#2'(&6/#>"<;"&9)

?2"()# ;$$)&087'$%>'#2%$(8'#$#2/$$/6)%( 7'#'1"#')3"($)'/&'#'@$)'( ;$ /$#2'(&6/# 2$8$#'#')$/')#2$8/$($)#&"($')'#'"77< '7$%A+?

>'#2"1/'$4")&$#2"##2612?9")"7(")%?0"/7"( 7")%>)$% ;<2$/>"("&B6'/$%3;6#(2$2"%)#;$$)"77##$%"87#6)%$/#2$6(#$$( 87'&<2$>/'#8$#'#')>"(%'(8($% )C

%'/$&#')12'$

%0')'(#/"#/3 #4$/'

<#2$1$)6')$)$(( #2$6(#$$($/#'

'&"#$ '((6$%') "46/ %$&$"($%26(;")% #2$8$#'#')$/;$ /$

")%8"(( "88/8/'"#$/%$/%$#$/0')')12$/&7"'0 /"77#0$)#

(B6"/$<"/%(87#;$ /$D

A2$)#2$/%$/>"()#&087'$%>'#23 #2$8$#'#')$/8/$ $//$%?

?2$("0$>"(%'(8($%

)

+)#'&')1#2$%$&'(')#"9$))

+#"77#

(B6"/$ <"/%(87###2$8$#'#')$/ />2'&27$##$/ ')#$)#2"%;$$)'((6$%)

+A2'7$%'(8(')1 #2$&)#$08#8$#'#')3#2'(&6/#;($/4$%#2"#

/0"7 7$##$/ "77#0$)# (2"77 ;$ '((6$% ') %6$ &6/($ ")% 82<('&"7 8(($((') #2$87#(2"77;$%$7'4$/$%>'#26#")<%$7"<A2$)#2$ )$$% 67>"()#%)$3#2$8$#'#')$/8/$ $//$%#2$8/$($)#&)#$08#8$#'#')

6/')1#2$8$)%$)&< #2$8/$($)#&)#$08#8$#'#')37$##$/

"77#0$)#>"('((6$%##2$8$#'#')$/) D

2'( "&#'()#%'(86#$% ;<7$"/)$%&6)($7 /#2$8$#'#')$/32>$4$/32$(6;0'##$%#2"#8(($((') #2$87#2"((#'77)#;$$)1'4$)#2'(3#2$(#")% /$(8)%$)#'( #2"#')&"($#2$"77##$$ "'7(##"9$8(($((') #2$87#>'#2') %"<(

/0#2$%"#$ "77#0$)#3'#(2"77;$8/$(60$%#2"#2$2"%#"9$)4$/#2$ 8(($((') #'("%$$0')1&7"6($"%%$%')#2$7$##$/ "77#0$)# / %'

$/$)#86/8($>$4$/37$"/)$%&6)($7 //$(8)%$)#(6;0'##$% #2"#"&#6"782<('&"78(($((') #2$87#')B6$(#')(2"77;$%$7'4$/$%# #2$8$#'#')$/) +

/#2$86/8($3#2$8$#'#')$//2$/"6#2/'($% /$8/$($)#"#'4$0"<4'('##2$

'&$ (#"#$

'&$/3/$"#$/ 2"7'/$"

$4$780$)#6#2/'#<3 2"7'/%$7"<')&087'")&$36)&)%'#')"7 "871<2"(;$$)#$)%$/$% $"/%7$"/)$%&6)($7 /#2$8"/#'$(")%8$/6($%#2$8"8$/ ;9 2$/$ &"))# ;$ #> 8')')( ) #2$ '((6$ #2"# #2$/$ '( (6;(#")#'"7%$7"<')&087'")&$ #2$%'/$&#')( #2'(&6/#3/"#2$/3#2$ 8$#'#')$/2"%# '7$&)#$08#8$#'#')(#>'&$#>"()7<#2$/$" #$/#2"##2$ /%$/>"(&087'$%>'#2>$4$/3(#'77&)('%$/')1#2$ "&##2"##2$/%$/ 2"()>;$$)&087'$%>'#2")%6)&)%'#')"7"871<2"(;$$)#$)%$/$%3 #2'(&6/# ')%(#2"# /"&&$8#')1#2$"871<')#2$&"($')2")%3#2$/$ (267%;$(0$&)%'#')"##"&2$%3>2'&20"<)#;$#$/0$%#;$"8$)"7#< "((6&23"('#'( /&00)1%3 /;$)$ '# #2$(&'$#<"#7"/1$)0< 8')')3"%'/$&#')'(/$B6'/$%#;$'((6$%##2$/$(8)%$)#(#87")#3+

#/$$(')8"/9(/1/$$)(8"&$(')#2$&'#<"# 2"7'%6/')1&0')1/"')< ($"()2$(8$&'$( #/$$(#;$87")#$%;$%$&'%$%;<#2$/$(8)%$)#(

'%"4'###2'($

$&#(2"77;$ '7$%')#2$$1'(#/<>'#2') 6/>$$9(# (2"77;$#2$%6#< #2$/$(8)%$)#(#$)(6/$#2"##2$<(2"77#"9$&"/$ #2$ 87")#(#'77(6&2#'0$#2$($"/$(#";7$087'")&$##2$" /$("'%%'/$&#')

(2"77;$#2$0/"7/$(8)(';'7'#< #2$/$(8)%$)#()&"($ "'76/$3#2$< (2"77;$&2$"#')1#2$0($74$( 2$8$#'#')(#")%(%'(8($% >'#2#2$"

/$("'%%'/$&#')

":$(2')%"7!

6%1$