High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1079/2019dismissed

Union Of India Through Its Deputy Chief Commercial Manager/Claims v. Manohar Kanwar And ORS

2019-03-07Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan8 pages

! "# $

" " "%

"'

() "* ( "% (!

!

"#$%

(()) *****

!

+ ), ' "

(()) - "

( "

% '

(( ) (&"

(()) - "

+$'

)0 /,

"1 0 "

" "

23234325 ( "

)

. )!

' "

1 '

%'!

' "

1 '

+' & &"

6' . )7, & % / % "

"

(( ) "

"

"- "$0

1'

+ % "% ",!

)/!

$'

0

( "

)

%!

2:5;

"

24<-

%!

2:5:

= )$1

%%$ ' . "-

1'

))1"

2>3;432< #))

0 "

"

( & &) " /!

!

2>3;432<!

"% "-

1'

((

&+ (()

.&$ . ), )('$

)) 1

$')

%)

' &!

' # %'"

.$ ""

1$

0 8' %'"

$:?@2 +.0 ' )

"$

$ ,!

" ))/ &)) "$0

"

( % A=

0))

()) ( '

( 1 1 #$

A

)

($

" ('/ % ) %'

"% "!

$ ) ' 0 )) %$ % '

?!333@-!

)% B % "!

% "

& %$/

()$/"!

$ %)) ('$ $ 0 %'

0 %$#"

. 1 %$ %)$' A$/ )$

"

($"

!

0 0' $.A% 0 ')"

24?+%,+4,

&' "

.$ & ( 1 )#

A$/ %$#"

($ "!

' !

)"

$

((% # ) %$ !

& &$))$0

- 6

!

"#$

!%" #! #&"#!

#!'

%#!

#!# (##! & #" ) #!* #) #!"+ # , '

* $$#

!# $!!"

'

+#"- $" (($ % - $'

0 +0 "$0 "% ", ($"%"

" " # .$1' % "$% !

D!

E8-2@2 E8-2@44

$ B$

($"!

F / .$1' %$" $ 4!

0 "!

.$'

$1' %$%)

0 "

% % !

')"

.$ & ( 1

24?+%,

$ ?

< 0 $1'

0 %$""

. )!

')"

- (() % )"

5!33!333@- )$1

:I

" 0 "

)) " ( / "

( (()) -

(1"

"1 # 1$" $

$$ )/ ')"

.$ & ( 1

%$""

%$#"

($ "% "!

/- (%' (($

" ) & ))

"$0 "% "!

E

"!

'$1'

(($"

% %%("

/-0 (%' $ #)) "% " %$"

(())

$.# $ )/

0 % % !

')"

" ) & ))

. % # "% '

.&$

)0 /

+ 0"

/ $-($"% % ) "

%$%)

"

#)

'$

# ) %=

)$1 #!%

"% ""

$.) (E $

$

0)) %). "

A"1 ""

" " "% ,! "

, -

+ , 4?94 B$ . ((% )# ( 1

"%

!

( 1 ('

$2;<

E %"

F$"

"- ./ & $ !

" , ! + # , $&# #! !

#( #!0

!

"# $

!% " # #& " &$!

#! #! #! 1(2 &

!

" # 3 #

#!0

#!!% #( #&

!

"#$

!% 4!## !# ! #& !#

! #

% ,"##!%

! ""# (# " ( ! "

! !#! #"! + # , ! #

! # ! "

!

!#!% # !

5# # ( #"&

!

""

" !5% $ ##!#!# % # ! 6$ #!

#!%,- B$

( ) ( 1!

(( 0 $.) (E $

( %

)) %$%) '$)"

A"

.$ ( 1 $0#!

. %

A"

)) 1

.$ ( 1 ."

% %' 1"

" # )# ." )) ' &

% "% ""

'$0 "

% % ( % !

% # "%

) .) (%' "

#))

. " ) & )) $0#!

%$"!

$/

!

&$ 1 "

A$/ .$ ""

' 1!

(()) - "

($"%"

() (( "

($

11 .0 ' )

"$

$:?@32 $0#!

&$"

%'

$

&$ # " 1 "

1 "

& ))

%) ' !

)&

($ .)

& ) )0 /

/ $(

% $)/

/

($(

F / (( "$ $0 "

"$

& ) )0 / '

%

24?+%,

8''

& ) & ) )0 /!

)# %

8'' % ))/

%

)# "

$ " 1 "

&$ 1 "

& ))

0'

E()

%=J 8'

E() " 'J

F ="!

.

"

(()) - "

1' %$ '$ D")/ %$)"

$#

&$ .

)& 0$ ( F $

/

0'' " 1 "

%)

&$

1 "

$#

)$

&

#/

.$" "/ 1 " 1 "

)/

&$

$

22?

%!

2:5:

) / "$0

%)

0'# = )

)$

& 1 #$ '!

$%%

' ))!

'$ ") /!

% % 1

" $) %!

0'$ A % $%% %

)$%$-" 1 "

"$

&$

1 "

$%%% '$1'!

&$ #

%= 0''

.$" "/ 1 " %$%"

1 "

%$%"

&$

1 "

)$

& $# " # " #J 0

# & % )

&$ #

%$"

F

0''

A '$0

($ $

%' E() #

1' ' (("

" $# / %$ J 0

1 $

A '$0

($ $

' # E %"

1 &"

( 1 ('

$232

(1"

"1 !

'$0

& %

%= % %# % ) !

""

. 1'

&$-' "

""

. )& %'= $( "$%$

%

"

A ) $1 )

'$%= ' $ 1!

%

$"

/ %$ 0' $(

1'

" & )) "$0

" &

"

( %

$# '

$"

%

$ % " 11"

.0 &$"

A/ 11

%$)"

' (("

" & ))

%

% # "%!

%$%)/ "

' !

. % % # "%!

= .& ' ((

) .) "

% %

/ $( 0' " #

1 "

"

(($"

$/

&$ # "% "@' . "

1 "

#) )('$ &$"

%=!

$# (% ))/

0 %$%"

A &$"

($ $

%$()"

$'

'$0 E %'

)0 /- '$ / ($) % ./ $ . 11 1 "% "

)/ ('/ % ) %'

%$"%" B'!

&$ " 1 "

.$"/ "

( %

' !

/ $(

0 "

% % !

$

%$%) ')"

.$ & ( 1

(

) 0 .

D

"

#) '$

0 (%'

%%("

24?+%,

%%$"

1)/!

"

24<-

%!

)"

$

(()) - "

" "!

$

($# ""

" + # ,

#! ! 7! 4!

#! &$!

#!+ 28820 $)/

< ) % )

""

% "

5 ) % '&$!

$)/

< ) % %$)"

0 ""

0' 0 ""

5 ) % .

.' )& (())

$"

$)/ A%"

$

)$1 #!%

"% ""

$.)

$

"%

""

"

, 1! !

2!34(

$. # )#

% .& )1 )

$ % )%) "

)$1

'

$ ( % ."

" 0 "

. )!

)) )"

1 1' 0$

$ ' #

$'

)/!

432<!

#

:I

"""

$

<!33!333@- '

""

$

5!33!333@- &&%

3232432; %'!

"%

'$)"

- (() % )"

5 ) % & )"

' )!

(( )!

"#$

!

" $0#!

$"

%$

+

,

C 3;3?432:

A ) 3#!%

!'9

$ '

9