Vinod Malik v. Sajjan Kumar & ANR
!
"#$ %$&'(')*+ + , -')%".'/ $#'#')$0 1$0(2( 3"44")526"0")%")#7$0 $(8)%$)#( 0"6* )9:.$0 2(#'&$"/$(7526"0 "') 0$($)#*
"/$(7526"0 "'); 0".
!
#$ %
&
#$ &'
)
*
*
+
# ,!, -% .
/ '
01! 2$3!, 4
)
)
)
)
5
)
" "
*
)(
""
* (6
)
(
1
*
"
(
7*
#$8
#$-%
&
#$-' (* ( "
) *
( )
9
. "
* (
*
" 6
1- :
"
;
<
4
* <1< =.
+
)
1 !-3!!, -)
(
?
! " #$
% "& "!
" #'()#()# ! ! #'()#()#@4
?% "&
#$* "+ ! ! , -*./)01 4 )
)
)
)
)( A/ ?
!
" !
! "
2
! 3* 0 -
+ ! !4 0 5 4 0 6 / " ! 2
1
" 6
1- :
9
8,#!, 8
""
=.
>
"
)
;( "
4
>
-,,#!, 8
1- :
*
0 1 ! 2$3 !, * ( (
""
) ;
""
1 - :
(
8 ,!, 8 "
(
*
""
!, !, !4
( 3
A 7 8(9 $()#()#
% & 2
% & )#()#()# - & * :-;:<)#()< ! 6
! % &
1 4
"
*
1 !
4B*((
(
((
!$, !, !
(
1- :
4
!:
"
)
)
4
1- :) ( (
(
!2,#!, 8
#$-
( (
) ""
# >
;
1 - : ( (
5
1 !
)
+
#
;(
)
* (
*
1- :*
/ *
6
+3 ,!, 8
)
""
( (
(
)
1- :
)
1!!!3$/44!, 8 )
;
(
*
""
4
" *
!,2
#$-
1- :
*"
1 -
8,, 9 !-,:!,
1:
"
5
3,2!,
>
(<
4
9
*"
* (
.
/-6 /-6:
:, !, !
1/-6! /-6-
* ( ) !, !, ! "
.
/-68 /-63
*"
*
4B)
9
.
, ".
)
.
(4
*"
"
>"
" !!,-!, (
) (
(
"
" ( ;
9
*
"
(
9
".
4
*"
(
) "
)
(
(
4B )
* * ) (
*
4
*"
"
(
"
*
)
) (
. / , "
(
) ) "
4
) (
3 ,!, 8)
4
( *
1 !
*(
*)
)
!!, !, !
!,2
"
(
) (
(""
*
"
"
*"
)
) *
*
"
)
#$-
#$
6
1 !
*"
(
"
*
1- :
"
#$-*
(
*
=
1 C!
*
( 4 )
*
)
1- : *
)
*
!%*'
#$ ?
@ ?! " "
" "!
! @ ,
#$
)
?+! 1 !
#$ )
?+
1 ) .
."
)
) " .
!
,,,6/ )
*
*
1- :
# ,!, -
<
;
( )
"4
(
* "
)
) ? ! = 0 ! !1 ( )
1- :)
)
" "
*
) ? 1
)
.
(* (
*
1- : " "
* (
1- :
9
)
? / " 1
* <1< =.
+
>
)
(
)
*
1 - :
""
) ) *
*
) )
1 - :
""
"
-%'
1 - :
1 !
)
* "
(
1- :*
-,,#!, 8
(
""
"
1-
: )
)
;
(
""
9
(
!, !, ! ) "
"
6 ;
*
1 !
* (*
""
* ( .
(
*
1- :) "
(
8 ,!, 8
"
1 !
1- :
) ;
7 *"
""
* "
"
#$-
*
;
"
1 - : (
" *
(
;)
"
* (
"
) ""
1- :
( *
" )
*
(
*
*
1- :
)"
# ,!, -
(
;
( )
)
)
"
4
1- :(
*
" ."
"
" "
)
!
,,,6/4
/ "
!
,,,6/
) " "
"
"
)
"
)(
1- :
"
"
(
.
E (
* ;(*
1- :
(
4
* ()
*
*
1 - :
*
)
1 !
;
""
)
)
<"/$(7526"0 "')= +0%"0&7; , 2%>$ 37'1")'5"2(7'/