High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/128/2003dismissed

Jalkaran Etc. v. State Of Hy.

2018-01-17Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri16 pages

!"# $ %&'%(%) %)"#*( ++*&&%)", -*(,., "%"*/%(0%)% *,+)1*)" 232

"%"*/%(0%)% ++*&&%)" -*(,.,

%("%+ "#*(, *,+)1*)", 45

!##$

%&'( ) *+)

!##$

,-,

!##$

(./&

') 0 $ 5

1 2& (0 34

5 !"

!##$ 34 44 3) (40 6 # !##$3) 7'2(4 892' 5 #:#!

---: !

!##! ;< 5 "- #= #$ --- 4 ( ' $#! . ' $,7 !# < 8< 9' !>8

9 0 3) . 2& (0 .

(3 ( ' $#! . ' $,< ' !>0 !

1 ' +) 0 34 (03

5 ,-,

!##$4 ) ? &&( ') 4 (40 6 # !##$ '3). ) ? &&( ') . @( 3) 7 ' 2(4 892

%6", $ < 3 ( ' ). 0 '4 %4 0( 2(4 . )(43 '(0(0(4!0 0 : 4 0 %4(&3( )3& (4 4 (3 . 4 ( (3 . ( . 03 0 1. (3

.. 3&&.( &. 0 (3 . A#> #$ --- 3( 6 $#0( 0 5 0 .&4 3& & 0 . (3 ..3))4 . + 3( 0 ' (0 ' (0 %4 4.. (3 . 0

. . 3))4 1)

3) '(0 1)0 0 ' ). 00 10 03)3

'4 . . 3) . 3( ( +( ( .0 )3 . 0. 4 ( 44 4 ( 43 ' ( 2 + . 0 1 ) 4 ;< 14(' 6,

.( 3)3 . )4 . & '0 .B0 1 . 1 0 0 C0 . 4 ( < 4 . ( & 3) A0 & < @( . 0 3( ( 4 (& (4 4 0 / +B 0( 4 0 ( ' =

1 0 3( (.0 . D'44 D'4 3 4 . ( 2& . 1 (. = #$ --- 2&'4 . 4 0( 0 EC3 1 4 ( 1 0 . 4 1 0 ( 0 #, #, ---EC3 / & 4 (& + 4 EC3 >

1 . 3) . 00 ( ' 1 ' ( ( 1( C0(03. ) . 3 @( 04 ( + 3) 3 (7.8*)", , / ( 2& (00 )4( ( F , '4 4 . ( ). .( . 3 & 3) 1 ( ' (30 F ,. ). 3) 3.

0) ( ( 1 .) ( 0) 4 < . ( 4 ( .

( 1 0 C (

.& 4 0 D'4. 0 .@( 3 34 . 1 D'4. )4 ( 2& ( 0 00 0 C

( 0 ) 4 (

. ) 2& . . 0 C

( (0 > 1( ( ) .02&

(00 44 0 ( 1 30) ) (4 ( ;'/3 )8;'/9 . 3( .0 ..3) 2& ) 4 ( 3 (3 (4 3 C < ( 4(0 ( 2& (0 C ( 0)

!"# $% $&'% ( )'

+&'

,)# $% $&'% ( )'

- .)

/ + "# , #

$% $&'% 00( 1) 2)& /3,"" - 1) /3,""

. + .)4 . 5)# $ % $&'% 0 ( + *, - 26

.)*4#

$% $&'%

.)*4

7$ % $&'%

(40 ( '* 2)

.)*4# 8$ % ;< !

',# 8

= <( 3) ' +)

5 ,-,

!##$( ' (30 ( 00 @( 4 04

(0) ) ? &&(') (4 .4 0. 1 0( 0 8

9(4 33 4 @( + ) .4 4 @( 34

5 ,-,

!##$ ),91*(%"9) F( 4 F( ( . F 4 (4 0;'/ "

F (40 3)( 2& (0 13( 3( (40 - ( . ( F , '4 3) 44 .4 GCCC CCC CCC

( 4 ; 0 ' ). '4( 0.. . (0) 4 0. ). 4 &4 + 0 . 3) ! $# +)0 4 3( = ## .44 (3.'(0

( &43 ..( H & .) 4( . 0 44 . 1 . . ( 04( ( (4 4 . 0 0)4 0 3 & 1 ) 0 (. ( 0 ( 0 ## % & 0 0 ( ) 0 ' (03 10 0 + .

3C F, ( 0 ) < 4 (0( 0 < ( ;< .( 3 4 4 0 + 04 3( C (4 4 )3) 3 4 + . . 3 %&. 0 0 ## . 3. + 00 ) ;( 0 . ( 4 . . 44 . . 4 ( 4 4. .

..( )4( 4.0) ' (0 < (33 + 44 . (3. . ( .@( 44 (3. &4 3 1 . 40 '(0 4..&44

I # ' ( F , '4 ) . ( 3) ( 3 . () 4 (4 (4

C0 ( . . ( . 3 ( J+( GA> $ --- 3( = ## <.44 0) 0 0) ( A( ( . 4(& <.4 0)('(0 F< H&.)0 & '(0< (4( 0 < ( 4( < ( 2&

&&( ? ). : ') (4 4 . < . 4 1).4 ) 0 < (0. 3

0)() < . 4 3( ## 0) 3 % & ( 0 3 '(030( < . 4. %&<. 3) ' (0 )4 0 .<4( ( < .( 3 . ( 2& 0) 0 I

< 0 ). . . .2& (0(44 ( 4( ( 0 ). 3)'(0.( < ( ('(0 3) ' (0 ) 3( . .( 0 ( + ( 44 3 3. ( ) + (..(4.) 00 4 0( ' (0 + .

4 F (03 ( &. 0 . 3) 0 00 4 0( . 0 34.

0 & 0 0 4 1 1 ( .( 4 0 ;< 4 ( 0 4 3( C ( 4 )3) 3 F 4 . ( < . 0 ( . 4 303( C(4 0( 3) ( . . 4 ' (.&.4 . 4 ( ( . .

(03( 3( C ( ) ) ( (0 C ( 0&4 ( ( 0) ;( 3( 3 3( ##0 . 0 0 1( . 3 % & .0 00 + (4 0 . 0 3 (30(4( & F 4. &3( = (3( 0( 0) 3 !

F ( 4 (3 . (4 .@( 44 (3 . 44 &3 F ) .. 3 ) C0 ((3. F ( 43 0 04 1

( ( 43)40 04 F

3 43) ( (( ) F3 F , '4 ). . ( . ) $ 1 ( D'4 F # F 4 (4 D '4 @( C ( 1 D '4 . 3( 4. )(( ( 0 03) 1(30 D '4. 0 . ( ( ( 2& .

( 4 0 4 00 ( 1 0 2& 0 3(3 0(4 3 3) ( A ). D '434&. 02&4 0 .( 04 4 00 00 C ( 0 ) (( ( 0 < . 0 . & D'43 3( < ( 0C ( .& 3( . 0(.

) 3 < (4 . 2& 0 C ( 0 4). 3) 2&.(3) D'4 + 0 . () < . 0 . ) 4.4.

3) ( )4 D'4 F@( 43) ( 3(. 4 44 ) . 0 2& (0 4 ( GCCC CCC CCC 1C (0 (0340 ( 2& . > $ -- . 04 ( . , 1( 2& D '4 0 C ( 3 0 ) 00 0('(0 34 0034 3(3 < . 0 ). 4).

. ) . @( 3( ( ( 0 00 34 0 ) 1 (30 ;< . 0 1 .

( 0 4 3 !.2& $ > 3 <( . 0 3 3) 0 0 0 <() 4 .40 =0C,0() ! 4 .60C,0 C .(."0C$ 0 104( 0 C 0 !

>0C >0 C 0 >C > 0 1C () 00 ).( C 0 C .(

> C > 0 ' 30 . ( ( . 0 /3 ). 3 (4 . .&4 A 3( .0 3) . /3 )4. . /3 ) C0 . 3 3( 30 $ >34 3)2& 0 . 0 3 30& ' 4 2& .

4 +. 3( ( 30 3) .( . (4 (4 ( ( 3 44 ! 3 ( . . .( ' 0(3 44 2& ( 4 ( . I , < ) . ( 4( . 4

(0 ;'/ F (0 0 ) (( ( 0 ( 4 ) ( 44)(( ( 0 03)2& (0 . 3 3 3 0 . 4)3 F4. 43) ( 344C ( )03)3 0 > 1( ) 0 10 . ( . . ' (0(4 (4 4()4 1 ( (30 ( .(3) ( 1 0)33( 3( 3) (

(3)'(00 0 1 0) 0 ' ). . . @( .(3)'(0 3() . 0( <. 3( @( 0 ( ' $ $

( 2& 0 3( ) 4 3 . 0 ) 0) . 3( '(0(4 ( 4. (4(4 C0 . 1 .) 0 ( 33 < ( . ( (() 0 0 @( F 0 3) 2& (0 .0 0 = 1 (30 0 3) ' ( 4 @(

5 ,-,

!##$ ( ( 3 0) ) ? &&(') ( < ( 44) ). 0)3 1 ( & . 44@( 3)4 .4 G+.4 04( . 0 ) 3) 3(3 13)3 ()( 0

44 4( 4( . 3).)43 4 04 ( 1) 4 4 1 ( 0 5 ( 0 . 03 ' !6 E 2& 0 ) . 0 C ( I F4. 3 0 3) ' +) "

< ( .0& .4

5 !"

A; !##$

5 ,-,

!##$ 0 !"#%).%(0$