High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/1486/2021disposed of

Suneel Jaiswal v. Harish And ANR

2023-09-19Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary6 pages

!"#!

$!! !!%!

&'()*+,)-./.*012 340))56'./7'5 2222)(.(.*0)8 9)8/4/ '8./:'0,'0*(:)8 222)/;*0,)0(/ !<= >"?< @ A!<!!

$ BBBB 8)/)0( 82*:'CD8*8'ED,F*-'()+*8 82'0./:3*0.ED,F*-'()+*8(:);)(.(.*0)8 G*0)+*88)/;*0,)0(G*2 82&:84F3.:'HEDDI'8J'0' BBBB !<!!

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

#$#! "$%!# # " &%'(" "(!#) ' "#!!%! %%"%# * * + "! "

% #" )("

#! " "

,* * - . $#

" )#! " (##

)#! )" #

$ "( *

/ .# " '& ".0& "!

(# $&

. 1"

" * * - (" "

# "( #" .!! (## ' )" & .%"&

. !# (" -* * & " .#

% #" )# .!! . 0# ) )' #

"& " " "( .# & "!

(#! %%!# #" (" $% #" ("$ %"! %% "!' ("

'& .# .

#$# 0# #$% "

-* * * 2 ")#!)! . . # & .# "!

)

% #" . ."3# 4#" "!

"1 !" "!

'& 11#%$ + 3".& 5& .

. . #

6 $& . )# %"!!' "

% & . "

0 2 % #" .

! %" !#$ %" 0# "

,* * & .# " $ # !"!' ("!!".#

$ "' %"0##" "( 4 #" **** # ) # # .#!(! "

!#) " " "(

" ("# # ' .#!!#

" 1"#

%" # # %'

" "%%" # ' $' )

" #$

" )("

#! " & .# $' 0 ) )1

" " * 2" )

# )$##"& !# # %! "

$ "(

# " #7 89:;77 <=>77 8?@?A77 9B77 C@DE@:@F7

#$#! ,& --

* * & #

"(7 8;DGH?7 8H:IJ77 <=>77 8?@?A77 9B77 K;:G@L7 & ,

! 7 M@IJ@<77 <=>77 8?@?A77 9B7 K;:G@L7 &

# "

,* ,* , &

! 7 N@G9D77 8H:IJ7

! "#$%&#$#'()* +* * * ,$-.($# /0-0$ %'1(2$3 '44'2$2 05$ 2-6$ 78 2176&00&(9 05-0 05$ &6419($# '.#$. 5-2 7$$( .&95038 4-22$# 78 05$ 0.&-3 '1.0 -2 05$ 4$0&0&'($. 5-# &(0$(0&'(-338-72$(0$#5&62$3::.'605$4.'%$$#&(92* )* $-.#* * ;5$ <$.8 41.4'2$ ': &(&0&-0&'( ': 4.'%3-6-0&'( 4.'%$$#&(92" &2 0' %'64$3 -(# 2$%1.$ 05$ 4.$2$(%$ ': 05$ -%%12$# 0' :-%$ 0.&-3 -(# $20-73&25 05$ .13$ ':3-="-2-32'0'$(21.$:&(-3&>-0&'(':05$4.'%$$#&(92* ?* ;5&2 '1.0 &(

214.-" =5&3$ 2166-.&>&(9 05$ 3-= '( 05$ 4.'%$#1.$ 4.$2%.&7$# 1(#$. /$%0&'( ." 0' 7$ :'33'=$# :'. #$%3-.&(9 - 4$.2'( -24.'%3-&6$#'::$(#$.@4$.2'("'72$.<$#-(#5$3#0512 A+* ;5$ $22$(0&-3 .$B1&.$6$(02 ': 2$%0&'( ': 05$ .***" +? :'. &221-(%$ -(# 4173&%-0&'( ': 4.'%3-6-0&'( -9-&(20 -( -72%'(#$. -(# #$%3-.&(9 5&6 -2 4.'%3-&6$# 4$.2'(@'::$(#$. 6-87$2166-.&>$#-21(#$.

& .&'. &221-(%$ ': =-..-(0 ': -..$20 78 05$ '1.0 &2 2&($ B1- ('( :'. &221-(%$ -(# 4173&%-0&'( ': 05$ 4.'%3-6-0&'( -(# 05$ '1.0 5-2 0' :&.20 &221$ =-..-(0 ': -..$20 -9-&(20 05$ 4$.2'( %'(%$.($#*

/$$C DEFGHCC IJKLMCC NOCC PHLHQCC ERC SQTFGCUCVWWXCYMTOCZOCV[\]C *

&& ;5$.$ 6120 7$ - .$4'.0 7$:'.$ 05$ '1.0 05-0 05$ 4$.2'( -9-&(20 =5'6 =-..-(0 =-2 &221$# 5-# -72%'(#$# '. 5-# 7$$( %'(%$-3&(9 5&62$3: 2' 05-0 05$ =-..-(0 ': -..$20 %'13# ('0 7$ $^$%10$# -9-&(20 5&6* '=$<$." 05$ '1.0 &2 ('0 7'1(# 0' 0-_$ $<&#$(%$ &( 05&2 .$9-.# 7$:'.$ &221&(9 - .'%3-6-0&'( 1(#$. 2$%0&'(

': 05$ .***" +?*

/$$C DEFGHCC IJKLMCC NOCC PHLHQCC ERCC SQTFGCC UC VWWXCYMTOCZOCV[\]C *

&&& ;5$ '1.0 %-(('0 &221$ 05$ .'%3-6-0&'( -2 - 6-00$. ': %'1.2$ 7$%-12$ 05$ '3&%$ &2 -2_&(9 :'. &0* ;5$ '1.0 6120 7$ 4.&6- :-%&$ 2-0&2:&$# 05-0 05$ 4$.2'( 5-2 -72%'(#$# '. &2 %'(%$-3&(9 5&62$3: 2' 05-0 05$ =-..-(0 ': -..$20" 4.$<&'1238 &221$#" %-(('0 7$ $^$%10$#" #$24&0$ .$-2'(-73$ #&3&9$(%$*

/$$C `GaFJbcLdLTCC eLFHEbCC LbcC EHFQMaCC NOCC fKgQMEMCC UCC hiDCC ]jklCC mLHbLCC l\\C -(#C SQNQbcQMC PGbnFCC oQnGCC NOCC PHLHQCC ERCC pOmOCC UCC ]jjkCC YMTCC qZCC rhTTLFLsLcC tYuC]vXlC *

" #$

" % & "#

$"!

$ ' " $

$ "

"# "( )"

% $ & !

* #$%

$# "

&!"

$ $#

$"!

) + ,-./00/++ ,-1/2++ /34++ 5678.9++ :;++ <6/68++ 5=++ >?95.8++ @++ ABCB+ + D.EFG++ HIC+

+ <75J/6++ K2E++ :;++ <6/68++ 5=++ L/.?3/++ @++ IMIMNIO+ + PDP+NDPQ>QRKFO+SSB+ (

T U

$ & V "

&!"

$ $#

$"!

$# ' !

"" $ &

$"!

% $X$##

$"!

$ &

(

)+ YE2Z/17++ <E317++ :;+ + <6/68++ 5=++ [-3\/Z++ N[]LO++ @++ IMA^++ NHO++ PDP++ NDPQ>QRKFO+ + ACC+

+ K975J++ _-`/.++ :;++ <6/68++ 5=++ L/.?/3/++ /34++ /35678.+ + @+IMAS+NaO+PDP+NDPQ>QRKFO+^^M+

$"!

$ & &!

$V "

(((W bc( d$ &!"

$"!

$ & # &!"!*

$% "$ "$ " $#

$V $ !!

' V"

"" $ !* e

$ &

##f

$ $% "$ "$

$ $ $%

"" $ !* $

$ $% "$ "$ " $# "

$V $ !!

"$ * $#

$"!

$ &

##f

$ $% "$ "$

$ $(

&"!

" "

(((W bc

"$g"

W V" %

V$!

& $ ! &!"

$ $#

$"!

$ !

%$ $# &!"

$ (

)+ [/h/3++ _-`/.++ ,-06/++ :;++ i78++ <6/68++ 5=+ + j;k;++ @++ ABlS++ D.EFG++ ASCH+ ( U

$ $ $

"$ * $#

$"!

$ &

$ !!* &!

!* V ""!

" V"

"" $ !* ( m &!*W $"!

$ & V #$ "$ $

$ " $#

"$ $#

$"!

$ % &

##f

$ $% "$ "$

$ $ $%

"" $ !* W

$ $% "$ "$ " $# "

$V $ !!

$ $% "$ "$

$ $

$ '

' &!"

$ % & %

#$ "$ * $#

$"!

$( m

$ "$ * V!! & V

$"!

$ & &! V (

% $#

' $##"

$ & "$ &*

%$ $# &!"

$ $#

$"!

)+ kE./4++ Y/3++ :;++ <6/68++ @++ AB^H++ D.EFG+

""#$

% &'()(! #

(" )(* ( "!(!

#! # + !#$ # !"

, (!

% &'()(! # +(" ,'- %.'"

# ( "% &/ , ,(- # ( )(## "% &/ , # &! #

0 12 3& "!(!

#! # + !#$ .-

" , &'( , .

#&'"

, #& (!

4 #!"

/ &! #

( .

# )%' , +!

(#, (!

% &'()(! # +(" %.'"

# "& ,(-

56789 :8; <= >?8?@ A BC D76EF

#,! #" "% &/ , # &! #

0 12 /

%.'&(! #

/ ( &'()(! # ($(#"! (# (."& #, ( )(#,(!

- H#- #& )%'(#&

&(## .

, (" (# I $'( !-I (#,

#, "

&'()(! # (#, %

,#$" "."

( #''!-

:@<@;978 >6;JK L@J6 8M68N :@OP <= >?8?@ QR S=T= 8;9 8;Q?K@7 A BU D76EF BVCW (#, T8M >6;JK <= XK@ >?8?@ A B D76EFWBC H, !#$

/(&!"

% #! &("

#" / #(%% ( (#&

% !! (! ,

%(""#$

)%$# ,

, 0 (%% ( .

Y"!/ , H! !) "0

(&&"

, &(# .

% #!

, .- "//& #!

#" %! (# (%% ( (#& .

(#, "& (# (."

#& &(## ""( '- .

#"!

, (" , '.

(#, +'/' + 0 ! " #&).

#! % #

) Y #

,#$"0 .

! (' !0 /

&')#(! #

"() #", #$

/(&!" (#, & &)"!(#& "

&("

# '$

Y,$) #!"

, (.

(#,

(,# "" (#, +''#$# ""

% !! #, (#, Y #

,#$"0 + & + ',

'% #

G% ,!#$

! ('0

% #! % !! # , " .

(#,"(''

+ ,#!

"! /Y"!& 1 H&& ,#$'-0

)%$# ,

, " ,(!

, 2 0 H## (#, 1 0 H## ( (", ".Y &! #, .-

% !! .

! ('

1 1 (#, , % "!#$ "0

Z .

,". "

"% #, #! [ / +!

" (''

+ ,

)(#

"() .('Z

! " " "# #$

% "

& ##

((

" # * # () ) ## +!( $

## # ' ) & ( (! $ , # !(

)

((( ) ) )! ) () $ $ , ( (

##& ( $ &'* # "

## (#

)!(# ))

((( "* ))

)& # &$ $ - ( " & *

# )#

(

( (

' ! & ) $ .

/0102.3405640789.

:56;<.

=>?@>AB>C.DEF.GHGI.

$J ! K ( % "L MLN K ( # MLN