← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/1097/2023

Yatinder Kumar Dhall v. Union Territory Chandigarh And ANR

2023-05-2415 pages



       

 

  

  



  !! "#

$ %

& '

()  "

  #$% %   &$ # *+*#*, 

*-

+*+ ,

  

* *,**# ##%&'

(  

.

** *$ +/!,

 

.

*

*    &$'  * & 

  0 (  (     **1 2,

3 #4 5   / !  6 ! (  '!'

(!

(7  8**2,

3#45   / !  ,

! +

 6 ( '

(   / ( 9: .

*   ** 

 +

  1

8 18:#'( # !+

+  '

(

7

7  /

 

!  

+

;'*#*'* * <  

(7 /!    !!(

! !! 9: =

2

3 ,

3

#4577(    

.

*  ! ,* * 

.

*  !,2   5      1>4    ;;  

 

   ,7   /  !    ,  '!  &/ ! 2   ?,'&@5

   /



 !  * <      

 

 

.

*7!  !/    /

!

(7  ! *- 7$   ,2  ?

7@57 .7< 0 :

 +   '

(* -   

  !  

 

     

 

    

  ,'& !

( 7  ! /  *     /

   /    / 0 7  7    /  (   

    ! 7! 7 7 ( 

  

7   =    * +/= !  7  !

 







  !!2   ?

@5

- A!!70 !! - .

*;+  4''

(7 / !!

  /'

(-  (<    /   .7!*&



/ (  (   



   7

  !@     7  (         

 !  

  7 !!  ! 

 *&(  

7!! 

7 /

 /! 0/ 7

3 7 /=       * &  7  ! !      3

 77!   

 /  (/! 0( *,

  7 

 7      !* - 7 

     !   7 

7



  < 077

! / 

* :

   7  !

/  7   7 /  ( 

 /   !* , 

 7  

  7 /   !

  /  

 

 !    *   7  ?/  ! 

@ 

 !   !

 !

 7 

7  !    =

(

 !

* - 7  7    

  ! 

 =    =



 7  / (- A!!

  

 7  7!! 

    7  /!    '

( (!  3 7   =

*,  7(  



7 - A!!7  '

( 

 

 !7 /

! *&

  !

- A!! 7 / 



**

 

 !



7  !0  /   7*&

!!( 

  /  !  

  / !!     **  7 



- A!!*&   '

( ! 

 !!/ 

7

!3

( /!



  !

0 * +/= !  7 (  

   ! ! 

7- A!!7



 77 /=! !

   =

*9

 

 7!!  

! !

 

 / / 

*'

!!( 

!   !

 

/ 0 7

/ 7

   (     -  A !! / /  (  /! 0 (  7   ! /B   =

*! !7

(!!

 /  /!! / 

*&

!!(  7 7!!- A!!7/ 

  (

  =

/3 (

/3

( 

=  !!(!

7

*

* +/=     (

  9:  =



 (

   ! !  -  A !! 

  

 '

!

 .

* 

    !!

! (  

7   

   $    ,* ,  !! 7   !



+

;'*#*'*7

 /  

   

 -  A !! 

  

  

!      ! !

( 7  7*

& !

7!!!

7 /!'



  ** 7

! -  A !! 7     / 

!*,(( 



4





  ! ,

!+

6 ( '

( /  (   

 

 7  7  7   * &  (     ! 

 !

 

 +

 ; '*#*'*   

(  

7

/

77   /!'



  *8** &    !   !



+

;'*#*'*7 ( /7   

*& 

!'

7! 0 ( / 

 ;* *1!!

7  







 /0    ! '

     !

  

+

 ; '*#*'* / 0  

 

 !!  ! 

!

 * & !  !'

0 

 

 

(    

! '

 (  **1



 

!  !*, 

7  (  

/ 

77    8**

(

 

!'

 ! (   7

 ;* *1

 







( !

7

 /!* * C  ! 

 !!! (  (

 !!

((



25 &'

/!

77! ( (    !       

   /  !  ( !! !

 D 25 &  !

 

 +

 ; '*#*'*   /

(!/! (7 !7 

!

*:7  /

A    

    -  A !!   7





 /!  ( 7   (  A       

!7 

* 25 &    

   

    

!   /! 

    4

3   

(*- 7   7

/ 







/7 

 

 

   !

(  

   7 /

7  (   / 

  

! * 2 5 &

  (      

   (   

7 (

(  /!

!!(

 ! !!  / 

 .

**     

 / !

  (

/  !    ! '

   ( !  !!

(!



+

;'*#*'*

2 5 &

 !

 !



+

25'*#*'*0 ( (

/   

 

   -  A !!   /

!

 *& !

7    -('

* 2 5 &7 !!

! (  !! 2,

3 #45     /  3  /7    

 

   ** 7  

 

 !!   

 7 !  7   *& 



/       /          =



   7   7       (  !!

/    

* 2 5 &

  

  /  ! !!  (   

/

= (

 

  !!( !

 

 *! /

   ! 

  

 

    

 !0     



0 !/!    =

* 2 5 & !  ,

! +

 6 ( '

(

  ;* *1  '

!  

 .

*1 *8*

/0 !'



    /  

/ 

 (   

 7 !  ! '

 7

 

/ !!

7!



+

;'*#*'*

* # 

 !   !  (    %& '

(   / !   !    

 7!

  (/ 

/ !       !   

 !!

((

 25 &

/   **  '

 '4.

*18 2,

3#45 !

   

  7         (

 

 +

 25 '*#*'* 

  

 / !

0     !

 7   /

 

 +

 ; '*#*'* 



 

! * 25 &  

  !!   

 7 

!

(

.

*



3!!

 7 

! 

  !!

7- A!!

 $   ,   !   (   

  

 /

0 (7(

/( ( ! 

  

 (  !        *9 (



!

 

!



!

(7

  /  (  !!*-   ! 

 !! !

( 

 

77!(* 25 &

 / 

/ 

!    /  !  ,

! +

6 (

  ( (  !!/  (  

/!7 

(

 

( (

   

      

!  * <    7   



/7   

  

 

  

 7   

   / 



 (!  =

3 *:

  !  !! ! 

  9+C 2E3*#F>,5(

(  !  7 /    

  

 =  

 

  



 





* 2 5 &  / !      (    !! 2,

34 5!!

 7 ( 

/

  

7 (  /   7 (7

*8*;; 7     (    !! 7    

*1*;;* C   !      7  ! 7 !

     

!  

 =

* 1* :  !  ! 

  !

 * 8* <   

(   7  / !    

 

+

;'*#*'*7 

 4

  

 



    





      

   

 

  

  

  

            

   

       



  

     

                 

        

                     ! "

  

               

      

 

  

  

   

 #      

       

      



          

  $  %                          & 

'  

      

   

   ( ;* &7!

7





 

+

;'*#*'*

 !

!7 !  

7*: 

   ! 

!  (   

      7 ! 

!! / ( ((  7

 +

 ; '*#*'*    ! /

0  /  '

 



  

    

!   /  /A /

 +

 ; '*#*'*      

 7   (!! !

(!* * :

( 7 /    !7!

/-

@/!+ '

 ()*+,,-%./012 %3)3, 4/5)6# 7 "% '7 7!



 )*+ ,      -

  !* ,    

       .

  

     /    .   

    

             

 /     .   0

   -  1    

         

    2     

   

     

                   .   



   

  **3       

         

        4.



  

        

   

3         

     .   

  

   



  .



     

    

 /  





   

  .  

       -

  !* ,  / -

 !* ,   

5

                

   

    6         ) 

       

   

  (3     5    

   63        

  

    -

  !* ,      

      ( * ,  (  

'

 !(  !7! )*+,,-%./01#89)8, 84-*)"'





     / 

 /  !   !    

 

  !!

 25 &  

#F4

  !, ! 7   

  

  !   !!(

   /  ! !!  (   

 ( !! 7- A!!

7



   



!

 

*&

(   3!

   

 

 7  7     7  ( 



   (  

!3!     =

 7  /     * :

   /      

 !  

 9+C   E3*#F4>8 7  



 /7   

 

 

 

*9



   !  

7(  !!E3*#73  7 

 *;*;;  7   (!  (  !!7    

*1*;;* &       (   !

( 7   

7   

!   

   =



   7     

     

  !   7  7      (  !!*& 7 !!(

  (    !! ! 7 /     

7 / 

 3! 

7  (  !!7 

 7 7 

 !   /  * . ! 



!!( !     

   (!* 25 !/ ( (( 

!! 

 /=     (

  9: =

7

/ (



 

+

;'*#*'*7       7 +

 ; '*#*'* 7   * :

)*+,,- %./01#8 9)8, 84-*)"'  -

@/! + '

 7!  (    +

 ; '*#*'*  ( !! !

       

  /

!

 / !  (

 !!/



+

;'*#*'* 25 & '

 

 / 3    /     

 (     !      /!  ( 

!  7

    

!  

7  ( /



 !(*  /  

-

@/!+ '

 (%4:1-);%./01&1).*)28 %3)3, 4/5)6#$.2,$)< %"  '7  / !

!



+

;'*#*'* /

    ( /       7   



  /  A ( =!7

 * * !  ( 

 !

 '

 3 ! 7 





+

;'*#*'* !!

(7  7 !  (!* &'

 





    !!!(!  (  7

/ 

!

+

;'*#*'* * & 

   

  * - 7   

!  /   / !!

/

 / 3



 *  * <  ('



 / 

!



  

!'

 

(  /0    ! '

   ;* *1* F    

!'

/!

7 

  

! '

7!!

     7       

(  

 

 +

 ; '*#*'* 7 * &  

! '

 

    0  /

!

( /0 

 

  !

 

 +

 ; '*#*'*   

7 

/ !   

!

  ! 

 ! 7(   '

*    &$"  )=7'  F0 (>

 

>.

F /!

>.