Jaswinder Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals), Punjab And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
--
#+.*,(%/ 0*,12 ------ %$*$*&,%/ 3%/+4+
77%#5+8 4,9#:
&$2%/+
------
%+7&,(%,$+
; < -
0 0
/%+%,$ /- =/*+2#, 0- !#(.#58 (>&)#$% '&/ 7%$*$*&,%/-
/- */6#59*$ 0*,12 !*.#,#8 0%,*&/ ! 4,9#:-
/- =- -0- #,,8 (>&)#$%
'&/ - - - 0
-
<
- /#?%/ '*5%( 4,(%/ /$*)5%+ @ &,+$*$4$*&, ,(*#8 *,$%/ #5*#8 '&/ *++4#,)% ,#$4/% )%/$*&/#/* '&/ +%$$*,1
77%#5+8 4,9#:
+2&/$ ;
&66*++*&,%/;- - /*%'5?8 &, (%6*+% 02/* !#?# 0*,128 7/%>*&4+ #/#1#/28 %2+*5 !*+$/*)$ &+2*#/74/8 7/&)%%(*,1+ .%/% *,*$*#$%( '&/ '*55*,1 #'&/%+#*( >#)#,)?8 .2%/%*,
#+.*,(%/ 0*,12
#/7/%%$ 0*,12 .%/% #5+& )#,(*(#$%+-
- 2% %2+*5(#/8 &+2*#/74/ /%)&66%,(%( )#,(*(#$4/% '&/ #77&*,$6%,$ #'&/%+#*( >#)#,)?8 .2%/%#+ 04:
#1*+$/#$%8 &+2*#/74/ /%)&66%,(%( )#,(*(#$4/%
75#)%( 6#$$%/ :%'&/% &55%)$&/8 &+2*#/74/
+2&/$ ;&55%)$&/;-
- <%#/,%( &55%)$&/8 #'$%/ )&,+*(%/*,1 /%5#$*>% 6%/*$+ (%6%/*$+ )#,(*(#$%+8 '&4,( +4*$#:5% )#,(*(#$% #))&/(*,15?8 #77&*,$%( 2*6 #/#1#/28 >*(% - @-
- - %*,1 (*++#$*+'*%(8 7/%'%//%( #, #77%#5 #1#*,+$ &55%)$&/;+ - @-
:%'&/% &66*++*&,%/8
#5#,(2#/ !*>*+*&,8
#5#,(2#/
+2&/$ ;!*>*+*&,#5 &66*++*&,%/;8 2&.%>%/8 (*+6*++%(8 >*(% - - @
- - 0$*55 #11/*%>%(8 7/%'%//%( /%>*+*&,
@ @ :%'&/%
&66*++*&,%/8 .2*)2 #55&.%(8 >*(% *6741,%(
.2%/%:?
- @-
8 &55%)$&/ - - @
8 &66*++*&,%/8 .%/% #+*(%-
- , #'&/%6%,$*&,%( )*/)46+$#,)%+8 '*5%( :%'&/% &4/$ '&/ +%%B*,1 /%5*%'
+8 ,&$*)%( 2%/%*,#:&>%
- $ .&/$2 ,&$*)*,1 >*(% - - 8 )&&/(*,#$% :%,)2 &4/$8 &7%/#$*&, *6741,%(
&66*++*&,%/8 +$#?%(-
- %#/(-
- , )#+%8 #77&*,$%( #/#1#/2 &55%)$&/ '4/$2%/ #''*/6%( &66*++*&,%/8 2&.%>%/8
&66*++*&,%/8 >*(% *6741,%(
&/(%/+ &55%)$&/ .%55 &:+%/>*,1 4,(%/
!" # #
"
#
$ % &'( $ $ #
)
&'(
$ $ *
# %+ , %+ -#
#
./%-
, ! #
* 0' *
#
1 $ % &'(
$ $ %+234 &'5
(
"
6 &' " "
7 * 8
" 922%4%5$ $4 5&:"+
;/ "
(
* (
"
) $
&
)
< #
# %2=%
%2" &'
" > #
* ?
"
#
&'@!7
%%-922% $%2 222A/
B
*
@!( # 1
# * ?
"
* ?
"
#
!
!
%2 92%
%32%92%
B B #
%32%92%
B B
%2 92%
"
8
< -
7%/4+#5 #:&>% %A$/#)$%( .&45( +2&.
7%$*$*&,%/;+ #77&*,$6%,$ 7/*6#/*5?
&, $2/%% 1/&4,(+C '*/+$5?
2%/%(*$#/?
)5#*6C +%)&,(5?8 4,9#:
#B'
&#/(8 >*(% - - 2#( *67&+%( '*,%
+- 8 &, &, #))&4,$ *55%1#5 )4$$*,1 $/%%+ '/&6 #B'
5#,( $2*/(5?8 ,#6% /%)&66%,(%( 04:
#1*+$/#$%-
@- 2#>% )&,+*(%/%( #'&/%+#*( /%#+&,+ /%)&/(%(
47+%$ #77&*,$6%,$ <#6:#/(#/-
+ '#/ 2%/%(*$#/?
)5#*6 )&,)%/,%(8 :%%, 2%5( :% 45$/# >*/%+ &,+$*$4$*&,8 !*>*+*&, %,)2 &4/$
-
- + /%1#/(+ +%)&,( 1/&4,( '*,%
+- 8 *67&+%( &, 7%$*$*&,%/C +4''*)% *$ +#?
,%*$2%/ #,?
+4)2 (&)46%,$ :%%, 75#)%( &, /%)&/(
,&/ )&7?
5%$$%/
- - :%%, +2&., (4/*,1 )&4/+% 2%#/*,1 7%$*$*&,-
- $ .&/$2 ,&$*)*,1 7%/ 7#/# 7%$*$*&,8 *$ :%%, %A75#*,%( #6&4,$ '*,%
+- 8 7#*( 4,9#:
#B'
&#/( )&67%,+#$*&, '&/ )4$$*,1 $/%%-
$ '4/$2%/ %A75#*,%( $/%% )4$ +#>% 5*>%+ /%+*(%,$+ .%55 7/&$%)$ 74:5*) 7/&7%/$?
#:&4$ '#55 (#?
&/ $.&- - <%#/,%( )&4,+%5 '&/ '4/$2%/ /%'%//%( 2*+ ./*$$%, #/146%,$+ +4:6*$$%( :%'&/%
&66*++*&,%/8 .2%/%*, 7#/#
*>8 '&55&.*,1 +$#,( $#B%, # $%2222A/
@)7
(
#
"
6
#
$%2222A/ @!7
'
8
D " 7
"
6
<
@
- $ ,&$*)%#:5% ,&$ '*5%( #,?
./*$$%, +$#$%6%,$ +#*( #:&>% /%'%//%( #++%/$*&, 1&,% 4,)&,$/&>%/$%(- - + /%1#/(+ $2*/( 1/&4,( ,#6% /%)&66%,(%( 04:
#1*+$/#$%C *$ &:+%/>%( /%)&66%,(#$*&, <&.%/
%>%,4%
''*)%/+ ,&$ :*,(*,1 &, &55%)$&/ &55%)$&/ #775?
2*+ &., 94(*)*&4+ 6*,( .2*5% 6#B*,1 #77&*,$6%,$ )&,+*(%/*,1 >#/*&4+ '#)$&/+8 7%/ 5#.-
- 7&, )&,+*(%/*,1 6#$$%/8 #6 )&,+*(%/%( >*%.
$2%/% ,& *55%1#5*$?
&/ 7%/>%/+*$?
&55%)$&/8 .2%/%:?
#77&*,$%( <#6:#/(#/-
4/$2%/6&/%8 &55%)$&/;+ #''*/6%( &66*++*&,%/-
2% 1/&4,(+8 &, .2*)2
7%$*$*&,%/;+ #77&*,$6%,$8 #/% 4,$%,#:5% 5#.
&$2%/.*+% #5+& #1#*,+$ .%55 +%$$5%( 7&+*$*&, 6#$$%/ #77&*,$6%,$ <#6:#/(#/8 )2&*)% &55%)$&/ )#,,&$ :% 5*12$5?
*,$%/'%/%(8 %>%, *'
$.& >*%.+ #/% 7&++*:5%8 4,5%++ $2%/% #,?
7#$%,$ *55%1#5*$?
&/ 7%/>%/+*$?
$2%/%*,-
-
%)%,$5?8 &,;:5% !*>*+*&, %,)2 &4/$ < @ 8 $*$5%( !
"
(%)*(%( &, - @- 8 #5+& &:+%/>%( 4,(%/ 3 ?
(
' "
#
$%
"
&' ()* +,+ (,!*
- %"
.
/,%%
"
&
&01
- , >*%.
#:&>% (*+)4++*&,8
4,+4+$#*,#:5% %?%+ 5#.
#))&/(*,15?
#+*(%-
4/$2%/8 - @-
8 &55%)$&/8 #77&*,$*,1 #/#1#/28 2%/%:?
6#*,$#*,%(-
- 2% #55&.%( (*+7&+%( #'&/%+$#$%( $%/6+- - %,(*,1 #775*)#$*&,
+8 *'
#,?8 +2#55 #5+& +$#,( )5&+%(-
0
!
--
+9B+ 2%$2%/ +7%#B*,1 /%#+&,%(
"%+
& 2%$2%/ /%7&/$#:5% "%+
&