High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/2807/2018dismissed

Ravinder Arora v. John Pulinthanam And ORS.

2019-03-19Mr. Justice Amit Rawal14 pages

!"#$ !

% %#&$'#$ &( ) *

+, %%%

- . ./0) %%% 1, #% %#&$&#$ &( ) *

+, %%%

- . 2%%-345 +) %%% 1, 6% %#&$!#$ &( ) *

+, %%%

- . %-% 32.0 ) %%% 1, 7% %#& $#$ &( ) *

+, %%%

- . 8 ,) %%% 1,

%94"5 ,+:

%55 0",+)

%/9 /",+"

1 %

%%5% :/"5 ,+:

%53 5;",+"

1,% <<<<< !"

, 0//,1.

8 ;%#&$'#& $#$ &":+8/,., 5 , #01.

" !' ://.//4,,/8 /4 +/;3.,;0,,$!% #%#$ =(>. ? *1,+/ @ %==#=#$ A,3.,;0,,$#%$'%#$ &(>.

?#* , ,+/11/%A!A6?A!A=#$ &% 8;

9 0 %#&$'#$ &% .

":/,,; %#=$7#$ 6/, 3- . 0,) C", .800, 8/,+: 11,;8//,+, ,

,, $% #%#$ 7"

,0 ;.

, /;

+,+%:.08 ,==#= #$ A,+, , ,,$!% #%#$ =",1,: , % 0, , :/, 0,+/11/ 8 D8/5.1 0.

":+8,1,+, ,

,,$#%$'%#$ &(>.

?#*84.; , % //;, 1,+00,01 .

//:; , 1,84;.

01/

D8/5.1 0.

,/4?,, ;.

: ; ,, ;5,./ / .

( .8/5 *,( "E 5D*,, # %$#%#$$A:%%%$ % %#$$7": , , ; 5,./,,$ %$ %#$$!,$ %$7%#$ 7:,0,84. 0148 ;.

," ".

:./,+ 3.

, , 4011% 1.

. ., 84 . " :

08/,//;; ://./,8,4

# , , ,83F.08/4011 .

8411/4;, 0 ; 1 0 ,

,,$!% #%#$ =.

> +;80 ;, : , ,,$#%$'%#$ &D8/5.1 0.

% & :

0"8//;, 55,./: +,140 1 /01/,,+ /.01.0,+/0,841 " "8;?

/,1 14A$G0;;0 , 8/A$G0H /./ ;40 84 91;0,/;,.

9 ,:// ;,+,"." 0,1 : +/1 + 55,./% : ,": .80,/01 140 8/ 1 5,./#$$!,#$ 781,,+%

% 94 " / , 5 ./ , 84

%55 0",+" 1 ;1 .80, .

014:4 ; ,, 1 , .

,://D8/5.1 0.

,8 1 0,.11/084,1;;?/,1 , ; 55,./ ;4 /, 5 5,./ 140A$G%.

:, : 0,5,./> ,3.,;0+% .

:./,+3.

, 4, 01 1 :, 84, ;5,./#$$!, #$ 7+8.1/,84D8/5.1 0.

".", 0 ; :./,11/4%

%%5% :/"/ ,5 ./, 84

%53 5;",+" 1 ; 1, , 8308/401184 /4;.1

,,,.//,.%&'()(*+ ,-'%( (./ 0+-'* ,-'*1*

0(0-

./+'( '(/-*+ (./ 0+-'*"

1&'-%- 1'0 (*-*

2, ,301*(+ 4-'3 (./ 0+-'* ,-'*1* 1'0

30* 5.

%03."

1&'-%- 1'0 (*-* # $ ,.80,+ 55,./ ,,1 +,4140" ;+,+;

., , , /:8; ,1 ; .

014% + ,/ ,./ 1 "11 , 11 89,+:83 ,84

% :/F. 08/401184. % .: ; ,01/0 , ;.

,D8/5.1 0.

08,8,.1 %&'()(*+* 6(*- *1&'(": ":/ /4;.1 ;.,/"

:/,+;51/I+ +/ 11/"%%".

,> ,84.1 .0, .830 //;/, 18/8;/,//8 , 0+ 11/8/4 , 0 ; % .1

,18/ + ;"0,4; D 0;D , 1. .8 %D8/5.1 0.

., / 6=. 04 + " 0,4 0 3.,;0?, , 11/, ;:/> ;11//3.

,,:/> ;

, 43.

,,1;1 1//+ 11/%":/,, 0 ; /411/4

0 ,/ % 98 +4" 76"7A"7&,7!

> , 8/:

$ % & ' ( ) *(+,(+--. / ) 0(-+1+--

,1(+*(+-- / )

0(+,,*+--

(2 ! ( #,**+3!!4+,(5!

# .-( 6 2 ( #,***.3!!6- ! 7

(/ "

(8 "

" "(:

1 2 ;

5 7 #/

"( # 5

) +. ! " (5

( #5

(2"

$ '

( = ) +. ! 3 !

' " $

" $

( 5

(

' > >(2 ( )

()

! " $

" ( #2 >

((

" ( ?

" 3 ! " ) ++!(3

" 3 ! "" "

3 ! )$ !

( "

3 !

" ( #8

3 ! > "

( #8

> 3 ! ! " '

#+A +8 4!&!(:

- 2 " !

! 3 B

" !

" ! (5 ! " (: / #!,# A.,/, 5.1 0.

,;.

./,1: 01%

98 +4"1 + / #!,# A > , 8/:

) +,-( 3 ! 53 !

" " ) ,+6( !

" " (:

,301*(+ 4-'3* 6(*- *1&'(" ;.

/ ., 1 ;./4019;.0.;J 1.8/1.8/, ,4",/4;/:11 :/ ; ./ / 1/ ; //;; 0. /

, 0 .,;,.D8/5.1 0.

,% 0/ 11/"D8/5.1 0.

" ; ;.0,1 + / #!."/, .//,.84./ 1 ;0

:./,1 + 3.

,5.1 0.

8; .1 .

,;. ,,1 .8 ,3., 4"

: 0+ 4898,0 3.%:/, :+/8/41: ., / #!,1/.,4 :4 /# A+ 8,,01: ;

1. 015.1 0.

%:./,81

1 ,. , #3.,;0,301*(+ 4-'3* 6(*-" , . ?

++( / " "

! !" " " #$ % && '

(( )*( 5

" 3 ! > !C % " > 3 B

( 5 " $

! (2" ) +,- 3 ! ! A "

""" ! A (5! ! 3 ! ! A ) +,- $ " ! A

" " (5 ! 7 ,-() +,-

3 !

" " # ( 5 $ ) +,-

$ ( 2 ?

! 3 !

" $

" (:

5 ) " 3 ! " " $ (:5$ : $ "" (5 ) +,-

( 2 !

" " $

( 5 ( / ) +,-

3 ! (3

3 ! ! ?? " "

" "

$ : "

) ( ) +,-

$ "

" (2 ) +,- " "" " " !

> ( 5

+,(5" ! A ) ,+6 "

$ (3 "

! ) ,+6() " ) ,+6 ! ! " "

> " (5

" D"

) +,-!(5

" ) +,-

" ) ,+6 " ! 3 ! (5 (23 !

" > ! 3 ! (E"

! " (:

:0; + 4,%, ., 84.

, ,,$!% #%#$ = ,. ?

2 !

B2&3)((*+(++(,** *+(*+(,**- *+(*(,*+

" $

*(*.(,*+4

*+(*4(,*+4"

*1(*(,*+6

"! 2 ! (:

, , , ,, $#%$'%#$ &

, ,84D8/5.1 0.

> , 8/:

B# 5 ! B2&3) ,+(*,(,**6"(((*+(++(,** ( / "

,+(*,(,**6

'( # 5

B2&3) ((*+(*+(,**- *+(*(,*+ "

! ( # 5 !

' (:

,.8" D8/ 5.1 0 .

?, 01/0 ./ ,,# %$#%#$$A+ 0$ % %#$$7"

8.: ; ,01/05,./,,$ %$ %#$$!, $ %$7%#$ 7" +;; K $"$$$H? 1/. $G / 9; , #$"$$$H? .08,/, A"$$$H? 1/. $G / 9;".1/,, .

%+, .

+8.1/,"8.+: ,,,.//,. %&'()(*+* 6(*- *1&'(", 0 ; :./,11/4% 51 //;,+/, , ;140 $$G84;4 1 +" 140A$G"49 , / ;

+.1 .0"%%"/011., / #!

# . ., 1 +01.

!' % :./,8/;04,.4> ;, .

014.11 ;+ 0140A$G8;

;?/,1 " & 1/4 ,. ?

B2 F 3 ! "

*-(+,(,*+. F ! !

B2&3)3 ,**- ,*+(5 B2&3)3 "

(2 ' 2 ! 6*G

6*G H

(5 " 2 ! > > "

(5 6*G ( 5 B2&3)3 (2

6*G B2&3)3

! 6*G

( 2

" *,(*4(,*+1 F 3 !

" !

.;" 11 /4 11 .

014 0 , .

11 , ,

$ D8/5.1 0.

84;. 4;?/,1 "8. 01/:./,8,001. , .

, 8+" 01 1 ,0,:/8 41 +/ 0,41 8 +0,8+% ('6+

! '(%-*+

9: !+-0+-'

*&-()3.;<'-(*.-/ =-*< !+-0+-'

-&'0(4>- =-*<