← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/2820/2017disposed of

Radhey Shyam And Others v. P Raghvendra Rao And Others

2019-12-13Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan3 pages

      

  

       !  " 

   !"! #$%$&'



#()*&+$#,-%./0!$&*#+12/'$3*'-

#!/#1$%- /.*40+12/'$ #'-$)$*'*&$#%

#!/&+$$)! /&&0!$&*#0/#5/&/   #$%% &'&()#*'+,- -$)$'*'*&$#% *.$+/3#*')$'*'*&%$$4*&6+*#$2'*&%''-$ #$%)&+$&'%  #  )/5  )/#*'5  3*'-  '-$*#  2(&'$#7)/#'%  *&  (8.*2  $/.'- &6*&$$#*&6  $)/#'9$&'0  /&2-4(./  -$  3#*'  )$'*'*& 3/%  /..3$+  &



:-$#$.$1/&')#'*& '-$;(+69$&'*%<('$+8$.3

=&1*$3 '-$/81$0)#/5$# '-$)$'*'*&$#%*%/22$)'$+ /&+*&%'/&')$'*'*&*%+*%)%$+ 3*'-/+*#$2'*&''-$ #$%)&+$&'%'.4*&''-$*%%($ )/#*'5 )/5 )$'*'*&$#%3*'- '-$*#2(&'$#)/#'% *& '-$(8.*2$/.'- &6*&$$#*&6$)/#'9$&'0/&2-4(./4$$)*&6*& 1*$3'-$

/2''-/''-$)$'*'*&$#%/#$9#$<(/.* *$+$+(2/'*&/..5/&+ /.%  )$# #9  9(.'* /#*(%  (&2'*&%  /%  /6/*&%'  .*9*'$+



(&2'*&%)$# #9$+85'-$*#2(&'$#)/#'%*&'-$(8.*2 $/.'-&6*&$$#*&6$)/#'9$&'0/&2-4(./ $'&$$+ (.8$ +&$/%$>)$+*'*(%.5/%)%%*8.$8('&'./'$#'-/& (# 9&'-% #9'-$+/'$ #$2$*)' '-$2$#'* *$+2)5 '-*% #+$#?

-$)#$%$&')$'*'*&3/% *.$+).$/+*&6&&729).*/&2$ +*#$2'*&% '-*%(#' (#*&6'-$)$&+$&25 '-$2&'$9)')$'*'*&0&@A

@0*'

3/%8%$#1$+'-/'2./*9 '-$)$'*'*&$#%-/1$&'8$$&2&%*+$#$+/ '$# )#1*+*&6))#'(&*'5 -$/#*&6-$.$/#&$+2(&%$. #'-$!'/'$'4 '*9$'%$$4*&%'#(2'*&% +/5/

*+/1*'+/'$+

@ #!/4$',(9/#0!0 99*%%*&$#0+/&+#(6%+9*&*%'#/'*&0/#5/&/ *.$+*&(#'*% '/4$&&#$2#+02)5-/&+$+1$#'.$/#&$+2(&%$. #'-$)$'*'*&$#% B*'-'-$/

*+/1*'0#+$#+/'$+

@*%/&&$>$+%)$#'-$%/*+#+$#0 '-$2./*9% '-$)$'*'*&$#%-/1$8$$&)/#'.5/22$)'$+0*$'-$5-/1$8$$& 6*1$&)/5%2/.$ C:

:

&&'*&/.8/%*%3$  C @@C/&+& /2'(/.8/%*% #9



:0*$'-$+/'$ +$2*%*& '-$3#*')$'*'*& -$+$2*%*&*%%(8;$2''('29$ '-$ )#)%$+'8$ *.$+0 $/#&$+2(&%$. #'-$)$'*'*&$#%%(89*'%'-/''-$#$*% 29).*/&2$ '-$+*#$2'*&% '-*%(#'0%'*..'-$6#*$1/&2$%(#1*1$%'-/' 8$&$ *'-/%8$$&3#&6.52/.2(./'$+&&'*&/.8/%*%3$  C @@C'



:$ (#'-$#%(89*'%'-/'&/2'(/.)/59$&'*%9/+$'*..+/'$ -$6#*$1/&2$#/*%$+3*'-#$6/#+'&'*&/.)/5 *>/'*&+$% &'  /.. 3*'-*& '-$/98*'   )#$%$&'  2&'$9)' )#2$$+*&6%0/% '-$#$*% %(8%'/&'*/.29).*/&2$ '-$;(+69$&'-$*%%($#/*%$+6*1$%#*%$' #$%-

A 2/(%$ /2'*& $/#&$+2(&%$. #'-$!'/'$0&*&%'#(2'*&% #9 #"*;/5 ,(9/#0  %%*%'/&'  D  99*%%*&$#0  +  E  #(6%  +9*&*%'#/'*&0 /#5/&/%(89*'%'-/''-$)/59$&'3(.+8$2#$+*'$+*&'-$/22(&'% )$'*'*&$#%3*'-*&$*6-' 3$$4% #9'+/5' *%  (#'-$#2&'$&+$+'-/'

+$'/*.% 2/.2(./'*& /9(&' (&++($/.%3*..8$)#1*+$+''-$ )$'*'*&$#%3*'-*&%/*+)$#*+ &1*$3 '-$/81$0'-$2&'$9)')$'*'*&*%+*%)%$+ -$   )$'*'*&$#%  3(.+  8$  /'  .*8$#'5  '  /1/*.  #$9$+*$%  *& /22#+/&2$3*'-./3 ##$+#$%%/. '-$%(#1*1*&66#*$1/&2$% '*% (#'-$#2./#* *$+'-/'*&2/%$'-$/9(&'%/#$&'2#$+*'$+ *&'-$/22(&'% '-$)$'*'*&$#%3*'-*&'-$%'*)(./'$+)$#*+0'-$53(.+8$ /'.*8$#'5'#$1*1$'-$2&'$9)')$'*'*& +#$%% &'&()#-  '.)%

A

@ B-$'-$#%)$/4*&6D#$/%&$+

$%D B-$'-$##$)#'/8.$

$%D