High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/789/2024allowed

Sukhdev Singh v. Union Of India And Others

2024-11-18Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma19 pages

!"#$%%%

"#"&#'

!"#$%%%

!""#

$ %

($ )*( ++

+ ,

)*( + ++ + ( & '() * +"%,&-". * $%"&."/,&-"" * "

0",&-" % * 1" """, "/ / % + 23#! +

+ ,

5 " .

%, % % "( "

" 6

7&8 "

'(/"

& 0: - 5 '"/,""

-/"0 % " "'/( % '-"0 -/

.'/&.0.'12"&#!

5% ."

//& 0( ;2" ."

0 - ; / -, -

"'/(, "0/(,

5 /"

0-"/ '"

"'/(9< =5 "'/(/0-/"0 % ."

>-'(0%& (, " % "

"'/(9."

" '"'/ '" ""'( 0/"

5 " , % %

" "%%"/ ; ?. , " "%%"/ ' 0 '"

"'(" --

5 " ,% /"/ ' ,. '(-"

"-"//"

>- 5 "/ ."

& 0 : - 5 '"/, ""

">-", . ,

"0."

" 6

7&8 95 % "%"

" - 8 "- "

6 :/ " 0" " 0" , % "

/ ".

%' #3

"3/45 "&/ ; !"//(, , ".

% -0%//( 0'"

$ /"/( "0'"

% '( - /"("/"- " @ 0

"/ * ,- / % '0 , " - - ,'(

?A'/&%8 ,-"

,.-/&%%"/+ '-"0 "

, > - -"//

'( /"

& 0: - 5 '"/'-"0 ? ? , '0 " -@- @/0" " -, % % ".

% 5 , - " - "

., .

0"""'/' $ /"/(,'"

/"(" /"- . "

" 0'/'/-"" % %

"/0%- - 6

,'( /"

& 0: - 5 '"/-- B ""

0 ,-"'"--%'( ,"

-0% "(%"

0% -("

,&%8 %"

"( 0

"% 0? 8 - > - % - % - '( /"

& 0 : - 5 '"/, % , 0(""/"'/% % , ."

"--

?A'/&%8 -"// 0% ?. , "

/(, '

@ %"

- '(&%8 -"

"# "," ("

, " "/0 ("

/"% - %"

0% - '( /"

& 0 : -

'"/,"

- -"//' ,- " - 0" 6

,'(/"

& 0: - 5 '"/

!0% "/("/ .- -"

/ "

" ."

0" , D 7 % "9 .- '-"0

3 /' &%8 ("

,. , 0% '-"0%"

$ /"/( , " % 0% -"// ."

@ ' 0", . , -"// '-"0/"(%/ ,. %" - , %-"//(."'/8%/-", 0"" 0 % @" 0

% 0%/( -

"% 0

"" 0% ,@".

%' ,

".% "

- /"("/"-

E""

0"(,( @ '""- -" > -* , "/ @ '

""/> -!0% "/("/ -"

0% 0" ."

"%%/-" 0,. ,0%

'-0 - "'/' "$ /"/(, , '"

/0""3 '/"-/"0''(- /"( "/"- ./'-0" "-

E % -0"" -">-"% % .

%, -

(.//%

!"##"$!% $"##&5 /"%

" %" "'-

( 8 - "-" "/-- %- "/0 "'/( ",% -%

/, . - '(0,"

" - %

/ 5 " /" % , '-0 8 "- "

( )

* , %"

" "%, %"

2 : 0 , %" "

"/ 8 "- " ,"%% . '-0 / "% F!!

B/0)1 "/ -%/

. %

/0/

# &!

# %

;

'"#

%" % ! # !

# !

# (!

! "!

)

" !

! %

# !

" #

* +

" # !# "!

! $"

) !

% ! !

" %" * +

",,,,, 1

% ! !

" " %

# "

!# !

" %

&&% & %

" !

"$"

) ) 2 ,

- "

! % ! # ! " %

3 ,,,, 4 ,,,, .

/% ! %"

# !

# #

" !

,,,,,

(

" % ! %

!" %

# "

" !

$" !

!% !

# !" # # &%

% !

* ! (!

! "!

" " # % " !

1 % " "!

$" !

% ! "

))))

+., 0 % "8 "- / /"%

!"##"$!% $"##&,"

' 0 . -/"

" 0" '( *-"/ E"

, "

0-"

, 6

% % !7 $6 '"-"/ , @ "0 '-0"--%

6 !"//( 0"',""// @ '0"0-"/8"0" % ,.-'-"0% %"

" 0 % % '-0 //0/"

-, . ,-" %" -- ,"""0,% '

-/"

' "3 '-/"

' "3

" 0"-

; 5 . % ", - /

%, 0"( .//-"-/"

" 0"'(*-"/E"

7&8 29,. " ."

-/"

' -"/ " ' " .// 0" -/"

" "/ ,- / %0"( "/ .//-,""

-"/ "'/( % % % , ."

"%, % % % 0 @" 7 % "9'-0 " ""'(

'" '"'/0/"

E""

0"(,"/0 " " -%

/,0"('% /0"

"00' -0'"" - "'/ 0* " " "%%@" /0 -%

/ "(, "

0( " -, 0-"/8"0","

0"% 0, 0"( "/ .- 0"( '-0

@/( - * , '( ,

@"/0 " %"(%

/ "( . - "'/ 0, 0"( ,

'-0- "'/"

0 0/"

-"3

% ,0"('-0- "'/'-0" ""'( '" '"'/0/"

! . , '

@ %' - " ,0"('"//.-0"( "

"00"( ',"

/ ."

" " 0"-(, %-"//("0

"%% / 0"%/"-$ /"/(,."%% 0"(" 0" - "'/, "/(" " "%% % /0"

(0-"/8"0" '-00"% -%

/!- @-, % "( " %/"-'% /0 -%

/-- , ",.-0"( @ "0'-/"

'-"/,( "-/"

" @ ""%- -'-0

0"'(0-"/'"

/") "9" G '9 " G -9 "0/( (" % - (G

! . ,- , "

'0% "/( - 0%/(0 " & 0-"/-@ '(00'

*-"/E"

, ' "0 "%% / 0"%/"-' '

@/( "/ ! " "/0"/(".// -

- H ,.-' //"( -%

/,' % /0, '-"/$ /"/( "0"

- 0"( /"//,.-' "// "

/,'- "'/' " '"'/

'-0 " ""'(0/"

-! @/, ./'".//"/ "'/(% -- * ,-"

"/0 ,--

% 0"- -'(& 0(

/, % '" "//(,0"('" @/ -%

/-- , - "0'" @/ "- /

-- "

/(, 0"('"-- "-

" -- : "-, ""/00"( "

. -%

/-- , /(' "

% / " 0, 0""."( 0 "-0/"

- 0"(' "(" /", "",. '-0%/( -"

-0'""'"/ - ( -"/(,"' "- ,. , 0"(' ""/ "'/(% % % ,.

'-0"

'-0% '( %,

0"( ' "( "/ "'/( % % % E " "

0"(, " / "

"- 0 . ' "//0 "( H "(00' -%

/,'% ' //"

0(, %" "/ ",% '-0 / , "

"00' -0'"" - "'/ 0, "0 0" -,("%% % % / 0-' - "'/' -"/ '- "'/'-0 " "" '" '"'/0/"

-, "-@ ,

0,% -%/ >0 '(?C'/ &%8 , -"

3% +

% 4567 .

+88 7695 /"%"

" "% " -"

8 "- " "8% (

9 :

!$ '

/ "#;

) < =2 % .8&"> % ,/--!< .?1$ !$ %

@< 3 < .B!$C !$ !

!< 8$ ! $-

@< .B!$C !

$- 6

@.B!$C !

@.B!$C+ !

/-- >

2 $"##"D>) :

> ?&8

2 &- "7 9 "'8 "-% -%/ , %/(-/"

,"." "'/('-0 "/% "(00' -0'"" - "'/ 0,".- 8 = , %,"( - "'/00'

@ '"/ 0& 0(,'( @ ' "

' "'/(% +/

0 "'/(% "( 00' -0'"" - "'/ 0,.'-0 "/ . " "'/( " @"0 = 0 , ' 0% "/(

@ " -/"

" 0 *-"/ E"

, -"/( % -" """ "'/('" '"'/

'-0" ""'(0/"

-5 "-/"

"'-0

>'() < =2 % .8&"> % ,/--!< .?1$ 6 : 0 , "% 0% "

H %( -"/"0"/"/ "(00' - "'/ 0-- , %-"//(." "

'-0 //, - "' '-0' ."( * , "/ "

% 0%, " . "( " , --

@/(, " "%% "7 9

"( , '% 0'" @/

- "

" 00' - "'/ 0 !0% "/(, % .0 @"'

% "9 H -- ,' 0%/( ," -"

, " 0" -"

, %,-/"0" '-0 / - "'/(% * ,"// "-

" - -0 "- "" - '( -- ,"

'-/ /( - I, -/"

. "( H -- , " @/@"

0/"

- "3 "0 ' " "" '( ' " '"'/0/"

- ; E""

0"(, '-0 "/ "

% -%/7 9"( -"'"/ "'/(% -- ,'/(%) "9&0 "--%"- -- 0/"

(

-, 0 '-0 - '(*-"/ E"

" ' ' . " .- . ,'-0 --/'( 0 '-0/ '9 &( " , 0"( "/

@/('-0--/'(*-"/E"

, "

0 0/"

( - ' " '"'/0/"

-, "0'"

-"/ : , 0-"/%/ " -/ "'-0-"/8"0" -- ' 0", % '-0/ -, % ,

"0.//'0""

-,(

"7 % "9,*-"/E"

@ "

--/ * , "/ -/"

% "," 0"" ( *-"/E"

//./ /"."% !!

J1*-"/7*/"

( 9, FJB/0) 1 "/ -%/ J 5 ,"

'. 0. "'% -%/ ,. "0 / 0 % % & 0(, " "% /0"

(0-"/8"0" '0" " "/, "'-"0 - "'

0 ' 0"3 . 0'-"0"%% " " ."

" 0" "* , "/

@ ' 0, 0 "- "",. "

-" "/8 % ,"3

, %

, % //0 % % "%/"-, " "- '(0 0/"

(

-,. , 0"(--/" ' ."

" @/ -& 0(""

- ."

" '"'/ '-"0" ""'( 0/"

- 2 !", "/ @ '" 0

- ,. *-"/E"

,"//(% -0""

"/- "-"/--,%"

-/"

/("%% " " , 0%/(0 " & 0-"/ -@ , / '/- -" - --, . 0 , '-"0 -* , " 0%/(0 "/ $ /"/(, 0"('-0--/@"

% , '

@"%% / 0" %/"-, ."

-"/'. 0/"

-' '" '"'/ '-0" "" '(% 0"- 0/"

- "

/(, % "0%/( -@ " " "%% / 0"%/"-, '( *-"/E"

-- ,/" "--/ ," "

0"-- "( ,'( " 0" % '/ 0 "(%

0(,"( "

-$ /"/( '

@"--3 % , -

0/"

-,'./" "//( /"".//--/ '(*-"/E"

," "- % ' '-"0 - 0 " - -" "/ - -- . ./'"/ "'/(% ?. ,. "" , @ '8 "-- %,"

'-"0 - '( $/"

*-"/E"

! " "

, /"%"

+6"

-- %/( /'"/ % + ; , 8 "- " ) FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF - <

G2)< )< 2-= %H- %-H E-%

7 2-%!7)*)G)I

2 & " - , -/ ""0 "%% / 0"%/"- '-"00"

% -%/ 7 % "9-/"

'(?C'/&%8 -"

;

3% +

"'(*-"/ E"

," 0 .-. , '% % ,'-0/ & 0(,0" % /0"

( ! , -/"

" /". >0 7 % "9 " "% 0%"-

" ."

" @/ -, @ ' " "'/( . " % 5 " % 0%

'"'/' /"- ' "% 0% '-"0-"

% % ?. , "-"

- "- -"

" % ,

-/( ' "% 0%,'" "//("/ -"

" ("/ %*-"/E"

," / " "

, 0%/(0 " & '/--"--" "/---@7 9,. 0"( '-"0 "/" "

0( %

/,'-"0 - 0"-"/- "0/( ( * , ."

"/ @ ' "0-"/ %," ' ".// 0 ."

-"/ " '-"0 " "" '( '-"0 " '"'/0/"

- 22 ?. ," " - , -/ ""

' - " (% 0" "' - 8 7 % "9 $ "/(, - - ' % 0%7 % "9"

'/'( % , ,

- "."% 0-"/ '"

%- /(,- --"'"

% "//

0 ,' -"'

"'" @/ "-"/- "0/( ( "

/(, @ '-/"

0 0/"

-! ", @ '-/"

'" '"'/ '-0 " ""'( 0/"

-'(% % E""

0"(,0% ,/"

&:5 -- , % - ( -/"0 / % % , , //.8 "-% 0 K5."% "'/(C?(% 0 %"C 5 "-- /( '" 0 , "

-00 -.-"/"

-/( - "

'>- 5 0% -

"//(-" '("('"//," , "/ " ,% '"'/('-" " /" 5 -00/(" - %%/ 0/", E,0"("/ '% 0' &-- +""/?"/ -,L,"%% 80"/(

2% - E %%/'. "6," ?% 0 %"" % -" "

/( /,"-- /(&0 -"&-"0( #%"/0/(, ./0//&0 -" " ("/ ,"

?(% 0 %-M 26 5 - "% 0 ( / % % 0 ,

//.- ) 6.75 "/I%0" " "//(-" "- - -/"

"7 % "9,. ," -

( '-"0-"

%& 0(*-"/E"

-- ,'" 0 / 0 / & 0(,", '

@/( %"

% % , ,"/"%% "'/(, "0%/(0 0-"// /"

- '0" "-"/-"/ - , ,

/"/0 "'/(7 % "9 6875 " "/I% 0"/( %- J K %

" -" 0' /( '-0 "%%/- 6'7 %- /(,.""/"/ -"

, 0%/(0 0-"/-@ % "9, ,

-/"

" 0" ' , ./'""'/( 0 %" ."

-"/""

0 0/"

-'(% / , ."

" '"'/, '-"0" ""'( 0/"

5#.0 !

"3/45 "&/ 2; !" 0", 0 .

%" .'

" "', "0 "//. 2 50% 7&8 9 @"

" "

'." - % -- ,% -

"'/(% -"

% ' "0'

% ->0 '(?C'/ &%8 -"

) #5"#"3#!5.9 .: /.C, % % + #05# %;% 2 5"'8 - 0"('."% 0 0"( 2 - /"(%"

% / ".

%' " "% 0%0""

>- "'/( % -/"0, , / % /".,"

% - - '(&%8

8 %

;6;6&;6;4 " +* 8 :

7045&7046 !

< + " 8 %

4., 455.

" +* 8 % :

4559 !

+ % 3

-# !

455.#

-0"-"

/ "

'-, ,"// %"%%/-"7 9, "(,"/ "7 9 % 6+

+ ,

6+ + (7 %%%

&>"/44 4 /4 < .15#2= .

"# !

4 /4 <"/.80