← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/1826/2020dismissed

Rajneesh Arora v. District Rural Development Agency (Drda) Bathinda

2023-08-31Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu14 pages

 





   

  

  

  



 !

"# !$%&%"'( )

) 



                    

  *+



                     (

 ,- ).

   . 

. 

   !  "

 " #   $!%!%&'()%(*(* !+ ,"

 " #   $!%!%-(.()%(*&' ! /" 0"1   . 

.  / )

  ## 1   3     #      4'( $$ #  5

#  $    3   5      # 1     1 "#    # $!%!%&'()%(*(*      #     #  5

#  "012%'

")* 3 !3 4) )      7       

    2     8"       $  # 1%   +  !  "   #

 9+!:;

(&*'(*&-%( 3  (**'(*&'%&*           3  3   %

 3     %

   &(*% "4&<"4(*"4*."4)-"4<&"&))=&)< #>    $

 #

 7>$8; #       (*&((*&' %&& 

 1 

 

 +  "  "  1               (**'(*&'3

4

  1 #         "

 #

7 8      

#     #1?   3                    @    # 2A" +

 ? *&*)(**&"  !    A  #

9!

A:3  112  A  " +

 #

 72A8 3    #        >   #   !

A"   !

A  *(*<(**( 3    1 3    2  ">   #2 >#   $  "! /3 

B    ## # 

  ?((*4(**'"   

 1   1  %  2    3    #2A

  1 BB   ##    #     .

  % * ? &4*&(*&("    5   3  #    #   

" "2  "

    $!%!%&'()%(*(*" "     

$!%!%-(.()%(*&'     !C    > #   

##     &(*% "4&<"4(*"4*."4)-"4<&"&))=&)<>$ 

3 #  1 

 / " ?" ##  # "  #  "  + !   6  $

 #

 7+!>$8" 3    C  

  #    (** $$"  # 

 (<*4(*&(" #  3  % 



   

    

  

  

 





 

!     "



  #



   $   

     

  

%&'(         )  *





!  +



   ,''

 

-.





/

   

   



 

       #





 

    # +







   $

 

  #  

   

  /







#   





  $

   #   

 ,%'0,'1,2

5 >     1   " 

   " 2   "          $!%!%-(.()% (*&' =  

      $!%!%&'()%(*(*   1 #    +! 3    1     ()*-(*&("&4*<(*&("(4*'(*&(=('*'(*&("   

       1   "     #  $!%!% D4(&.%(*&( #  5

  5     3   3



##1    $  *&&&(*&(  1          #      1 #    

$ "    % +    

   

3&, 

 4#

  ) 0  

13'1,'1,   #

   ,('3,'1,

  5 #  6   

 #





   



#

 



 

  

 





   

 #

 

  

,('3,'1,    5 #  6



2

+ >  1  1   " # $" 3   3    1  

 

 +  "    (.&&(*&D"3  3   % +   7







 

7#

 

  #    



   

  /  



   +     

 











,'1,,'182

.

   (

>        (.&&(*&D "   +!>$#              1     "  

 

 (&*'(*&-   #  

; 1

" 5## 

" ">!C   >   3       # "    

"      (&*'(*&-;      1 #    +!>$  3     

 1     *4&&(*&- = *)*((*&)  ,  "  %      3   

   # "    +!"    (**'(*&'"   %

 

# 

"       &(*% "4&<"4(*" 4*."4)-"4<&"&))=&)<>$      ##  "     

 #  $  

 4'* # (*&' *-&&(*&'" 1    3

 1  

 

+       (*&((*&' 4 E     



 .

- 

 ) 

.



* ,      

           % $   # 2A (4&((**';  " 1      3  1  !

A *&*)(**&=*(*<(**(" 3   3  #    6 1        3    1 BB   ##

 3 3 C   $   #2A3 #(4&((**'      3   #    

 .

-  ) )) . 

*)  ,   #      

 1    @F "    @  " 2A     C 3         ##

 3   #@F    A   *) 

#  1     "3 

1 # #1   +!3  #        %      # %

 / " 3              

    3

3 

B        "

  "          # 1  ;        *) 

           1          #    3    ##             # C      ## ;       

#$  

 .

-  . 

- 

 ?   "     #    3  

    #  " 1 #                  1     "    +!   

 (&*'(*&-"     "#  

   " 3     1  ;  

3  #  3

 1   )  6    #    #  %     "   +!  %

# 

 (**'(*&'   "3     " 3

  #    

  3  #   3 #        1  

 (3  $G     1 

% F 1 #   )   # 1       #        3     %

"   #            1 1

 1 3    3     #   1 ; "     1 #     



  "1   # C 

    ;    %

  3   #   

1 C 3 

)  ,  1     "    #    5"3  1   #  $ 

 33  F  5 E     #     

 

6  

" 5     3 # 1 

/ "

  ?## " "   1 #

B ('*<(*&*=&(*.(*&&> #  

#  "         4'( $$ 3  #  1    % 

 $!%!%D4(&.%(*&( #  5

    3 

## 1     1   $   *&&&(*&(   1    $ 

2C  #    1   "     #  $        #

 (<*4(*&(     +  (.&&(*&D" 3         #    "    +!>$  

#

   + >       $ "  +!" #              C     1    "

(&*'(*&->   #  #     "   

  ;      1 #    $ 3

 1  

 1            +! F  

 ; "#   

 # " 1  # 

"1

 5## " "!C  >!

 "   # 1  +! 5   1 #   #  #   "     

   %

79 #      

 # 

 

    

  

 

 /     

    #  



  

   

    

   # :/ 1



5 ,''1 :/ ,



, 5 

,'', :/ 8

   ,,',,''( :/ 3



  

'8'('( :/ 0



   '%'&'( :/ %





  ';'('( :/ (



 )  80& :/ &

< 

  :/ ;



 ) 8=,&=,''& :/ 1'

 )  10('3

  ,('8'& :/ 11



   ,('8'& :/ 1,



 :/ 18



   '%'8';

:/ 13



  

1,1'';

:/ 10



  !  :/ 1%





 !  :/ 1(



  ! 

:/ 1& 

   ,011'& :/ 1;





- .

 

11'8'& :/ ,'





- .

  101,'& :/ ,1





- .

  '%','& :/ ,,



  

,%'8'& :/ ,8 > 

 

  

 #  



 

  1

=

3,'

3';

3'&

3%&

3(1

1%%

1%(

,1(

,1& 6  +

  # 

# 7  # 6 

  # 7  # 6

 

  ) 1

  

 #

 

  

 

 ,%'&,'102

  



            " %      ## $G "3   

"? % -.

  @ 

  - 9@1.

-.

)  5

  A

-.- 9@,.

B

#

 # 

+C

5  - 9@8.A

-.





   

 :

+C

5  - 9@3.  # "    +!"   C      1    "  %

 

"     3  #    #   

##    

&(*% "4&<"4(*"4*."4)-"4<&"&))=&)<>$

 $ 5    

(&*'(*&-"  1 #    $ 3   

 #       3

  1   1  2 "       "  #     (**'(*&'" 3  1"      3  3    %

"1  3

1  + (*&((*&'"  

  3 

% 13

 #

 #

 B

 $ D 

/

  

  



  #  







  

   

 #

#

#

    

7  

  

  



  +



    



     

    

  





#

   

   



 

  





  # #



  

 #

    # 

   



       

 



7

#



   

 

7  #



   #







   #  #

+    

   #  

   

  

 #      # #

 

  4   #

   

 #



=

  

    #

 #  

  B

   

1% +



    

 



 # 

 

 

 

  





  #  

#

 #

 



     



  +

   # 

#

# 

   



 #

 





       

 









5 ,'1;

 1'@''

 +

     7 

 



  #2



     1   F       + 3  

     #      @        $     #              3 #    > 3  

  



   ;      "   #    

  ;     # ;      3 # " #   





1 1 1 BB 6

   1 ##   #1  

" 

## #    #     #     

   #    3    #1 "  3

  %

 #    3 #    

 3 # 

 3     4 "       #           # #     #1 #  

;    #  #          #     

 

  

  1    %

    #     1 BB  #    #     

3 #

1 F 5  * ,   +! 

" @  #  

##   1    

"        3   

 

(&*'(*&-   " 3    %

(**'(*&' @              

  3

#  %

    &(*% "4&<"4(*"4*." 4)-"4<&"&))=&)<>$

  "     1 #  #   "       3  

    "     3

1   1   D**-(**.%'       

   %

13

+









  #

# 

 <  





! 



  

 

 

7#    



 

 *C  



 / +







  



  #

# 

 <  





!  

    



   

  



   

# 

 +C



 <   





! 

7    





 



  

 

    

 +CD

:   $ 

 #

  

 / #

  

 <   





! 





   

  

 =  

  

   



 





! 

C 

 

:  



#   # 

 +C   

   



 / #

: 



 <   





! 

 7

 



  



#

  

 

   

#

10



  

 

 C

  

   # /

  

8% ,1 130=@

 

1( 1;

1;1=@ *



    

8% ,1 130=@ 

 

 < 

 C  

 

, 1% (,&=@

 





     -83 '13 31(=@.

  

 

       ) 11  

+

C 









 

 #

     

 

 #    



 C 

   2

5 >   1    "  3 C 1 5     2 " 

 3  "  /      &&*4(**.%&   #2A 3  ! 1  $  >    "   /     ;   1 

E  "     

 1     #     

B #  / 3 3

31 "  1  1  1    !

 " 5        @          5    >

"         3     " 

    

 # 1   ##   #           1  

   1E :1    $   

    / + 4 . *

      #  )  

    % %

   #  



B

    

 

   



/ 

   #

  # 

 

  + 





   #

   

#



7# 



  :





  







 

 

   

  

       

      #

 <  



   

#

 B

  /

 

   # 



 



  # 

  

 

 

 #   # /   



   2

EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

9   1;'





  

  

 

 #      

  4  

  

4

  # 

      ! 

  #   

      

         



 

  1;0

1;;

   +     

   

 

 

  



 



 

    

#

 B 6

 

  



   

 

    



    @    

    +

#  

    



 

 

   



 

    





 # 

 F 

,-.

 G

  

 

   

  



    



 #

  + 



     

   

 



 +



 

  

  7 

 

    #

       /  

 

 



 #



  

  #  



#  



     





   

 

  

      

  

  



 

  

  #





B

    

 # #

 

#

   # 

 

 





  

# 

  @B7

 

  7 

 B

  /   

 / 2

 "    5    #      D**4(*&- @F%( #     / " ?!3 

B            *4 

  E  "  3   1              

"    1 #       $            *(  $G      1  

% F 1 

+  

1 #     1   

     #   # C      ## " 

1  1    

  

      #   1 #   ##     &(*% "4&<"4(*"4*."4)-"4<&" &)) = &)< >$ E  "    "  3     1     #   $    F        ;1  "  3 #     

 1  " 1   @  ##        ? "   ##  1              #    # 

 1 F 5        #  1      A#  "  

 

#

"   

   1 1





 "       "   ;         4'($$"3  1   

    

#          #      3   1

  #   1 1 

#$   "     $ " 5

     

#     3    7    #38 3  7           8E  "       #  3  ;    %

;    

 1  

 

 +  ;  "       1    #     "      F 

  ?   4          #           &&   "  #  "  +!  5     F   *     "#"



 

## 

 

  1      #  #     D&*'(*(D   . 

.  

 

67! 7!8 &1!9%':;8!&"'!3( !&; "

67! 7!8 !1"8 <2!(

!&; "