M/S Sumit Wool Processor Ludhiana v. State Of Punjab And ORS

  
  
 


 

 !  " #$ %&$ '(


  !
    !
"! #$%$&'



#!()*+,-!,&.*#/#0+12/'$ #'*$-$',',&$#  )*++,,-.)  *$  3#,'  -$',',&  ,%  ,4$+  #  5(/%*,&.    #+$#  +/'$+

6  7-/%%$+89"/4($++$+/:#,8(&/40(&;/8< #%*#'0'*$ #,8(&/4=(-*4+,&.'*$#+$# '*$--$44/'$('*#,'9+,%>,%%,&./--$/4

# /,4(#$'>/)$-#$?+$-%,'/%-$#!$2',&@ < = '*$(&;/8"/4($ ++$+/:2'0

< #%*#'0'*$2'=(#'*$#-#/9$#,% #+,#$2',&' '*$--$44/'$('*#,'9'*$/#'*$/--$/43,'*(',&%,%',&. #-#$?+$-%,' *$ /2'%/#$'*/''*$/%%$%%>$&'9$/#,&141$+,% 6? *$ -$',',&$#3/%#$.,%'$#$+(&+$#'*$2'/&+3/%$&./.$+,&'*$>/&( /2'(#$ )&,''$+24'*&,&%-$2',&3/%2&+(2'$+& 6A 89'*$

,2$#% :2,%$/&+/:/',&$-/#'>$&'/22(&'8)%3$#$-#+(2$+/''*$ ',>$ ,&%-$2',&0*3$1$#0+(#,&.'*$-#2$$+,&.%'*$/22(&'8)%3$#$ -#+(2$+3*,2*3$#$&' (&+3#'*#$4,/&2$*$$%,.&/'$+

,2$#

#/>$+8$%';(+.>$&'/%%$%%>$&'1,+$#+$#+/'$+B   /&+#/,%$+/& /++,',&/4  +$>/&+    060@60@A C?  &  /--$/4  3/%  ,4$+  8$ #$  '*$ --$44/'$('*#,'90/22>-/&,$+89/&/--4,2/',& #3/,1$# -#$?

+$-%,'/%-$#!$2',&@ < = '*$2'*$--$44/'$('*#,'9#+$#$+ +$-%,'  D '*$/++,',&/4+$>/&+8$+$-%,'$+*$-$',',&$# ,4$+

(#'*$#/--$/48$ #$'*$#,8(&/4*$%/>$3/%+,%>,%%$+,&1,$3 '*$ ;(+.>$&' '*$!(-#$>$
(#',& 

# "/"

%&$ 0102# 0*$&2$'*$-#$%$&'-$',',& !$2',&@ < = '*$2',%#$-#+(2$+8$43

E!
@ !

:::::: < =/--$/4%*/448$$&'$#'/,&$+0(&4$%%%(2*/--$/4,% /22>-/&,$+89%/',% /2'#9-# '*$-#,#>,&,>(> -/9>$&' '3$&'9?

,1$-$#2$&' '*$''/4/>(&'

/++,',&/4+$>/&+0-$&/4'9/&+,&'$#$%'0, /&9F *$1,#$% '*$%/,+-#1,%,&3/%2*/44$&.$+8$ #$'*,%
(#'

,&8(&2* -$',',&%0'*$>/,&8$,&. %&3
( / "#$ %&$ 41 2'
'1
"!2

0 *$1,#$% '*$%/,+-#1,%,&3/%(-*$4+0*3$1$#0,'3/%*$4+'*/''*$ --$44/'$('*#,'9*/+,&*$#$&'-3$#'.#/&',&'$#,>-#'$2',&/./,&%' -#$?+$-%,' #*$/#,&. /--$/4&>$#,'% *$!(-#$>$
(#',&

# "/51(2 (-*$4+'*$;(+.>$&' '*,%
(#'3,'*#$./#+''*$1,#$% !$2',&@ < = '*$2'0*3$1$#0'*$%/,+;(+.>$&'3/%%$'/%,+$''*$$:'$&''*/''*$ --$44/'$('*#,'9*/+,&*$#$&'-3$#'.#/&',&'$#,>-#'$2',&/./,&%' -#$?+$-%,''3/%*$4+'*/''*$--$44/'$('*#,'92/&&'././,&%''*$

B %'/'('#9-#1,%,&/&+2/&&'3/,1$

'*$#$5(,#$>$&' -#$?+$-%,'*$ #$4$1/&'-#',&% '*$;(+.>$&'/#$#$-#+(2$+8$43

 

    

 





  

  !"#"$ 

% %&%

%  

' (  $   %   %%$

%& % & " 

)     %*++ ,   %%- $ 

%  +    %+$



+

%+   % ,  +     ::::::

6    '*$  ,&*$#$&'  -3$#  '*$  $:,%'$&2$    3*,2*  ,% %-$2, ,2/449/2)&34$+.$+89-#1,%,&%%(2*/%!$2',& '*$

/&+!$2',&6A '*$
#
,%'8$#$/+3,'* '*$  4,>,'/',&  '*/'  $:$#2,%$    %(2*  -3$#  2/&&'  8$ (&+$#'/)$& #+,&.'*/'3*,2*,%%-$2, ,2/449-#*,8,'$+0 %/>$4,>,'/',&>(%'8$#$/+,&''*$%2-$/&+3,+'*

,>-4,$+-3$# /&/--$44/'$/('*#,'9(&+$#/%'/'('$& /&92/%$'*$-#,&2,-4$4/,++3&,& /'/;.8$9A%'/'$% 3,'*24/#,'9'*/'%4&./%'*$#$,%&$:-#$%%,&*,8,',&0'*$ ,>-4,$+  -3$#  2/&  $:'$&+  '  +,&.  /44  %(2*  /2'%  # $>-49,&.%(2*>$/&%/%/#$#$/%&/849&$2$%%/#9 #%(2* $:$2(',&*$#$4,/&2$&'*$-#,&2,-4$4/,++3&,&G(&*, 2/&&'.''*$$:'$&'0/%2&24(+$+89'*$,.*
(#'0

$&/84,&.'*$--$44/'$('*#,'9'1$##,+$'*$4,>,'/',& -#$%2#,8$+89'*$%'/'('$/&+././,&%''*$#$5(,#$>$&'

6 -#$?+$-%,'  *$  ,.* 
(#'  3/%  24$/#49  ,&  $###  ,& /&%3$#,&.5($%',&<2=

%%'/'$+,& /:>,$1, /&+/#$1,%&/&,0,& .$&(,&$2/%$% */#+%*,-0#$2(#%$3(4+%',448$-$&' '*$2&2$#&$+-$#%&3$1$#0,'3(4+8$2>-4$'$49/ +,

$#$&''*,&.'%/9'*/''*$--$44/'$('*#,'9,'%$4 2/& .#/&'%(2*#$4,$ %%'/'$+,&!*9/>G,%*#$H/&9%(2* $:$#2,%$3(4+>/)$'*$-#1,%,&,'%$4 (&3#)/84$/&+ #$&+$#'*$%'/'('#9,&'$&+>$&'&(./'#9

@&'*$-#$>,%$%03$/22$-''*$2&24(%,&%+#/3&89'*$ ,.*
(#'/%#$./#+%5($%',&%</=/&+<8=/#$2&2$#&$+ 8('%$'/%,+$'*$1,$3'/)$&89'*$,.*
(#'/%#$./#+% 5($%',&  <2=  *$  /--$/4%  -#$ $##$+  89  '*$  /%%$%%$%  /#$ '*$#$ #$+,%>,%%$+/&+'*%$-#$ $##$+89'*$!'/'$/./,&%'

'*$+$2,%,&,&#$%-$2' 5($%',&<2=/#$/443$+2%'%F $/#&$+2(&%$4 #'*$-$',',&$#/#.($+'*/''*$#,8(&/4 $##$+,&+,%>,%%,&.'*$/--$/4',%%(8>,''$+'*/''*$-$',',&$#,%,&

,&/&2,/42#(&2*0,'%/22(&'*/%8$$&+$24/#$+/%&?$# #>,&.%%$'89 '*$8/&)/&+'*$*9-'*$2/'$+-#-$#'93/%-(''/(2',&89'*$8/&)8(' 2(4+&'8$%4+*$-#/9$#,% #%$'',&./%,+$'*$#+$# '*$#,8(&/4 /&+ #+,#$2',&''*$--$44/'$('*#,'9'*$/#'*$/--$/43,'*('-#$? +$-%,' $$84$/''$>-'3/%>/+$'/#.($'*/''*$/%%$%%>$&'#+$# -/%%$+3/%3,'*('.#/&',&.#$/%&/84$--#'(&,'9 '3(4+8$-$#',&$&''&'$/''*,%%'/.$'*/'&$,'*$#'*$#$3/% /&9-#/9$#/./,&%''*$/%%$%%>$&'#+$#&#'*$%/>$*/% 8$$&/&&$:$+ 3,'*'*$3#,'-$',',&

*$#+$#-/%%$+89'*$#,8(&/4,%,&'*$4,.*' '*$+$2,%,& '*$!(-#$>$
(#',&

# "/51(2%-$# '*$%/,+  +$2,%,&0'*$ --$44/'$ ('*#,'9 */%  & -3$# ' 3/,1$ '*$ 2&+,',& -#$?+$-%,'

D '*$/++,',&/4+$>/&+ *$!(-#$>$
(#'3*,4$+$/4,&.3,'*'*$,%%($*/+2&%,+$#$+ ,'%+$2,%,&,&) !!
/" .% 106 2 

6 03*$#$,&,'3/%*$4+/%(&+$#

E*$#,.*' /--$/4,% '*$2#$/'(#$ /%'/'('$ ,'*('  /  %'/'('#9  -#1,%,&  2#$/',&.  %(2*  /  #,.*'  '*$ -$#%&/..#,$1$+,%&'$&','4$+' ,4$/&/--$/4$ /,4$+ '(&+$#%'/&+/%'3*9'*$ $.,%4/'(#$3*,4$.#/&',&.'*$ #,.*' /--$/42/&&',>-%$2&+,',&% #'*$$:$#2,%$

%(2*#,.*'F *$-$',',&$#*/+$:$#2,%$+'*$#,.*' /--$/43*,2*,%%(8;$2'

''*$2&+,',&*$>$#$ /2''*/','%/22(&'*/%8$$&+$24/#$+/%&? $# #>,&.%%$'3(4+&'$>-3$#'*$--$44/'$('*#,'9'3/,1$

-#$?+$-%,' *$-$',',&$#*/% /,4$+'>/)$('/&92/%$ #,&'$# $#$&2$ (&+$##',24$

@ '*$
&%','(',& &+,/ *$3#,'-$',',&,%+,%>,%%$+ 1)*++,,-.)2 1))7#+)'-2 8 .+8 .+ /&(/#9B 0

>) *$'*$#%-$/),&.C#$/%&$+

$%C *$'*$##$-#'/84$

$%C