Pawan Bhatia And ORS. v. T.C. Gupta, Ias And ORS.
! "#$% &'(
) "*
+ * %!
,$
+ * %!
-# ./- 0 0 -0
! " # $$$$$ 0 -0' %& ' ))
*))+#
,-,../,0 + .,,../,0%1 2.'
(3.,-4. ./,0 +# 5
+# 6( 5 # ! 67( # )8 +9 ! ! " #2 , 4 ! "#$ %
'
! ( )*+* % "#, )-+))" %
.+
. ( "
+#)- .. . ..
$+ $*)- % .
+/
( . 0
' 1 ! .
$+ $*)- 0
+ 2 .3.(+4 5
!
!) ) "
)( #,0:,;<= 5 ! +)# "
) # ) # " ! !),0:,;<= + ) # 6
+#
3 ! 6 ( %.! ( '( +'
.
...$5+$"+"#$% 0 .+/6
. 7
( . $+ $*)- % .
+
8 . .0 .( 1 ...
"#$ . ..%. .
:!& :&9/
. .; +) $#4
. . . . (.0 .6
...$5+$"+"#$+/ . 8 . ' & ( . ( + & $5+#"+"#$64
,/,,./,4 + +# 5
/=/,./,= ) ) 67( # ) !" #2 . + 5 .
4 + . !9! %
& ; +)) "#$6
$6+#"- (<7 +&.+ ( . +$)-#) .. # +#*+"#$6 '
( 8 ! 7. ; +*" "#$6
+=>: +. ( '
+&.+ .
.
( -+5
...#)+#*+"#$6 % . 7
"#, 0. ' ! (
+ '
. .0 :
...$5+$"+"#$ . ( ( % . ! ( '(%%
(.0 + $+ $*)-
! ( % .
+ ' % .
.
. . +/ % 0 .
. . + . %
. .
$+ $*)- %. ( .
..
+
)*+* . "#,
' ! ( )-+))" + . %. ( ++ $+ $*)- . ..
++ "+$-"- +
.. % .
(<7 +&.+9# +#*+"#$6 .3883
"+$-"- ++ +<% . +< % . . ?2 /. +&.+ "
+#)- @. 3.
$# +
. (.
.
. ?2 /. + &.+ (
3 . .
. .
3 ( #5+#6+"#$6+
; +*"
"#$6 . . . + =>: +. ( ' + &.+ . . . -+5 +' % . .
. ' ! ( (
..
+8 "):6*5"$ .. $5+#*+"#$ A ( .
B+ ( -, . 7 $# A.. "#,0.
! (B .+
.
. '
! ( % .
' ! ( % "#, 0. . +
-+5 .
. ' ! (
. $+ $*)- @
. (+4
6(
+#
#
1 + ) # +#
!
) ,0:,;<= +# ) "
)( :02 )6 # ! # ! 6
+ *+
,0:,;<= + !
+ +
+# 6
+ #* ) # 5 ( +
+#
! ) +) 6 !
1 0 -02 $% &'( '