Deen Bandhu Chotu Ram Thermal Power Plant Hpgcl Yamuna Nagar v. M/S Green Vision Testing And Enviro Services
!"#$%&% !!'()( )* (+*, -+,! .*)!
/+ %%%%%% !+ 0+ ) 123+!0 ! !/!'!4 + 3+4 %%%%%% 5 !'! 1" 6.1%3
3 3
!!!!!
3 3
%7+,8 "
# $
%
&
'
((%
) *
+
&
- .
#
#&,
/# - +
&0
1 1
&0
-23-3-- &
41 1
/# 5 363--3--" 1
&
#
78 1
,
9#
4
+ # 4
+ 4
1
4
+
'
1
& +
&
#
- & #&
+
#
1
&
&
,
&
$ &
& ,
&0 +
+
:;'. 1 &
&
&
+
:
# #&,
1
7-6
7<"
&
7<"
1 &
/#
&
#
+
$ &
:
#&,
&
+
&
#
&0
+
3=3=-3-=
/# 5
+
,
# 1
1 &
&
:1 , 1
&0
1
/# =&#
1
>
9#
+ #
&
+
+
&
&
&
5 :
#&,
,
, +
+
&
1#
+ #
<
+
$
6 1
&
+
$
65 &
+
&
1
+
$
6=
&
+
1
+
#,
+
&0
/ +
/
+ ,
5
,,#
#
+,,#
#+
1 +
/ +
,
1
+
+ &0
0
&0 :
#&,
1
# +
+
&
1# 1
,&
#&$
= $
6
,# 1 , &0
1 1
&0
+
#
&
1 1
1
&
#
+ 0
&
+ # # 0$ &
,0&
&0
'# #
&
=
#
#&,
/# -
,
/# 1 1
, &0
1
&0
1
1 +1
1# &
0 "
/# 51
&0
1
1
41
&
#
:
#&,
1
1
&
7
#
+
1
:;'. #
,
# 1
360
= 1 1 1
# &0
+ #
&
$
1
,#
+
1 # &
9#
0
& &
2 I have heard the learned counsels for the parties. % "
/# -1
-23-3--
# #
!
"
"
!
#
$ %#& '
(
)&*+,- '
(+
(-./01 #
12(1#3 ++
45.-67-060.
) 4 060.8$9#8.7/5:;8.,-
! "
#
$%&'& (!# #&)*+ )'%,-). /0 12 / 3 4
12
/
-5&5&6&&# 789 3 121 &&&
12
1 4
/
:
21
6 "
&
#
2 &
41 1
/# 5 1
&
+
1
78 -6'
7 1 &
# &0
#
"
78 -6
# # . ; < <7 !!"!
= 1* 7 > ?
8
@
1&A
12 '.< + <; <
53 5 5
1 / /
/ / 1 / /
5
/ 8 </ / /"
5* 7 > <1 </
/
/
A.
<
4
B 8
/#
7<"1
%
&
#
#
($
/#
- 51 &
# &
#
&0
#
:1
0&
&0
#
,,
&
7
+
&
# $
1# & ,
& "
'#
# &
&0
#
1
$
6 1
# # CA </ D(. 5 B /
/
1 @ 1 / 1
5 1
(.< /
(%.<
/ 1 (,.< 1 D ( . /
E (/. = 5 =5 F
6 G 1 @
E (. =
1 =
/
/ (.
1 2
B ( ?010
/# -
1
&0
& , #
#
/ +
&
9#
/# 51
1 1
&0
<
1
&
#
781 &
# & " ,
1 &
7 #
1
+
,0 & , #& ,
&# , & # # 0 #
+ &
+ & &
3 " 11
+
#
&
&0
'# # $
&
'
((%
+ " , &
#
0
&0 : *& $#
'#
<9+ %
+
#=
&4 >- ?
=
@ 060:
## * & #
8 .A/:
#+,
: *& $#
'#
<+ =
4
#
.BB;
= .7BB +
@ )060:, ;
## .
#
0
"
#+,
: *& $#
'#
9+ %
+
#=
&4C
)=
,
# # C& = 8 (-#<. = 8 A = @
3
@
3
/ 1 H = I 8 (-#<.
H I 8 -
3 (-#<.
=
5
/ 351
/
H I 8 - @ 1 = 2 /
/
/
@ 1#
J 5
1
1 =
(
5
5 0
/
=
% 8 ;/0
</ (< .<5&51 / @ $
( . * 8
= =
@ / @
= / 1$ C&6 /@ = 8
*
C = =
B @
5/
1 3 0
< 5 C B
=
/
8 '8 = 5 5
1
8 <
/ 5
1
3
</ < =
#/
FKG (!
.
,@ 1 / @
/ $
( .5
3
= 5 L 51
/ @
M ( .
@8 ">( . 0
1
1 C B 8 = 1 =# #
@ 1
/ 3 $
( . C B
1 23 = 1 <
/
0 5 5 /
/ @ 1 5 = @
/C B - 3 C B5/ =
3
1 5 1 = @ 0
/
5 1 / 1
5 @ # 1
3
1 = @
/
5
/ 2 /
5 @
5/
/
2B "
+
#+,
+ =
4
#
.BB;
= .7BB +
)=
,
# # C& @ 1 /@ 5 1
L5
/ 8 -
0 </
/
/ @
8 5
0
/
3 0
/ @
/ 1
/ @ / @
51 @
5
5
- 5 1
5
E L5 @
5 @
5
1 </
/
0 1 0 / = @
5
/
@ # ====== -
8 (-#<. = =
N = N 1
8 </ <
# 5 3 N = N
1 A </ < L ( .5
5
= #1 1 @ 1 @ / 1
5 = 8 (-#<.
/ = 8 A8
5 @
5@ 18 A5
/ 3
@
3
/ 1
@ # /
@ / @ = @
/
/
/
8 - O
1
1M
( . =8 ' </ < -- / @ =
2
0 51
# 5 = /
/
/
1
@ =
= @
= @
/ @ /
/
1
/
B - <
1
1
11
1
,
+
# $
'#
9#
/,
0
,
&
#
@
+,
+
<
+
& 0
,
,
& # &
&
1
'# 5 <
1
#,
'#
1
&
$
+
= '
9#
0
1 7
A#,
$
#+ >
B +
# : # "
+ C,# + &
78(536-555D, 7
#, (-(%2E+, ,
,
$ &
#
&
#& ,
0
#
+$
- 2
&
&
& ,,#
&0
&
2
%
&
&
1
F# $ # &
,
6 .
&
9#
,
+
& # $
-(
8 9#
+1
0 &
7
A#,
$
#+ >
#$%&% 73 3
1 G
+4
C
47 G
&
C
47