Shiv Kumar And Another v. Canara Bank And Others
!"#""$ %# & &' ""#"(" "$ %# #)* !" "!
!" # & &"+,-,*,."*/
&,)& &# (,."*/
&,&)*0(+ 11111 "!$ %&' ()* (( $, ))2 & )23 &&* , , &* "3&4 ** 5
6 * , 7'& "3&4 ** 5
6 & & , &* 2 8** 9 , (/&3:"8'&05*0; <& , & 4* , ))2. , 4 22=**"8'&05*0;&+&&*.'>?22?' 8) ( ( $, )& ,/ ,223* , &*& ** @
"8'& 0 )* >- , > #/&- $&>'20 . ,*3&,.
,& && &&*A4)'3*#$&*&B.=,&>-,,4
&*&**6
"8'&05)*>-,#/&-
&0
. #$0
. ,*3&, , 2* & (+ / 9 2 &+. ,3 , 2* , )& 4'&3 @5 +2 ; 4&2.,>&&* C&*'2 &,)&'>4,)& ,& )& $, ,& ,)&.42-.+&
3, + &*2- 2 &4 , D' 42- ?- '4&.
,/ '4& ,&4 * #?, "3,& * , , ,* 8'* 7&2 =& "&- ** 5
,& & & &&* A7"B,& /'& =/&.,7",2*&/2*4'2)2&*
2 &4,&)*0(+.>-4'3,7".*4*+&
3,,3'&&5 ,&* 2$,&2/*2 ,3'&*23&4.&&)&*'*,>2>2=
& C"9 2 "3&4 92 *&+ C"3&4 #;
2+,>* >-,,"3,&.2 ,-) * '4& 65
*, 24 , 4 = &* 5
# &&.,=3+&
3,3'&& ,(/&3 C 2- /2* >- , '4& , & # 2+, 5
6: 7'& "3&4 ** 5
6 ,=3 +& 3, 3'&& ,&'3, 7" ,2*& #?, "3,& 92%&)& 0
6 ,-)$&*& 7'&3&4**
6
>$&*& 7'&3&4**@
5 (,= 7'&3&4** 5 @
%&)&
'&,&'>4,,3'&3&4 D',2 , (/&3*,/> '&,*,-&
6.=,&.+&
3,,*2&*-8)&*5
&/&.,)&)&-=,, ,'>?04& ,3'&= !<)&)&-*,.'2* ,/ > 4&33* =,' , , & * , ,& 44>& , !< 2'*3 , )& ,& $,'. , 223* 3'& ,* > '&,* &'*'2 4&. & , *, +& 3,*.,& &.,'&,'2*8&=&?'&* **,&*& ,4 2* ,)& C&*'2 &,&)*0(+'>4,&'. ,, &3'& D', 2 ' 9 2 *&+ & 4' #;
C+,,*> '&,*>-=- ,7"8'*>- 2+& 3,.>',*> '&,* 6 5
.*'&3, 2 4 +& 3, =/&.2-.,*3'&.=,, = '&,* 5
. &,*, +& 3,>-,7" &-,2*&.42-.#?,"3,&=,), &*C4 2- # C+, '&,&'>4,,)& ,/2&/&4*- ))&,3,#"$,223,&*& )*>-,#$.* ))&,3,'&>-)& &&3=&
2 '>4 , , )& ,/ ,223* , 4)'3* #$
&*&> &,'& &*2- >'-&*,2 , ),> 2* ;
<'&,&4&.,)&= )&-,&/&-)&*3*=,,,&2 ' >$&*&. ,(/&3* ,-)$&*& 6 "
&,&32&*'2 &,)&*,/3)&'* ,4&2&&*.=& ,*&*/=,, *=&&- & & &4, '&. /2/ *)'* D' *=&?'&*'*&"&2 5 ,' '3,>8&*, &* *&'4 & , 4) '& *&4 , *)'* D' & 843,/*&&*
<'&,&4&.,)&,/,'&-&4*- 23 ))2> &,#"$,223,4)'3*&*&)*>-, #$ 5
&.,,*&&-&4*-'*&"&2 5 , ' * 4' > 8&* )&32-. )22- =,
'2&&4*-)&/**'*&,'# &> 4*,?'*34 , ')&4'&, "+,-./0&.
&.1 !,/ ,-2%3 42%3+3 &522. &,-26 -0'07 .%$ ) 050' 88 $, &2/ 8& , ?'*34 &)&*'* ,&'*&
!
!
" !
6
!
#
!
!
$ %
!#
!
# !
! !
&
!
" ! !! !
!
#
' ; #2 2 > )2* , ?'*34 , ')&4 '&, 93/%2:"&%&!22!,/42%3+3-2;<032&./ &;&,0.
0<2%(<+=(332330.> +,-%0,? %3$ ) " @. =,&,>,2*,2- ,&/&-)'&2-232. **/2/*)'*D' .,.,'2*>***>- , 3,'&* *43,=&,3&'* 2&/ &4*->3/2>2$,&2/8& ,?'*34&)&*'* ,&'*& ( %
!
!)! ! )! # !
!
!
' E %/,&=.,)&,/))&,*,'&
>2* 3. 4', , 4)'3* #$ &*& = )* @ . * , )& ,* )&* *- 2 ))2 > & #"$ >' * 8&3 ,& '&- &4*-. ,- ,/ ))&,*,'& & 4,* 2*,)&=&)
;
,,-=&'=& ,)&*3)&3 2 ' , )& = 2 )&- , &/&- )&*3 =, , 2 ' > $&*& &/&. ,& = / =,)& >' - A &'*B ,/3 > 44* , >? 2* , ,4 &*& * , 2- 3&'* + ,& = , , '&* = !< )&)&- <'&,&4&.,&32))2 2*>-,(+ &&/&- , '*3 4' ,/ 2&*- > *&* * , #/&- & =,,2' ,/2>'*. *2 =,,&',&'*& C"' #/&-& 2 *&+ ;
@ 2%&)& 5;
@ ,(/&3 5 ,-)$&*&
5 >$&*& 6 6 @
2*&/>*,,2=*, -&
6 &>'#&&*,'*3*'*-.)& ,2'2 ,(+ &&))&842- $,& &.,)&*)'*D' * ,)&,/,'&-&4*- 23))2> &#"$., 5
'&='2*& & &48&3=&?'&*D'2-., ) *4* $, )& ='2* > 2>&- /2 , 2&/&4*-.&*=,2=
2& * , = & 8)&3 - ) , 4& ,4&$,&*&,22,/>&3*?'*>-, 4)'&9$&>'2
"!
# ) ,,& )+39#* F9 ,,&#)&>2 F9 ;