← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/719/2021dismissed

Lovepreet Singh v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2021-01-27Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi22 pages

  

 ! !"#$#%&

'(!)*!! +#%,- ! # #%!* .!*$/$ +  ! *0%%1% -!* !$)%1!% $

-*/,-(#1!"% !*!%"#%,

 

 

    

   





    !



" !    

#$  %

&&&  

  !



 "

  ' 

 ((   " )  * * #*#  ! '

 % +   

,%,-

  .( +%- " "   $%   

/  0  #*/ +)  $-  (   " " 1!

  " ) "   '

 '

   " 1!  '   !

" !

 

#

3 '  (  (

 "

  

#  $%     

/ #*/ +)  $- (

  .( +%-  .( + -

#0

  .( +%- "  "

 "  51" %  +5%- 

3   

 "   "  '  '

 !

 " 

 #** 1  $ " ' #/ 1

3 '

 !

 "  '!

3 % .((  $6 % .((  $66



   

    !

"    '   7*8 1 

    /*8 1 ((( 

 " 9 "

1

:



 ) " "   *:

*;

#*#*  */ *;

#*#*    " ) "   $%  * * #*#

 "     " )  "   "

 

  %  " (  " 1!

  $%   " )   *< *;

#*#*   !

 "

3 (  ' 

 =  

7/ % .((  $6 =  

#0 % .((  $ =  

#/ 4# ;0 ;<  '!

3

/



 

  (   (  !

" 1!

  =  

;0 ;<  '!

3

 

 

:

%  "

!    " ) "  '     * * #*# ' 

9$  '   ( " 1!

    "

   '



        !

 "



3     !

  " 1!

    "

   '

 "      " 1! " "



6  !    '  1 ( "

 '

     (

  "

' .)  %   1 ( "

 .)  % %  1 "(  $  





 



 ! 

   "

 # $#

%  &

 ! 

(    ((  

)  ((   





 #*



++ 

 ,* ,-

%  &

 !





)  (( 

 '.

  

! 

/

0



 (( 



 (( 



)  ((  & 

'.

 ! 





 



 





 

  # $#

%  &



1!.

0



 (( 

! ! '

 

0

)(





)  (( 2

3     !

   " 1!

=  

;0 ;<  '!

   "

   '



<

  (   

 ' 

  

 

 (     $%   > ! #*# 1 ( "

 !

  $%

;

?  

  '   "   '   

  $ %   .)  %

7*8 1 2   

 

  2 !

' " "

,     :;

;8 1  '!

3     '   

 7*8

   1

 ('  '  "

?  

  '   !

  (

  51" %  +5%-   " ) 1 

 '   

 :;

;8

 7*8  '!

3     '  "

"  "

   '   "1 > ! #*#

*

?      '

   (    

  (     

!



 " (   (  1  

  :;

;8  7*8    1  ('  '  "

 "   1 7*8

 '

' 

   

/ 

 '      ' ('  '  "

   )



 !

     

!

  (    :;

;8  7*8 !

1!

'   '(  '



    

  (  (  "  ' 

#

  '   

  

 

! ($   " )    > ! #*# %

  .( +%-

    

/  0  #*/ +)  $-

:

3 !

!   

   %    (  :;

;8 1  

  '!

3  7*8    1  ('  '  "

6      

  

'   " 2   ' 7*8 1   /*8 1 (((    '     '  "

%

3  )  !



   "  '( !

)

'   

 "    

 

 "    :;

;

 1  '!

3   ('  '  "

7

  

!

  (  1     



 



( ,'

 %  6 % 

 

7*0;

#**7  

"# $ % "



&

$' () ' % "

*

#**/ +-

%3 /#7   *7 * #**/

?  

   " 

(          '           !

   ' 1  

?  

 (  

 

(  

 )  :;

;8      

   '    '   7*8  :;

;8

?  

  



( @ 5 ,'

 %  6 

 +%- 

44< #**  

)% + 

&

, -

)% *

) %  % "

* #**<+-

%% #::   : * #**0 "  ,'

 %  6     *  

/

5

(

"  '( 

   



 ' 1   ,'

 %  6 % 

 

4#* #*    $). - +-

"" % "



&

)/ 

 "'% 0 % "

* #*+7-

%3 7;   *# *< #*

,'

 %  6  ( '

(    "   1(  1  (         ('  (   

'

,'

 %  6   $' () '  -

)/!

%

)% +   -

)/!*  " (  '

 2   '   '

( 

   (!

   (  "

 " '   ' " , ('!

  '   ! "  2  1 (

  )  ' (  

3 

( 

(  $). - +-

""  -

)/!

 

 $ *

3 





 



( 



4  

  &

!  5(  '/

 

6 ,,*  4 $7.

4  

8 &

! 

0

9( 0

 !

 

6#77 # 4 7.

+  4 :

!

9(

 

6#77* - 4 ;! 4!( 5   <.

; !! &

!

 

6#77-

4 #==



'.

0

  

    



 





> 

  

    

 !

 



 &(     

  0!

0  0





(/

0!



    '

! 



  - +

!

    

   0 !

   ( 





  1!

(

< 6<5    <  4      4 

<  4   <  4 ?.

#77* ? # !  '

    (

  

 0 ? #  !@

# 5 (

(

  

 0 A1! (( 

!    

 0 0!

! 



 ' 



< (

(/

  (

((

 '

!

 (

(/

!



B

0

)(

2 ,

&  

    (/

'  



 '

0

)(

   !

 

(

((

==C (/

!





C

(/

 

 0



B

)(

D!

( !



? 

(

(( (/

 

(/

   (

(( (/ !

 

    ! 



)

 7 1!

0



   E?

(

!



 (/





  

(

((  ( +



.

!



)

0

(   1! ?     '

 



( (

!

?

(  

  

( 

    '







)

D ('



0 



 ( 

   ! ( .

:

(  D ? 

 4!

 '.

:

( &

!  B 1

 4 

5

 

6 ,,7 = 4 $ +

 (

! 

0!

 (

(

   

(

(



(

( 

'

 0

 !



  1!      0!

! ( 



   



  0!

!

 !'

  

(

 ( # 1!

 

(

0

)(

;

0 

   0!

!

  !  

   0!

!

(





   !





 ==C (/

!

 ! ( 

'

0!

/ +

.











    0!



 ==C (/

!



B

0

)(

 !

 ! 



  )(

.

0!

!

 (

'

   (   



 





   '

= D!



     .



(  .

.

!'

 

'





'

(

.

  

 

(

  

 .

& /

 1!

( 

 

? # 





  







0!

!

 

0! 0

 4    1! .



  (/

(

0

 (    

? #

? 





1! !

 .



.

! 

((







  

(



.

0!

 (/  0

C C.



 0 0!

0



  

0!

!



!

  '





 

)(

 

  !

  !( 



 0

'

 !'

!  (

C

(/  

C (/

(

0

)(

 2 4

3  "

"  ,'

 %  6 " ( % 

 

4#*/ #*  

) $ /

* &

"# 0 % "

* #*+7-

%3 40   *# *< #*

6       7;

<8 1 ( /*8  2   ' ('   ' > (

 ! %

 +>  5- )

,'

 %  6      

"

      

  ( ( 1   (  1    '(

   2     (   ) 

'

3 

(  

(  

 $  #  





(  



!   ,-C

 

  



 .

(  !

 ! 





7C

  0!

!

 !





 

(

 

 

 

( 

  

((  '







! 0  (



 !  E  

'

( (

 E







 ( !

) H







 E    ( !

)  (!

  







0!

!

(

 

 = 1!   ( 







0 0   





 (



 !    '

(

 '

 0 ( ? 0!

!

    '

  .

! .



 !

(

 H 

( ! 



(/  (  '

(

 !  ?

 (

.

! .

! 0



  







 +

!

 

   0 !

    ( 





 

1! 

? ! '



)    

&  

    (/

'  



 '

0

)(

   !

 

 ==C (/

!

  7C  '

(/

 

 0

 1!  ! (  

    

  

)(



 

 7C (/

 



   D!

( ! 

? 

(

(( (/

 

(/

   (

(( (/ !

 

    ! 



)

  !

( 



  1!

0



   

!



0 (

 (



   '

?

(

!



 (/





  

(

((  (

+



.

!



)

0

(   1! ?     '

 



( (

!

?

(  

  

( 

    '







)

$ D ('



0 



 ( 

   ! ( .

:

(  D ? 

 4!

 '.

:

( &

!  B 1

 4 

5

 

6 ,,7 = 4 $

+

 (

! 

0!

 (

(

   

(

(

# 

(

( 

'

 0

 !



  1!      0!

! ( 



   



  0!

!

 !'

  

(

 ( * +



8(

!

:



 '.

 

 

6#77 = 4 =$ 0!

 

0

4

((  )

( ! !@

&

!   0!

!

! ! ! 



)

( & !

!

(

/

 

 (

  )  

   .



   

!

 '





0

(   '

  ! 4

(( 

!

0

) 

  

.





      

  

  +

9 ?(!  +'  

+ 

6 ,- +33<= 4 !

  ! !

0

) 

  

.





   0



  !

(

   ( 1!

0

) ( '





!0  ) 2 - 3  

)(

  (

!  +

 



 !

( ! !

( 





0!

! (  ==C

  0!

/

(

!



0!



 7C

 

0

 .







!'

 

   +

 .

! 

(

!

 0!





:

(  ! (

(( (/ 

 !  (0!

!

0

!

   '

 0!

!

/

3/!(

?/!



(

  

  ?  ;

4

((   

 !





( 

? 0!

!

    '

 



)

! 0! ! 0'

 (/

  

'

( 

  0!

!

 2 0

   (  1    ( ('!

( 

 ' ,'

 %  6 A  +%- 

#*0   0  1

&

     "#



")

"# ,

*   4 *# #*<

,'

 %  6 (     ('!

  '

'

  )

      " !

)  1  (      1

 (((  

'

3 

(  

(  

 #7 







(/.

.

0!

   

   '.



( (   )

+

(  

(/

 ( !

(/

(

((   #  1!

 .

  * 2+ % +  "#

- - *  "

+   

% * 34536!

  3453!

 7:9.

! 

( (  



  



 '

)(

( 

% 

B 6

 ?'







7 $). - +-

"" ;

 + )/ 

 "'% 0 % * 34556!

 6<  3455!

 549.

@ I- +

 $). - +-

"" %  + )/ 

 "'% 0 %  34556!

 6<  3455!



(0! (   

 0! !     ) ( !

 1!  

 4 (( 

 !

 (



 (        <  4

)(

.

#77,   (



**

 

< 6<5



 ( .

 ?



!



  4!

/

 (

'

0

)(

4! 0 

 )(

4!.

.

/ (

0

)(

1!

   .

0!

0  

 0.

0

 !

0!

!

 ?

 J

( 0

! 4!   (/ !  4!  G ! !  ==* (/

*7  ,=C

(/

  (

==C

(/

!

  , &

 ? #

  4 

<  4   <  4 ?.

#77* 6 !

I !   ?I.

   0!

! 



C

(/

 



(

((

==C

(/

!



0

)(

!

    

 ?



!

!  ,=C (/

  ! 0



 0E   1!  ?



!   !

  1! !

 0 0

1!

  ( 

 0 

 

/ 7 & 



  ?.

)/ 

 "'% 0 -

3455!

 ! ? # ! (

 I



 '

0

)(

   !

 

(

((

==C (/

!





C (/

 

 0



(

)(

I 64

.

 7 1!

 0!

( ! 

 

(

(( (/

 

.

! 

)

 + 0



0 0



   E

(

!



 (/ + 0  ! @ 64

#.

 7 I 7 1! K L ?     '

 



( (

!



(  

  

( 

    '







)

I +

.



(

'



 



<(

> ; !

&! !

& $ /

+ , - "   * %-

%)- " %  %  344==!

 6<3   344= 5:6 (

> ; !

 H' !

() %/  *

   * $)2.

>- "/" " +

"# $)2.

% * 5<<95!

 ==<  5<<8!

$  5.

0    !'

/ ( 0 0.

0

 !



(

 

 4 (( 

6 .

'



  

 # 

   

 ( !  ! 

!

.

0!

!

(

4



  

   '

)(

( 

% 

B4 6

 D!

  

 

 '

)(

.

(    '

!

& 

( 

 /



!    1!

; !

!







 < 0 !



* C

C



(/ ?



  ( 

%  4!

 ( (  I ## 1!



 ( !



0

 (

 

(

((   (/



 0

 

2 <

3

( $' () '  -

)/!* "  '( 

   

  '  (  %$ 5  %  " ( %A 

/;0:

#*7  

+ % )

&

"# $)2.

% "

*  *# *;

#*7

6  "



     ('!

* #<8 1 "  '"

 7*8 1 2 

 

  %   ( 

(  7*8    1  ('

3 %$ 5  %    $' () '  -

)/! "   (  '

 2   '   '

(

 

  (! "  (  

'  

'! " ('!

   '    

( 1 2 

3 

(  

(  

 $ 1!

.

0!

 7#-C

0 (/   7C.

!  

 

(/ 0 



 0!



(.

 ! 

      ( ! 

  (

 ( 

B;;4  3 4

  '

; !



;

('

!

&

/!

:' :



#7 = 6# &+?

;

('.

$, !.

0!







   ( 

;!

&!

  .

0!

 0 7C    !

 

,-$C

 .



(



 



 0!



( 3 4

  

 ;

('

!

0 '

! (( ; !

(

4 (

4  

8 &

! :

0

9( 0

! 6#77  # 4 7.

0! 4 ( 0







 

 

(

     

(

0!



 (



 .

! 

0 E#

(

!

   



E#.

!



   .

+  

! (( ; !

(

4 (

0

9( 0 J 6  ( '



0 .

.



(

  



(



.

.



!

0!



 

 +

'

 

.



 '

!

(

 >

(/

 '



  

( +(



  '

(

 

 (/ 0 '

0

('

0.

+ ( 

 ('





; !

;

('

!

2 ;

B "      



< ' 

( "  '( 

  

  ' 

' 

( $' () '  -

)/!

 @ 5 > ( (  ,' > ( " 

(   @ 5 ,'

 %  6 ( " ,' > ( 

(  5 (  ,' > ( "

 

( ( 5 ( " ,' > (

#*

3    

 ' ,'

 %  6 A

 +%- ;0# ;<7   + % % .%) % $' 

&

"#  

*   *;

 ;<7

3 ( ,'

 %     (       )   " " (  @ 5 ( " ,' > ( @ 5 (  ,' > (

3  ' ,'

 %  6 " " @ 5 (  ,' > (   

( @ 5 ( " ,' > ( !

'    (  "

3 ,'

 %  6  

 %    " 

( 1  !

' 

  @ 5 (  ,' > ( 

      @ 5

( ( "

,' > (



(  

(  

 $  ))) ))) ))) ))) ))) 1!  

   ! 

0! !

;

; !

!  

 (

; !

 ('

 ! 

1!

!  /



('

 

; !

! 

 

; !



&%

?")

&

 "

"/ 

"

%* 5<663!

 %  /"

 3<=

+ ('

!0  0! > ; !

; !



D

0 

(/





+



 0   

 0

 (  









/



&  #

D  

'

!



 !

  

 

(

(

   

'2 #

. "  "    ' " ! )   ( '

( " ' '(   

 '  5  %  %A 

:;#:

;<4   ).



 %  ( 

()

&

"# $)2.

% "

*   *;

*:

;;*

" "   "  '  1    ( '

(  !  ) 9 (    

( "  (    '

( " ' '(

3 

(  

(  

 $  , 4!



 

99

J  6  0



  ( ; !



 >

.



"# $ +   % + %*  5<8:

)/

")

3768 +

 ##

0 

#*   @ ID! !



  0

0 )   ( !

 M





/ 0 )   ! 1!

  !

!

.





" "# % + ( ). + // " "# 5<87 % -% % " ) 0 =4* 5<8:!

0!

!

 0

 '.

'



)   !



 )  ( !

0!

!

 ! .



!.



0  0 I ? 

(

/    + 1 % "

 + @ /% 

 5<95 )/

")

5<7:.

"#  % "

 +   ) $/    "/0



% % "

* 5<97 )//!

 394 +  

 

 

   0!   ; ! ('

! ' ) 

  (

 ; !

4 (   1!  

0! !

  0

0   ; !

( ; !.

( 

 .



!

 



( +



.

( ; ! ' ) 

  <(

; ! 1!

'



0 ) 

> ; !

 ,) 

  "1 

% "

 +

"# $)2.

% "

*  5<8:

$)2.

% 0 =46 + 0 !

 

0!

!

4 ( 



 





'

 !



( 

! 

> ; !

"# $)2.

+ 2  * 5<8:

 

5:69 + 0

 @

# ID!

  (

4 ( '

   ; !

0 /

  

 

    !



.

0

!

 I & > ; !

% !

A)%% )  +

""-1 / ;

#   "

%* %% % "

 5<8< )2

'

 /"

 3<4   4 #==.

 



 @ I .

0 )     !

4 ( ! 

) 



( ; !





.

) 

( !

4 (   

 0 !

   0!

(   

 !



) 

( (

( !

   !0 .



  ;.

<.

" "# % + ( ). 6  !

 

 ; !

4 (  I H

 (  '.

0 

0   

.



!

( ; !.

! ' ) 



; !

99

J  6  0  ) 

   



##

6

  @ 5 ,'

 %  6 (  ,' > ( $' () '  -

)/!*

 !

' 1   )  @ 5 ( " > (

,'

 %  6 )/ 

 "'% 0  -

)/!

3 '(   @ 5

(  (  @ 5 ( " ,' > (  '(



##  ' (  '(

!   



#:

 ( "



  "

 $$ '

!

  (  

(  :;

;8  7*8     '!

3  

' 

!  !

 

  "

    

#7

 ( "

'

!

      2 !

 

#/

A

   "     

%/*0 2

+3++

/ !

 D! ! /

E

@ NE

D! !

 

@

NE