High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1252/2019dismissed

Gurdip Singh v. Gurmeet Singh And ORS

2022-11-29Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

## $

%!""

'( #!")*

)* " ##

,#)* - .*

////

0#1)"" #

% !""2 !" !

!")& ,2,3+ * 1) 0# (## &% ' 4! %!%##5 2( #- 6

!"("!# 4#7%# #% !4#8%## *##! 0 ")9"#0#)

!!" #%%"- :"#* !*1 7);8). %1(##

% %! <" " #" !"# %, #

"" #)

!"6 - "(!%##5 ("

"%#4#7%##" 5)). )*! % )8 ).%1:" = !#(= : - "!!" #%%- "= "#* # 2# % !" #)""21 (##! %" )"(*)- %(" :" #"!" 2 !)">!2 ?

" !!" #= !"* )"(*" % ("" #"# #2 % # !" # )"= = #(##7 ) 2!)" >!2 ( !)")""!"" =(4!1 ?

"*" #("# " " ! " 2!) " >!2 ?

)"(1!(""%"2# 1%%1 % 1 = = " # ) "(*) - " :" #!" %421 (1 * % @= * !) " >!2

" * " # ! - % &%' "2##!!"

!"6- "#"# " !" # "#) 1)##!#) ##**A !"" #2 - 7( ##1(!%##2(

!" 6 # 3#! !!* 21 "

- )" #" ""+ 21(1 #! ! %

) ## " " # (%!"

<"(%#21- )"" "*!1!%##" #("" #*!1% %1 ! "

)"!%## 21" #! 2 %2! ##1 !" %!)" 1%#"

<"(% 2%2"# - )""#- 6

!"( %!! (".> .">!2 1:"(*" %!!"2!%21 1! ##%!!% ( " 1 % %2 " !" %#"

<"(% (2"# - 7)"""" #!" " 4(#!

!""= !%##*

? # 8"#% !4#7%#" #4" :"!%(221B4"(!"

%%)C"= #(= 7 ?

2 " #!"!%% #% #2!%5 * ("C##!!( ! "

)"2 "(" 8 4# # 4# 8 %# " 21 " % - *(#

54# %#

4#%# 1!"%!

) "#*%#"

9" # " # # *! " ##!"(%("!"*% " #

;

" #! " ) ##(! ( %

< C""&## % "!%##1"#*#D &&

<<C"" &# " #(1 % 1 (##! %" "!%##D &&

<<<C"""##!# = 21 * 5 7"21 # # D &&

<$C"" !% # 5 #

2D &

$C""&#" #" D

$<C"" #1*# D &

$<<C""+ ", 1" D &

$<<<C"" %2#" %D &

<EC"" 72 "*# ("

(" D &

E# ;

9" #* " *#%

< *")&#"%# (2=&C "=%B4"(!" %%) *&C),!"&C7)

#F!"&C?)"

# "% &C5

#" '

% &C;

9") &# #*! %

<2 #)

!""%# (2=C "=%&%' C7 ") # # # * ! %

"!"# #" )"# + -

<) <<) <$ $* " # !": -

<<< <E( * #!") - $<$<<*

#!") - $<<<* #

5 !" #! )" " #((" % !%##5 @= & #% ! 4#7%# #% !4#8%# *##! 0 ")9"#0#)

(2 * " #!" 9" # ( 2##% (" %"%" 1, !% "- (!"#= !* " #%!%## ("(%")#!("")" #( #2#21! "#= !"* " !"!1" + ", !%( 5

3#! !!* 21 " , !% ) " - " # # " + G !)

) ("" ( ! # # G !)

)("*, !%5 8%" #%!", !% 21"#+

0!("", !% 21 "+ 2#()"-

!"" " !

# #2"+ 9" #. -

%!""#* # !

"%"

<"*"# #" 2!!

" !""

; 7

0""+ 2#(21 #1#1!"* *( " # #!# ! " %""**"# " -

!"!%##5 (" #

%!"#4#7%## 2#!!"% *##! 0 ")9"#0#)

H 5)). )*! )8 )." #"21(##! %" 2 " #% - "24 " % 9" !""- ""= "

!% 2 # 21 #! !" ! *!

*# !"(%&C2=%&C B4"(!" %%)*)2"!%@= &) &C?

#F!"!(!%&C;

#" '

%)% $)(""5 )"" % .

!"" !% !"%"!"*!%%" 24% ##1 *"= !% ##@= & #" !"

!" !C" "= "!%2 !"=%) ""! @= &&0+ 9")" #+ ( ##1, !!" #" ##1 *"= "!%##@= & 1%%1 )8 ). ?

< %1 2 % " " " # " #

8 *!"""21(##! %" "" !" 9" !" "#!# ) "= !%##)""4

#" #"21(##! %" -*"#)" #" ##12#" - 7"" !"#2##"!%## @= &!2 %2 "1#2! * * "(" "( (

9")"##!%1

! #

= 21- * - 7)"( = ! " 1 " *# ) ("" ( # (##1"21 # )% "9& 1 - 7% 22 ")")"2!# - !"%" 4"* 4(#!- "*!= !%##@= & ("" # 9"+ 2#("*!"#1," # - 72!2 " 5

9" (!"#1#121"#+

9"3 ##+ #G !)

( , %!", !% 21"#+

9" !

# ##21"- ##1 #4%

;

- 2#A #(" #

<1##!#1%1", !% 21"+ 2#( ""%2 # * #(

3!%" #)"%%

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#