High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/3281/2014disposed of

Nirmal Singh @ Dharam Singh & ANR. v. Sukhwant Singh Gill

2015-11-02Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri2 pages

"#$%"% &' $()* $&+, - ,))( $&+, )&% )&.," ".$.$&"/ 0/ 12,3)&. $&+, $** "/4&%"&.

"/"&.'

)$&$5 %0#)." 6 .," 4".$.$&"/ &)&. 7).)$)5 5 1&8)9 ::

," 4".$.$&"/ 4); 6 )444$)." )#.$& . 9" .)2"& )+)$&/. .," "/4&%"&./ 1&%" .," 40$/$&/ 6 .," &."(4. 6 1.</ #. $& 0$"3 6 .," 0$*).$&/ 6 .," %$"#.$&/ +$0"& 9; .,"

&<9*" 14"(" 1. %"4"#).$&+ )1.().$# )"/. 6 ) 4"/& $&0*0"% $& ) #)/" 1&%" "#.$& = 3$.,1. #(4*$)&#" 6 40$/$&/ 6 "#.$&

," 4".$.$&"/ )&% .," #(4*)$&)&. $& ) #)/" "+$/.""% 0$%" %)."% )" 9., & "/$%"&. &%$)&/ ," #(4*)$&)&. ,)% 4"6""% ) #(4*)$&. . .," &/4"#. "&")* 6 *$#"5 )&% >("& >$&+5 ,)/" ?5 ,)*$ ()2$&+ /"$1/ )**"+).$&/ 6 .," 4".$.$&"/ ).."(4.$&+ . 1.)+" ," (%"/.; $& ) %1&2"& #&%$.$& )&% )..)#2 ," /& $& .," 4#"// ., .," 4).$"/ )" "/$%$&+ ). )&)%) )&% .,"" )44")/ . 9" /(" /"$1/ %$/41." "+)%$&+ ) ,1/" )&% .," 44".$"/ ,"

#(4*)$&. 3)/ +$0"& & )&% 3)/ "+$/.""% & )&% .,"

4".$.$&" )"/."% &

," "/4&%"&./ ,)0" 6$*"% .,"$ "4*; 81/.$6;$&+ .," )"/. 3,$#, )##%$&+ . .,"( $/ $& )##%)&#" 3$., *)3 . ,)/ )*/ 9""& /.)."% 61.," .,). .," /$.1).$& 3))&."% .," )"/. 6 .," 4".$.$&"/ )/ .,"" 3)/ )44","&/$& 6 0$*"&#" . .," #(4*)$&)&. )&% ," /& )&% .,""6"5 &.$#$&+ .," .," )**"+).$&/ 3,$#, 3"" %$/.$&#. 6( .," )#@1$/$.$&/ 1&%" "#.$& = 5 .," )"/. 6 .," 4".$.$&"/ 3"" &"#"//$.)."% & %1" #&/$%").$& & .," ().."5 )( 6 .," 0$"3 .,). & #)1/" 6 4#""%$&+ MAMTA 2015.11.06 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

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

&<9*" 14"(" 1. ," ()$)+" $/ A ;")/ *%5 .,""6"5 .," 6)#./ % &. /1++"/. )& $(("%$)." %$/41." )&% #1"*.; 3$.,$& /,. %1).$& 6 ()$)+"5 3,$#, %$&)$*; $/ .," #)/" 91. 6)#./ )" /1++"/.$0" 6 0$*"&#"5 3))&.$&+ )444$)." )#.$& & )&; #)/" /$&#" .,"" #)&<. 9" )&; $&6""&#" 6 0$*).$& )&% %$/9"%$"&#"5 $. $/ &. ) 6$. #)/" . 4#""% 1&%" .," &."(4. 6 1.</ #. $/4/"% 6

3"0"5 $& #)/" .," 4".$.$&"/ 6""* .,). $. $/ ) #)/" 6 3&+61* )"/.5 .,"; 31*% 9" ). *$9".; . .)2" "#1/" 6 .,"$ .," "("%$"/ )0)$*)9*" . .,"( $& )##%)&#" 3$., *)3

"#$ "%

&' MAMTA 2015.11.06 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document