Pardeep Kumar Singal v. Prem Bansal
!"#$!%&'&"()*+,
($-
.$!!/0*1.2&(3+ 44444//+&%( 5//!++( 6!.'*' .!1('+ 44444!'/"($!( ' ) ) ) ) 7824208 7824208 7824208 7824208 .!'!( ) .4,*'9*/ -$:"% ! #". 9!//+&%( 4 08-4 08-4 08-4 08-4 4 9! //+&%( 9' #&+!$ 9! /.!'!( //+&% &"( '!!;&(3 3.( "#+!:! "//!+3&(' 9!<*$31!( "#%=*& +/''!$&( %"1/+&( %'! &(' & * !$ *($!. 2!% &"( > "# 9! !3" &?+! (' .*1!( '% ->> 9!.!&(# !..!#!..!$ "'-@% A-B9!.!?, 9! %"1/+&( #&+!$ ?, 9! //+&%( B' $&'1&''!$ ($ 9! %%*'!$ B' %=*& !$4
4 9! +&1& !$ =*!' &"( .&'&(3 #". %"('&$!. &"( &( 9! /.!'!( /."%!!$&(3'&'B9! 9!.(//!+3&(' (".$!."#%=*& + /''!$ &( %"1/+&( %'! *($!. 2!% &"( > "# 9! % %( ?! !( !. &(!$ *($!. 9! /.":&'" " 2!% &"(
"# 9! .444 9! &(' (%!"# 9!%"1/+&(( C 4 9! &''*! &' (" +"(3!. .!' &( !3.4 ( @5' !+!' &*1 @5' !+!' &*1 @5' !+!' &*1 @5' !+!' &*1 &((%&+ 6'4 4 (('!;.( %4
2 > D)
&((%&+ 6'4 4 (('!;.( %4
2 > D)
&((%&+ 6'4 4 (('!;.( %4
2 > D)
&((%&+ 6'4 4 (('!;.( %4
2 > D)
.&1&(+
>A
.&1&(+
>A
.&1&(+
>A
.&1&(+
>A- 9!"(7?+!2*/.!1!"*. * 9".& &:!+,9!+$ 9
%"1/+&(( &(/."'!%* &"(*($!.2!% &"(>"# 9!% -=*+&#&!' '@:&% &1A*($!.2!% &"(
B"# 9!.444-?!&(3 9!/!.'"(B9" '*##!.'#&((%&++"''$*! " 9!$&'9"("*."#%9!=*!4"('!=*!( +,- '*%9 %"1/+&(( &' !( & +!$ " /*.'*! ( //!+ 3&(' %=*& + *($!. 9!/.":&'" "2!% &"(
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
"# 9!.444 "*. 9+,- 9! .+&1!( 9' (" 1!($!$ 2!% &"( > " %&.%*1'%.&?! 9!:&% &17'.&39 "/.!#!.(//!+<*' '& 9' B& 9 .!3.$ " %"1/+&(( ". 9! 2 ! #&+&(3 (
//!+4( 9!" 9!.9($- 9!.+&1!( 9'&('!. !$ 9! /.":&'" "2!% &"(
'"' "!(:&'3!'*/!.&"..&39 #". 9!:&% &1"#("##!(%! "/.!#!.(//!+"( 9!3."*($' 1!( &"(!$ 9!.!&('%"1/.!$ "%"1/+&(( 4 &# 9+,- 9! &(:"+:!1!( "# 9! 2 ! &( .!'/!% "# ( "##!(%!*($!.2!% &"(>"# 9!% &'%"('/&%*"*'?,& ' ?'!(%!4 9&' &' ?!%*'! 9! %"1/+&( #&+!$ *($!. 9 /.":&'&"( &' &( 9! ( *.! "# /.&: ! %"1/+&( ' /!. 2!% &"(
"# 9!.444($2!% &"(D"# 9!% ?,( !E/.!''&( !( &"(&(%"./". !' 9!/.":&'&"('"# 9!.444 &( 9!1 !."# .&+"#'*%9$!!1!$"##!(%! .&!$' %.&1&(+ "##!(%!4 9!.!#".!- 9! %"1/+&(( - B9" &' 9! :&% &1"#$&'9"("*."#%9!=*!1*' ?!%"(' .*!$ "?! :&% &1&( !.1'"# 9!/.":&'" "2!% &"(
.!$B& 9 9! $!#&(& &"("#:&% &1*($!.2!% &"(
B"# 9!.444 EEEEEEEEE 4 ' +.!$, (" !$- 9! /.":&'" " 2!% &"(
"# 9! .444 B' &('!. !$ &( 9! ' * ! ?""; "(+, B& 9 !##!% #."14
49!"?<!% ($.!'"(#".'*%9&('!. &"( 1*' ?!.!+&'!$($1*' ?!3&:!(& '#*++!##!% "?, %"*. 4(:&!B"# 9!#".!'&$$&'%*''&"(-B!9"+$ 9 9! :&% &1"#("##!(%!9' 9!.&39 "/.!#!.(//!+*($!. 9! /.":&'" " 2!% &"(
"# 9! .444- &..!'/!% &:! "# B9! 9!.9!&'%"1/+&(( ".(" 4:!(&# 9!:&% &1"#( "##!(%! &' %"1/+&(( - 9! %( ' &++ /."%!!$ *($!. 9! /.":&'" "2!% &"(
($(!!$(" $:!. "'*?'!% &"(
D"#2!% &"( >"# 9!.444G 4 9*'-B9 #+"B'#."1 9!?":!"?'!.: &"('&' 9 9! "(7?+!2*/.!1!"*. -# !.(!E9*' &:!!E1&( &"("# 9!' * "., #.1!B".; ($ /.!:&"*' <*$&%&+ /."("*(%!1!( ' &(%+*$&(3 @++&;.<*(0"$3+&6'42 !"#0.( ;" 9!.'A
2 @++&;.<*(0"$3+&6'42 !"#0.( ;" 9!.'A
2 @++&;.<*(0"$3+&6'42 !"#0.( ;" 9!.'A
2 @++&;.<*(0"$3+&6'42 !"#0.( ;" 9!.'A
2
-%+.&#&!$ 9 9!.&39 "#//!+%"(#!..!$*/"( 9!@:&% &1A*($!. 9!/.":&'" "2!% &"(
"# 9!.444&'&($!/!($!( ($'*?' ( &:! &( ( *.!- (" %"( ."++!$ ?, 9! /."%!$*.+ .!3&' . &"( *($!. 2!% &"( > D"# 9!.444 H4 $"/ &(3 /.31 &% ($ <*' &%!".&!( !$ //."%9 ($
D 3*&$!$?, 9!/.&(%&/+! 9 /."%!$*.+.*+!1*' '!.:!($(" "?' .*% 9!%"*.'!"#<*' &%!- 9&'"*. $!!1'& //."/.& ! "$&.!% 9 9! /.!'!( //!+ ?! .! !$ ' "(! * 9".& &:!+, &(' & * !$ *($!. 9! /.":&'" "2!% &"(
"# 9!.444
4 ( :&!B "# 9! * 9".& &:! /."("*(%!1!( &( 5'!+!' &*1&((%&+7'%'! '*/. 5'!+!' &*1&((%&+7'%'! '*/. 5'!+!' &*1&((%&+7'%'! '*/. 5'!+!' &*1&((%&+7'%'! '*/.($ 9!:&!B ;!(?, 9&'"*. +'"&(2 /+2&(39:42 !"#*(<?(.4
H
H
H
H $&'/"'!$"##"( 4
- 9!/.!'!( //+&% &"(&'$&'/"'!$"#B& 9 $&.!% &"( 9 9! +!.(!$ 2!''&"(' *$3! %"(%!.(!$ '9++ .! 9! /.!'!( //!+'(//!+#&+!$*($!. 9!/.":&'" "2!% &"(
"# 9! .444 ($ ''&3( 9! '1! " ( //."/.& ! "*. #". $&'/"'+ "( 1!.& '-&(%%".$(%!B& 9+B4 >4 9!%"(%!.(!$//!++ !"*. '9++/."%!!$ "$!%&$! 9! //!+!E/!$& &"*'+,-B& 9"* ?!&(3&1/!$!$?,(,$!+,&(#&+&(3 9! //!+-&(:&!B"# 9!+!3+/"'& &"(("B%+.&#&!$?, 9!"(7?+!/!E "*. 4
4 9!!3&' .,&'$&.!% !$ " .('1& 9&'".$!.+"(3B& 9 %"/,"# 9! %"1/+! ! //!.?""; ($ .! *.( 9! .&+ "*. .!%".$- &# .!%!&:!$- " 9!+!.(!$2!''&"('*$3!4 *+,
*+,
*+,
*+,
($ ($ ($ ($-
-
-
-
08 08 08 08 *(!! I9! 9!.'/!;&(35.!'"(!$ )
!'5" I9! 9!..!/". ?+! )
!'5"