High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/881/2003disposed of

Shingara Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana

2017-09-05Mr. Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul,Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa9 pages

Sumit Gulati 2017.10.26 12:12 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

!"# $%&#'()*+"+&$,-'+""+-+""+.' ,(/,00+11,$'(23*,%+-&1+. '*+0"+(+$',00+,1,4,&$(''*+5!.4+6+$' -# $%&#'& $.,'+.7 9,$.

".+" -(+$'+$#+.,'+.

9%&.+:*&#*'*+;:+"+# $%&#'+.,$.

(+$'+$#+.<;1+,"$+.+((& $(!.4+=,"$,1!$.+"+#'& $9"+,.:&'* +#'& $9> - "1&-+&60"&( $6+$'- "# 66&''&$4'*+6!".+" -6' ,5 =,!")*+"+&$,-'+""+-+""+.' ,(/.+#+,(+.23

(0+"'*+"+0 "' -5,&<&$4* 1&#+','& $,.," =,"$,1,00+11,$' *&$4,",&$4**,(.&+..!"&$4'*+0+$.+$#; -'*+ ,00+,1,$.'*+"+- "+'*+,00+,1?!,*&6: !1.,<,'+

*+<"&+--,#'( -'*+#,(+,"+'*,' 7.,'+.@

!$.+"+#'& $(9 A9> :,("+4&('+"+.,' 1&#+','& $,.,"=,"$,1 $ '*+<,(&('*+(','+6+$')B A936,.+<;6'

,5=,!").+#+,(+.3:&'* <!"$&$5!"&+( $.,'+.@

,' , "+# ".+.<;C91+,"$+.

!'; ,4&('",'+A =,"$,1 ,' +$+",1 (0&',1 =,"$,1 ,$. '*+ '",$(1,'+.%+"(& $ -(,6+"+,.(,(!$.+" /

" # $%$%&$$'$($$) )

* * + + ,+ -

. / !

/ $0$%&$$'$1$$2!

* * * * 3 . ++ + -

. 4) .

4 +)

! * *

* * + + 4) )

! )

/2! )

! ! 5 ! ) 4) 6 +

9 5)

)

- 7

* * * * ++ 6

) / * * * * )

. )

)

2 !

* 2 >

*+ "+# ". "+%+,1( '*,' ,5 =,!" .&+. $ 8

,$.

# $(+?!+$'1; --+$#+!$.+"+#'& $ 9 :,( ,..+. <;'*+0 1&#+

*+"+,-'+" &$%+('&4,'& $ :,( #,""&+. !' %+0"++' =,!" D %+1;

).,!4*'+" -,00+11,$'( 9,$.>3:,(.+#1,"+.&$$ #+$'<;'*+0 1&#+,$. # $(+?!+$'1;"+0 "'!$.+"+#'& $ 9 "

:,((!<6&''+.,4,&$(''*+ 0"+(+$'- !"# $%&#',00+11,$'( *+"+,-'+"'*+#,(+:,(# 66&''+.- "'"&,1 &$'*+ !"' -1+,"$+.+((& $(!.4+=,"$,1,$.!1'&6,'+1;#*,"4+(!$.+" +#'& $9"+,.:&'*+#'& $9> :,(-",6+.,4,&$(''*+,##!(+. ,00+11,$'(- "#,!(&$4'*+.+,'* -6'

,5=,!"<!',11'*+,00+11,$'( 01+,.+.$ '4!&1';,$.#1,&6+.'"&,1

*+0" (+#!'& $+B,6&$+.,(6,$;,(>:&'$+((+(,$.01,#+. $"+# ".. #!6+$',";+%&.+$#+' 0" %+&'(#,(+

C*&1+6,E&$4'*+&"(','+6+$'!$.+"+#'& $99 "

'*+

> ,##!(+.,00+11,$'(,.6&''+.'*+&"0"+(+$#+,''*+(#+$+ - ##!""+$#+<!' #1,&6+.&$$ #+$#+ *+,##!(+.,00+11,$'(,1( 1+.+%&.+$#+<;:,; -7 :&'$+((+(&$'*+&".+-+$#+

+,"$+.'"&,1 !"',-'+"# $(&.+",'& $ -'*+6,'+"&,1,%,&1,<1+ $"+# ".# $%&#'+.'*+0"+(+$',00+11,$'(!$.+"+#'& $9"+,.:&'* +#'& $9> ,$.(+$'+$#+.'*+6' !$.+"4 1&-+&60"&( $6+$'

+$#+'*+0"+(+$',00+,1

+,"$+.# !$(+1- "'*+,00+11,$'(*,(# $'+$.+.'*,'1+,"$+. '"&,1 !"'*,(# $%&#'+.'*+,00+11,$'(0"&6,"&1; $'*+<,(&( -(','+6+$' .,'+.@

6,.+<;'*+.+#+,(+.<+- "+1+,"$+.!';,4&('",'+A =,"$,1:*&#*:,(# $%+"'+.&$' .;&$4.+#1,",'& $ !''*,'&($ '1+4,11;

(!(',&$,<1+&$%&+: -'*+-,#''*,',(0+"'*+6+.&#,1"+0 "')B 3'*+ .+#+,(+.:,(*,%&$48F<!"$&$5!"&+(,$.(*+*,.<++$,.6&$&('+"+. +B#+((&%+(+.,'&%+(,$.'*!((*+:,($ '-&'' 6,E+(!#*,(','+6+$',( #1,&6+.<;'*+0" (+#!'& $ '&(-!"'*+","4!+.'*,',(,6,''+" --,#''*+ .+#+,(+.# 66&''+.(!&#&.+.!+' *+"-"!('",'& $,(&(#1+,"-" 6'*+( #,11+. .;&$4 .+#1,",'& $ &'(+1- <+#,!(+ (*+ :,( $ ' *,%&$4 # ".&,1 "+1,'& $(*&0:&'**+"*!(<,$.:* :,(1&%&$4&$ "'!4,1,$.*+:,($ ' (+$.&$4,$;6 $+;' *+"

*+"+- "+(*+:,(-+.!0-" 6*+"1&-+ '*,( -!"'*+" <++$ ,"4!+. '*,' '*+"+ ,"+ 6,'+"&,1 # $'",.&#'& $( ,6 $4(' '*+ 0" (+#!'& $:&'$+((+(,$.'*+"+&($ (!--&#&+$'+%&.+$#+' 0" %+'*+#*,"4+ !$.+"+#'& $9"+,.:&'*+#'& $9> 1+%+11+.,4,&$(''*+,00+11,$'( <;'*+0" (+#!'& $<+; $."+,( $,<1+. !<'

+,"$+.','+# !$(+1*,(,"4!+.'*,''*+(','+6+$' -.+#+,(+. :,( "+# ".+. <; C9 1+,"$+. !'; ,4&('",'+ =,"$,1 ,-'+" *&( -!11

(,'&(-,#'& $ ,$. '*+ .;&$4 .+#1,",'& $ &( -!"'*+" # "" < ",'+. <; '*+ (','+6+$' --,'*+" -'*+.+#+,(+.)C83 +*,(,1( ,"4!+.'*,''*+ 0" (+#!'& $ *,( -!11; 0" %+. '*+ #*,"4+ ,4,&$(' '*+ 0"+(+$' # $%&#'( ,00+11,$'(,$.'*+,00+,1.+(+"%+(' <+.&(6&((+.

+,".1+,"$+.# !$(+1- "< '*'*+0,"'&+(,$.0+"!(+.'*+ "+# ".#,"+-!11;

*+0"+(+$'#,(+&(6,&$1;<,(+. $'*+(','+6+$' - ,5=,!"

)(&$#+ .+#+,(+.3 .,'+. @

:*&#* :,( 1,'+" $ '"+,'+. ,( .;&$4 .+#1,",'& $<;1+,"$+.'"&,1 !"'&$%&+: -'*+-,#''*,'(*+:,(,.6&''+. &$'*+* (0&',1:&'*8F<!"$&$5!"&+( $@

,'> >, ,$.(*+.&+.

,' 9, ,(,"+(!1' -&$5!"&+((!--+"+.<;*+"

+- "+ 0" #++.&$4:&'*'*+6,''+"-!"'*+"&'&($+#+((,";' *,%+,1 E!0 $'*+ 6+.&#,1"+0 "'&$'*+0"+(+$'#,(+ 9

(0+"6+.&# 1+4,1"+0 "'.,'+.@

)B 3&((!+.<;

,1:,$&$4*+.&#,1 --&#+" +$+",1 (0&',1=,"$,1 ,5=,!"

)(&$#+.+#+,(+.3:,(<" !4*'' '*+* (0&',1,'> >, ,$.(*+:,( +B,6&$+.&66+.&,'+1;,$.'*+- 11 :&$4&$5!"&+(:+"+"+0 "'+. /)

) 6)

) !

) )

9) !

) .

) 9)):$;8 >

&E,(=!6,"0$, (0&',1=!"!E(*+'",6,.+, (','+6+$''*,'.+#+,(+. ,5=,!":,(<" !4*'' 0$, (0&',1 $@

,' 0 -" 6 +$+",1 (0&',1=,"$,1:&'*8F<!"$&$5!"&+(,$.(*+

7 +B0&"+. $8

,' 9,

C>"

*,&1+$.+"=!6,"+.&#,1 --&#+" (0&',1 =!"!E(*+'",,1 $4:&'*"

" %+",$."

,.*!*,"6,# $.!#'+.

0 ('6 "'+6+B,6&$,'& $ $'*+.+,.< .; - ,5=,!" $8

,' 9 ,$. 0&$+.'*,'.+,'*:,(.!+' (* #E,(,"+(!1' -<!"$&$5!"&+( :*&#*:+"+,$'+6 "'+6&$$,'!"+,$.:+"+(!--&#&+$'' #,!(+.+,'*&$ ".&$,";# !"(+ -+%+$'(

C9 "

<.!1 ,5&. +*,6 *,. "+# ".+. '*+ (','+6+$' - ,5=,!")(&$#+.+#+,(+.3 $@

,$.*+*,((0+#&-&#,11;

(','+..!"&$4*&(#" ((+B,6&$,'& $'*,'/

) ) " <.

! 2

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

6,'#*('&#E:*&#*:,(*,$.+. %+"<; %+0"++'' *+"

C9 "

&$4*,1 +.&#,1 --&#+" +$+",1 (0&',1 =,"$,1,1( 6,.+,(','+6+$''*,' $,$,001&#,'& $6 %+.<; 1&#+ $ @

*+.+#1,"+. ,5=,!"-&'' 6,E+(','+6+$'%&.++$. "(+6+$' B A *+"+,-'+" $'*+(,6+.,; $,(E&$4 -'*+!';,4&('",'+*+ ,4,&$ .+#1,"+. ,5 =,!" -&' ' 6,E+ (','+6+$' %&.+ *&( +$. "(+6+$' B A C9-!"'*+"(','+.'*,'*+,4,&$4,%+*&( <(+"%,'& $(%&.+ +$. "(+6+$'B A>,$.A'*,' ,5=!6,""+6,&$+.-&''*" !4* !'

:*&1+6,E&$4(','+6+$'

*+(','+6+$' -C9"

<.!1,5&.!';,4&('",'+:,( -!"'*+"# "" < ",'+.<;'*+(','+6+$' -C>&5+$.+",1' '*++--+#' '*,'':&#+'*+ 0&$& $ -C9"

&$4*,1:,( <',&$+.,$.C9 .+#1,"+. ,5=,!"-&'' 6,E+(','+6+$'

C>(','+.'*,'*+%&(&'+.'*+01,#+ - ##!""+$#+,$.-" 6 '*+" 6 -,00+11,$' *&$4,",&$4**+# 11+#'+.<!"$'(E&$('!#E' '*+#1 '*+('*"++*,1-<!"$'6,'#*('&#E(1;&$4 $'*+-1 " $+01,('&##,$ (6+11&$4 E+" (+$+ &1 ' E :*&#* :+"+ ',E+$ 0 ((+((& $ %&.+ "+# %+"; 6+6 B

$%&+: -'*+ 0&$& $ -'*+ #' ":*&#*:,(',E+$':&#+<; '*+!';,4&('",'+,$.,-'+"*&( :$(,'&(-,#'& $'*,' ,5=,!").+#+,(+.3 :,(-&'' 6,E+(','+6+$''*+!';,4&('",'+"+# ".+.*+"(','+6+$'!$.+" +#'& $7> "

'*&( !"'&(&$-!11,4"++6+$':&'*'*+1+,"$+.'"&,1

!"''*,''*+.+#+,(+.:,(-&'' 6,E+(','+6+$',$.'*+.;&$4.+#1,",'& $ *,("&4*'1;<++$"+# ".+.

*+0" (+#!'& $*,(,1( <++$,<1+' 0" %+'*+6 '&%+<+*&$.

@ '*+ &$#&.+$'

+#+,(+. ,5 =,!" *,. (0+#&-&#,11; (','+. &$ *+" .;&$4 .+#1,",'& $ '*,' '*+"+ :,( , .&(0!'+ "+4,".&$4 (+$.&$4A$ $(+$.&$4 - 6 $+;<;*+"*!(<,$.-" 6 "'!4,1<+':++$*+",$.'*+,00+11,$'(,('*+ ,00+11,$'(:+"+,11+4&$4# $#+,16+$' -"+#+&%&$4,6 !$'((+$'<;*+" *!(<,$.-" 6'*+6:*&#*-!"'*+"-&$.(# "" < ",'& $&$'*+(','+6+$'6,.+ <;C8 !"6!E*&$4*-,'*+" -'*+.+#+,(+.

%+$&$'*+&"(','+6+$'

!$.+" +#'& $ 99 "

'*+ ,##!(+.,00+11,$'( 6,.+ , 6+$'& $ '*,' =!1:,$'&$4*!(+.' (+$.6 $+;' ,5=,!")(&$#+.+#+,(+.3<!' ,5 =,!":,($ '.&(#1 (&$4'*+(,6+' '*+6

=++0&$4 &$ %&+: '*+ 0&$& $ - '*+ #' " "+,. :&'* '*+ (,'&(-,#'& $ -!';,4&('",'+ ,(:+11 ,( -!"'*+"# "" < ",'& $ <;'*+ (','+6+$' --,'*+" -'*+.+#+,(+.,$."+# %+"; -6,'+"&,1+%&.+$#+,$. '*+,.6&((& $ -'*+,##!(+.,00+11,$'('*,''*+;:+"+0"+(+$',''*+(0 ',' '*+ '&6+ - &$#&.+$' ,$. '*+"+ +B&('+. .&(0!'+ <+':++$ '*+ ,##!(+. ,00+11,$'(,$.'*+.+#+,(+.

6&$4' '*+" 1+,''"&<!'+.' ,00+11,$' 9,"<,$(=,!" .+#+,(+. ,5=,!"*,.(0+#&-&#,11;(','+.&$*+"(','+6+$'A.;&$4.+#1,",'& $ '*,',00+11,$' 9,"<,$(=,!"(,' !'(&.+'*+" 6,$.&':,( $1; ,##!(+.,00+11,$'( ,$.>:* (0"&$E1+.E+" (+$+ &1 $*+",$.(+' *+" $-&"+ C8,1( .+0 (+.'*,',(0+"'*+(','+6+$'6,.+' *&6<; ,5 =,!":*&1+&$* (0&',1,00+11,$' 9,"<,$(=,!"E+0'(',$.&$4,''*+ . ",$.'*+ '*+",##!(+.(0"&$E1+.E+" (+$+ &1 $*+",$.(+'*+" $-&"+

*+"+- "+:+,"+ -'*+# $(&.+"+. 0&$& $'*,'"+1&,$#+*,(' <+01,#+. $ '*+.;&$4.+#1,",'& $6,.+<; ,5=,!")(&$#+.+#+,(+.3,$.'*+.+0 (&'& $ 6,.+<;C8,$.&$%&+:'*+"+ -<+$+-&' -. !<'*,(' <+4&%+$'

8 ,00+11,$' 96'

,"<,$(=,!"

$%&+: -'*+,< %+,00+11,$' 96'

,"<,$(=,!"&( ,#?!&''+. -'*+#*,"4+(1+%+11+.,4,&$('*+",$.'*+,00+,1?!,,00+11,$' 9&(,11 :+.:*+"+,('*+,00+,1?!,,00+11,$'( ,$.>&(.&(6&((+.

,$.'*,' -,00+11,$' *&$4,",&$4*&(.&(0 (+. -,(*,%&$4,<,'+.

,&1< $.-!"$&(*+.<;,00+11,$' 9(',$.(.&(#*,"4+.

*+,##!(+.,00+11,$'(,(:,$'&$4*,$. !"6&'=,!","+ $ <,&1 *+&"<,&1 < $.((',$.#,$#+11+.

*+;(*,11(!""+$.+"- "'*:&'* <+- "+'*+ *&+-!.&#&,1,4&('",'+=,"$,1:* (*,11(+$.'*+6' 5,&1' !$.+"4 '*+"+6,&$&$40,"' -'*+(+$'+$#+ -'*+;-,&1' (!""+$.+"'*+ 1+,"$+. *&+-!.&#&,1,4&('",'+=,"$,1(*,11',E+# +"#&%+('+0(' (+#!"+ '*+&"0"+(+$#+,$.(+$.'*+6' 5,&1' !$.+"4 '*+"+6,&$&$40,"' -'*+ (+$'+$#+

+0'+6<+"

!1,'& C*+'*+" +0 "',<1+ +( C*+'*+"0+,E&$4A +,( $+.