High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/524/2025disposed of

Amarnath Ram v. Union Of India And Others

2025-04-03Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj8 pages

! "

"#

$ %&$ '( ' ) *****

! "# $%

& '()# $%

*

+ '&# ",( " *

* ----- ( ' )+ , -./ ,&""

/

0 0203

( 5 6 " 7

8 4 &"* *

6 "#+

%( 5% $

/&%&

&$ %$

% **

5

)"5) + "" + /("

4% . &$ *( **

% 5

*)"5 ) *

" * %)

+ &(.& ,#+'& ,)#

-2-

(:4# (%& 9( &"" 4

%

(

% /""4

<

" .4 &"**

%

/ $""5

* +

%( 5% , 76 "( 58 /

(4 5 . ,

7,8# + '& ,)# &(#

(:445= 2> 02 , 9( ( .*

,)#& /

, 6 "( 5/

= 2> 02 / ""

?!@ %)5 * 4% . / & + %& 02> /&%&

/

32 2= 02 &

# &/ #

+# "'& ,)# (:4

#02/ &%)" ** A "

&("

.& &*2 = 5 4 .

)

/ .

(

% * + + /& ( (4 %(" 78 )

/

* , (4 %(" 7;

(")5+8 % *

/*(

6# ,& .& /& . * + + / %*)

*

% (% .$ .

)

(

/ %("

&

%(.

6#,& .& /

%"

* 45 6#,& .& () )"% $ * % *%

2 2= 020 / (

%" (

# &( "# 6# ,& .& &

& # &/ # %% * % * 6 /)

*%

%"+ . ,)

"#

9(

+#!" & 2 020 * . ( 4" 5 *

*

%"+ *(

(*

4%

-3- . ( **(

$ /* B7

8,%("

0C 2 &/ ,(

23 2 020*

) * /%% ."5 (

(

("

3 * + ("

# DD &

(4)

& "./ )

%" %() * $ /

%" + /&%&/%$

.C 023#/&%&.&

(*

4% .

*

/ *

)

(

("

0= * + ("

# DD /

2> 02>*

.( *+ +/ 4% / .("< / %&..(#/ &( 5 54 * ..

*#

*"

,E

02C * 021 * & ,(

20 2D 0203# /

/

*/ &

& %

% *

5)

%""5 .

%

* % *

* 5 & *,

%)"%

# )(.

01 0 0203&4

#

%". %") & $ *

&(

F

! "#$ %%& '"(( )$ *"

+

'

' , &-

'

.%.

&

'

'

-4-

-

'

'

%/0%1 '

' ! "#$ 2

3

!"#$

4"

2

# %%

$&

"

& 2

56 5

' 3!

#4 "#$ 7 -

' '

)9"#$)

%/

' 4

&

8

'

2 &

&

'")4 ,

%

"#$ , '"

) 4

' '

& -

: 4

"#$ %%

! "#$ -

'

&

&

-5-

"#$ ' #4"#$7 - # ,

2

-

' % 4

'

; ;

' < ; '

( /%:%1 => ) ?

63< = > & :

* %")*

& &()

* /

= <

"*

&.()

%")*

4 5)

%""5%

% & & "

5 4

*( * 6# &

) * * 45

%" + $ /

%" + *

& &("

/5 *

*) (.

, "( ,( "*

& %

* "

"%

6 $% / * "

**)

" 5 5* ))() &5%" (% & /&%&

4

5 ) * *%

& % *%

(

6 %*5 % *% *&5%"* )

%4

* (*)

-6-

) ** 45

%"+ %

) * )

& 4 %

)( *( %

& " %) 4 * &,( %&""

..

*

) *

" * &

5 + )5# %")*

*4 .

, 6 "( 5/ %%

& ,( "5 / (

%

%")*

5)

%""5* 5 &(#

% & .

#

.

( &"

54

* %"

&,( $

$(

*( (4) )

& &

5)

%""5 %

&. .$ 45 &,( %*%""5 %

+/&%&

4% . /("

;

&%

)5 $ * *( (4) ) ( * 5)

% %&#

&$ "

5 %$

*)"5 *

)5"5*%)

+ (%& 9( (4)

) &""4

%

(

% /""4

&(# 4 * ;

.() &4

$%

"* * 5:( .) %

,( " *

& 4

%*

& ,( / .

2* )(.

/& *4" 5 ** 5"

$

-7- &4

.$ % 4% .)

5* %& 5 /"

&) /&

%

5 /

+ * /&%& 4% .

/&%&& *"5%%

(%& $ / * * %(" % # &,( & 4 " .

( # & ,( "* &5%" (% &

* %&.. *(% (*)

/("

" &.& &/& .

)

*&5%"* ).& 4 (

.

" , *%

(

6% *%

"5 ;

%(

* /

#&/ # ) % 4 % (

* % *%

"" )

%4

*

+ $.

$"(

&5%" )

* (% & %4

*(*)

#& % *%

% 4

( * )

%" ("

/ 45

) "$ 2 /"( " /&

& %("

5("

G (% (

/&%& .

)(.

%4 "

& $"

*"5%%

*5(%&("

(% (

/&%& %")*

%("

4 %

.$ %%() # /("

4

*

&,(

-8- / + 45 ;

) . &) *) (

.. 4%

. ) /("

)( "( . 4%* *

+ " "5 &$ %% . ** $ "" ( 4" 5# (% # &

* *)

0 "

&$ "

5 )

**

5

*)"5 ) )5 "5 * %)

*5(%&"% # % &"" 4

%

(

% &"" 4

* ** *** )

3

#/&"

&"

. (4 $ ) 5 )

) % 4 %%

#

G&

*)"5 ) )$

"% *

. %)

.(

) *(4)*5(%&"% #

&""

% % %

( # $ / * (% G(

. %

)

*01 0 &

%% ."5

* ,( ' )/

& +"

"# ?

# E&

.G

G E&

G