Karan Pelayi v. Union Territory, Chandigarh And ANR
!"
%"&'('#) * * + , )"- .'
****** "!'!'#)", /",(0( )'#) ",,'!#,.1 2 )%'3 ,2 )#!2", ***** "(4#)%")!(
,"(")!
,*
*5* 5 - ,1
%6#& !"
$#, 4"!'!'#)",*
,* 37#!
5* 8 --'1
%6#& !"
$#, ,"(4#)%")!* 2 )%'3 ,2* * "!'!'#)",
+ , ) "- .' $'-"% ')(! )!
9,'!
4"!'!'#) 0)%",
,!'&-"( :
;
#)(!'!0!'#) )%'
(""<')3 '((0 )&"
9,'!
) !0,"
&",!'#, ,'
$#, =0 (2')3 '>403)"% #,%", % !"% *;*
))"?0,"
@ 92","A.
%'(&2 ,3"% $,#> ,#--( 2 )%'3 ,2 0 ,%(
,3 )'B !'#)1 %"&- ,')3 (",6'&"( ,"
)# -#)3", ,"=0',"%*
$0,!2", 4, .", A"") > %"
$#, %',"&!')3 ,"(4#)%")!( ! <"
A &< ,#--( 0 ,%(
,3 )'B !'#)
0 ,% /#-0)!"",*
*
,'"$-.1 "),#--"%
0 ,% /#-0)!"", ." , !! &2"% 9'!2 #-'&"
5! !'#) 5"&!#, :1 2 )%'3 ,2*
& ("
#* % !"% @*:* 0)%", 5"&!'#)( @C C@1 @:
& >"
A"
,"3'(!","% 3 ')(!
!
#-'&"
5! !'#) 5"&!#, 1 2 )%'3 ,2*
4", 4"!'!'#)",1 2"
$ -("-.
'>4-'& !"% ( '% & ("
A.
&#>4- ') )!* !
44" ,( ) #,%", % !"% *;*
))"?0,"
@1 4 (("% A.
#>> )% )!
")", -1 0 ,%(1 2 )%'3 ,21 92","A.
%'(&2 ,3"% $,#> ,#--( 0 ,%
,3 )'B !'#) A.
(! !')3
(",6'&"( ,"
)# -#)3", ,"=0',"%*
2"
&- '>( $#,"( '% & ("
1 2"
,"-" ("% A '- 2"
<"4!
44,# &2')3 0!2#,'!'"( --#9 2'> 7#') %0!'"(1 2#9"6",1 )# 2""% 4 '% ,"=0"(!*
!
44" ,( $#,"( '% & ("
& >"
A"
=0 (2"% A.
!2'( #0,!1 6'%"
#,%", % !"% * *
))"?0, : 4 (("% :@ !2"," $!", > %"
,"4,"(")! !'#) #>> )% )!
")", -1 0 ,%(1 2 )%'3 ,2 ** :
))"?0,"
; (! !')3 !2","') )##)"
0 ,%
,3 )'B !'#)
4 .')3 ).
2""% ,"=0"(!
2"
(#032!
')%0-3")&"
#>> )% )!
")", -1 0 ,%(1 2 )%'3 ,2 ')!# > !!",*
!
'( & ("
(0A("=0")!-.1 ) >"
3 ') ')&-0%"% "),#-->")!
4,#&"(( 0 ,%(
&#>4-"!"% *;* ;1 2#9"6",1 ) >"
)#!
&#)('%","% A.
#A(",6')3 2 % )#!
44" , "),#-->")!
4,#&"(( 2"
> ,<"% A(")!
A.
),#-->")!
#>>'!!""
# ,%*
2"
(! !"( 2"
,"&"'6"% )# ')!'> !'#) (<')3 2'> 44" , A"$#,"
).
0!2#,'!.*
C* ) $#,">")!'#)"% &',&0>(! )&"(1 $'-"% ')(! )!
9,'!
4"!'!'#) A"$#,"
!2'(
#0,!*
@* ) !2'( & ("1 9,'!!") (! !">")!
A"") $'-"% A"2 -$ ,"(4#)%")!( #*
!2,#032 #>> )% )!
")", - 0 ,%(&0> ',"&!#, ")", - #-'&"1 ** 2 )%'3 ,21 92","') 4, .", > %"
A.
A"") #44#("%1 ')!", -' 1 3,#0)% $ , &2 --")3"
#,%", % !"% *;*
))"?0,"
@
'( &#)&",)"%1 ( >"
'( A ,,"% A.
%"- .
- !&2"( ')(! )!
9,'!
4"!'!'#) A"") $'-"% #)-.
." , 6'%"
#,%", % !"% *;*
))"?0,"
@1 %'(&2 ,3"% (",6'&"( 9","
)# -#)3", ,"=0',"% !",>( 0-"
0)7 A 0 ,%( 0-"(1 :
44-'& A-"
** 2 )%'3 ,2*
0,!2", ,"-' )&"
A"") > %"
2 4!", D/ 0 ,%( #>4")%'0> )(!,0&!'#)(1 >#,"
(4"&'$'& --.
')(!,0&!'#) &#)! ')"% - 0("
, C*C ( '% #>4")%'0>1 92'&2 4,#6'%"( #>> )% )!
")", - #, #>> )% )!1 & ("
> .
A"1 4#9", %'(&2 ,3"
).
0 ,% !
).
!'>"1 '$ #4')'#) (",6'&"( ,"
)# -#)3", ,"=0',"%*
&&#,%')3-.1 4, .", $#, %'(>'(( - 9,'!
4"!'!'#) A"") > %"*
:* 2 6"
2" ,% -" ,)"% �)("- $#, ,"(4"&!'6"
4 ,!'"( 4",0("% 4 4",A##< 9'!2 !2"', A-"
(('(! )&"*
;* 2"
"),#--"%
0 ,% /#-0)!"", ." , * 2"
) >"% ) &&0("% & ("
C
#* % !"% @*:*
))"?0,"
C* !
'( )#!
%'(40!"% %'(&2 ,3"% $,#> ,#--( 0 ,%
,3 )'B !'#)1 6'%"
#,%", % !"%
*;*
))"?0,"
@1 92'&2 ," %( 0)%",
!
" #$ % & *
4",0( - 4 4",A##< 9#0-% ,"6" - #)-.
#)"
,"4,"(")! !'#) % !"% ** :
))"?0,"
; A"") !! &2"% 9'!2 4 4",A##< (2#9 2 % > %"
3,'"6 )&"
A"$#,"
#>> )% )!
")", -1 0 ,%(1 ** 2 )%'3 ,2*
!
44" ,( !2"," $!",
2 % 3 ') 44-'"% $#, "),#-->")!
0 ,% /#-0)!"",1 92","') &- '> ,"7"&!"% 2"
%'% )#!
44" , E > ,<"% A(")!
A.
),#-->")!
#>>'!!""
# ,%1 A#,)"
#0!
$,#>
))"?0,"
))"?0,"
*
#)&"%"%-.1 $'-"% !2'( 9,'!
4"!'!'#) ." , *
"(4#)%")!( 2 6"
#44#("% 4, .", 4"!'!'#)",1 ')!", -' 1 3,#0)% %"- .
- &2"(*
*
!
'( 9"-- ("!!-"% 4",'#% -'>'! !'#)1 > )% !"% $#, $'-')3 &'6'- (0'!1 '( -(# !!, &!"% ')(!'!0!'#) 9,'!
4"!'!'#) A"$#,"
!2'( #0,!*
* )
'
(
) " *+ * ,+
5*** @ 1 !2'( #0,!
2"-% 0)%", - .
,
@
+ /
") + -011
23012 .4 51
+ " " 6 .4 57 5 53 58 " + " + .4 51/) + +
) + - +
) ++
)+ /,
" ( ( ./: 037 , + 3
( , + ;
") /
<
,,:
" , 9
./: 00 , + (
"'
;") " ""
+ )
)+)
4 = 4 + + ) >
=
"
+" , 2
. "= .
01#
"
? .
?$ :
+" " ) + ") .
) "
:
. 1 , ++ @ .
03-/)
+ )
" = "
@ + ,, :
?
# + $ A5 / +++ +"
, 2 . "= .
, 5 #$ +
+ ; ++
+)
+ 4 " #-$= " ? < ;
)
.
" "
. 1
"
") + B + ") . " = .
"
. 1& C
" + )++
D") + ++ + + = ) + & * 0,!2",1 & ("
D* , ( " <
, D (
C 5*** @;1
'6'('#)
")&2 !2'( #0,!
2"-%
0)%",
/ ) "
++
;
013 %
) ) + . D = ++ "
++
)
4
/ ) + +
<
( ?
, +
, 9
"( @ ( ./:
037 , + 3 =
) + +
+ + " .
) ")
++
& * ) 9+ , ++ ,)
( "==9 (
#27$7, 1 !2'( #0,!
#4')"%
0)%", - C ) )
/ 9 , :
= + + "( ) : 9 ," . "
./:
030 , -20 + +
,(
;@
"+ . .
C ) ' + #187$ 22 ) ) A5
E)
D%
) +
< "
+
)
% "
) " )
+ + ) "
+ + ) )
+
)
)
+
( "
) )) < +
"
+ + + %
=)
)
+
"
)
+
< < ;
& /, 9 "E '
) ./:
018, 2 " ) +) +++ ) . 223
4
%
/
+ +
+
4+
" 4 ) < D+ ) + +
4 ) <
;
+ "
< 3 =
. ) % ) 4+
+
= 4 4 %
< .
+
! ;+ " + + + )
" + )
% ++
) + )
!)
(
)
% /
) "
); ;
*
"
+
)
+
& ) + + ; +4 *
!
< . 4+ " +5)
+)? ;
? ?:+ ;?/ +
"
) " ) +" " & * ,#>
4",0( - ")!',"
9,'!
4"!'!'#)1 '!
'( "6'%")!
)#!
"?4- ')"% ).
&',&0>(! )&"( #, ," (#) $#, %"- .
- .')3 &2 --")3"
#,%", % !"% *;*
))"?0,"
@ 92","A.
%'(&2 ,3"%*
20(1 &2 --")3"
#,%", % !"% *;*
))"?0,"
@ (0$$",( $,#> %"- .
- &2"(*
C*
,"3 ,%( 4-"
&- '> $#, "),#-->")!
0 ,% /#-0)!"",
92'&2 '( (! !"% A"
&#>4-"!"%
*;* ;
A"") 9,#)3-.
,"7"&!"% A.
(! !')3
2 % )#!
44" ,"% E 92"," ( )"6", ')!'> !"% A.
),#-->")!
#>>'!!""
# ,% $#, 44" , )&"F '!
'( #A(",6"% ,"(4#)%")! "4 ,!>")!
! <")
& !"3#,'& (! )% "),#-->")!
4,#&"(( A"')3
40A-'& 4,#&"((F '!
%0!.
> <"
2'>("-$ 6 '- A-"
$#, ( >"*
20(1 #)&"
2'>("-$ A(")!"% $,#> "),#-->")!
4,#&"(( 0 ,%(
&#>4-"!"% *;* ;1 &&#,%')3-.1 )# ,"-'"$ & ) A"
3, )!"% >","
4-"
2"
)#!
')!'> !"% ,"3 ,%')3 4,"(")&"*
@* ) 6'"9 A#6"
%'(&0(('#)1 %# )#!
$')% ).
>",'!
!2'( 9,'!
4"!'!'#) ( >"
'( &&#,%')3-.
%'(>'(("%* :*
44-'& !'#) ( 4")%')31 '$ ).1 (2 -- (! )% &-#("%*
* *
(7<( 2"!2", (4" <')3 ," (#)"%
"(
#
2"!2", ,"4#,! A-"
"(
#